Kindness for Weakness
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating

Kindness for Weakness

3.86 of 5 stars 3.86  ·  rating details  ·  206 ratings  ·  63 reviews
One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest meets Catcher in the Rye.

A fifteen-year-old boy from an abusive home desperately seeking his older brother's love and approval starts pushing drugs for him and suffers the consequences.
Hardcover, 272 pages
Published May 14th 2013 by Delacorte Books for Young Readers (first published January 1st 2013)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.
Baby by J.K. AccinniEvil Among Us by J.K. AccinniEcho by J.K. AccinniArmageddon Cometh by J.K. AccinniHive by J.K. Accinni
Eye Catching Titles
141st out of 174 books — 109 voters
The Sin-Eater's Confession by Ilsa J. BickThe Coldest Girl in Coldtown by Holly BlackThe Dark Unwinding by Sharon CameronThe Wicked and the Just by J. Anderson CoatsMidwinterblood by Marcus Sedgwick
21st out of 58 books — 3 voters

More lists with this book...

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 874)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
A strong 3.5, especially because of its potential boy appeal and reluctant reader appeal. Always nice to have those qualities for the recommendation arsenal.

James tells his story in first person, a story of poverty, isolation. He subsists in a home with a weak mother who bends to the will of her meth-head abusive boyfriend and has already lost one son because of it. Louis simply left, remaking himself as a bodybuilder and a drug dealer to gain some control. He has cut ties with his family even t...more
Sarah (YA Love)
Review originally posted at YA Love

Shawn Goodman’s sophomore release, Kindness for Weakness, made me feel an array of emotions: hope, grief, dismay, and more. I absolutely loved Something Like Hope, so when I featured Kindness for Weakness on Waiting on Wednesday, Shawn offered to send me an ARC of it. I had requested a copy via NetGalley, and hadn’t received a response yet, so I accepted his kind offer. Regardless of how I received a copy of this book, I thoroughly enjoyed it and can’t wait to...more
Initial reaction: Probably somewhere between 4 and 4.5 stars. I'm not sure, I don't think I've quite recovered from the ending and how the book really took a dark turn after some time, though it was dark to begin with in this story of a boy who was caught in a very tough lifestyle, made terrible choices, had some glimmer of hope in stages, but, I think I'll leave that for my extended review.I thought this book was very well done. Really wish I'd read it sooner.

Full review:

I thin...more
Abbe "The Sexy Gryffindor" Hinder

I was really rooting for this one. I loved the beginning, it's very strong and exciting. It starts with a flashback and then we learn about where it sort of began.But after awhile, James's story starts to get boring and at many times, he feels like a brick wall, only relying on books and other people to build his character up.

There are manybook references in this novel! Too many for my taste. I can deal with one or two butKindness for Weaknesshas around four book references which I found too co...more
Cathy Blackler
Goodman's heart wrenching account of boys trying to become men gives readers a glimpse into the darkness that takes over without the proper guidance during this critical journey. I have a fondness for books that reference other books, exposing the layers and connections a reading life can offer, and this one is filled with literary references that serve as anchors during the storm. Sadly, I see too many of my students within Goodman's characters; boys who believe in the "kindness for weakness" p...more
"... I smile inwardly, thinking that maybe there are such things as second chances."

There are, James, and I wish you would have realized sooner that strength isn't just a bodily measure. I wish you could have been the one to rise up against the tide of hate and fear. You should have gotten that second chance.

Review of SLJ Teen:

"Kindness for Weakness follows the story of James, a teenager who has lived his whole life surrounded by a lost and broken family. With an alcoholic mother and an abusive...more
Jan 14, 2014 C.R. rated it 4 of 5 stars Recommends it for: Everyone
3.5-4 stars

A gem of a book. Discovered this book while growing through New YA section at my local library. The title caught my eye and I was highly surprised at how much the book grasped me. As a YA fiction fan, Its funny enough to say that I've never read a book that deals with the juvenile incarnation system and boy was happy to read such an honesty and enlightening story. I think everyone grows a lil bit rough, James was an easy retable character who has to learn what it means to be a man ins...more
You guys, I just recently gobbled up Kindness For Weakness by Shawn Goodman which really hit my intellectual sweet spots. I mean, I started this book the same day that I DNFed a contemporary book and basically read all of Kindness For Weakness in a single sitting – including about 88% of the book while I was on the exercise bike. Goodman’s book has a stellar main character and then actually made me think deeply about issues in our society AND made me want to read this classic Jack London book th...more
Good book. Its about a young man who is looking for someone to show him how to be a man. His mother has remarried a man who treats her like dirt. His older brother moved out of the home leaving him there by himself. The stepfather hits the mother and the young man. The older brother wants nothing to do with the family nor his brother, except when he gets his younger brother to do something illegal that changes both their lives forever.
James has little to hold on to except his love for his disintegrating family. After he's sent to a detention center for dealing drugs, he has to figure out how to survive there without transforming into something he doesn't want to be. A meditation on the construction of manhood, told by a narrator it's easy to empathize with. Much like James's feelings about The Sea Wolf, I felt that (view spoiler)...more
Although Kindness for Weakness isn't your typical "happily ever after" story, be prepared for a seriously eye-opening experience. Expect to be educated, and while you may feel terrible throughout the process, you will likely have a new-found appreciation for your life. After discovering what the title Kindness for Weakness means, you will have a better understanding of a broken system and broken lives. Author Shawn Goodman has insider knowledge of New York's juvenile justice system as he worked...more
This is not normally the kind of book I read. At all. But there was just something so intriguing about "One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest meets Catcher in the Rye," that I couldn't resist picking it up.

James is used to taking care of himself. Since his mom got together with her abusive boyfriend and his brother left, James can only find solace in his books and conversations over a cold glass of root beer with his English teacher. But when James gets into trouble helping out his brother, he finds...more
Waiting For Wentworth
I really wasn't sure what to think about Kindness For Weakness going into it, but I ended up really loving it. I cried on more than one occasion, and maybe I'm more emotional than some, but I felt this was an unexpectedly powerful story.

I really felt for the protagonist, James, because he had such a crappy home life. With a piece of junk mother and an even worse step-father, James prefers to walk the streets alone than spend time in the same house with them. It was so bad at home that his older...more
Turn your cheek. Yes, we have all heard the saying but who can actually do that when the chips are down. I thought of this saying a lot when I read this book as fifteen-year old James tries to do that many times but it’s ole’ so hard. James lives with his mother and his stepfather, I guess you call it living if you sleep on the sofa and you leave early so you can avoid a beating (verbally and mentally) from your stepfather. The mother, yes she has checked out years ago. His brother Louis, James...more
First of all, I want to say that this book is really an amazing, good read! I actually picked it up by random from the library!

Basically, here's the summary of what the book is about. James (no mentioned surname), a 15-year-old boy who lives in Dunkirk - a small town in western New York. He's got no friends. Friendless. His family is not on good terms. The only person he's got is his brother, Louis - strong, tough, and all with muscles - and looks up to him like he's some kind of hero who can sa...more
Actual Rating 4.5 stars

As seen on The Quiet Concert

The synopsis for this book does not reveal much so I didn't really know what to expect when picking up Kindness for Weakness. I guess my love of contemporary and male POV is what really compelled me. That, and what we do get in terms of a summary hints at a serious and thought-provoking story. Whatever the reason, I am so glad I read this book because it was every bit as eye-opening as I thought it would be. Shawn Goodman told a story that neede...more
Kim Graff
More of my reviews can be found at YA Asylum.


Pros : The start is so interesting. There's high tension, James (the MC) comes off as sweet and loveable, and you're going to want to know what happens next.

Cons : It's what I classify as a False Start, which is a dream, a flashback, a flash-forward, or anything like that. You know, that thing that's done to grab your attention and keep you reading when the real start isn't as intense. In this case, it's a flash-forward. The first ch...more
Review first appeared on my blog: Book Addict 24-7

I received a copy from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review

I don't even know where to start with Shawn Goodman's young adult contemporary novel Kindness for Weakness. This novel is so good, that I devoured it in one sitting.

I. Could. Not. Put. It. Down.

Funny how I was wary of it at first--a teenager sent to prison because of his relentless need for approval from a less than stellar big brother? I honestly didn't know how this was going to...more
Julie Wolfe
I rented it from the library thinking that it looked good, but it took me a while to pick it up. Once I did - I read it though in three hours. This account of one boy's life in juvie seems to be an honest interpretation of the world from the boy's point of view. James narrates with a clarity that gives the reader a picture and insight into his view, but the reader has to step back to see the truth behind all of what he is saying. The author created a commentary on American culture, recidivism, m...more
James doesn’t know who he is or what he stands for. He feels weak. He feels he’s not a man. He’s been left behind, abused and misused by his family and has no friends to speak of. His mom chooses drugs and scumbag boyfriend before James and his brother Louis. Louis, is someone James admires, but Louis left him behind and moved out. Louis asks James to help him out with some work and James, aiming to please his brother accepts. But- this isn’t just any job, it’s dealing drugs door to door and soo...more
This is one of those books that I think is for adults who like ya. I don't know many actual teens who have the kind of perspective it takes to appreciate this book. I'm sure there are some. It is a sad book because it is a true book. I know it is fiction, but it tells a truth about teens in poverty that is really hard and heartbreaking. But, it is beautifully told.
Tough One

Read in 2013,YA,Good for Dudes

Kindness for Weakness was an eARC I received through netgalley and one I thoroughly enjoyed. I blew through it quickly because it was one of those books that sucks you in right away, with a main character, James, who is completely real and sympathetic.
James has a mother who never should have been a mother: she is a drunk and lives with an abusive jerk who beats her and James both. He has an older brother, a poser-creep drug dealer who drags James into his...more
Heather Loy
Would have given four stars, but for a plot device that I felt was unnecessary or used to either shock or hurry the ending. I can't write it here without giving the story away. The outcome could still have come about without this particular tactic. I was disappointed.
Paul Lunger
Scheduled for release in May, Shawn Goodman's "Kindness for Weakness" is a book that will grab your attention & should get a lot of attention later on in the year. The story revolves around James a teenager who comes from a broken home & who gets caught in an honest mistake set up by his older brother that lands him in the NY juvenile corrections institute. It is there that James grows up from being the boy he is into a much stronger character through the interactions with a wide variety...more
Paul Cumbo
This was a nicely written story that felt underdeveloped in certain areas, including the protagonist's relationship with his mother and brother. It read a bit more like a short story than a novel, since it seemed to gloss over too many areas in which one would expect a bit more development in a novel. Throughout the course of the book, I found myself empathizing with James; however, at the end, I wasn't that upset by what happened. I don't know if enough happened for me to care too deeply. All i...more
This is a young adult novel that I would say is squarely aimed at teenage boys. The story follows 15 year old James who has grown up in a broken home idolizing his older brother. When he naively gets involved with his brother's drug trade he winds up in a juvenile detention facility. Most of the action of the story takes place there where James has to try and learn to navigate between the other juvenile detainees and the less than friendly guards. Though fiction, the story is probably all too tr...more
Flower Mound Public Library
A fifteen-year-old boy from an abusive home desperately seeking his older brother's love and approval starts pushing drugs for him and suffers the consequences.
Emma James
I really love this book. It shows the changes he has been through in jail.
Another powerful story by Shawn Goodman about troubled teens in the juvenal detention system. James is a 15-year-old boy trying to be a man, wondering what it means to be a man, who is failed by his family and the system and a culture of violence. What is so heart-breakingly sad about this book is the fact that boys like James exist and places like Morton exist and people like Pike and Horvath exist. This story makes us look at what we don't want to see and is told in a way that makes it impossi...more
This book blew my mind away and two months later after reading it, I can't find myself to forget it.
The story follows a boy that has grown up in a not-so-safe environment. A series of events happens and each one leads up the most frustrating ending I have ever read. (And that's saying a lot because it like to read)
You will laugh and I will guarantee you that you will cry. The book is amazing and is number one out of all the books I have ever read. You will not regret buying this book. I read...more
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 29 30 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
  •  Out of Nowhere
  • The Witch Collector Part I
  • The Namesake
  • Marco Impossible
  • A Trick of the Light
  • Pieces
  • Wise Young Fool
  • Dear Life, You Suck
  • I'm With Stupid (Stupid Fast #3)
  • Fitz
  • Louder Than Words
  • Sex & Violence
  • Nine Days
  • Manicpixiedreamgirl
  • Yaqui Delgado Wants to Kick Your Ass
  • Somebody Up There Hates You
  • Revenge of a Not-So-Pretty Girl
Something Like Hope The 7 Secrets of Slim People The Seven Secrets of Slim People

Share This Book

“If life is hard and we don't celebrate the small accomplishments, what's left?” 3 likes
More quotes…