21st out of 183 books
—
57 voters
Homecoming
Growing up with his mother in Germany, Peter Debauer knows little about his father, an apparent victim of the Second World War. But when he stumbles upon a few pages from a long-lost novel, Peter embarks on a quest that leads him across Europe to the United States, chasing fragments of a story within a story and a master of disguises who may or may not exist. Homecoming is...more
Hardcover, 272 pages
Published
January 8th 2008
by Pantheon Books
(first published 2006)
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
1,798)
Perhaps more daring in conception but less well realized in execution than The Reader, Schlink's Homecoming uses Homer's Odyssey (in the sense of its being of the class of nostoi) as a metaphor for "homecoming." As is so often the case, this is an example of demanding too much of a metaphor. The basic idea is sound and interesting, but Schlink has relied too much on references to the details of the Odyssey appearing in strange ways throughout the narrative, which has the dual effects of strainin...more
Bernhard Schlink should have written an essay or article on the theory of law, justice and the philosophy of good and evil and left it at that. Instead he tried carve a story about a boy’s search for an absent father into this lecture. I think there are some interesting concepts explored in the book, and it had the potential to be another “The Reader”- his first novel, but it needed to be revised (more than once) and a heavy hand of editing would have helped too.
I like books that have a mytholo...more
I like books that have a mytholo...more
I discovered ‘Homecoming’ by Bernhard Schlink a few years back during one of my random browsing sessions at the bookstore. Schlink was more famous for his book ‘The Reader’ which was made into a movie of the same name and which won Kate Winslet her first Oscar. ‘Homecoming’ appealed to me because of its bookish cover and the plot. I thought I will read it for German Literature Month. It was gripping from the first page to the last. I finished reading it today. Here is what I think.
What I think
‘H...more
What I think
‘H...more
Homecoming is usually a memorable and happy experience however this journey is one filled with so many twist and turns I found myself lost on several occasions.
The story starts out simple enough. Young Peter travels across the German / Swiss boarder to visit his grandparents during the summer. The descriptions here are well done and easy to visualize. The stories were interesting.
Peter becomes infatuated with a story his grandparents are editing and is frustrated when he can’t find the rest of t...more
The story starts out simple enough. Young Peter travels across the German / Swiss boarder to visit his grandparents during the summer. The descriptions here are well done and easy to visualize. The stories were interesting.
Peter becomes infatuated with a story his grandparents are editing and is frustrated when he can’t find the rest of t...more
'We make our own truths and lies....Truths are often lies and lies truths...'
Bernhard Schlink stunned the reading public with his brilliant novel 1999 THE READER and once again with HOMECOMING he proves he is one of our most important authors today. Written in German and translated by Michael Henry Heim, HOMECOMING addresses, as did THE READER, the prolonged impact of the WW II fall of Germany on the lives of those who survived it. Not only is this a gripping story of a deserted son's search for...more
Bernhard Schlink stunned the reading public with his brilliant novel 1999 THE READER and once again with HOMECOMING he proves he is one of our most important authors today. Written in German and translated by Michael Henry Heim, HOMECOMING addresses, as did THE READER, the prolonged impact of the WW II fall of Germany on the lives of those who survived it. Not only is this a gripping story of a deserted son's search for...more
I am a big fan of Bernhard Schlink's "The Reader," even though it has now been Oprahfied. So I began "Homecoming" with high expectations. I was somewhat disappointed. "Homecoming," I believe, tries to do too much. It is a story of a lost father and the guilt and sense of mystery a young German feels as he tries to recuperate someone whose life was lived in the shadow of the Third Reich, but it is also organized around The Odyssey, attempting to play off that classic, and is, moreover, a meditati...more
This book showed much promise from the blurb on the back cover. I had read his other book The Reader before it was made into a film and really enjoyed it so naturally I did not hesitate to give this book a go. A fair go I did give it, 159 pages to be exact, and it went nowhere, well, nowhere I wanted to continue to go!
The premise of the book was good in that a man who had spent most of his childhood with his grandparents during the summer months realises that the have been writing manuscripts an...more
The premise of the book was good in that a man who had spent most of his childhood with his grandparents during the summer months realises that the have been writing manuscripts an...more
Fabulous! As much as I enjoyed his stories in Flights of Love, especially "The Circumcision", I absolutely loved this book. First, hats off to the translator. I am sure it's easier to translate a German language book into English, rather than, say, Russian to English, but this was done so well that the words just sang. A testament I'm sure to the author, but also to the translator, who has to pick the right English words to do the German justice. Fabulous.
Peter Debauer is a fabulous character. T...more
Peter Debauer is a fabulous character. T...more
So the criticism that the lady who gave me The Reader had of it was concerning this part where the main character goes skiing toward the end of the book and he skis in a teeshirt. And she was like "That just seemed over-the-top and melodramatic and idiotic to me, like [affects silly German accent:] 'Oh I am so German and desensitized I will just ski in the freezing cold in a teeshirt because I have no feelings after all that has befallen me,'" which, yeah, is pretty dumb, I guess, if you read it...more
Let me start of by saying this, may be a wonderful book but maybe just was not the perfect match for me. I've given it 3 stars based on my experience with it, not based on the author's talent.
There were a lot of philosophy references and existential thought comparisons. I have never been a philosophy student nor enjoyed the disputes and conversations of the whole existential thought movement, so with this in mind, it was a slightly difficult read for me. I enjoy a good story, simply. I do enjoy...more
There were a lot of philosophy references and existential thought comparisons. I have never been a philosophy student nor enjoyed the disputes and conversations of the whole existential thought movement, so with this in mind, it was a slightly difficult read for me. I enjoy a good story, simply. I do enjoy...more
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
The first two-thirds of this book were pretty good. We start with young Peter describing his childhood visits to his grandparents in Switzerland. His grandparents edit a series of light novels, one of which is the story of Carl, a German soldier, and his struggle to return home from the Russian front after WWII. Unfortunately, Peter has only the manuscript of the book, and the ending is missing. What happens when Carl returns home and finds his wife with another man and two small daughters? Does...more
Mar 02, 2009
Stephanie
rated it
2 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
found-in-translation
As befitting its title, the opening chapter of Homecoming is luminously nostalgic: the narrator recalls the train journeys he used to take by himself from post-war Germany to visit his grandparents in bucolic Switzerland.
But the comforting image of friendly train conductors and boat rides on a lake is swiftly dispensed with in the next chapter, in which the narrator recounts a harrowing series of truck rides. His single mother hadn't the fare for the train, and so cast her child upon the kindnes...more
But the comforting image of friendly train conductors and boat rides on a lake is swiftly dispensed with in the next chapter, in which the narrator recounts a harrowing series of truck rides. His single mother hadn't the fare for the train, and so cast her child upon the kindnes...more
A lecture/philosophical paper masquerading as a novel. The story, when the novel followed it, was interesting, but Schlink spent too much time lecturing to make it flow well. At one point, a character quoted someone he talked to ONE time. The quote went on for an entire page. Here's a sample:
"...and the willingness to turn the staid, mechanical world of the Enlightenment into an organic, creative world of excitement, to overcome untrammeled egoism and individualism by working together, to bridge...more
"...and the willingness to turn the staid, mechanical world of the Enlightenment into an organic, creative world of excitement, to overcome untrammeled egoism and individualism by working together, to bridge...more
Schlink's novel 'The Reader' was excellent so I was excited to read this however, I found 'Homecoming' to be disappointed. Don't get me wrong, Schlink is a great writer and first 2/3 of the book are very well written but the latter portions of the book I found to be flawed and dull indeed. Losing a star for that.
'Homecoming' involves a young German man's search for the father who disappeared before his birth and his father's involvement in the war.
My problem is Schlink's work seems to too high o...more
'Homecoming' involves a young German man's search for the father who disappeared before his birth and his father's involvement in the war.
My problem is Schlink's work seems to too high o...more
Feb 05, 2009
Bookmarks Magazine
added it
Bernhard Schlink's The Reader (1995), an Oprah Book Club pick, explored a love affair and wartime guilt. Homecoming ruminates on guilt, justice, history, identity, and evil, and it uses the idea of homecoming to chart Peter's journey toward truth and love. Lies surface and questions about identity emerge as Peter follows clues to the mysterious author's
I'm on a tear with Schlink novels. I love his simple clean prose (maybe it's the translation from German?). I appreciate his ambitious narrative conception, believeable characters, and organically intrinsic plotting, as well as a depth appreciation for the unique psychology of modern Germany. So I got sucked into this meditation on the classic mythology of Odysseus, the reinterpretation of themes in the telling of a German legal scholar and editor with a troubled past the reaches deeply into Naz...more
I liked this book. Or, I tried to like this book. No, I liked the bits of this book that didn't go over my head. I think I need a book club or something to discuss this book with.
I can't think of another book that I've read that deals with WWII from the German perspective (and how the German population suffered equal horrors at being bombed, lives shattered, generations warped, etc). I am unused to thinking of the Germans role in WWII in any way other than "villain" so it was weird to suddenly...more
I can't think of another book that I've read that deals with WWII from the German perspective (and how the German population suffered equal horrors at being bombed, lives shattered, generations warped, etc). I am unused to thinking of the Germans role in WWII in any way other than "villain" so it was weird to suddenly...more
The novel operates on several levels, which include the boy and the man Peter's search for his father, several attempts at recreating the Odyssey, and meditations on good and evil, deception and truth, and the function of law in Western society. I found the writing well done, and though there may be minor quibbles the translation, it worked well overall. However, I found most of the characters shallow, perhaps because the author intended them to be so, and the various locations in which action t...more
It took a while for me to figure out where Bernhard Schlink was going with this book. I loved The Reader, so thought I was in for another treat. Not so. I enjoyed the perspective of WW11 from a German insider, and the details of the fall of the Berlin Wall, there were some good quotes that I stopped and thought about but really the story did not grab me. I really did not enjoy the way the narrator kept finding meaning in pieces of an old novel he found and pieced together. It seemed too coincide...more
I love Bernard Schlink's writing. His discussion of the human toll of war, even generations later, is like a balm for the open wound.
Schlink's The Reader was an amazing book and Homecoming is equally remarkable. As the title suggests homecoming is explored with the backdrop of Germany after WWII. This was a difficult time for Germany, but also for other nations whose troops were returning home after the devastation of war. This powerful novel comments on evil, justice, ethics, and morals before...more
Schlink's The Reader was an amazing book and Homecoming is equally remarkable. As the title suggests homecoming is explored with the backdrop of Germany after WWII. This was a difficult time for Germany, but also for other nations whose troops were returning home after the devastation of war. This powerful novel comments on evil, justice, ethics, and morals before...more
Interesting story - using the Odyssey as a backdrop and homecoming template, young fatherless German comes across a series of clues pointing to the whereabouts of his long-vanished father. The tone of the book is very cold - cruel almost - how his mom and lover have almost no sympathy for his search and in many places attempt to obfuscate it. Enjoyable story but I, and probably most people liked The Reader better. I would love to read some meaningful modern German literature that had no links wi...more
The premise was interesting but disappointing in the end and I only finished Homecoming because it was for a book discussion group. The plot device of The Odyssey set in modern day got in the way of the story it was too obvious that Peter was making his life and the life of his father fit into the Odyssey, especially when Peter sets out to sleep with the types of women found The Odyssey. Many elements of the book seemed contrived or put into the book just to be in the book but really had no plot...more
Bernhard Schlinks Roman über mehr als nur eine Heimkehr zeichnet die Geschichte von Peter Debauer, der über die Geschichte einer Heimkehr, auf die er zufällig stösst, mehr über seine eigene Lebensgeschichte erfährt, indem er sich auf die Suche nach dem verlorenen gegangenen Schluss der Geschichte macht. Schlink versteht es, die Odyssee mit modernen Rechtstheorie zu verknöpfen und mit dem Hauptstrang des Romans zu verweben, ohne dass es langweilig oder anstrengend wird. Peters Beziehungn mit Barb...more
I really liked this book and read it while visiting Europe last summer. 'Home Coming" is a search for identity, a quest for one's roots, a judgment about what might be true or not. The story is set in Germany, World War II, a time of loss and turmoil. The antagonist Peter Debauer, slowly learns that the stories his mother has told him about his father begin to diverge more and more from reality. Schlink examines the question of what coming home means today intertwined with the eternal question o...more
The whole thing feels rather forced. It begins with an unlikely obsession (fragments of a long-lost novel that the narrator, Peter DeBauer just has to find out more about) becomes a search for his father who was supposed to have been killed in the war. But there are way too many far-fetched clues - people who remember conversations and incidents from over 40 years earlier, for example.
The characters themselves don't come alive. They're more like pieces in a chess game, and often seem to be ther...more
The characters themselves don't come alive. They're more like pieces in a chess game, and often seem to be ther...more
The story is perhaps well written, but I personally did not like Peter. He whines too much.
So the story pursues a few threads:
The Odyssey - the book itself, books Peter is reading based on the book, and Peter's own life of discovery.
justice - Peter's unfinished dissertation, his father's exploitation of the ideal.
homecomings - a partial book he read as a child - of a war hero returning to his wife, to find her with another man & 2 children... what happens when she opens the door? He pursues...more
So the story pursues a few threads:
The Odyssey - the book itself, books Peter is reading based on the book, and Peter's own life of discovery.
justice - Peter's unfinished dissertation, his father's exploitation of the ideal.
homecomings - a partial book he read as a child - of a war hero returning to his wife, to find her with another man & 2 children... what happens when she opens the door? He pursues...more
I have loved two other books by Schlink --- "The Reader" and "The Weekend". This book, however, is not his best by far. It contains self-conscious "puzzles" larded with theorizing. (I think that this is arid and that this type of contrivance should be left to Umberto Eco.) And all to show that our own personal homecomings are sometimes not easy given the vagaries of our lives and pasts, and even the lives and pasts of our mother and father.
(But I do like how Schlink makes passing references to t...more
(But I do like how Schlink makes passing references to t...more
Like "The Reader," "Homecoming" deals with the lingering effects of fascism on Germans who participated in it and those who didn't. Deals with the idea of justifying evil behavior by saying that in exceptional circumstances we are all capable of evil.
Plays with themes of the son's search for the missing father and the idea of homecoming in relation to "The Odyssey," giving the book a mythic overtone--in a less experimental fashion than Joyce.
The character of De Bauer the ex-Nazi, now a deconstr...more
Plays with themes of the son's search for the missing father and the idea of homecoming in relation to "The Odyssey," giving the book a mythic overtone--in a less experimental fashion than Joyce.
The character of De Bauer the ex-Nazi, now a deconstr...more
Le narrateur qui n'a jamais connu son p?re est hant? par cette absence. Il va tout mettre en ?uvre pour le retrouver. Ce livre est ax? sur la qu?te d'identit? et sur le mythe du "retour" de ce p?re absent dans sa famille. Tout au long du r?cit, l'auteur fait r?f?rence ? l'Odyss?e qu'il utilise comme fil conducteur.
Le livre est construit en une succession de chapitres tr?s courts ce qui hache ?norm?ment le r?cit. D'autre part, le narrateur laisse souvent court ? ses pens?es mais ces digressions s...more
Le livre est construit en une succession de chapitres tr?s courts ce qui hache ?norm?ment le r?cit. D'autre part, le narrateur laisse souvent court ? ses pens?es mais ces digressions s...more
There are no discussion topics on this book yet.
Be the first to start one »
Bernhard Schlink is a German jurist and writer. He became a judge at the Constitutional Court of the federal state of North Rhine-Westphalia in 1988 and has been a professor of public law and the philosophy of law at Humboldt University, Berlin, Germany since January 2006.
His career as a writer began with several detective novels with a main character named Selb--a play on the German word for "sel...more
More about Bernhard Schlink...
His career as a writer began with several detective novels with a main character named Selb--a play on the German word for "sel...more
Share This Book
13 trivia questions
More quizzes & trivia...
“I did not know that children think the hard questions they ask are easy and thus expect easy answers to them, and that they are disappointed when they get cautious, complex answers.”
—
6 people liked it
“The value of being brave, working hard, saving money keeping order depends on what it's for.”
—
2 people liked it
More quotes…

Loading...






























Apr 18, 2009 06:47am