Smart and Gets Things Done: Joel Spolsky's Concise Guide to Finding the Best Technical Talent
My rating:
didn't like it it was ok liked it really liked it it was amazing
add to my books

Smart and Gets Things Done: Joel Spolsky's Concise Guide to Finding the Best Technical Talent

3.81 of 5 stars 3.81  ·  rating details  ·  153 ratings  ·  39 reviews

A guide to attracting, recruiting, interviewing, and hiring the best technical talent.A comprehensive system for hiring topnotch technical employees Packed with useful information and specific advice written in a breezy, humorous style Learn how to find great peopleand get them to work for youin an afternoon

The top software developers are ten times more productive than a

...more
Hardcover, 182 pages
Published May 31st 2007 by Apress
more details... edit details
There is a good chance some of your friends read this book. Sign in to see!
sign in »

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 280)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Riz
Riz rated it 3 of 5 stars
Recommends it for: IT recruiters, managers, supervisors
I read this book on a 5 hour flight and had lot of time leftover to nap and play with the onboard tv screen. Overall, it was a decent book and somewhat useful to me personally.

The book has some good references and also some good pointers which are valuable to keep for the future. His site, http://www.joelonsoftware.com/ is mentioned a number of times and is a good site to follow. His style is sometimes sarcastic and casual, which may appeal to many techies, and I personally found ...more
Mykola
Mykola rated it 5 of 5 stars
This is a great book both for people who are interviewing programmers and for programmers who are looking for a job. I've read it briefly a couple of years ago and now I read it again. This time from cover to cover, taking notes, thinking of what the author says, how it aligns with what I did on the interviews and what I should do differently next time. I have several interview books in my collection, But this one is probably the best so far. This book is short, to the point, with lots of practi...more
Bhall
Bhall rated it 4 of 5 stars
I read this book this morning after it was recommended (and loaned) to me by our fantastic new recruiter, Ali. She had read a post I had done for my team on hiring and interviewing and thought I'd like.

couple macros before I go into what I took away:
1) I am going to try to hunt Joel down next time I'm in NY. I've read two of the books he's written and enjoyed (other is Joel on Software), he's clearly a very smart guy, and we have a few overlaps that could be fun to explore ...more
Chebe
Chebe rated it 3 of 5 stars
Enjoyably written, and delightfully short and to the point. I do feel though that it goes over a lot of the same ground as 'Peopleware', only in less detail. What it does have going for it is a discussion of hiring practices from the point of view of managers and interviewers. A very valuable insight indeed, especially for those of us who haven't gone for many interviews and even the very idea of which makes us nervous. That said, Joel doesn't do anything to relieve my fears, describing a proces...more
Caitlin
Joel has a very distinctive style that I find appealing because it is matter of fact, slightly bitter, but also resolutely "visionary". I scare quote the visionary because it seems like he considers himself more of a visionary than anything else, but that's how it gets baked into his style for better or worse. Full of useful tips, tid bits, and anecdotes, I find this book to be useful in my own evaluation of my working environment, myself as a worker, and my colleagues. I am recomme...more
Maxim Boguslavsky
Короткая и локоничная книга, которая нужна не только людям, работающим в сфере найма персонала, но и каждому айтишнику. Она позволит вам понять как выглядит нормальная компания, на чем стоит экономить, а на чем нет, как выглядит адекватное отношение к персоналу, о чем спрашивают на собеседованиях, что стоит отвечать, а что нет.
Более того, в ней содержится небольшой опросник, который дает понять что должна содержат нормальная группа, занимающаяся разработкой программ. Положительный ответ на...more
Rachel
Rachel rated it 5 of 5 stars
Recommended to Rachel by: Carl
Shelves: technology
I'm giving this book a five because I think everyone in the software business should read it, even though there are points I disagree with. Spolsky's contention (as everyone who reads his stuff knows) is that one should only hire the very best programmers, and then treat them like rock stars. Being (IMHO) a top programmer, I can't help but enjoy that concept. However, I can't entirely agree with it. As Spolsky comments at one point, it really should be "Smart, Gets things done, and Not ...more
Matthew
This is a thin book on a narrow topic, so I think the author had a difficult task of getting the length right and this is probably as good as one could hope for.

I read the book from the vantage point as someone who attends interviews and sometimes is asked if I know anyone who could work in a position, so some good advice had to do with things out of my span of control.

All that said, this is likely the definitive volume on the topic.
Emad Mokhtar
It's a great book; to know what to do when you're running interviewing process, but for me I'm still on the other side of the table and it's good to know How are folks on the other side think.
I like the way he's running the interview, and when he's choosing a developer he's choose him according on his way of thinking (Smart and Get thing done), not according on what the language/technology he knows because if his mental power is great then he can learn any new language/technology fast.
...more
Rich Leland
I read this when I was a manager at Discovery and found it a worthwhile read. While I don't necessarily agree with some of the formulaic interviewing techniques mentioned in it, I do like its no-nonsense approach to hiring technical folks. There are some really sound interviewing practices in it and some common pitfalls to avoid. Overall I'd say if you are planning on recruiting or hiring technical people, give it a read.
Jonathan
Jonathan rated it 4 of 5 stars
Shelves: 2009
A very interesting read. Joel's ideas on finding and retaining good talent ring true to me as a developer. I cringe a little at the private offices because I am really social, but in terms of productivity, he is probably right.

His interviewing techniques do not resemble what we do at my current job, so that could account for our difficulty in hiring top talent.

His insistence on having a steady stream of interns to feed your permanent personnel seems spot on as well.
Chibimagic
Chibimagic rated it 5 of 5 stars
Shelves: programming
It's just a collection of his essays that you can already find on the web, but a great refresher course for hiring. Definitely recommended as a gift to your manager if your company seems to be constantly hiring terrible people. A good read for yourself too if you play any role in hiring, as most developers should.
Christian Ternus
I wish more recruiters had read this little book, a how-to manual for recruiting engineers by the author of Joel on Software. I liked the anecdotes and the advice seemed salient, though I probably won't be sitting on the interviewer's side of the desk anytime soon.
Steve Nay
Targeted to people who hire programmers. Gives good insights into how to find the people with the best talent--the ones who can "hit the high notes." Also has some great pointers on making a software team better, whether you're the manager or one of the members.
Jason Conner
Very quick read. It's means for people hiring programmers rather than the programmers themselves. The book is useful to programmers, though, to give us an idea of what we should be looking for in a workplace and what the interviewers might expect of us.
Ram
Joel with his rich experience has written the best, and that too, in a concise and a more practical manner. Some of the chapters make you laugh and some of them make you think seriously about how a software organization should be and how it should treat its developers etc. I liked reading each page of this book and I believe that I will revisit it once again sometime in the near future.
Stephanie
Stephanie rated it 4 of 5 stars
Recommends it for: computer science professionals
Shelves: software
Spolsky is, as usual, on his high horse, explaining all the wonderful ways in which his company (Fog Creek) is the best place anyone could ever want to work. Despite the fact that most of his ideas originated during his stint at Microsoft (private offices, college and even high school intership programs, and other perks), they are important in attracting good employees. I will definitely pick this up again if I find myself interviewing for another job in the future, so if anyone is currently int...more
Bill
Bill rated it 4 of 5 stars
Smart, opinionated but has justifications for those opinions. Correct about product companies being the best to work for but his notion that profit will just happen lacks his normal analytical rigor.
Cbuck
Cbuck rated it 4 of 5 stars
Shelves: startups
Short, to the point, and classic Spolsky humor. I've followed Joel's blog for a couple years now, and much of this content comes from points he makes again and again, but it was great to put it all into context of how to identify, attract and hire great engineers.
Brian Zaugg
An excellent book that is ostensibly about hiring software developers, but is actually about hiring, leadership, and team-building for anyone who works around tech geeks.
Dmitri Nesteruk
Totally loved this book. Brief, concise, and to the point. Very common-sense advice about the challenging process of recruiting technical specialists.
Efsavage
Nice little book, if you read Spolsky site you'll find little new, but not a bad compilation regardless.
Stephen Evans
Great and simple book if you are in charge of assessing or hiring tech talent.
Michael
Most of the material in this book was familiar to me from reading Joel's blog, and I would recommend reading that instead of buying this book. In fact, I read this at a Borders one afternoon because I don't want to financially support his work and certainly not his authority. I agree with most of his hiring and workplace philosophies, but less so his technical philosophies. I wanted to hear what he thought about resumes, but it turned out to be uninformative since I am seeking work not hiring...more
Aaron
Aaron rated it 5 of 5 stars
Recommended to Aaron by: Jeff Poulton
At my business we've been trying to figure out the best way to find new employees that are well...smart and get things done. Joel has a funny but real way of writing what he has learned in the process of growing his buisness Fog Creek. Not only does Joel have excellent ideas on how to hire the best he also addresses how to manage a team and a simple checklist that can help one's business be better.

Great stuff and a quick read.
Jason Shao
Jason Shao rated it 5 of 5 stars
Recommends it for: people looking to hire programmers
Shelves: business, hiring
Basically a collection of several articles from Joel's blog composited into a book -- this lays out Joel's philosophy on how to find, hire, and retain star programming talent. Joel makes the argument that you really want superstars since they're much more productive than "normal" employees, and that you should go to most any length to find and get them. He also talks about some of the things they do at FogCreek to make that happen.
Andrew
Andrew rated it 2 of 5 stars
Extremely readable compilation of columns from Spolsky's website, themed around hiring within the IT sector. The key ideas are that IT productivity varies by magnitudes, and that companies have to work to attract and retain the star performers.
John
A quick, easy read. This is the sort of book managers should read but, of course, don't. His prescription for hiring is interesting, but I can't see it being used anywhere other than a small programming shop. Nonetheless, a lot of what he says would be helpful to anyone managing programmers.
Mark
Mark rated it 3 of 5 stars
A lot of the material here is recycle from his website, so there's not much new content if you already follow his blog. However his writing style is entertaining and straightforward enough that I didn't mind, although his insights aren't as impressive the 3rd time you read them.
Mark Cheverton
Lots of practical advice on hiring developers and how to create the right environment to attract and keep the best. Nothing too earth shattering, but stuff that's easily ignored in the rush to fill positions and the desire to cut costs.
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
Руководство Джоэла Спольски по подбору программистов и управлению ими (Paperback)
Smart and Gets Things Done: Joel Spolsky's Concise Guide to Finding the Best Technical Talent (Kindle Edition)
Smart and Gets Things Done: Joel Spolsky's Concise Guide to Finding the Best Technical Talent (ebook)
Smart and Gets Things Done (Paperback)

Goodreads is Hiring Engineers!

If you like books like these and love to build cool products, we may be looking for you.
Learn more »

Readers Also Enjoyed

Joel on Software The Best Software Writing I More Joel on Software: Further Thoughts on Diverse and Occasionally Related Matters That Will Prove of Interest to Software Developers, Desig User Interface Design for Programmers Joel e il software

Share This Book

Your website
Pin It