Nobody's Secret

Nobody's Secret

by
3.72 of 5 stars 3.72  ·  rating details  ·  54 ratings  ·  33 reviews
One day, fifteen-year-old Emily Dickinson meets a mysterious, handsome young man. Surprisingly, he doesn't seem to know who she or her family is. And even more surprisingly, he playfully refuses to divulge his name. Emily enjoys her secret flirtation with Mr. "Nobody" until he turns up dead in her family's pond. She's stricken with guilt. Only Emily can discover who this e...more
Hardcover, 241 pages
Published April 30th 2013 by Chronicle Books (first published April 16th 2013)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.
Nobody's Slave by Tim VicaryStrands of Bronze and Gold by Jane NickersonDark Triumph by R.L. LaFeversThe Madman's Daughter by Megan ShepherdBorn Of Illusion by Teri Brown
YA Historical Fiction of 2013
35th out of 38 books — 108 voters
Walking Disaster by Jamie McGuireThe Sweetest Dark by Shana AbeUnbreakable by Elizabeth NorrisThe Flame in the Mist by Kit GrindstaffThe Eternity Cure by Julie Kagawa
On My April 2013 List
35th out of 36 books — 19 voters


More lists with this book...

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 859)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Reading Teen
Nobody's Secret is a novel of historical fiction based on 15 year old Emily Dickinson, the famous poet of the 19th century. Emily becomes entangled in the investigation of the death of an unknown young man. She must keep her sleuthing secret from her disapproving mother and nosy sister. The story takes place in puritanical New England where Emily challenges the accepted rules of behavior for young women of that time. The story is very clearly and simply written. The characters are well-developed...more
Sabrina
Short and Sweet:
Nobody's Secret was sweet and wonderful for a murder mystery. I loved the imagination of the author concerning Emily Dickinson and the poetry mixed through out. I felt like I was reading a historical Veronica Mars episode and I want to kiss Michaela MacColl's face for writing this wonderful book. :)

To Elaborate....
The story begins with Emily laying in a field of wildflowers hoping a bee will land on her nose.... just to experience something different. After a few moments she hear...more
Cindy Hudson
A young Emily Dickinson is daydreaming in the woods near her home when a handsome young man interrupts. She’s never seen him before, yet when she asks his name he tells her he’s nobody. The air of mystery deepens when she sees him in town and he still won’t say who he is or why he’s visiting Amherst, but he hints at family crimes. The next day Mr. Nobody ends up dead in her family’s pond, and Emily suspects foul play. She sets out to discover who Mr. Nobody is and why he died.

Nobody’s Secret by...more
Jannatul
I got this book as an ARC from Goodread's First Reads.

I has so many expectations for this book. The blurb, the cover, even the title looked so promising. It ended up being not as good as I thought it would be. There was some mystery, which I liked, but there was barely any romance at all. The cover said "A novel of romance and intrigue," But there was a huge lack of it. There were some flirtatious exchanges, but they could hardly pass for romance. Also, I was usually pretty bored and I ended up...more
Ashley Granger
I would give this a 3.5, rounded up to a 4.

In “Nobody’s Secret,” Emily Dickinson is a 15-year-old who meets an older boy. Emily is eccentric, and finds that this boy is also strange his own way. She doesn’t know his name, yet he makes a definite impact on her. Before their relationship can progress, he is found dead in the pond outside her house. What starts as a mission to discover his true name becomes a quest to discover not only his name, but who he was, how he’s related to this town, and t...more
Emily Rachelle
This was a really nice book. I've always loved Emily Dickinson's poetry and the days before I read a variety of genres were filled with mysteries like these. Every chapter started with some lines by Emily that really fit the tone of that chapter. The emotions were generally very realistic - the laughing flirtation with Mr. Nobody, the mixed dread and odd curiosity of death, the combination of excitement and fear found in investigating a crime. The mystery itself was very well-written, complete w...more
Anna (Gatsby's Girl)
Emily Dickinson is always looking for a way out of helping with the numerous chores her Mother creates for her and her younger sister Vinnie. On one such afternoon when Emily is hiding in the meadow, she strikes up an acquaintance with a young man who mysteriously refuses to tell her his name. To each other they are Mr. and Miss Nobody. So when she arranges to meet up with him again soon and show him about town, Emily is excited to have a secret. Then Mr. Nobody is found dead in the Dickinson fa...more
Melissa (YA Book Shelf)
Thought I knew where this book was going, but boy was I wrong. Great mystery with unexpected twists and turns. I also loved how Michaela MacColl uses Emily Dickinson's poetry to tie together the story, making the reader actually believe that she was involved with solving a crime at one time, even though it was a complete fabrication.

Mrs. Dickinson reminded me of a non-silly version of Mrs. Bennet, in the sense that she was always putting the idea that Emily would be marrying someone someday and...more
Heidi Rikard
I absolutely adore the poetry of Emily Dickinson, and am fascinated by her life. So, when I read that this book was a fictional account of Emily as a teenager, I knew I had to read it. This book did not disappoint. It's a fun little mystery, and even though I pretty much had it figured it out, I still enjoyed reading to see how Emily sleuthed out who the murderer was and what she would do about it.
The author uses Emily's real family, real town, and her own life and hobbies. The only fictionaliz...more
Nancy
This is an ARC won through Goodreads First Reads giveaways.

Emily Dickinson the next great Sherlock Holmes! Ms. MacColl's second novel centers around famed American poet Emily Dickinson. In this novel, Emily is 15 and has found herself compelled to investigate the murder of a gentleman she briefly met and who calls himself 'Mr. Nobody'.

A classic who dunnit, the story flows quickly. The author intertweaves between Emily's 'career' as sleuth and her dutiful 'career' as a young lady of the 1800's. M...more
Renee Patterson
Emily Dickenson is a free spirit with a love of writing. She happens to meet a handsome young man that she refers to as Mr. Nobody. After several unscheduled meetings, Emily becomes friends with Mr. Nobody. But before she can learn his real identity, he is found floating in the Dickenson's pond. Many questions arise from this grisly discovery. Who was he? Why has no one identified him when he told Emily he was in town to handle family business? And why was he dressed in clothes of a farmhand? Em...more
Leanne (The Selkie Reads Stories)
Originally posted on The Selkie Reads Stories (http://selkiereadsstories.blogspot.com)


Nobody's Secret was a nice light read. The writing was fluid and easy to understand, and I especially liked how the dialogue flows between the characters. The historical setting was quite evident in the way the book was written and in how people acted. I enjoyed hearing Emily's opinions about the people and things around her. She was considered "odd" by most people and was depicted in Nobody's Secret as quite a...more
Christina
Fifteen year old Emily Dickinson, dreamily playing hooky in the fields instead of doing her drudgery household chores, meets a mysterious handsome stranger, who talks intelligently with her and is very charming. He coyly refuses to tell her his name, so Emily calls him Mr. Nobody. It is 1845, and the quiet, introspective, sometimes frail but still rebellious Emily chafes at being so often confined to her house by her protective mother. She has no real friends apart from her younger sister, so it...more
Teresa Gibson
Emily Dickinson, girl detective! MacColl imagines the elusive poet as a fifteen-year-old girl, who meets an intriguing young man she names Mr. Nobody. Without giving away any spoilers, I'll only say that this meeting leads to a great mystery which Emily makes it her mission to solve. While I enjoy books which take real people and thrust them into decidedly fictional situations, the whole time I was reading this, I kept thinking, "Mamma Mia." You know, the musical that weaves its story from ABBA...more
Jenny
Reading books about real historical figures always gets me curious about them and I end up looking them up online to find out more about them. So that’s exactly what I did with Emily Dickenson. MacColl’s version of a young Emily Dickinson is an intelligent young woman with a thirst for life and knowledge. Not content with staying at home and doing housework all day, Emily would much rather spend her time outdoors and writing poetry. After reading up on Emily Dickinson online, I could see why she...more
Tara Renee
I received this book as an Advance Reader's Copy to review. I love reading fan fictions so I was delighted to find this in the mail. Truthfully I loved it. I was only disappointed that there was not more interaction between Mr. Nobody and Miss Dickinson. I would have like to seen a little bit more blossom between them. However the author did such a good job of drawing you in from the moment the two meet. I enjoyed how fearless Emily was. The sisters personalities played off each other very well....more
Lindsay
It's 1845, and for fifteen-year-old Emily Dickinson, every day follows the same patters: chores, chores, and more chores. So when she meets a mysterious, handsome young man, she's intrigued. Surprisingly, he doesn't seem to know who she or her family is. And even more surprisingly, he playfully refuses to divulge his name. Emily enjoys her secret flirtation with "Mr. Nobody" until he ends up dead in her family's pond. Stricken with guilt, Emily sets out to discover who this enigmatic stranger wa...more
W
Feb 12, 2013 W rated it 3 of 5 stars
Shelves: 2013-read, arc
Young Emily Dickinson tries to discover who has murdered the young stranger who caught her attention and asked to simply be called “Mr. Nobody.”

Mr. Nobody had met the real Emily Dickinson, with all of her unconventionality, and he had liked her for it. It was up to her to find out his name, and how he came to be floating facedown in her pond.

I certainly wouldn’t claim to be a poetry buff, but I remember reading Dickinson’s “I’m Nobody” poem and enjoying it, so when I heard about this book, I ha...more
Brooke Banks
I won a free paperback copy through a First Reads Giveaway in order to give an honest review.
Originally posted at my blog: The Broke Book Bank

As a fan of Emily Dickinson since I was young, when I first read the blurb it was an instant grab for me. I feel in love with her work when learning about it in school and used to daydream about Emily having a real Mr. Nobody, though it was told to us in no uncertain terms he didn’t really exist. Apparently, I’m not the only thing that had the same unreal...more
Kacey Vanderkarr
I won Nobody’s Secret as an ARC on Goodreads.

Nobody’s Secret is a rich step into the past. Following a fictitious version of Emily Dickinson’s life, the reader experiences Amherst in 1845 through young Dickinson’s eyes while she investigates the murder of Mr. Nobody.

The story is as refreshing as Miss Dickinson’s refusal to live by the social norms placed on her by society. She’s feisty, driven, and prefers to spend time exploring nature and writing poetry instead of cooking and doing chores.

Th...more
Shay (Shannon)
*This is an ARC copy I received via library thing*
In 1845 Emily Dickinson is just fifteen and already feels the monotony of a domesticated lifestyle. While waiting for some kind of excitement to enter her life she meets a handsome young man who knows nothing about her or her family for a change. He’s a mystery that she finds surprising and she wants to keep their new friendship a secret. The mystery of his identity, however, turns Emily’s life upside down when his body is found in her pond and s...more
Ms. B
Received an advance copy from the publisher through Goodreads. What a pleasant surprise! Even readers who don't usually enjoy historical fiction could find themselves easily falling into this mystery featuring a young Emily Dickinson and an enigmatic, charming young man. It includes plenty of references to her poetry, but nothing that's alienating for those unfamiliar with her work or life. I would recommend for a middle school library.
Kim Storbeck
Mystery featuring Emily Dickinson. Picked it up at ALA mid-winter for Lily, who read it and wanted me to read it too so we could talk about it.

Interesting to see Emily Dickinson portrayed as a girl, with a great intellect and bursting at the seams to enjoy life beyond the bounds of her very protective parents. I saw the solution (at least one of them) fairly early out, but it was still a good read. Writing was excellent.
Grace Spalding
Good historical fiction with well researched roots in the youth of Emily Dickinson. She is brave, intelligent, and although this is obviously fiction, I would like to think of her as being very similar to how she is portrayed here. Rich with snippets of poetry and suspense, I would definitely recommend it, though it is not really a life changer.
Sunshine
I received this book for free through Goodreads First Reads.

Edit 1: 1 Apr. 2013
So far, I've been hooked. I always make up an excuse to sit somewhere and focus my thoughts on this great story. I LOVE how this story takes place in the past. I have always had an interest in historical fiction. What I love most about the book so far is the design Michaela MacColl has for each chapter. In my eyes, I think that those hex shapes represent the bees Emily had tried to get to land on her nose. It reminds...more
Sarah
I'm not entirely sure how to rate this one. It wasn't bad; it just wasn't particularly good.

http://librarianosnark.blogspot.com/2...
Dawn Abron
3.5. It was a cute story and a great introduction to Emily Dickenson
Carmela
Mar 20, 2013 Carmela marked it as to-read
Read a review in SLJ on 3/20/13 by a 14-year-old who liked it.
Andrea
Fun mystery concerning Emily Dickinson and a foxy young gentleman who turns up dead in her family's pond.
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 28 29 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
Nobody's Secret (ebook)
3444520
Prisoners in the Palace is my debut novel. I like to create historical fiction that has a modern appeal to teens and adults.


Regency romance blends enjoyably with historical fiction, with a plucky heroine for each mode. (Kirkus)

This novel is full of historical detail, vivid settings, and richly drawn characters, and themes of friendship and romance give the story teen appeal. (Booklist)

MacColl offe...more
More about Michaela MacColl...
Prisoners in the Palace Promise the Night Prisoners in the Palace: How Princess Victoria became Queen with the Help of Her Maid, a Reporter, and a Scoundrel

Share This Book

Your website