100th out of 411 books
—
412 voters
The Captive Mind
The Captive Mind begins with a discussion of the novel Insatiability by Stanisław Ignacy Witkiewicz and its plot device of Murti-Bing pills, which are used as a metaphor for dialectical materialism, but also for the deadening of the intellect caused by consumerism in Western society. The second chapter considers the way in which the West was seen at the time by residents o...more
Paperback, 272 pages
Published
August 11th 1990
by Vintage
(first published 1953)
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
1,794)
This is a book of acute psychological understanding, commiserative rumination, and towering moral fibre. Miłosz, a Lithuanian-Pole—a member of the untermenschen that Hitler deemed so pernicious to the rightful ascendancy of the Master Race—was raised imbibing enough of the West, whilst soaking in the East, to enable a judicious and sagacious appraisal of the Soviet Totalitarianism that overwhelmingly blanketed the entirety of Central and Eastern Europe in the aftermath of the Third Reich's colla...more
Feb 24, 2011
John David
rated it
3 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
modern-history,
philosophy
“There are occasions when silence no longer suffices, when it may pass as an avowal. Then one must not hesitate. Not only must one deny one’s true opinion, but one is commanded to resort to all ruses to deceive one’s adversary. One makes all the protestations of faith that can please him, one performs all the rites one recognizes to be the most vain, one falsifies one’s own books, one exhausts all possible means of deceit.” – Arthur Gobineau, from ‘Religions and Philosophies of Central Asia’
“The...more
“The...more
It has been an illuminating and deeply moving experience over the last several months to read or re-read books by Hungarian, Russian and Polish authors, from John Paul II to Anna Akhmatova.
These Eastern and Central European authors have insights into the tragedy of Western civilisation that seem unknown, and are certainly still ignored, in Western Europe and the rest of the world that is under its influence.
This wonderful book by the great Lithuanian-Polish poet Czeslaw Milosz, so exhilirating...more
These Eastern and Central European authors have insights into the tragedy of Western civilisation that seem unknown, and are certainly still ignored, in Western Europe and the rest of the world that is under its influence.
This wonderful book by the great Lithuanian-Polish poet Czeslaw Milosz, so exhilirating...more
The context in which I read this book was exceptionally perfect. After traveling for several weeks and reading many works of historical fiction about wars, occupations, and eastern european dictatorships in the 20th century, this book was recommended to me by a surly, cell phone hating, beardy long-hair in Halifax. Ok great! The philosophical and academic tone of the book means that each page demands full attention, and much time for reflection... I happened to pick this book up on the way to th...more
Milosz provides a haunting portrayal of intellectual life within Soviet Poland, revealing with lucid language the overwhelming pressures to conform that the Polish intellectual and artist faced. This book struck me all the more for the author's refusal to condemn those who yielded to the Soviet state's influence, and Milosz's unwavering ability to avoid dehumanizing caricatures. Reading as an American who grew up in the post-Soviet era (having entered Kindergarten the year the wall fell) I might...more
This book is really a 2.5 stars for the intriguing ideas to the reason communism is the worst system in the world. Communism treats individuals as clogs in the machine that is the communist society. Ironically in trying to free the proletariat from the emptiness of being a "machine" in the capitalist factories, communism creates a society in which all men feel like machines. Milosz created this book because he sees beauty in individuals that makes up humanity.
Until this book, I failed to see how...more
Until this book, I failed to see how...more
initial impressions (6/15)
This might be like that Social Construction of Reality book I tried to read last month, where I'm just too stupid to get it, but so far I'm enjoying whatever misunderstanding I'm taking away from this book. At first I thought it was a novel and he was making up this fake sci-fi novel where everyone goes anti-Atlas Shrugged and all the intelligensia take the blue pill (red pill?) and get taken over by dumbing-down-ing Totalitarianism, but then he makes this reference to...more
This might be like that Social Construction of Reality book I tried to read last month, where I'm just too stupid to get it, but so far I'm enjoying whatever misunderstanding I'm taking away from this book. At first I thought it was a novel and he was making up this fake sci-fi novel where everyone goes anti-Atlas Shrugged and all the intelligensia take the blue pill (red pill?) and get taken over by dumbing-down-ing Totalitarianism, but then he makes this reference to...more
Apr 24, 2013
Lorenzo
rated it
4 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
2013-readings,
aaa-my-library
I'm not an avid reader of essays - well, actually I have a tendency to keep them out from my bookshelves -, but 'The Captive Mind' is a different matter.
As some earlier Goodreads reviewer stated: 'This book has some power'.
Well, a Hell of a lot of power, indeed!
'The Captive Mind' is an extraordinary study on the different behaviors of human beings when they are engulfed by history.
At first it was all but easy to get into the spirit of the book, but then the whole fruitful meditation took off fr...more
Jest to ważna książka, którą warto przeczytać. Pomimo, że jest parabolą, rzuca światło na sytuację w powojennej Polsce. Mnie właśnie bardziej zaciekawił wątek lokalny, niż ponadczasowe przesłanie dzieła, które odczytuję jako przestrogę przed systemami totalitarnymi. Ciekawy jest też opis Europy przedwojennej. Antagonizmy, które wówczas dominowały na naszym kontynencie nieuchronnie prowadziły do wojny. Byłoby głupotą i ignorancją lekceważyć globalne zagrożenie, jakie stanowiły ówczesne Niemcy i Z...more
While the political analysis of the co-opted intellect was first-rate, the memoir sections--which were intended to provide examples of individuals who surrendered their personal philosophies to the collective will of Stalinism--came across as flat and distant, primarily because he referred the people he knew as Alpha, Beta, Gamma, and Delta. While the aliases likely protected both the author and his subjects from recriminations, it had the effect of reducing people to archetypes, which, ironical...more
What happens to an artist living in a totalitarian regime? Take your answer from Czeslaw Milosz, who knew better than almost anyone, living in Nazi-occupied Warsaw. This interesting and thoughtful series of essays and arguments is a compelling glimpse at the interaction between war and culture.
I really love his concluding paragraph, too:
"When, as my friend suggested, I stand before Zeus (whether I die naturally, or under sentence of History) I will repeat all this that I have written as my defe...more
I really love his concluding paragraph, too:
"When, as my friend suggested, I stand before Zeus (whether I die naturally, or under sentence of History) I will repeat all this that I have written as my defe...more
I started reading this book somewhere in April last year, then abandoned it due to travel schedules, and have been reading it amidst different books since last month. A long drawn read sometimes hampers a reading experience, but not when the book has been written with as much clarity as Czeslaw Milosz has accorded the Captive Mind.
Milosz, a Polish writer, lived through the Warsaw uprising of 1944 and the Russian rule in Poland, and initially lent his cooperation to the Communist government by be...more
Milosz, a Polish writer, lived through the Warsaw uprising of 1944 and the Russian rule in Poland, and initially lent his cooperation to the Communist government by be...more
While I wish there had been more context given for the material (maybe when the book was written dialectical materialism and the time frame of Poland's involvement in WWII were self evident, but it's been a while since I learned about them--that is, since high school), it was enlightening to read this account of culture and allegiance cast in the frame of the possible historical inevitability, and to have it brought home just how fragile the systems of civilization within which we function reall...more
quite an interesting book about communism essentially but also touches on capitalism = focus is on the polish russian, luthuanian, latvian areas and the communism there. were not that many wow moments in the book but as its short its certainly worth a read. there are a couple really horrifying concentration camp scenes (jews getting off the train and a mother trying to deny a 3 year old is her baby even though the baby is calling her mama mama amidst tears) - shit did this sort of stuff really h...more
I just could not stand the authors writing. It was especially disappointing as I think the author had a lot of interesting and relevant things to say about a number of issues from Totalitarianism and Communism to the the effects of war on the mind. It just did not pull together for me. I thought the last four chapters which were supposed to be the "pinnacle" of this work felt really detached and were terribly delivered. Making the people unrealatable by omitting names, focusing on famous writers...more
The Captive Mind has been described as one of the finest studies of the behavior of intellectuals under a repressive regime. In the preface Miłosz observed that "I lived through five years of Nazi occupation . . . I do not regret those years in Warsaw". But it is his analysis of Poland and her intellectuals under the heel of Soviet Communism that is the primary content of this book. Through the examples of four intellectuals Milosz is able to capture the psychological impact on the lives of his...more
This book was written by a Polish author in the 1950s, when Poland was under Communist rule. The author takes a philosophical approach, with a series of essays on various intellectuals who fell prey to totalitarian temptations. The author examines each case, and discusses why he believes the individual in question reacted as he did. The book examines what totalitarianism does to the mind of the average person.
Jul 22, 2012
Val
rated it
4 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
world-tour,
world-tour-2013
When Poland was liberated from Nazi rule many people, including Czeslaw Milosz, saw socialism or communism as the best or only way forward. It was only later, as 'socialist realism' began to stifle independent thought, that Milosz exiled himself from his country and its government. This book is his intellectual journey. He shares with Orwell and Camus the distinction of being criticised for his anti-totalitarian polemic against Stalinist communism and for 'being a communist'. Anyone who can't se...more
An excellent read and justifiably a classic. It's certainly a dated piece, as political works usually are, and yet Milosz's instance on confining his commentary to his own experience and epoch (i.e., Nazi and Soviet occupation) makes it a timeless work of intellectual history. Particularly salient are his observations about the function and psychology of the artist in society. Just read it.
Quando la Storia si è sostituita a Dio, ovvero quando non solo era impedito scrivere ciò che si sentiva ma anche pensare dopo aver vissuto totalitarismi, guerre e rischiato di perdere identità nella tempesta della prima metà del secolo scorso. Eppure non è un saggio, ma un narrare fluido e poetico che entra dentro.
Interesting to read about the totalitarian mindset from a psychological perspective. Thought his approach of writing portraits of those he knew when he was young and how they changed once they began to see History and Progress as twin gods was extremely effective. The last chapter about the Baltics, specifically the last page, brought tears to my eyes, really the perfect culmination, very artful and moving. What I found myself thinking of most of all were parallels with today in terms of mindset...more
In the wake of WW II many French intellectuals were enamored of Communism. Milosz, then the cultural attachee of the Polish embassy in Paris, knew better, having survived the "liberation" of Lithuania by the Russians, under which sixty percent of the intelligentsia disappeared in the direction of Siberian labor camps.
However, Milosz's main fascination is not with those of his colleagues who simply vanished, but with his fellow writers and artists cunning enough to have gained state support. Thi...more
However, Milosz's main fascination is not with those of his colleagues who simply vanished, but with his fellow writers and artists cunning enough to have gained state support. Thi...more
I was very disappointed having had high expectations from what I knew of the reputation of the book. The first two chapters were "4 stars" while the rest merited only 2. I particularly disliked Milosz' chapters on "representative" writers (that's how I interpreted them): "Alpha," "Beta," "Gamma" and "Delta." They were vague and Milosz would have better served (what I saw as) his goals by doing straight forward readings of their lives and works while making it clear that they were, while individu...more
May 23, 2008
Kelly
rated it
4 of 5 stars
Recommends it for:
cold war historians, those interested in philosophy or psychology
This book was absolutely fascinating. The arguments he made to explain the capitulation of writers and artists under communism were things I would have never thought of before. It's a good read to help blow away any bits of American propaganda about Soviets that are being taught in school still, and help you see the other side of the issue. Mind, this book was written by a man who left as well, so it isn't as if he agrees with the Soviets, he was actually forced out. It explains so much about ho...more
A critique on Communist and Western civilizations. Written by Nobel Prize Winner Czeslaw Milosz. Rather complicated, but thought-provoking. Described/discussed the materialism of the West and compared/contrasted it to the East. Also, I really liked his explanation of the almost schizophrenic nature many people in the East after WWII. Just going through everything, having no hope in mankind, being assaulted by Communism, pretending to believe in the New Faith, committing atrocities just to stay a...more
Yang minat sama buku ini silahkan ke Facebook Gerai Buku Kunto
https://www.facebook.com/media/set/?s...
https://www.facebook.com/media/set/?s...
There are no discussion topics on this book yet.
Be the first to start one »
Czesław Miłosz memorialised his Lithuanian childhood in a 1955 novel,
The Issa Valley
, and in the 1959 memoir
Native Realm
. After graduating from Sigismund Augustus Gymnasium in Vilnius, he studied law at Stefan Batory University and in 1931 he travelled to Paris, where he was influenced by his distant cousin Oscar Milosz, a French poet of Lithuanian descent and a Swedenborgian. His first volume...more
More about Czesław Miłosz...
Share This Book
No trivia or quizzes yet. Add some now »
“When, as my friend suggested, I stand before Zeus (whether I die naturally, or under sentence of History)I will repeat all this that I have written as my defense.Many people spend their entire lives collecting stamps or old coins, or growing tulips. I am sure that Zius will be merciful toward people who have given themselves entirely to these hobbies, even though they are only amusing and pointless diversions. I shall say to him : "It is not my fault that you made me a poet, and that you gave me the gift of seeing simultaneously what was happening in Omaha and Prague, in the Baltic states and on the shores of the Arctic Ocean.I felt that if I did not use that gift my poetry would be tasteless to me and fame detestable. Forgive me." And perhaps Zeus, who does not call stamp-collectors and tulip-growers silly, will forgive.”
—
3 people liked it
More quotes…

Loading...







































Mar 30, 2012 01:25am
Apr 17, 2012 08:30pm