Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “Though Mountains Fall (Daughters of Caleb Bender #3)” as Want to Read:
Though Mountains Fall (Daughters of Caleb Bender #3)
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating

Though Mountains Fall (Daughters of Caleb Bender #3)

4.33 of 5 stars 4.33  ·  rating details  ·  594 ratings  ·  82 reviews
Unique Amish Historical from a Bestselling, Award-Winning Author
Amish pacifism is sorely tested in the Paradise Valley settlement in the 1920s. When an army of bandits descends on them, the Amish are saved by the last-minute arrival of government troops. But they soon learn that soldiers can be as cruel as the bandits themselves. Then a bishop travels to Mexico, and Caleb
Paperback, 352 pages
Published January 1st 2013 by Bethany House Publishers
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about Though Mountains Fall, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about Though Mountains Fall

The Shunning by Beverly  LewisWhen the Heart Cries by Cindy WoodsmallThe Covenant by Beverly  LewisThe Betrayal by Beverly  LewisThe Sacrifice by Beverly  Lewis
Best of Amish Fiction
137th out of 205 books — 181 voters
The Master's Plan by Stephany TullisUnconditional by Tanya EavensonA Voice in the Wind by Francine RiversThe Gladiator by Carla CapshawThe Protector by Carla Capshaw
Inspirational Romances
403rd out of 526 books — 231 voters

More lists with this book...

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 1,016)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
A Series I Won't Soon Forget!

This conclusion to the series, The Daughters Of Caleb Bender, will stay with me for awhile. I feel like I need to just sit and let it all sink in. This book is a real page turner and was so full of emotion right down to the last page.

If you are looking for a feel good book where everything is predictable and blah...this isn't the book for you. If you are looking for a book that will take you through every emotion of your being...this is for you. I laughed, I cried, I
I LOVE Dale Cramer's writing. Though I am mad about part of the ending to this book, I will not tell why I am mad and give away the ending, I still loved it. The characters are true to life, the descriptions make you feel like you are right there, and the trials they face are real ones that anyone else put in that same time and place would face in real life. I have NEVER read a book by Dale Cramer that I did not love. I recommend all of his books and if I could, I would give this book 10 stars o ...more
Author: Dale Cramer
Publisher: Bethany House
January 2013
ISBN: 978-0764208409
Genre: Historical/Amish

Unique Amish Historical from a Bestselling, Award-Winning Author

Amish pacifism is sorely tested in the Paradise Valley settlement in the 1920s. When an army of bandits descends on them, the Amish are saved by the last-minute arrival of government troops. But they soon learn that soldiers can be as cruel as the bandits themselves. Then a bishop travels to Mexico, and Caleb
Janet Sketchley
Caleb Bender has done what he believed God wanted: transplanted his family to Paradise Valley, Mexico, to establish an Amish community free from governmental interference. Other families have followed him, and after three years, the population is over 100, including many children.

They've survived illness and bandits, and their farms are thriving, but they live in the shadow of violence. And unless they can convince a Bishop to join them, Caleb knows the community will fold.

Caleb's own world is f
Review of Though Mountains Fall by Dale Cramer
I have to confess to being somewhat burned out on Amish fiction. Though I've enjoyed reading some in the genre it seems like there's just so much out there now that I've gotten a little tired of seeing it. That said, though, I've enjoyed reading Dale Cramer's The Daughters of Caleb Bender series. It's Amish fiction, but the Mexico setting and complex character have kept it feeling fresh for me. The third book in the series, Though Mountains Fall, is
Christian Fiction Addiction
This third book of the "Daughters of Caleb Bender" series finds Dale Cramer at his absolute best. "Though Mountains Fall" is deeply moving, and sees the return of Caleb and his daughters Rachel, Miriam, and Emma in a thoroughly absorbing read that was every bit as good as the first two books in the series. I absolutely loved returning to the world of these Amish characters who are struggling to survive in a violent, uncertain Mexican valley. The characters are complex and unique, and explore lif ...more
Cass Wessel
Jan 23, 2015 Cass Wessel rated it 5 of 5 stars
Recommends it for: mature readers
Though Mountains Fall
(The Daughters of Caleb Bender Book #3
Bethany House Publishers, 2013
Kindle Edition.
In “Though Mountains Fall,” the story opens with the idyllic picture of Caleb Bender planting his fields alongside the Mexican peon, Domingo, who is like a son to him. A single rider breaks the news of yet another external threat to the existence of the Amish community from El Pantera. The bandit seeks revenge shuddering terror through the valley farmers and throughout Caleb’s family.
I have been a life-long reader and as unbelievable as it is to a lot of people, I easily fit from 8-10 books into my reading schedule each week. To think that I never knew about Dale Cramer's "The Daughters of Caleb Bender" until last week causes me to have some regrets. I will read this series of books over and over throughout the coming years.

This third book in the series spends a lot of time developing the romance between Miriam and Domingo. Although Domingo doesn't have a lot to recommend hi
Liz melia
This book is very gritty, there is hurt, fighting, violence..the valley has traded bandits for federals, the bandits came back for blood on Miriam and Domingo's wedding day, lucky the amish managed to get behind the walls of the hacienda to safety, the bandits would have burned, raped and killed the amish families if the federals hadn't turned up when the my did the bandits might have succeeded.

The federals turn out to be as bad as the bandits for taking stock and livestock, but no more bandits
I had never read anything by this author but I do love historical fiction and Amish fiction so I thought I would give this book a try. Though I had not read the first two books; I was not at all lost and was able to follow along perfectly as a standalone novel. This book was well written but I didn’t enjoy it as much as I thought I would. It has nothing to do with the author or the writing and more to do with the fact that I just didn’t find the setting to be all that interesting. Perhaps I shou ...more
Jordan Mierek
I received a copy of THOUGH MOUNTAINS FALL by Dale Cramer from Bethany House. It is the third book in the Daughters of Caleb Bender series. Overall, I have very mixed feelings about the novel. I haven’t read any other books by Dale Cramer, and I’m not sure I’ll seek them out, although if one does fall into my hands, I’ll give it a try.

There were aspects of THOUGH MOUNTAINS FALL that I loved. For one thing, Dale Cramer based the series on his own ancestors. That is a huge plus for me. For anothe
I am not a stranger to Amish literature and I always love everything written about them. I believe it is the unique, seemingly simple, lifestyle that is forgotten in our society. I do admire the hard work ethic that is shared throughout these novels. I must say this is the first one where I have ever read about a banning of a family member and one that takes place outside of Ohio or Pennsylvania. Very interesting! This was my first book that I have read from Dale Cramer and I learned that this i ...more
This is what I'm guessing is the final book in the series. I was teary through probably 75% of the book. The author makes the characters and their struggles very real, and I like that he lets you peek into so many of the characters, not just 1 or 2 main characters. He shows a lot from the daughters' point of view, but their father's experience and struggles are a big part of the story as well. I don't read a lot of Amish fiction, but this does have quite a different spin on it as the Amish famil ...more
Feb 04, 2013 Will rated it 4 of 5 stars
Shelves: ebooks
This book is the last one in a three book series entitled “The Daughters of Caleb Bender”. Dale Cramer is the author of this excellent series of historical novels based upon the real life events of various Amish families who migrated to Mexico in the 1920's. Mr. Cramer wrote the series from the viewpoint of two of the eight daughters of the title character in the series. Taking the female perspective in writing the series was a particular challenge for Cramer since he is a male; and yet he does ...more
As I said in my very first post about this series, if you've given up on Amish Fiction, these books just might change your mind. This book was intense and had themes and situations you normally do not see in Amish fiction.

In this book, we meet up again with the Bender family and their neighbors who are still making a valiant effort to establish an Amish settlement in Mexico.

Amish folks? In Mexico?

You'll have to read the first book to find out how it all begins, but the story is based on actual
Jalynn Patterson
About the Book:

Inspired by Actual Events!

"I want you to promise you will always be my sister."

There were tears in Miriam’s eyes as their foreheads touched and Rachel whispered, "No matter what. Always."

Now in its fourth year, the Amish settlement in Mexico is thriving. But as new settlers arrive, sons and daughters marry, babies are born, and crops grow thick, a storm looms on the horizon. And Caleb Bender knows--perhaps better than anyone--that the worst of storms don't come from the western sk
It is 1920 in Paradise Valley, an Amish community in Mexico. This book continues the story of Caleb Bender and his family. It concludes the Daughter’s of Caleb series which fills in the story from the Paradise Valley series. Caleb left Ohio to avoid the school law that required all children to attend government school. In Paradise Valley the land is good enough to grow crops to survive but the bandits coming into the community make it difficult to live peacefully. In Though Mountains Fall, Caleb ...more

"Though Mountains Fall " by Dale Cramer gets 5 stars from me. This book is the last in the series “The Daughters of Caleb Bender. This is a series that I could read time and time again even knowing how it well end. It is the fourth year that the Bender family has lived in Paradise Valley and things are not improving, The bandits have all been killed by the Mexican government. Caleb Bender says the other differences between the bandits and the soldiers are the uniforms. The soldiers took the Amis
Dale Cramer series "The Daughters of Caleb Bender" book #3 Though Mountains Fall.

In the previous books 1-2 we saw how this family had moved from their quite amish community to the mountains of Mexico to Paradise Valley to avoid having their children made to go to public schools.
Life was hard in Mexico and they had to forge their way making homes and clearing lands for their planting. hard work and perseverence had their amish community in Paradise Valley growing, others had came and it would be
I was very surprised to see that Though Mountains Fall by Dale Cramer, Book 3 in the Daughters of Calab Bender series was set in Mexico. I have not read the two previous books in the series, but after reading this one will be reading those as well. This title can easily stand on its own though. The other two book in the series are, Paradise Valley – The Daughters of Caleb Bender – Book 1 and The Captive Heart – The Daughters of Caleb Bender – Book 2. The characters in Though Mountains Fall were ...more
There is much turmoil as time progresses for the Bender family and other Amish families that are living in Mexico. The bandits have chosen a time to attack the Amish and just as the last of them are entering the safety of Hacienda El Prado the federales finally show up to protect them also. Once the bandits are captured and/or killed everyone returns home. A Bishop finally arrives so people can be baptized and married, things are looking up.

After some time they find that the federales are just a
Holly (2 Kids and Tired)
The Bender family has lived in Mexico for four years. They've built a thriving Amish community in the hills of Paradise Valley. They have endured loss, but their family has also grown. Now threatened again by El Pantera and his bandits, they ask the Mexican government for protection. But when the federales arrive, Caleb begins to wonder if they aren't nearly as bad as the bandits.

Rachel and Jake face another crisis before they can be married and Miriam finds herself torn between her love for her
This book was more about the Amish and their troubles with the federals. They asked the federals for protection from the bandits, but it created even more problems. Problems that lead to choosing to either stay in Paradise Valley or go back to Ohio. It was also about two shunnings that took place. Reading about the process of shunning in this book was a very sad thing that should never happen. You need to have church discipline, but you should not shun the person.

Overall, it was pretty good. Yo
Beth His handmaiden
Caleb Bender is determined that God has led their small Amish community to Paradise Valley Mexico but it seems that everywhere they turn they are faced with more loss and heartache.
When bandits begin to threaten their community they plead with the haciendado to send for soldiers to protect their families. However they soon learn that a uniform does not change the hearts of evil men.
Facing persecution, the death of two sons, and the shunning of his daughter Miriam, Caleb believes that he has fail
I thoroughly enjoyed this series. I loved the history and the Mexican setting, and the writing was fresh--sometimes omniscient POV, which is rare in current Christian-fiction circles. My favorite characters were Caleb Bender and Domingo, although the three sisters were also lovable.
Paradise Valley, the first book in "The Daughters of Caleb Bender," is currently free on Nook and Kindle. I highly recommend it!

Now I want to read Levi's Will. :-)
Connie Hoover
Sorry to see it end!

seldom do I read a book that completely draws me in. I have read Dale Cramer's series from the beginning and if we had a fourth I would welcome it. I loved. the characters the plots and the history of the Amish family
Mr Cramer wrote a story for the person who wants Christian romance with action and compassion. I recommend all three to anyone.
Julie A. Powell

It had been many years since I had read novels involving the Amish as central characters and I am glad that this was the series I chose to get reacquainted with them. From the first day I started reading this series I knew it was masterfully written. I have already recommended it to several of my friends. I look forward to reading more of Dale Cramer's work.
Barbara O'Neal
Though the mountains fall

Though the mountains fall

This series of books about an Amish family is very unique. Being about Mexico and the hardships that they face I love the characters the author made them so real to you you will laugh when they laugh and cry when they cry this series is worth reading
Dale Cramer is a favorite author of mine, and I will echo what other reviewers have said, I never read a Dale Cramer book that I didn't love. His take on amish subculture is so much more real and in depth and he is not afraid to shy away from the tough questions. For example, how do pacifists stand in judgment of those who bear arms to protect them? How do you live with yourself as a man if you stand by and let someone rape your daughter? Brutal stuff that.

I recommend this series and any work by
Jan 31, 2015 Linda rated it 5 of 5 stars
Shelves: 2015
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 33 34 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
  • The Lesson (Stoney Ridge Seasons #3)
  • Katie Opens Her Heart (Emma Raber's Daughter, #1)
  • The Memory Jar (Seven Brides for Seven Bachelors, #1)
  • The Guardian (Home to Hickory Hollow #3)
  • The Winnowing Season (Amish Vines and Orchards, #2)
  • Daybreak (The Days of Redemption #1)
  • Faithful to Laura (Middlefield Family #2)
  • A Life of Joy (Kauffman Amish Bakery, #4)
  • Promised To Another (Amish of Seymour County, #3)
  • Love Comes to Paradise (The New Beginnings, #2)
  • Hills of Wheat (Amish of Lancaster #2)
  • Abby Finds Her Calling (Home at Cedar Creek, #1)
  • The Wonder of Your Love (Land of Canaan #2)
  • A Home for Lydia (The Pebble Creek Amish #2)
  • Levi's Will
About Dale

Dale Cramer was the second of four children born to a runaway Amishman turned soldier and a south Georgia sharecropper’s daughter. His formative years were divided between far-flung military bases, but he inherited his mother’s sense of place—

"I remember knee-deep snow in the Maryland woods, chasing horned toads in El Paso, playing soccer in Mainz, and the way German shopkeepers and hau
More about Dale Cramer...

Other Books in the Series

Daughters of Caleb Bender (3 books)
  • Paradise Valley (Daughters of Caleb Bender, #1)
  • The Captive Heart (Daughters of Caleb Bender, #2)
Paradise Valley (Daughters of Caleb Bender, #1) The Captive Heart (Daughters of Caleb Bender, #2) Levi's Will Kiss of the Jewel Bird

Share This Book