Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “When It Happens” as Want to Read:
When It Happens
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating
Open Preview

When It Happens

3.75 of 5 stars 3.75  ·  rating details  ·  29,504 ratings  ·  1,112 reviews
An off-the-wall love story told in two voices. Straight-laced Sara dreams of two things: getting into her first-choice university and finding true love. Rock-loving slacker Tobey also dreams of two things: winning Battle of the Bands – and winning Sara. He is determined to make her fall in love with him. Tobey's quirky wit and big blue eyes are hard for Sara to ignore. But ...more
Paperback, 320 pages
Published May 3rd 2012 by Scholastic UK (first published May 4th 2006)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.
Divergent by Veronica RothCity of Bones by Cassandra ClareThe Fault in Our Stars by John GreenThe Hunger Games by Suzanne CollinsClockwork Prince by Cassandra Clare
Perfect Boyfriend List
147th out of 598 books — 419 voters
Epic Fail by Claire LaZebnikThis is What Happy Looks Like by Jennifer E. SmithThe Accidental Movie Star by Emily  EvansBreathe by Abbi GlinesThe Accidental TV Star by Emily  Evans
YA books with Film Stars/Famous Musicians
36th out of 102 books — 112 voters

More lists with this book...

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 3,000)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Maja (The Nocturnal Library)
Adorable isn't a word I use often to describe books. In Majaland, the word is not even a compliment in that context– it’s almost insulting, really, like calling a guy cute. But there have been a few exceptions along the way, and When It Happens happens to be one of them. It’s just… adorable.

Told from alternating POVs, this is a story about Sara and Tobey’s senior year in high school. They both start the year single, but Sara has a small crush on Dave, the new boy, and Tobey has a huge crush on
Steph (Reviewer X)
Oct 20, 2008 Steph (Reviewer X) rated it 4 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommends it for: People looking for a very endearing, feel-good romance book.
Recommended to Steph by: Khyrinthia, Nurin
Warning: It took about 30-50 pages for me to get sucked into the narrative. So if you don't feel the effect super quickly, at least give it those initial 50 pages. The book's a quick read anyhow :)

God, I needed this. (A girl has much to grain from a pinch of romance amidst the midterm hustle.) I have no idea what worked here to make this novel as, I don’t know, endearing? Whatever it was, kudos to Ms Colasanti—a mi me gusta.

Okay, so the theme of this novel is already stamped on the title—what ha
I was born too late! I wish I were more conscious/aware the decade when The Breakfast Club, St. Elmo’s Fire and Pretty in Pink were cool and hip. Then my inexplicable crushes on Andrew McCarthy *sa-woon* and John Cusack *sa-wooning some more*, wouldn’t be so… well, inexplicable. But thanks to weekend reruns on ABC5, I have watched them over and over and over again (much to my brother’s confusion.) Why am I so into those movies anyway?

I am very fond of those movies for the same reason I am very
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.
When It Happens begins on an awkward note. The author's use of "so I go" and "then she was like" instead of the tried and true "he said", "she said" was more distracting than anything else. It jolted the reader out of the narrative long enough for them to think, "Wow, the author's trying too hard," before sinking back in to the story.

With little things like that, it took awhile for it to really feel that Colasanti got into the groove of the story. Things started to sink into place between pages
The synopsis of When It Happens was interesting; unfortunately, that's not what I cay say about the book. It falls short and by a large margin as well. I was really psyched to read Susane Colasanti after Something Like Fate. Thus, I decided to read this out the three options I had: Waiting For You and Take Me There.

My feelings about the book could be summed up by a repetitive dialog in the book, “You"re so much more than you"re letting yourself be." That's what I felt like saying to the author,
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.
"Maggie's like, 'Did he call'" Already, by this line in the second paragraph I was frustrated and disappointed by "When it Happens." The author is a high school teacher; she should have been able to write realistic compelling dialogue. However, her writing seemed to fall between corny and contrived. The alternating first person narratives between the two protagonists does not present a cohesive story but rather a battle of the sexes and comes no where near the writing of "Nick and Norah's Infin ...more
Sarah Augustinsky
I read this book on the recommendation of a very sentimental friend, and the novel turned out to be everything I expected: predictable, overly-forced, and out of perspective.

Within the first fifty pages, I had planned out the whole entire plot of the book. After I finished, I was completely right about the whole thing. Every part of the plot line was predictable. It's quite a boring read when you already know what happens.

This author, honestly, is something out of touch with anything that teena
When is Happens by Susane Colansanti was a great read. I truly enjoyed it! I couldn't put it down, so I finished it rather quickly. I liked the alternating POVs between Sara and Tobey. However, I found myself looking forward to reading about Tobey. He was such a great addition to this book.

About the story: Tobey's fallen head over heals for Sara. She's smart, focused, pretty, but unfortunately unavailable. After waiting for her dream guy to call her all summer, Dave finally asked her out when s
This was a really cute story about the inner workings of the dramatic teenagers mind.
The crushes, the swoons, the plans and plotting of it all brings back fond(and not so fond) memories of what it was like to be a teenager searching for "something real", and then realizing that it's even better then you realized it would be once you found it.

This is very dialog driven, and at first I had a hard time connecting with the characters but after a bit I found each of there voices and what I thought wa

Literally one of the most awful books I have ever read, and this is coming from a girl who has read a lot of books, and always finds something to like about them no matter what.

Unless you’re thirteen or have a thirteen-year-old’s ideology of love, I suggest you skip over this one.

Sara wants Dave the hot guy and Dave wants to have sex with Sara, the hot/smart girl. Tobey likes Sara for who she is (and also wants to bang her) and Sara feels something “real” for To
I cannot, in good faith, recommend this. It is a totally vapid novel about a high school romance that is told from two alternating perspectives -- Sara (Ms. Smarty Pants) and Tobey (Mr. Indie Guitar Player/Slacker Guy). I really can't overemphasize how totally shallow the book and its characters are. All of Sara's thoughts and conversations seem to be about what she is going to wear on her dates and Tobey is "all about his music" and trying to get Sara to fall for him. It's just really one-dimen ...more
Bookaholic (reads every mortal thing)

This was so...immature. Let me extrapolate:

1. Tobey's EXTREME wooing tendencies.
2. SARA.
3. SARA.
4. SARA.

You see where I'm going?
This was really fluffy but I enjoyed it a lot! It doesn't start off very well but after about 50 pages, I was completely hooked. Can't wait to check out Colasanti's other books!
This book was really good! I read it in two days which is very fast for me. It was such a cute book.
Andrea Eliza
"There's just... this intensity... something real."

This book is a love story. An insta-love story. And if you don't already know this... I am not a fan of insta-love.

"I peer into my dresser drawer at my ancient underwear. If I were seeing my underwear for the first time, what would I think? It all looks kind of damaged. Do I need to get new underwear? I hate having to ask my mom to buy it for me. Everyone wears underwear, but it's humiliating to admit this fact to your mother. Even if she doe
Sara is on a quest her senior year; to find something real and to get into NYU. She is a self-described nerd and proud of it, yet secretly longs for popularity and acceptance.

Tobey comes across as a lazy, but musically talented guy. I sort of picture him as a skater boy. He is majory crushing on Sara and even with his gorgeous eyes, he just can't figure out how to get her to notice him. There is the whole problem of Dave, seriously his nickname sould be D-Bag Dave.

Sara, for whatever reason think
First of all, i gave this a 1 star at first...but then I changed it because I finished the book. I am very confident that if a book was a 1 star book I would not have finished it HOWEVER this is the only book that I can remember reading and thinking the whole time "...only ____ more pages until this thing is finally over". this is the only young adult book that I have read and thought, man, maybe i', too old for these books. I am well aware that these books are intended for YOUNG adults but gene ...more
i wish there was a rating for 'hated it' because that's exactly how i felt towards this miserable excuse of a book after i read it.
ive thought about writing a review and it was soo bad that i couldn't even do it.but now i'm going to.i feel like i need to warn people.
i think i read a review for this saying that we would be rooting for the characters. well let me just tell you that i most certainly did not 'root for the characters'.i didn't even care what happened to those crappy characters.
Karla (Reads and Thoughts)
Like other books, i wanted to read this just for its pretty cover very likely of me. haha

Basically, this one is a very fun, fresh and witty read. Since i'm a big sucker for happy endings I love love stories like this. What i trully like about this one is how it is told in both the perspectives of the main characters Sara & Tobey regarding the same situations. The scenes between these two are so sweet, romantic and well-written. I especially like the remake of the scene from Say Anything
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.
Q. Did I like 'When It Happens'?
A. It was alright.

Q. Did I get confused?
A. Erm... YEAH!

Seriously, I did like the book. It's very good, easy to follow between the alternate points of view and Susane Colasanti has done something that few other female authors can do - write in a male perspective and make it seem legitimate. Which was refreshing.

Tobey and Sara are the main two characters. Sara is independent, knows what she wants and how to get it, intelligent and a good friend. Tobey is bright - bu
Its been a while since I've read a YA book and after reading this book, I'm ready to dive into more YA books. I'm thinking where in the world were these books when I was in high school? I think the authors were probably in school like me trying to figure out what we were going to do with our lives ha! I'm so glad the world of books has expanded into something that is totally unstoppable, whethere with the physical books or efiles- all is good in my eyes.

When it happens, totally brought me back t
Jessica Lawlor
I think I’ve found a new favorite author!

When It Happens by Susane Colasanti tells the story of Sara and Tobey, two high school seniors. Sara is serious about school and getting into college. Tobey is serious about music and winning this year’s Battle of the Bands. Both of them want to find their true love this year. Sara finds Dave, a popular jock and is thrilled when he actually likes her back. Tobey only has eyes for Sarah, but he is discouraged when he sees Sara and Dave together.

Told from t
GOODREADS RECOMMENDED THIS BOOK TO ME AND I DO NOT KNOW IF I CAN TRUST THEM ANYMORE. Anyway, I probably would've picked this book up if I was just perusing the library shelf so I'll shush up. ANYWAY. I've been meaning to read a Susane Colasanti book for awhile now and... This book probably shouldn't have been my first one. I mean, don't get me wrong, it was a good read (haha) but... It took over 100 pages to even be invested into the story. I really like that Colasanti discredited Dave right off ...more
Wow. Well that was pretty... bad? I picked it up from the library as a quick-read trashy romance novel that hopefully would make me smile at how unrealistic it is.
Well it didn't. It really didn't.
***WARNING*** This review may contain spoilers. So if you are thinking of reading this (which I probably wouldn't recommend) don't read it :)
So the book starts off and we meet our main character Sara. And that is where the problems started. So Sara has just spent her summer moping around waiting for a b
Sara Tyler has goals for her senior year. The first is to get into NYU, but the second is to find something real. This means finding a boyfriend and having that perfect connection that comes with first love. Tobey Belcher has goals for senior year, too. Win battle of the bands, and win Sara's heart. When Sara starts dating douche bag Dave, Tobey's discouraged, but then he decides to pursue her anyway. It isn't long before Sara's ditched Dave and is with Tobey, but are they really meant to be?

If he’s so interested, why didn’t he call? I hate that a boy is making me feel this way. And I hate that I’m letting it happen.
- Sara
I’m tired of waiting for my life to begin. Something has to happen. Like an amazing boy. I know he’s out there. I just have to find him. And it would be awesome if that boy was Dave.
- Sara
Love isn’t based on intelligence.
- Maggie
An admirable quality of parenthood is the ability to respect your kid’s privacy
- Tobey
I can be the person I want to be.
- Sara
People pay fo
It’s both Sarah and Tobey’s senior year of high school. Sara’s got everything planned out: she’s going to attend NYU after she graduates. And she’s all set to go with her stellar grades. Tobey on the other hand doesn’t plan on attending college. He figures he’ll win Battle of the Bands and move onto greater things than school. But there is one thing he’s sure on: making Sara fall in love with him.

When It Happens was a cute and funny story that I thoroughly enjoyed. Sara and Tobey have the perfec
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 99 100 next »
topics  posts  views  last activity   
Crazy for Young A...: When It Happens by Susane Colasanti → Start Date: July 14, 2014 13 22 Jul 29, 2014 08:44AM  
The Story 2 30 May 21, 2014 05:26PM  
The book! 22 99 Feb 26, 2012 12:27AM  
  • Perfect You
  • Two-Way Street
  • Lost It
  • Take Me There
  • The Book of Luke
  • The Nature of Jade
  • Getting Lost with Boys
  • Winter Longing
  • Endless Summer (The Boys Next Door, #1-2)
  • Where I Belong
  • Sticky Fingers
  • Island Girls (and Boys)
  • Drive Me Crazy
  • I Know It's Over
  • Breathing
Susane Colasanti is the bestselling author of When It Happens, Take Me There, Waiting for You, Something Like Fate, So Much Closer, Keep Holding On, All I Need, Now and Forever, and the City Love trilogy. She has a bachelor’s degree from the University of Pennsylvania and a master’s degree from New York University. Before becoming a full-time author in 2007, Susane was a high school science teache ...more
More about Susane Colasanti...
Waiting for You Something Like Fate Keep Holding On Take Me There So Much Closer

Share This Book

“Too bad guys aren’t like Mr. Potato Head Where you can pick and choose which parts you want. Then we might come up with a guy who meets your standards.
- Maggie”
“I'm thinking that it might actually be possible for things to work out sometimes. Definitely not everything and maybe not the way you imagined. But sometimes, when you least expected it, life surprises you.” 162 likes
More quotes…