1st out of 11 books
—
9 voters
Eight Girls Taking Pictures
by
Whitney Otto
Bestselling author Whitney Otto’ s Eight Girls Taking Pictures i s a profoundly moving portrayal of the lives of women, imagining the thoughts and circumstances that produced eight famous female photographers of the twentieth century. This captivating novel opens in 1917 as Cymbeline Kelley surveys the charred remains of her photography studio, destroyed in a fire started...more
Hardcover, 352 pages
Published
November 6th 2012
by Scribner
(first published January 1st 2012)
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
3,000)
I confess that I shorten unfamiliar proper nouns when I read a book. I didn't try to phonetically read "Naakkve" each time I come across that name in Kristin Lavransdatter - I just accept it as that block of letters and move on. "Anna Karenina" becomes either "Kareninininina" or "Karena" or "Anna K" while I am reading the pages to myself. I blame third grade speed reading drills.
There were not a lot of unfamiliar proper nouns that I needed to breeze past in Eight Girls Taking Pictures, but there...more
There were not a lot of unfamiliar proper nouns that I needed to breeze past in Eight Girls Taking Pictures, but there...more
I enjoyed this book, but some of the stories seemed rushed & misplaced. I also thought that more of the stories were going to intertwine. It only seems like Cymbeline Kelly was a recurring character. One of the stories that I loved left me with so many unanswered questions. I wasn't sure what happened next. Overall it was good, but not the best that I've read.
Whitney Otto has done her homework. Not only does she beautifully capture the history of photography, the details of the art, and the social contexts of her eight ‘girls’ over time, she has provided a thoughtful meditation on the role of women in history as well as the role women play in their own lives. While the struggles remain constant in scope, each of Otto’s photographers approaches her conflicts in a different way, creating a kind of literary canvas for the intersections between life, lov...more
"Eight Girls Taking Pictures: A Novel" is none of the things you might expect from the title. Rather than a novel, it's actually a collection of eight short stories, some novella length. And while there are eight stories about women photographers, at least one of those stories features two women, so I count at least nine girls taking pictures.
That nitpicking aside, it's a wonderful book. Author Whitney Otto explores the ways women's lives and opportunities changed and the ways they stayed the sa...more
That nitpicking aside, it's a wonderful book. Author Whitney Otto explores the ways women's lives and opportunities changed and the ways they stayed the sa...more
I have really conflicted feelings about this book. I enjoyed it, and yet it wasn't what I wanted or expected. It is broken up into 8 "short stories" about women photographers in history, and it is based on real women but fictionalized. I love historical fiction, but this is not that, and I found it frustrating. I found myself wanting to know, needing to know who the real life woman was and then actually scoffed at the changed names to some of the other historical people -- Tin Type instead of Ma...more
This was neither the book I expected, nor really the one I wanted. I went into it hoping for uplifting, empowering, some success in the face of adversity wrapped up in photo jargon and a vivid description or two or twenty. What I got was the same story told over and over again in different cities and in different time periods: Girl has progressive parents, girl takes up photography, girl eventually settles down and gives up or otherwise hamstrings her art for her male love interest and we get to...more
This book had lots of potential, I thought ... photography through the ages, across the world, through the female artist's eye ... and it did all this, sure, but really every woman's story was how her life was affected/changed/thwarted/overpowered/distracted/overshadowed, etc. by romantic entanglements with men. Men men men. Men were the photographers, women assisted, or modeled. Men worked, women photographers ultimately resigned themselves to marriage, kids, and "hobby" photography, maybe. So...more
This book was well written, detailed and knowledgeable on the topic of photography and its evolution in the 20th century. Furthermore I was inspired by the way in which this book explored the role of art in the life of the "new woman". The book delves into the idea of what it means to create art as a female. The book explores the criticism placed on work inspired by the domestic, more "every day" sphere in spite of the fact that the times often relegated women to the domestic world. In particula...more
I should have loved this book: I studied photography and art history. I just couldn't get into it. It felt less like a novel and more like a college student's first attempt at a collection of historical short stories. Facts about whatever areas/periods were being covered were thrown in, often interrupting the flow of prose and creating a sense the author was trying to show off her breadth of research. Good historical fiction writers weave the facts in so they color the story, not footnote it. Th...more
Perhaps if I had noticed this authors previous works I would not have picked this one up, shows that I do not entirely read the front cover when I pick out books. Otto also wrote How to Make an American Quilt.
The writing in my opinion was lacking. There is nothing that hooked me into reading farther into the text than I got. The stories felt too repetitive after the first three. The women in focus are all dealing with too similar issues and maybe that is the point of the text. Professionalism vs...more
The writing in my opinion was lacking. There is nothing that hooked me into reading farther into the text than I got. The stories felt too repetitive after the first three. The women in focus are all dealing with too similar issues and maybe that is the point of the text. Professionalism vs...more
Liked it but... I read a review someone wrote where they said though the stories were good, she was unable to care about the characters. My experience was the same in that I didn't feel much for any of the women. It was a strange read because I did find the stories interesting, well written- but I didn't like them or feel they were alive. I can't really express my tangled feelings about this novel- it really is a weird feeling. The key moments in history and the effects they had on each woman mo...more
This is not in the typical genres that I usually read. I did enjoy it, especially considering I only had 20 seconds or less to read the inside cover when I first was looking at it. The joys of having a toddler at the library with you.... Despite all of at I thought this was a very interesting approach to feminism. I loved that the book focused on the different women that all ended up being interconnected in some way. I also really liked that this book circled and started with one character and e...more
I have heard a lot of things, both positive and negative, about the work of Whitney Otto. I was interested to read a piece of literature written by her and see for myself what all the fuss was about. Recently, a good friend of mine was assigned a book by Whitney Otto for a college class and she did say that it was hard for her to get into, but that once she did she found herself enjoying it. I can say the same about this book; it did take me awhile to start getting interested in what I was readi...more
I very rarely choose not to finish a book, but in the case of "Eight Girls Taking Pictures", about half way through the book I decided not to waste any more of my time on it. There just seemed to be no point - or maybe I was just missing the point. Each section of the book somewhat described the life of a different female photographer - but other than the location, they all seemed interchangeable. Additionally, I never felt any connection with any of the characters - it became almost a chore to...more
I loved this novel, each chapter exploring the life of a different woman photographer. Inspired by actual photographers but reimagined by this talented author. The stories take place at different times, with some overlap (late 1900's, 1920's, '30s, '50's, 1980's, so that some characters actually meet, while others discover earlier photographer's work while pursuing their own. Some fabulous references here that I'd never heard of: Nutshell Studies of Unexplained Death, Bomarzo Garden of Monsters....more
I really like Whitney Otto's ability to weave together stories about women from different times & different places around one central theme. I loved the movie How to Make An American quilt so I had really high hopes for this book. I enjoyed reading about Berlin between the World Wars as well as the different nuances of women's photography. However, sometimes the narratives were a little heavy-handed and I felt like the characters didn't really come to any conclusion. Also, the photography ja...more
Am in love with this book! All of my female photography friends will connect with a lot of the experiences the women go through. But I think male photographers will appreciate the photo history. This is definitely a book that should be judged by its cover. Great artwork! The only thing keeping me from giving it 5 stars is the fact that it is 8 separate stories that get referred back to. Had a hard time keeping everyone straight and had to keep flipping back. Could just be the fact I can only sta...more
This book was a series of short stories which were interesting but all rather sad. The author did an excellent job of portraying different eras and the issues each woman faced unique to her time. However, I am not sure any of the women portrayed were truely happy - most had settled, accepting less in her career or her personal relationships and never really seeming happy or content in the way life turned out. I would have liked seeing more hopefulness or satisfaction, but maybe that is the way t...more
I put this book on my "to read" list because the description said it explored the tough choices women have to make in life, such as between motherhood and art. Which resonates right now for me! And sure enough, it presents the stories of eight women and how they negotiate such conflicting demands. Overall it was an OK read, but kind of simplistic. In addition to photography, all the women share at least one progressive parent, international travel, and wealthy privilege. The privilege part seeme...more
In "Eight Girls Taking Pictures" Whitney Otto turns her prose camera on the lives of eight fictional twentieth-century female photographers. As one who often skims descriptions in favor of storylines, I found myself dawdling among the Otto's unexpected images. I wanted to know these women, their craft, their locales, and the people in their constellations. The book was not compelling; it was mesmerizing. Each woman crafted her own personal story from behind her own personal lens, and I felt priv...more
I LOVE This book from middle to end. Yes, Middle to end because at the beginning I was clearly driven by the title... but it ended up being a novel on which girls who take pictures fall in love with guys (or girls) and these guys affect their life, sentimentally and professionally.
I thought it was then okay to read regular novel about love, romance and photography, and I am glad I did so! As I kept reading I discovered that this book is written in some sort of Chronological order, it shows the...more
I thought it was then okay to read regular novel about love, romance and photography, and I am glad I did so! As I kept reading I discovered that this book is written in some sort of Chronological order, it shows the...more
If you are a Whitney Otto fan, I would recommend this, with the tip to just read it, don't read the reviews, don't get a preconceived notion of what the book is about, just read it because you enjoy her writing.
With that said, here's my review...
For me, I felt this book, at least the first five (of eight) short stories was more about sexuality than photography; the girls were all described as androgynous. There was more focus on their affairs and sexual relationships and lack of "normal" sexual...more
With that said, here's my review...
For me, I felt this book, at least the first five (of eight) short stories was more about sexuality than photography; the girls were all described as androgynous. There was more focus on their affairs and sexual relationships and lack of "normal" sexual...more
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
Interesting book about 8 women photographers whose lives intersect. These are women who work and are successful, famous photographers at a time when women did not work outside of the home. They manage to have careers, husbands, and children in spite of being conflicted about the time it takes from their work and their
drive to be the best at their profession. Loosely based on real women photographers from early 1900's to the 1960's whose interesting lives bring them all over the world during war...more
drive to be the best at their profession. Loosely based on real women photographers from early 1900's to the 1960's whose interesting lives bring them all over the world during war...more
I loved the feminist aspect of the stories, that they were based on real photographers, and the vignette/short storytelliing style. It was reminiscent of the Emma Donoghue collection, Astray. That said, I think Donoghue did a more masterful job with historical material. While I enjoyed Otto's stories, I found ti hard to distinguish between the different women. They seemed so similar as to be indistinguishable. But still I cannot help but get behind any book with such a strong feminist focus.
I don't care much for short stories, as a genre, and as it turns out, that's what this really is. A collection of stories on a related theme. After the fourth section, when I realized there was no weaving together of these eight girls, I checked out. Also, found it a bit uneven, with some characters much more hurried and sketched in than others. If you really love photography and want to know more about how women contributed, worth a read.
Loved this book. I'm not one to write down lines from books that speak to me - but this book had several I wanted to keep. Just a beautiful read. Otto tells us eight stories of women in the 20th century who experience life, love, careers and professional successes and frustrations as they work to integrate thier artistic, creative sides with the cultural norms and expectations of "the woman's role". Just elegant!
Although this is not the best book I've ever read, it was one of the most interesting. In short-story fashion, the author compiles the life of each of eight girls/women, all of whom are photographers struggling with acceptance in society, relationships and their rights as women in the early-to-mid 20th century. In places, their stories coincide, as they meet one another, often by chance.
Eight Girls Taking Pictures is not the genre of book that I normally read....but I am glad that I went out of my comfort zone on this one! I love the individual short stories that intertwine with each other. The historical times in which the fictional characters lived is rich with new ideas, and big changes, that women launched to change our societal views of what women can do and who women are.
Otto, author of "How to Make an American Quilt," presents eight fictionalized portraits of female photographers spanning the majority of the 20th century. Successfully exploring the challenges that women artists have faced throughout the recent past, this is an accessible work of fiction that is sure to be popular with bookclubs. The author includes a bibliography for those readers interested in learning more about the real lives and work of the women fictionalized in the novel.
Major Appeals: C...more
Major Appeals: C...more
There are no discussion topics on this book yet.
Be the first to start one »
Whitney Otto is the bestselling author of How to Make an American Quilt (which was made into a feature film), Now You See Her, and The Passion Dream Book. A native of California, she lives with her husband and son in Portland, Oregon.
More about Whitney Otto...
Share This Book
No trivia or quizzes yet. Add some now »
“...but she never knew what it was like to walk away from the thing she had most wanted. Years later she would say, "Photography allowed me to make the world and be in the world.”
—
2 people liked it
“I never think anyone in love is foolish. We do the best we can.”
—
2 people liked it
More quotes…

Loading...





























Feb 19, 2013 07:52am