29th out of 114 books
—
45 voters
Evolution: What the Fossils Say and Why It Matters
Over the past twenty years, paleontologists have made tremendous fossil discoveries, including fossils that mark the growth of whales, manatees, and seals from land mammals and the origins of elephants, horses, and rhinos. Today there exists an amazing diversity of fossil humans, suggesting we walked upright long before we acquired large brains, and new evidence from molec...more
Hardcover, 408 pages
Published
November 1st 2007
by Columbia University Press
(first published 2007)
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
1,630)
Darwin. Evolution. The two terms are now synonymous and inextricably associated with another, more unfortunate pairing: controversial and polarizing. Indeed, depending on which side of the ideological divide one falls, evolution can denote very different things to different people, regularly conjuring up deep-seated emotion and animosity.
It’s no surprise why. Evolution’s conflict with a literal exegesis of Genesis is a not insignificant problem for religious fundamentalists, including Charles D...more
Despite Prothero's somewhat agitated style (the list of things that annoy varies from the incorrect use of the word fish to creationist distortions of science) this is possibly my favourite of the evolution primers around at the moment. Prothero discusses comprehensively the various mechanisms currently thought to contribute to evolution, and the varied areas of scholarship, from molecular biology to paleontology, which contribute to the field. He has a much more expansive view of evolution than...more
"Evolution: What the Fossils Say and Why It Matters" is the best book I have ever read emphasizing the importance of the fossil record as the indisputable "facts" of biological evolution, documenting the history of life on Planet Earth. Its publication is long overdue, and yet, remains quite timely, when major publishers like Simon and Schuster have mistakenly published sterling examples of mendacious intellectual pornography like Michael Behe's "The Edge of Evolution". Indeed, Prothero's book o...more
Evolution: What the Fossils Say and Why it Matters by Donald R. Prothero
“Evolution: What the Fossils Say and Why it Matters" is an outstanding book that focuses on the fossil record as strong evidence for evolution. It covers the science of evolution with great expertise and eloquence. The book is basically broken out into two main parts. The first part focuses on the science or progression of evolution while the second part gets into the more technical and fossil case studies. Dr. Prothero’s sc...more
“Evolution: What the Fossils Say and Why it Matters" is an outstanding book that focuses on the fossil record as strong evidence for evolution. It covers the science of evolution with great expertise and eloquence. The book is basically broken out into two main parts. The first part focuses on the science or progression of evolution while the second part gets into the more technical and fossil case studies. Dr. Prothero’s sc...more
I very much enjoyed this book. Though I was familiar with a lot of the arguments, it was great to have an overview from an expert in the field. It's remarkable how many incredible specimens have been discovered even in the last 30 years, and how they have added clarity to the picture of the past. It's also amazing how well defined a lot of the "transitions" are in the record. (sea to land, reptile-like to mammal, dinosaur to bird, etc.) I appreciated the introduction to cladistics, as well.
I'd h...more
I'd h...more
Fascinating read. Very enlightening on the subject.
I mainly bought this book because I thought it would cover some of the more unique factors and discoveries within evolutional history. While it does contain some interesting facts about evolution (like how whales and snakes still have hips), an portion of the book is spent discussing the ignorance and deceitful tactics of fanatical creationists; which is understandable given the fact that prothero has dedicated his life to the subject and has t...more
I mainly bought this book because I thought it would cover some of the more unique factors and discoveries within evolutional history. While it does contain some interesting facts about evolution (like how whales and snakes still have hips), an portion of the book is spent discussing the ignorance and deceitful tactics of fanatical creationists; which is understandable given the fact that prothero has dedicated his life to the subject and has t...more
This isn't a book for the feint of heart. The first half is thorough and convincing, the second half is a bit overwhelming. The second half of Evolution is devoted to going over fossil evidence, and it's very detailed and technical. Overall I thought this was a fine book, and a good one if you need a reference book. My only complaint is Prothero's intense interest with creationism, it can get a bit distracting, though in the light of the immensely overwhelming evidence in favor of evolution I su...more
This is an outstanding book. Donald Prothero has put together an extremely comprehensive account of the fossil record as it stands today. There are chapters on the origin of life; prokaryote development; microfossils; the evolution of the backbone and the first vertebrates; the transition from fish to tetrapods; from primitive tetrapods to amniotes; the evolution of dinosaurs and from avian dinosaurs to birds; from primitive synapsids to mammals; and the evolution of humans.
Each chapter lists th...more
Each chapter lists th...more
I sincerely hope that I never again read or hear an argument against the truth of evolution based on the lack of transitional fossils - or so-called "missing links" - from anyone who hasn't read this book.
Prothero describes dozens of transitional fossils here - and to be extremely generous in giving creationists the benefit of the doubt, many of these have been discovered and/or documented in the past 20 to 30 years, so anyone who relies on data older than that will find some gaps. But that is...more
Prothero describes dozens of transitional fossils here - and to be extremely generous in giving creationists the benefit of the doubt, many of these have been discovered and/or documented in the past 20 to 30 years, so anyone who relies on data older than that will find some gaps. But that is...more
Outstanding treatment of the subject matter. Works great on the high-side of intermediate level as there are a great many Eras and fossils discussed in rather rapid succession, so a solid precursory knowledge of paleontology is helpful. I actually did not expect such a bruising account of the Creationist mythology that was offered in the first half of the book, and then made example of to a lessor degree as the book went on, but Prothero fully excoriates the phonies with absolute contempt, and y...more
I'd unreservedly recommend this book to anyone curious about the evidence for evolution. It appears to be targeted at the scientifically interested but non palaeontologically educated reader.
The production values of the book are superb and, like its text, it oozes business-like quality. It is hardback, printed on a beautiful heavy paper stock. The author's style is very clear and remarkably concise, considering his academic background. (My past experience is that many learned gentlemen - and it...more
The production values of the book are superb and, like its text, it oozes business-like quality. It is hardback, printed on a beautiful heavy paper stock. The author's style is very clear and remarkably concise, considering his academic background. (My past experience is that many learned gentlemen - and it...more
It's my own fault that I did not read the book description or the other reviews here closer. I didn't get the impression from the book description that so much of it would be devoted to countering the fallacious arguments of the creationist-ID crowd. Not expecting that, and not one needing to be convinced, I was a little annoyed at all the time and ink spent describing and shooting down the creationist positions. For those who need a little more convincing, or who regularly debate creationists,...more
This book gives the person interested in fossils a look at what's been found in the last 20 or 30 years. It's fascinating stuff! I didn't want to put the book down at times.
Prothero goes from detailing both the finding of the fossils and the fossils themselves, to how pissed he is at creationists who do no actual science at all, then spend their time taking pot shots at the work of real scientists, and quote-mining their works. I enjoyed Prothero's attacks on such people, Duane Gish most promin...more
Prothero goes from detailing both the finding of the fossils and the fossils themselves, to how pissed he is at creationists who do no actual science at all, then spend their time taking pot shots at the work of real scientists, and quote-mining their works. I enjoyed Prothero's attacks on such people, Duane Gish most promin...more
This is a very entertaining but intellectually rigorous history of all that constitutes the fossil record AND it is current research and results.
It is a very absorbing combination of firsthand observation and scientific discovery abd analysis.Where are the legs that Creationists and ID advocates stand on? After this they have none!
It is a very absorbing combination of firsthand observation and scientific discovery abd analysis.Where are the legs that Creationists and ID advocates stand on? After this they have none!
Very good book. Prothero isn't a great writer, and the prose is awkward at times, but this book (especially the second half) is a relentless barrage of well-documented facts about the existence of the transitional forms and fossils creationist nut jobs like Duane Gish and Ken Ham like to pretend do not exist. If anyone open minded doubts that the fossil record is best explained by the theory of evolution then this book should convince them.
Prothero doesn't target religious belief in general and...more
Prothero doesn't target religious belief in general and...more
This book has some great images, figures, and information, but it's real value lies in the introductory material dealing with the evolution/creation controversy and WHY it exists. I have read far and wide on the topic, and this is one of the best treatments of the matter I have come across.
I do take issue with a few of the figs, in particular 8.18 on p.195. It is highly misleading, as there have never been any dragonflies or dragonfly-like creatures that had more than at most 3 pairs of wings (e...more
I do take issue with a few of the figs, in particular 8.18 on p.195. It is highly misleading, as there have never been any dragonflies or dragonfly-like creatures that had more than at most 3 pairs of wings (e...more
Very good & thorough answer to silly creationist and I.D. critiques of evolution. The first half of the book explains what science is and how it works, what the theory of evolution is and how it works. The second half of the book follows the fossil trail of evolution through the geological strata. I am constantly amazed at how incredible the true history of life on this planet is; and at how much more amazing these facts are than the hoped for fantasies of creationists.
My wife made fun of m...more
My wife made fun of m...more
Apr 14, 2012
Ahmad
marked it as to-read
لو كان هناك كتاب جاد يسعى لإثبات الداروينية بطريقة "علمية" ممنهجة فهو هذا. تحد حقيقي يجب على كل من يسعى لتسويغ نفيه للانتخاب الطبيعي على أسس العلم الحديث أن يخوضه
قرأت بعضه ولي عودة إن شاء الله.
قرأت بعضه ولي عودة إن شاء الله.
Scientific language and readability come together in this book. I was surprised by some things that he presented and can't wait to discuss them with my paleontology professor. However, while I understand that a war has to be waged against the creationists, I became bored with the constant ranting. I understand that most of the leaders of the creationist movement have not actually studied fossils or have actual scientific training, I don't need to be told eighteen times. Given that, the last chap...more
This is one of several recently published books that address some of the "objections" to modern evolution, in this case the claims by some that there are "gaps" in the fossil record, or otherwise that the fossil record really doesn't support the evolutionary hypotheses. Prothero addresses and dismantles these claims one by one, showing how they are either based on hopelessly out-of-date results, or are in some cases willful distortions of known data. For those who wonder whether "creation scienc...more
Incredible book. See mini-review at http://relaxandhavefun.com/?p=152
This book is by far the most detailed pop science ook on the fossil record that I have been ale to find. Growing up I often heard that the fossil record was a total embarrassment for evolutionists due to the lack of transitional species. I would love for someone to read this book and still try and argue that the fossil record does not support evolution. The evidence for evolution is totally overwhelming and this book is a must read book if you are npinterested in evolution.
Anyone who has to debate the fossil record with a creationist should read this book. It is authoritative and well-written and comprehensive and completely demolishes the anti-evolution position with an abundance of facts and well-reasoned argument. It is also a great way to get a handle on the profound contributions of vertebrate paleontology to our understanding of the evolution of life on planet earth.
He spends the first half of the book explaining the basics of the scientific process and the fundamentals of evolution before diving into the fossils. It's great to see an explanation of the fossils by someone with first-hand knowledge. Prothero very thoroughly eviscerates the creationist arguments with pure evidence. The illustrations are especially illuminating.
Mar 10, 2010
Clay
marked it as abandoned-books-for-the-moment
I am enjoying this book, but I am DRAGGING through it.
As a geologist, most of this information is not new to me at all (sorry if that sounded arrogant). However, I do see it as possibly a good book to put on my shelf, if I am a professor at some point, to lone to students who are struggling to break free of their creationist upbringing.
As a geologist, most of this information is not new to me at all (sorry if that sounded arrogant). However, I do see it as possibly a good book to put on my shelf, if I am a professor at some point, to lone to students who are struggling to break free of their creationist upbringing.
A great book, full of all the information you need to understand why, indeed, the fossils matter and why they say what scientists say they do. He spares no criticism for the phony b.s. that is "intelligent design" (a philosophy of ignorance, as Neil deGrasse Tyson has often said) and holds nothing back. Fantastic, and everyone should read it.
There are no discussion topics on this book yet.
Be the first to start one »

Loading...






























Oct 27, 2012 11:36am