214th out of 348 books
—
381 voters
Better Off: Flipping the Switch on Technology
by
Eric Brende
What is the least we need to achieve the most? With this question in mind, MIT graduate Eric Brende flipped the switch on technology. He and his wife, Mary, ditched their car, electric stove, refrigerator, running water, and everything else motorized or "hooked to the grid," and spent eighteen months living in a remote community so primitive in its technology that even the...more
Paperback, 234 pages
Published
August 2nd 2005
by Harper Perennial
(first published 2004)
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
2,429)
While it had an interesting premise, it didn't come close to living up to my expectations. A naive city boy decides to go "off the grid" for a year, but rather than try it on his own (a la Helen and Scott Nearing), he throws in the kitsch of moving into a community of religious folks akin to the Amish or Mennonites. He drags along some chick he knows (and marries for whatever reason) and spends 200 pages poorly documenting their experience. The style was bland and tedious, though the story could...more
I have recently learned that this kind of book is called "stunt nonfiction." The stunt, in this case, was author Brende and his wife living in an Amish-like community for 18 months and writing a book about it. The idea was to explore Brende's mixed feelings about technology by trying out life with little or no modern conveniences. It was all a little pat: their supportive community helped them avoid any real suffering as they learned how to live off the land, their experiences were almost entire...more
5/18/07- Purchased during a book bender at Powell's a few weeks back. Oddly enough, my profession is in information technology (although I'm more interested in the information side than the technology side when it comes to improving business performance.)
Looking forward to the read.
A review will follow...
6/30/07: I would recommend this book to anyone interested in contemplating their use of (addiction to?) modern "conveniences" and the personal, emotional, spiritual, physical and environmental e...more
Looking forward to the read.
A review will follow...
6/30/07: I would recommend this book to anyone interested in contemplating their use of (addiction to?) modern "conveniences" and the personal, emotional, spiritual, physical and environmental e...more
A good concept - one of those silly experiment for a year, back to nature books - that was pretty frustrating in the end. Very little about the actual work involved in living on an off-the-grid farm, and a terrible relationship with his wife where she was essentially disregarded throughout the book, made it much less good than I would like it to be. Sure, it made me more interested in living off the grid and growing my own food and not having a car - but I don't think I'd want to live in the sam...more
When did 3 paragraphs of "what I did on my summer vacation" turn into a genre of "goofy stuff I did for a year"? Mix a year (or 18 months) of finding one self and a word processor gets a autobiographical / self help / travelogues all in one. I'll admit, I usually mop it up and this was no exception. Take Barbara Kingsolver's Animal, Vegetable, Mineral. A lovely, in depth, well written exploration of a year creating new life patterns. In general, the substance Better Off was addressed living off...more
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
Billed as a story of a couple who "flipped the switch" on technology and moved to an Amish community, giving up electricity, running water, and everything else that comes along with it. This book is an interesting look into the Mennonite community and, without question, caused me to stop and think about my day-to-day consumption of technology.
It is, however, predominately from the perspective of a man, with little mention of his wife's experience. I really would like to have heard more about Mar...more
It is, however, predominately from the perspective of a man, with little mention of his wife's experience. I really would like to have heard more about Mar...more
Mar 28, 2009
Andrea
rated it
3 of 5 stars
Recommends it for:
wanna-be-luddites
Recommended to Andrea by:
Robert Pless
A bit indulgent, Better Off is nonetheless a compelling read for someone who dabbles in the notions of living with less and deliberate slowing down. It chronicles the eighteen month sojourn of a young MIT student and his wife in an Amish community, where they learn to make do without electricity. The purpose of their sudden immersion into luddism is to understand the impact of modern society's ubiquitous electronic gadgetry. Does it actually improve life or does it simply put us on a vicious cyc...more
Friendship, conversation, exercise, fresh air, all melded together into a single act of mutual self-forgetting. A truism in the economy of life with less technology-an ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure. In being slower, time is more capacious. The event is only in the moment. By speeding through life with technology, you reduce what any given moment can hold. By slowing down, you expand it.
Leisure didn't end when work began, but prevaded every moment of the day. Just as conviviality...more
Leisure didn't end when work began, but prevaded every moment of the day. Just as conviviality...more
I was torn between a three or four star rating for this book but settled on a three start because what starts out as a premise I already agree with and an experiment I've often dreamed of undertaking myself gets bogged down with a lot of contrived religiosity and a noticeable dose of sanctimoniousness. Coming from working in the IT world for over ten years, I've witnessed countless examples of how overwound and hopelessly dependent we've made ourselves on technology, despite the fact that its in...more
This book is a fairy thin novel that tells a interesting true story. Eric Brende is a MIT graduate and the writer of this book. It goes though his journey of living amish after meeting a strange man in a subway station that is the beginning of his journey. It starts out with a prologue of a story when he was in a fast food drive through, the man at the register was un-able to math manually after the cash register wasn't working. This got him thinking of how it would be without technology in our...more
There are many things not to like about this book, for sure: middle class white kid decides MIT isn't cool enough and decides to opt out of "society", but not before GETTING MARRIED (okay...) and then living with a group of Mennonites so they could survive...uh, I mean, learn from them. Add to that an unnecessarily flourish-y writing style (you're supposed to be keeping things simple, no?) and the pretentiousness has now turned off a good portion of your readership (who, interestingly enough, ha...more
This book was recommended by an acquaintance and somehow made it to the top of my to read list faster than other books. Every once in a while I have to find these "back to basic" books and sigh for a time with no computers and no phones. I loved working at a museum and cooking over an open hearth and the thrill of getting the bake oven going and making pies, breads and baked beans over warmed bricks and hot coals ... but I always loved being able to go home and take a hot shower. Maybe I fall in...more
To be fair and give full disclosure, I didn't finish reading this book. As I was reading it, I supposed there might have been a few things of worth to pull out of it, but I was so overwhelmed by how arrogant it was that I was done with it long before the book was over.
Eric Brende struck me as having such a 'me first' attitude that he didn't even write about other people like they were real. He was the only person who was described as having serious or complex thoughts and everyone else was descr...more
Eric Brende struck me as having such a 'me first' attitude that he didn't even write about other people like they were real. He was the only person who was described as having serious or complex thoughts and everyone else was descr...more
Brende disappoints. There are two major problems with his work. The first is that he isn't a very good writer. His sentences are rambling and overwrought, and it is often hard to discern his meaning. He also uses the parenthesis until it dies. The second problem is that he is on a very full bandwagon. He goes "off the grid" for a year, laments the current state of society, and then returns to that same society having made only minor (as far as I can tell from the text) life changes and insisting...more
This was an interesting book. It was not quite what I expected but it read nicely as a journal and account of the time spent living without electricity.
The author Eric Brende, and his wife decide to take eighteen months and live without the modern benefits of technology. This includes electricity, washing machines, and motor powered farm equipment. They also do without refrigeration and have to come up with a way to preserve their own food; largely this is done by canning. While some of this is...more
The author Eric Brende, and his wife decide to take eighteen months and live without the modern benefits of technology. This includes electricity, washing machines, and motor powered farm equipment. They also do without refrigeration and have to come up with a way to preserve their own food; largely this is done by canning. While some of this is...more
Better Off is as close to a contemporary 'Walden' as I've come across. And it's author, Eric Brende, is the real deal. This Yale, Washburn, and MIT grad is an expert on the interaction of society and technology. As part of his graduate research, he (and his new bride) takes a sabbatical to live among and study the lifestyle of an Old Order Anabaptist community that limits their use of technology. What he discovers there is told with excellent, evocative writing. With themes like the value of wor...more
First of all, a delightful book, heartfelt and well written. It's a parable with a lesson author Eric Brende proposes teach us, after first learning it himself, by direct experience.
We all feel overwhelmed by technology sometimes, usually after a computer crash, car breakdown, or something of that ilk. Brende empathizes and takes the extra step to say it's the machine's fault, not ours. Surely he's right: a good tool is one that makes you happy ("look how easy it is to smash open these coconuts...more
We all feel overwhelmed by technology sometimes, usually after a computer crash, car breakdown, or something of that ilk. Brende empathizes and takes the extra step to say it's the machine's fault, not ours. Surely he's right: a good tool is one that makes you happy ("look how easy it is to smash open these coconuts...more
To follow up the book Ecocities w/ Better Off at first seemed like it would be too much 'reality' reading for the summer, but Better Off was a surprisingly light read focusing on the people's story - then interweaving the less technology ideals.
The writing and story was good, but the ideas better. The highlight for me was the final chapter and epilogue. Especially since it had so many references to which I am familiar, "one night it was Henry Louis Gates going to a Spanish restaurant on the Camb...more
The writing and story was good, but the ideas better. The highlight for me was the final chapter and epilogue. Especially since it had so many references to which I am familiar, "one night it was Henry Louis Gates going to a Spanish restaurant on the Camb...more
While it's an interesting book on the joys of simple living, I found that there were some things that were either not mentioned or very "off" in Brende's description. He mentions Catholic vs Anabaptist leanings, but talks about religion as a component of living off the grid -- while he has questions about the orthodoxy of the church and boring church sermons, he doesn't have a problem with the basic concept of religion as an integral part of life there. I do. Every time I was interested or found...more
An interesting reflection on the role of technology and community in our lives from a Science & Technology Studies (STS) student (like me!) at MIT (unlike me :-p). Strong points awarded for the immersiveness of the experience, the easy to engage with writing, and the blending of the social, human, and technical. It was a relatively quick and easy read, and provokes reflection on a number of important questions.
Yet, at times it fell back on a simplistic characterization of technology free liv...more
Yet, at times it fell back on a simplistic characterization of technology free liv...more
I loved how this started out, because I identified with the general stance taken: instead of being an out-and-out Luddite, Brende posits himself as someone who merely wants to question the role of technology and be wary of humans serving it instead of the other way around. In other words: cautious and careful use, mixed with a feeling that less than the average American consumes is probably not a bad thing. As a result, he and his new wife spent eighteen months living with a quasi-Amish communit...more
I usually avoid "gimmick books," since they all follow the same cookie-cutter format: Author embarks on a radical experiment for a set period of time, testing the limits of some given idea. "Better Off" is no different, but I picked it up because I've recently been trying to live more essentially and mindfully (although I fully grasp the irony of reviewing it on an online reading log).
Author Eric Brende spends eighteen months in a Mennonite-style community (dubbed the "Minimites"), growing his...more
Author Eric Brende spends eighteen months in a Mennonite-style community (dubbed the "Minimites"), growing his...more
I'm an easy audience to please when it comes to 'this is what I did for one year' accounts. I love reading about these forays into completely different worlds and how the author was affected. Heck, someone could write a book about "a year of living off tag sales" and I'd pick it up. So, given that I'm a target audience for this book, I came out of it questioning the author more than enjoying his journey from the MIT campus into an Amish-like existence. (He never names the community he joins 'out...more
This is a book with a simple premise that I believe goes beyond its stated purpose, but in a good way. Eric Brende questions our reliance our modern technology. Is it a benefit or a burden? Thus, for his master's thesis at M.I.T. he gets married and moves to a quasi-Amish community in the Midwest. All their work is done by hand. There is very minimal technology. Brende and his wife even have to pump their own water and carry it into their house. They survive, even thrive, raising their own food...more
My freshman year in college, we studied the Amish in my philosophy class. We studied the way they think about the world, and as an extension of that, the way they live. As far as I know, I was the only one who was thinking the whole time, “That sounds great!” As you may have guessed by the fact that I’m posting this on a website, I did not end up going that direction. But I have often wished to simplify my life, and this book made me think that technologically may be the way to do it.
On the su...more
On the su...more
I blazed through the first fifty or so pages of the book, loving the premise, and initially, loving the author's take on the subject of self-sufficiency. I felt inspired to try a hand cranked washing machine and seek out other ways to minimize my dependency on electricity and unnecessary mechanization, but then things started to head south.
Perhaps it was the discussion of religious doctrine, which was interesting from a cultural standpoint at first, but soon began to make me feel claustrophobic...more
Perhaps it was the discussion of religious doctrine, which was interesting from a cultural standpoint at first, but soon began to make me feel claustrophobic...more
I saw this at the local library and immediately grabbed it. This kind of memoir (consumerism, sustainable living, off-grid thinking) is of great interest to me right now. Unfortunately, while the author certainly throws out some interesting ideas and writes a readable-enough book, ultimately I think that the story is very lacking in many ways.
Brende decides that life-as-we-know-it isn't working for him, and prompted by a chance meeting with an almost-Amish man on a train, he and his new wife so...more
Brende decides that life-as-we-know-it isn't working for him, and prompted by a chance meeting with an almost-Amish man on a train, he and his new wife so...more
Very interesting book about a family that chooses to live with an Amish-like community for 18 months. My main complaint is that it is painted in a very rose-tinted way. One wonders while reading why they left if it was so great? It comes down to a couple of reasons. The wife is allergic to horses and horses are necessary (however, the author--the husband--has a conversation with a member of the community after realizing that horses are _not_ that necessary so it doesn't really jibe) and the wife...more
There are no discussion topics on this book yet.
Be the first to start one »

Loading...





























Mar 03, 2010 02:43pm