109th out of 305 books
—
485 voters
The Drowning Tree
by
Carol Goodman (Goodreads Author)
August Penrose created the stained glass 'Lady Window' to adorn the chapel of the university he founded for the daughters of the women who worked in his factory, the Rose Glass Works. Depicting his wife, Eugenie, as the Lady of Shallot, it's a mesmerising portrait that has come to embody the spirit of the school itself. But now, eighty years after it was created, the Lady...more
Paperback
Published
March 3rd 2005
(first published June 29th 2004)
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
2,970)
Jul 25, 2007
Eilene
rated it
4 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Recommends it for:
people who like myths
Shelves:
fondmemories
Once again, Goodman delivers with a fabulous setting seemingly drawn from her own imagination. I would wager that Goodman has spent time in upstate New York, because she writes of the place as if she knows it, as if she has thought it was beautiful for a long time. And it sounds amazing, her descriptions make me want to visit so much more than any of those "Discover (insert state here)" commercials I see on television.
The Drowning Tree also has that element of myth woven into the story. The bac...more
The Drowning Tree also has that element of myth woven into the story. The bac...more
Carol Goodman continues with her theme of secrets-from-the-past in her third book. Once again, she's created a world that I became completely absorbed in and a mystery that I couldn't figure out. Each time I thought "ah ha, THIS is what happened" the main character thought of it herself and sent the story in another direction by disproving it.
It happens too often that I love someone's debut novel and then end up disappointed in everything that follows, so I'm really glad Goodman isn't falling vi...more
It happens too often that I love someone's debut novel and then end up disappointed in everything that follows, so I'm really glad Goodman isn't falling vi...more
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
My sister gave me this to read in hospital after one of my surgeries years ago. It was ok. Setting was well-drawn, but characters were pretty one-dimensional and the denouement was fairly predictable. It was a good book for the purpose, which was escaping into something else for awhile and not needing to think while I did it.
The book would definitely have been better if I hadn't read it right after one of Goodman's others, The Lake of Dead Languages. Of the two, I liked the other better, but I'...more
The book would definitely have been better if I hadn't read it right after one of Goodman's others, The Lake of Dead Languages. Of the two, I liked the other better, but I'...more
"It’s been thirteen years since I last saw Neil – and fourteen years since we both nearly drowned in the river – and I still dream about him every night, and because he told me once that he believed that we could visit each other in our dreams, I always have the feeling that that is what he’s doing – coming to me in my dreams each night." – The Drowning Tree
Carol Goodman’s interest in Latin and Art and Literature is obvious. The first novel I read by her, The Lake of Dead Languages concerned a L...more
Carol Goodman’s interest in Latin and Art and Literature is obvious. The first novel I read by her, The Lake of Dead Languages concerned a L...more
When I started this book, I was looking forward to a good mystery - something that really pulled me in from Page 1. I will say that this book captured my attention with the Hudson River backdrop. Goodman did an excellent job with the setting; she truly made me smell the water and see some of the old buildings and statues in my mind's eye. There was a good mystery to this story as well. I confess that I'm generally always interested when family secrets and mental institutes are involved, and this...more
Mar 13, 2012
Laura
rated it
5 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Recommends it for:
Mystery lovers, mythology lovers, imaginative people
This is by far my favorite Carol Goodman book. I love the characters in it, the elements of mythology, the art, the settings, all of it. It's also one of the saddest books I've read. When I read this book the first time, in high school, it was probably the saddest book I had ever read, and it took me about a week to get the story, and especially the ending, out of my head.
This book has a lot of elements in common with other Carol Goodman books, such as the protagonist being divorced, having a ch...more
This book has a lot of elements in common with other Carol Goodman books, such as the protagonist being divorced, having a ch...more
This is, perhaps, the fourth time that I've read The Drowning Tree. Carol Goodman is a beloved author, and I return to her whenever I want an escape book, one that is both engaging and intelligent. As I've commented before on Goodman's novels, she has the amazing talent of creating these fantasical landscapes and buildings that the reader will long to visit for themselves. She manages to interweave fairy tale and mythology into her stories and, like Kate Morton's work, often has a double-mystery...more
This was my third Carol Goodman novel and from the outset it's clear; she definitely has a formula down. Secrets from the past shedding light on the present, tight knit academia, meditations on art and literature, and gripping literary mysteries. I suppose I should feel as if I've read this before (and from the same author), but instead I'm waiting for a new one in the mail.
'The Drowning Tree' is the story of Juno McKay, former artist and current expert in stained glass. She lives in the same s...more
'The Drowning Tree' is the story of Juno McKay, former artist and current expert in stained glass. She lives in the same s...more
Upon reading the second Carol Goodman book that has been sitting on my bookshelf for too many years, and after having recently read Girl With the Dragon Tattoo after putting both off for fear they'd be nightmare-producing (I don't like scary books) I have learned three things:
1. The thriller/suspense genre is nothing like the horror genre. It doesn't produce nightmares.
2. After reading the three thriller/suspense genre books I've read recently, while realizing that thriller/suspense novels are c...more
1. The thriller/suspense genre is nothing like the horror genre. It doesn't produce nightmares.
2. After reading the three thriller/suspense genre books I've read recently, while realizing that thriller/suspense novels are c...more
This is the first Carol Goodman book that I have read and I was very impressed. A pleasant surprise! I don't know anything about the author but I would have to assume that she has a background in art history -- if not, she must have done some seriously extensive research to be able to write this one. The descriptions of the paintings, statues, and stained glass throughout and the way that story itself is woven into the art are beautifully written.
I selected the book from my shelf based on the d...more
I selected the book from my shelf based on the d...more
Why haven't I heard about this boook before? Astoundingly good.
Layers upon layers of symbolism and metaphor, from pre-Raphaelite art to Greek mythology. The layers show up not only in the characters' activities, but in the language the author chooses. The book is so lovely and carefully wrought, it makes my head spin (in a good way).
In addition, there is a mystery to be solved. Those of you who hate mysteries, I am one of you. Never read them. Nope. But I was sucked into this one by not knowing...more
Layers upon layers of symbolism and metaphor, from pre-Raphaelite art to Greek mythology. The layers show up not only in the characters' activities, but in the language the author chooses. The book is so lovely and carefully wrought, it makes my head spin (in a good way).
In addition, there is a mystery to be solved. Those of you who hate mysteries, I am one of you. Never read them. Nope. But I was sucked into this one by not knowing...more
When I finished "The Lake of Dead Languages" about a month ago, I couldn't wait to read more by Carol Goodman. I liked everything about it: the setting, the characters, the references to art, literature and classical mythology, and the mystery (although it wasn't very hard to solve). Those same elements make "The Drowning Tree" worth reading too, but the similarities go so far that I sometimes wondered whether I wasn't still reading the same book. Single mother with daughter faces mysterious dev...more
I read The Lake Of Dead Languages on the recommendation of an author I enjoy, and was intrigued enough by Carol Goodman's style to try out the rest of her books. As far as mystery and literary allusions go, this novel is even stronger than TLODL, but I felt it lacked something vital in its characterization of the protagonist, Juno. It wasn't that I didn't like her, it was that she felt hollow, almost like a marionette being used for the rest of the story to happen to and around her. Maybe it had...more
I’m not joking when I say Carol Goodman could be my idol. Granted, I’ve only read two of her books, but she’s exactly the kind of writer I hope to be some day. Her novels are full of artistic and literary themes, with beautifully dynamic settings. Who wouldn’t want to write such intriguingly mysterious books?
The Drowning Tree centers around Juno McKay as she’s forced to confront her past during a reunion at Penrose College. When her best friend, Christine Webb, is chosen to give a speech on a fa...more
The Drowning Tree centers around Juno McKay as she’s forced to confront her past during a reunion at Penrose College. When her best friend, Christine Webb, is chosen to give a speech on a fa...more
Gosh, this all just felt so FORCED. It seems obvious that Goodman has a passion for mythology and stained glass (what an odd combination). But I learned in my basic creative writing class that just because you're passionate about something doesn't many anyone else will be. You can't make people care about things; it's all about the characters and making the reader care about them. She was really trying hard to force a bond between two or three completely unrelated ideas. Ugh. It was awful. It le...more
This book fascinated me. Though not categorized as a mystery, it contained all the elments of such...plus so much more. An art hsitorian gives a lecture on a famous stained glass window at a prestigious university; her research seemed to show that the mythological figure in the window was not modeled by the university founder's wife (as had been believed), but by the wife's sister. After the lecture was delivered to a somewhat skeptical audience, the art historian was found dead...was it suicide...more
I tried to wade through all the pretentious quotes in Latin, the lessons in Greek mythology, the prestigious school name-dropping, among other things, but after 70 pages I still couldn't find a story in this book. If you're really interested in the art of stain-glass making or the rowing sport--crew, then you'll enjoy the tedious, mind-numbing descriptions that go on ad nauseam. Unfortunately, I don't find either subject very appealing, especially not in the dosages the author is handing out. Wh...more
This book was NOT a favorite of mine. The book is very descriptive and those descriptions were painfully simple and one dimensional. And the details were MANY. Forget subtle foreshadowing, when some little detail of note occurred in the book, the it was explained in such overabundant detail, and flaunted things that were painfully obvious observations. But this was not the end.... If this detail was then remembered by the main character, all the same information was written again as the small de...more
Jan 21, 2010
Marika Gillis
rated it
4 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Recommends it for:
Erin, Shannon, Andie
Juno's best friend, Christine, mysteriously disappears after giving a controversial speech about the influential founding family of the college they both attended. As Juno searches for answers about her friend's disappearance, her own dramatic past- the unplanned pregnancy that kept her from graduating, her former husband's attempt to drown Juno and her daughter, and his subsequent admittance to a nearby mental hospital- begins to emerge in uncomfortable and haunting ways.
Dark, mysterious, and f...more
Dark, mysterious, and f...more
I first discovered Carol Goodman this past summer and enjoyed the Seduction of Water and the Night Villa (gave them 4 stars each). I found this book at Goodwill for a dime, and enjoyed it immensely. Goodman weaves elements of art (specifically sculpture, painting, and stained glass), mythology, and academia into this literary thriller, while at the same time she explores the themes of love, friendship, and loss. I want my book club (or at least Annie and Alison) to read this so I can have someon...more
I had this for many years before picking it up. And I couldn't put it down. As with "Lakes of Dead Langauges, which I had read years before, this was a gripping novel. I was spellbound by the storyline, the mystery and the language. Both novels involve water, this a river and "Lake" a lake naturally and her words also flow like the current.
The novel makes many references to mythology and her imagery brought to mind the paintings I had studied in classical mythology of Waterhouse's "Lady of Shal...more
The novel makes many references to mythology and her imagery brought to mind the paintings I had studied in classical mythology of Waterhouse's "Lady of Shal...more
Juno is best friends with Christine and Juno falls in love with Brilliant who later tries to drown her n Bea which is his daughter...Brilliant gets locked up at Briarwood n gets on the drug Peridine 13 years after the accident ....then he slept with Christine once....got her pregnant ....she got killed by Neils psychiatrist because she was digging into old records n found out the doctor was slowly killing Neil ...Neil died with the psychiatrist in the water....Juno got away n ended up falling fo...more
In reading a thriller I usually try to fathom the who-dunnit as I go along, but the style in which Carol Goodmand writes captivated me from the start - beautiful prose, good combination of words and marvellous in-depth descriptions - that I never even tried doing so while reading 'The Drowning Tree'. I savored every chapter, not wishing the book to end, yet nearer the end I couldn't wait to find out the denouement! :-) Upon hindsight I realized there certainly were revelations to let me second-g...more
Not my favorite out of all the Carol Goodman books, but as all her books do for me it is light reading that takes me away into whatever place she's imagined. Usually the place is somewhere back East near NY, but her writing takes you into a fairytale setting with art and English history mixed with mysterious tales. There is always a man or two involved as the main character who is a single mother of a daughter, finds herself in the middle of a mystery in which she is deeply embedded and kind of...more
Well-written and with complex characters, this is an engaging read that did not disappoint. It involves close friendships that build foundations for a lifetime, troubling secrets, an interesting historical mystery, a lovely landscape and sense of place, and love that is lost and found. The twists are surprising, but not very intense and the storyline was drawn out a bit at times. What Goodman does well (and many others do not) is allows you to like the characters and root for them. You become in...more
This is my first Carol Goodman novel and I think I'll go back and read her earlier work. This was a really good novel. This is such a well written book - the imagery created by the author is just wonderful! I enjoyed the intermix of the modern mystery and the ancient with the use of mythology throughout the book. Really effective way to tell this particular story!
This wasn't an 'easy' read yet it wasn't what I'd characterize as difficult either. It felt a bit academic but perhaps that was more...more
This wasn't an 'easy' read yet it wasn't what I'd characterize as difficult either. It felt a bit academic but perhaps that was more...more
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
Ahh, Carol Goodman. Returning to her novels is like ordering your favorite meal at a restaurant. You know exactly what to expect and will most likely enjoy it. I certainly enjoyed this one.
Juno McKay sees her best friend Christine Webb off at the train station after their fifteenth-year college reunion. Christine had just delivered a lecture at the Penrose College Library, shocking the crowd with little known details about the founding Penrose family. The next day, Christine disappears.
I find...more
Juno McKay sees her best friend Christine Webb off at the train station after their fifteenth-year college reunion. Christine had just delivered a lecture at the Penrose College Library, shocking the crowd with little known details about the founding Penrose family. The next day, Christine disappears.
I find...more
| topics | posts | views | last activity | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| the book 2 | 2 | 14 | Nov 30, 2011 01:25pm |
Carol Goodman is the author of The Lake of Dead Languages. Her work has appeared in such journals as The Greensboro Review, Literal Latt, The Midwest Quarterly, and Other Voices. After graduation from Vassar College, where she majored in Latin, she taught Latin for several years in Austin, Texas. She then received an M.F.A. in fiction from the New School University. Goodman currently teaches writi...more
More about Carol Goodman...
Share This Book
15 trivia questions
More quizzes & trivia...
“You told me trees could speak
and the only reason one heard
silence in the forest
was that they had all been born knowing different languages.
That night I went into the forest
to bury dictionaries under roots,
so many books in so many tongues
as to insure speech.
and now this very moment,
the forest seems alive
with whispers and murmurs and rumblings of sound
wind-rushed into my ears.
I do not speak any language
that crosses the silence around me
but how soothing to know
that the yearning and grasping embodied
in trees’ convoluted and startling shapes
is finally being fulfilled
in their wind shouts to each other.
Yet we who both speak English
and have since we were born
are moving ever farther apart
even as branch tips touch.”
—
9 people liked it
More quotes…
and the only reason one heard
silence in the forest
was that they had all been born knowing different languages.
That night I went into the forest
to bury dictionaries under roots,
so many books in so many tongues
as to insure speech.
and now this very moment,
the forest seems alive
with whispers and murmurs and rumblings of sound
wind-rushed into my ears.
I do not speak any language
that crosses the silence around me
but how soothing to know
that the yearning and grasping embodied
in trees’ convoluted and startling shapes
is finally being fulfilled
in their wind shouts to each other.
Yet we who both speak English
and have since we were born
are moving ever farther apart
even as branch tips touch.”

Loading...










view all 4 comments






















