Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “The Man of Feeling (Penguin Modern Classics)” as Want to Read:
The Man of Feeling (Penguin Modern Classics)
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating
Open Preview

The Man of Feeling (Penguin Modern Classics)

3.67 of 5 stars 3.67  ·  rating details  ·  511 ratings  ·  59 reviews
On a train journey from Paris to Madrid a young opera singer becomes fascinated by those in his compartment: a middle-aged businessman, his alluring wife and their male travelling companion. Soon his life of constant travel, luxury hotels, rehearsal and performance will become entangled with these three people, and the singer will find himself fatefully consumed by Natalia ...more
Paperback, Penguin Modern Classics, 144 pages
Published August 2nd 2012 by Penguin Books Ltd (first published 1986)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about The Man of Feeling, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about The Man of Feeling

This book is not yet featured on Listopia. Add this book to your favorite list »

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 1,015)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Kalliope




This book is a gift.

A few days ago, showing the center of Madrid to a visiting friend, we stopped at the bookshop patronized by Javier Marías. In Librería Méndez they are usually well stocked on his books. Because of its connections with Opera, I had wanted to read this particular one, but as it is an early work it is less easy to find. But there it was, and my friend very kindly offered it to me.

The opera link is with Verdi’s Otello. This is another sample of Marías’ interest in Shakespeare. I
...more
Kris
This is yet another brilliant novel by Javier Marías. I'm not going to pretend to any kind of objectivity; he has become one of my favorite writers in a very short time. In this short, intricately crafted novel, Marías explores the intersection between love and dreams. Is the true experience of love something a person experiences actively and with intention, or is its essence made up of recollection and imagination? And what happens when a person's best chance of happiness seems to come while dr ...more
Ian Klappenskoff
Love Both Possible and Opposed

I don’t know whether I should tell you my judgement or just my impressions.

Marias captures your attention from the very first moment he opens his mouth or puts pen to paper (or rather, presses the first key on his Olympia Carrera de Luxe typewriter). It’s like being at a dinner table and discovering that an infinitely more interesting guest is also in attendance, or sitting down in a cinema and realizing that this could be the best film you will see all year.

Another
...more
Mike Puma

This is a beautiful, melancholy novel. Stunning in its accomplishment and execution. Another winner from Javier Marías, a man I beginning to feel I know. At the risk of sounding sacrilegious, where other Goodreads’ friends have their David Foster Wallace or their Thomas Bernhard, and where previously I had my Cormac McCarthy and Roberto Bolaño and with whom I’m was quite content, I now have to add Javier Marías to that list of Those Who Do No Wrong.

While traveling by train to a performance as Ca

...more
Mary
I read this book on a mattress in an empty apartment while on the cusp of making a cross country move and a complete life change. I read this book while being in love. Perhaps this is why the dreamy and emotive tone of Marias' strange novel resonated so much with me.

This is a curious and short tale of reminiscence. Of dreams vs. reality. Of longing.

Very little was happening in the story, just as nothing much was happening in my empty apartment with the whirling ceiling fan and the occasional v
...more
Jonfaith
The Man of Feeling is a reinvention of Othello, one both wicked and wicked-smart. An opera singer reflects on a visit to Madrid to perform in Verdi's Otello. He encounters three people: a married couple and their (paid) companion. The Shakespearean roles are all twisted and dislocated. The matters are more mercenary here than the Bard's tale. Madrid is both home to the itinerant singer as well as some blurred noir, teeming with after-hour temptations and the ubiquity of garbage trucks. Marias of ...more
Stephen P
Marias writes as the master of realism. It is faithless to believe it is about the realistic, detailed rendering of events and objects. The Man Of Feeling instead searches out, in elegant prose, the portrayal of inner reality, its speculation as both strength and defense, or the need to discard it as cumbersome to the enjoyment of life lived within the boundaries of a life.

The first person narrator, a budding opera singer on the cusp of stardom, who must travel frequently for professional reason
...more
Abailart
Joy upon joy. Halfway through. Getting to know Marias. There's the woman on the bed sitting with her thighs showing. Here are six imagined scenarios of a woman undressing for bed as imagined by her absurd lover who's singing Cassio in Otello. Metonym after metonym of gnarled fingers, gleaming teeth, the space between breasts setting off a cataclysm, thighs that feel like scar tissue. Oh, and the poor fat boy, most ridiculous of all prisoners forced to wear short trousers until he was 16 by his c ...more
Carmo Santos
A história deste livro parte de uma dessas situações banais que acontecem todos os dias e que à primeira vista não trazem nada de novo. Um homem - um cantor de ópera que passa a vida em viagem por cidades diferentes e que fica sempre hospedado em hotéis de luxo, conhece numa dessas viagens, um casal que viaja acompanhado por outro homem. É aqui que a situação começa a ficar estranha, pois o terceiro elemento exerce a função de "cão de guarda". Aquele casamento foi um negócio e o marido - homem r ...more
Io?
Il libro che non ti aspetti. Lo scrittore che non ti aspetti. Ogni tanto succede. E quando capita è bello. Avete letto la trama del libro riportata qua sopra, tratta dalla quarta di copertina? Ebbene, cancellatela dalla mente, dire che è fuorviante è poco, dire che è una cagata pazzesca è un semplice eufemismo. L'uomo sentimentale (il titolo a mio parere avrebbe dovuto usare il plurale) è tutta un'altra cosa, sono i riflessi di uno specchio riflesso su altri specchi sull'amore, è una camminata f ...more
Oscar
La historia comienza cuando el narrador pone por escrito (y al mismo tiempo nos cuenta) el sueño que acaba de tener. Los hechos que nos narra (y que ha soñado) empezaron hace cuatro años, cuando el protagonista, tenor de profesión, viaja a Madrid en tren para una actuación. Será durante este viaje en tren donde se fije en tres personas, que le llaman poderosamente la atención, dos hombres y una mujer. La afilada percepción del protagonista (y de Marías) nos describe detalladamente como son estas ...more
Donato
[Note: Italian translation]
It's taken me awhile to write this review. Because I'm trying to get a handle on my thoughts.
I really liked the structure of the book. It turned a simple story into a suspenseful one too. Marquez-like, Marías blends past, present, future, memory and dream, but he adds something else to the mix: imagination -- that is, the narrator imagines what other characters might be doing or thinking. Like he needs to create a story beyond his own story.
Marías himself says, in an e
...more
jeremy
an early and exceptional work from the great spanish novelist, the man of feeling (el hombre sentimental) is "a love story in which love is neither seen nor experienced, but announced and remembered." in an explanatory epilogue entitled "something unfulfilled," marías expounds further:
can such a thing happen? can something as urgent and unpostponable as love, which requires both presence and immediate consummation or consumption, be announced when it does not yet exist or truly remembered if it
...more
Margarida
um livro apaixonante, uma escrita intimista, sensível, narrada na primeira pessoa por um cantor de ópera, um tenor espanhol. quase em forma de diário, o protagonista descreve o sonho que tivera nessa noite, com as mesmas pessoas que conheceu 4 anos antes, durante uma viagem de comboio.

'E no entanto resisto a contar-vos tudo. Um pobre tenor que tem medo do seu próprio relato ou dos seus próprios sonhos, como se utilizar palavras em vez de letras, vocábulos não ditados, frases inventadas em vez d
...more
arcobaleno
Dopo un iniziale disagio per i periodi lunghi che mi lasciavano senza fiato anche la mente, mi sono ritrovata trasportata da un’onda scorrevole e tranquilla di pensieri, ben articolati e consequenziali… Una scrittura che sembra, d’altra parte, adattarsi alle immagini sfumate, tra sogno e realtà, tra memorie e proiezioni, in questo breve romanzo: potrebbe apparire un banale “triangolo”, ma in realtà niente ha di banale né di retorico; l’amore vi risulta impalpabile, stranamente sfuggente nell’att ...more
Justin Evans
Not quite up to Marias' usually high standards, but perhaps a good place to start nonetheless, because it's a much easier read than his later work, and more similar to them than the other earlier novel that you can easily find in English, 'All Souls.' Here his method of juxtaposing a few stories to come up with a... well, I don't really know what to call it (constellation? universal? passion? idea? myth?), but with a complex thought-feeling, is in its earliest stages. Rather than reflecting two ...more
Linda
Nov 16, 2014 Linda rated it 4 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommended to Linda by: Mike Puma
Me encanta como escribe.....sin embargo, no veo a ninguno de estos dos como sentimental, sino egoistas.....voy a pensarlo, como lo terminé anoche, a ver si cambio de idea. Como persona que viaja sola bastante, me encantó la descripción de los viajes del tenor, de su anhelo por poder conocer bien un lugar, su gente, por tener vínculo en los sitios donde cantaba con frecuencia, para sentir la sensación de pertenecer a un lugar. Es la primera de Marías que leo, y sí que voy a leer otras; posiblemen ...more
James
A tale of cosmopolitan love, The Man of Feeling is a novel of recollection. A memory of love remembered ala Proust, but with a shortened span of memory as if the dream is fleeting as the love. A ghost story in the sense that memory is ghost-like and this memory, while filled with desire, is haunting with fragments of what happened or may have happened. For an opera-lover like myself it had just enough passion to suggest the music of love. It had the libretto, if not the music.
Cheryl
I quite liked Marias's employment of duality; a story told in fragments without much dialogue. On one hand, the haziness of what was dream or reality was lulling. On the other, the game of fulfilled versus incomplete love was exciting (as were the ardent, operatic characters in the backdrop). Strange to be left satisfied without resolve.
Foroogh
"در بیشتر موارد آدم خودش نمی داند که دیگری عشق او را چه لحظه ای پذیرفته و در چه لحظه ای او را ترک کرده است و دلیلش هم صرفا این نیست که همیشه این اتفاق در غیاب ما می افتد بلکه علاوه بر این قضیه این است که مشخص کردن لحظه واحدی که این تحول اتفاق می افتد غیر ممکن است.درست همانطور که آدم هرگز نمی تواند بداند که پذیرفتن عشقش به خاطر وجود منحصر به فرد،اعمال مشخص و سجایاو ارزشهای خودش بوده یا صرفا نتیجه قرارگرفتن سر راه سرنوشت دیگری"ص175

رمان"مرد است و احساسش"درباره عشق است ولی این بار خلاف معمول حول محو
...more
Rick
Marias is a prize-winning Spanish novelist. He wrote two novels before he was 20; counting them, The Man of Feeling was his fifth book, published in Spain when he was 35. His more recent novels feature characters, who, like Marias, work as translators and teachers (as does the protagonist in Llosa’s The Bad Girl, a translator but not a teacher)—characters who give up their own voices to take on the voice of another. Opera singers also give over their voice in service of their characters, creatur ...more
Matt
An odd, enigmatic little fable, which like all these things, starts on a train, with our narrator seeing a triangular arrangement, two men bookending a woman, and who then forces the formation of a new triangle. Why does he do it? Why not, he might ask.

I enjoyed this one a lot more than the book of stories I read previously-- there seemed to be less force employed here, and more time instead laying elaborate traps for the reader and characters. So we've got an opera singer playing the role of th
...more
Jim Leckband
Reading Javier Marías is like being a frog in boiling water. At any one point while reading a sentence I do not notice its quality (or the opposite) or notice that taken alone that it is somewhat banal and really, is it that interesting? Until an hour later and I've realized that the water in fact was boiling and I've never jumped out. Unlike the frog, I believe I like the feeling.

The plot of "The Man of Feeling" could be summarized in one sentence. Man meets woman, other man loses woman. Plot i
...more
Nate
Beautiful, beautiful, beautiful. This novel is simple, playful, elegant, sad, slim, and slow burning. The ending is great. The book, like others of Marias, also contains great psychological & philosophical observations. He's like a poet of psychology. Highly recommended.
James
So absorbingly enchanting. The prose feels like mercury, and it's a type of writing that is a rich decadent pleasure to read. (It's what I wish I could write like.)
Laura Little
I'm a sucker for any book that promises to recreate the magic of Tolstoy's train station meeting between Anna and Vronksy in the peerless "Anna Karenina." Marías delivers some of this through his wonderful protagonist: a lonely opera singer and his keen observation of an unusual couple in a train car. Not much "happens" in this novel, so lovers of Tolstoy style drama (war! love! death! alcoholism!) might be disappointed. I have read a novella of Marías before - my sense of these two data points ...more
Cliodhna Ni Ghadhra
Terribly dull protagonist - very whiney. I find Marías to be very hit and miss, All Souls was superb but this and A Heart So White were only fair. I liked Manur's cognac coloured eyes though, and the obsession with distinguishing the commercial traveller. Interesting take on memory too, I wonder if the Lion of Naples will find another woman in three years and speak of Natalia as he speaks of Berta (very much the mad woman in the Attic).
Liviu
A short novel and a fast read which absorbed me though in the end felt a bit empty; an opera singer and his traveling life which precludes a "normal" settled existence, so he constantly feels in-between (whether love, women, places, even life itself); a slice of his existence book-ended by two affairs, one with a woman he lived in with for about 18 months (sort of - see above) and whom now some 5 years later is just a ghost memory and another with a beautiful married woman as per the blurb

Excell
...more
Jin Zhao
This is one of the best love stories I've read. Marías is a damn good writer (duh), although sometimes good writers overwrite.

"What I want there to be at the hour of my death is the incarnation of my life--what that life has been--and in order for you to have been that too, you must have lived by my sided from now until that final moment. I could not bear it if at that moment you were only a memory or a confused figure belonging to a vague and distant time which is this clear time that we are li
...more
Gravity
In the afterward Marias writes: "The man of feeling is a love story in which love is neither seen nor experienced, but announced and remembered." That one sentence coveys the abstracted melancholy of the narrative voice, sad, but not self-pitying. The story hovers around one meeting between an peripatetic opera singer and a married woman and her platonic companion. It could be a novel of obsession but it's not, rather, just like most of Marias oeuvre, it's a study in careful and sustained observ ...more
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 33 34 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
  • Dublinesque
  • Carlota Fainberg
  • Journey to the Alcarria: Travels Through the Spanish Countryside
  • O Caso Morel (Colecção Mil Folhas, #87)
  • El embrujo de Shanghai
  • Symphony in White
  • An Episode in the Life of a Landscape Painter
  • The No World Concerto
  • Granta 113: The Best of Young Spanish Language Novelists
  • In Search of Duende
  • Locos: A Comedy of Gestures
  • El cuarto de atrás
  • Requiem: A Hallucination
  • Tres
  • Consciousness and the Novel
  • Cartas de um Sedutor
  • Soldados de Salamina
  • The Leviathan
71956
Javier Marías was born in Madrid. His father was the philosopher Julián Marías, who was briefly imprisoned and then banned from teaching for opposing Franco. Parts of his childhood were spent in the United States, where his father taught at various institutions, including Yale University and Wellesley College. His mother died when Javier was 26 years old. He was educated at the Colegio Estudio in ...more
More about Javier Marías...
A Heart So White Los enamoramientos Tomorrow in the Battle Think on Me Fever and Spear (Your Face Tomorrow, #1) All Souls

Share This Book