Twelve Patients: Life and Death at Bellevue Hospital
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating

Twelve Patients: Life and Death at Bellevue Hospital

3.41 of 5 stars 3.41  ·  rating details  ·  525 ratings  ·  121 reviews
In the spirit of Oliver Sacks Awakenings and the TV series House, Dr. Eric Manheimer's TWELVE PATIENTS is a memoir from the Medical Director of Bellevue Hospital that uses the plights of twelve very different patients-from dignitaries at the nearby UN, to supermax prisoners from Riker's Island, to illegal immigrants, and Wall Street tycoons-to illustrate larger societal is...more
Hardcover, 355 pages
Published July 10th 2012 by Grand Central Publishing (first published January 1st 2012)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about Twelve Patients, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about Twelve Patients

Divergent by Veronica RothBeautiful Disaster by Jamie McGuireThe Last Lecture by Randy PauschA Game of Thrones by George R.R. MartinThe Thirteenth Tale by Diane Setterfield
2014 Reads
28th out of 116 books — 13 voters


More lists with this book...

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 1,389)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Katie
This book was definitely worth picking up, but isn't going to stick in my mind as much as I thought it was. While the stories of the twelve patients were interesting, the writing bothered me. Manheimer is extremely verbose, and some of the tales come off as pretty convoluted, with an almost romantic, wispy writing style at times. It's as if he's writing in a style that he thinks is how writer's SHOULD sound, as opposed to his real voice. It especially irritated me when he used the same speaking...more
Trish
When embarking upon this book, I had seen a BBC2 programme about nursing in Mexico 'The Toughest Place to be a ... Nurse'

Although the Author is based in Bellevue in New York City, like that BBC2 programme this book was a real eye opener. In the space of one book he takes us beyond the walls of a busy hospital and shows us modern day America in terms of what you sow, so shall you reap!

The Author's detail in writing suggests a screenplay writer could take the characters off the page and transfer t...more
Claire
Only a few chapters in and still interested, but the author could really have used an editor interested in cutting out the countless unnecessary details.

Finally finished and I'm not sure why I stuck with it. The patients' stories were interesting but the writing was not very good. The author wandered frequently, and while I love a good tangent, these did little to add to the story or my interest. He includes so many tiny details that do not need to be there. I think this book would have been gr...more
SF_Fangirl
This was a very disappointing read. It was not what I expected; it is not a tale of 12 medical mysteries (and certainly not in the spirit of House or Oliver Sacks.) The author was the Medical Director and was not the primary doctor in any of these cases. He tells the emotional story of these patients, but the medical diagnosis is unimportant and is simply introduced at the start of each story. He focuses on the larger social issues related to immigrants, poor, and prisoners. He also goes off on...more
Ted Lehmann
Feb 19, 2014 Ted Lehmann rated it 5 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommends it for: social policy, liking medical books, or general purpose readers of memoir and non-fiction
Recommended to Ted by: Bob Cook
In Twelve Patients: Life and Death at Bellevue Hospital (Grand Central Publishing/The Hatchette Group, 2013, 349 Pages, $9.99 Kindle edition) Dr. Eric Manheimer tells a story about the American health care system set in Bellevue Hospital, which is the oldest and largest hospital in the United States. As a public hospital it serves the needs of those populations not well-served by the huge infrastructure of America's hospital and larger medical industries. Through its vast doors come the immigran...more
Esme Pie
Only kept reading because the patients were so interesting, both as illustrations of the kinds of cases that come to Bellevue, and as a lens through which to examine current topics in medicine today. I even liked the author's personal cancer story.
But the author is a horrible writer and could have been so easily helped by a good editor. First, time and sequence are hard to follow. The author was allowed to tell too much of his own personal (non-medical) story so that he comes across as super-hu...more
David
I've been on a kick reading books by doctors about the practice of medicine, and this is one of the finest. Far more than just a series of case histories, though it includes that, this is a literary text, as good as any book of fiction, with a strong voice, wonderfully wrought images and characters, and a goal of exploring the lives of people, both patients and doctors. I wish this author was a friend so that I could go out to dinner with him and just listen to his stories. Smart, engaging, full...more
Charlotte
HAD to finish this book, if only to say I did. Did not enjoy this book. I liked the parts about pt. care, but the Backstory was frustrating. Every chapter had a lecture about how America deals with illegale immigrants, obesity,hospital budgets, pt. care in poor conditions. I'm familiar with medical terminology & procedures which was the only thing that kept me reading. Did not like being lectured to after each Pt. care. I found that the author used this book as a platform for his beliefs, wh...more
Melinda
I couldn't wait to read Twelve Patients. The jacket summary depicted a well rounded read with the luxury of a glimpse behind the scenes through Dr. Manheimer's experience during his tenure as director.��

The patients profiled came from various walks of life and varying background and circumstances. The book also touched upon issues plaguing the medical community as well as social questions on these issues. Addressing the hot topics from the eyes of a professional medical practicer is enlightening...more
Melissa Dally
Wow, this could've been so much better. The parts where he sticks to discussing the patients and their stories really is interesting. The parts where he digresses and goes off on tangents and tangents to those tangents is just boring. I wish they could clean this up, it would rate at least another star (two more stars if the parts where he gets judgmental were removed).
Matthew Dixon
Such a disappointment. The subject matter fascinates but the book goes off the rails almost immediately and stays there. The physician who wrote it has limited writing skills. the prose is dry and clinical. But more than that, every case chronicle comes back to the doctor himself and his own life, habits, loves, etc. Just way too self-absorbed.
Gabriele Ott
Great book! I've always enjoyed medical books for the scientific/medical aspects of them. But this book also teaches you about humility, history, compassion and just genuine caring. Well written and one could just hope to have a doctor like Eric Manheimer, who truly deeply cares about his profession after years and years.
Susan Olesen
Eh? Took me almost a month to hack through it because it just never grabbed me. Not a "this is my daily insanity" book, but a very slow, thoughtful, evaluation of 12 cases he's dealt with. I've read much more exciting books about Bellevue. It boils down to this: All patients have a story; most seriously ill patients, whether disease or trauma-based, almost always have some major emotional/physical/mental trauma that brought them to the circumstances where they needed the hospitalization, and Doc...more
Kasey
I really enjoyed this book. I'm sure my interest & experience in ER/Psych/Corrections nursing is a big factor in my fascination of the Bellevue world described; as well as my interest in the Latin American culture. Not sure someone who doesn't share these interest would enjoy it as much, but I sure did! I sure would like to meet someone who knows Dr. Manheimer personally, and be able to question them "Is he really that nice?" "Does he really go out of his way so much as to help out the famil...more
Emma
A really fascinating read; Dr. Manheimer attempts, and mostly succeeds, at integrating short-story/journalistic profiles of individual patients with macro-size analysis of healthcare and social policy in America. His style, though, is not going to be to everybody's liking. I understand why he would want to frame things using conversations between himself and his patients, their families, and colleagues. But while his authorial voice is very strong, it may be too strong. When he is writing as "Ma...more
CD
A 'life & death' memoir that contains both therapeutic and political statements by the author.

This was not exactly, or probably even vaguely what I expected when I started reading. A balanced slice of life work that perhaps leans a bit more towards the sadder and tragic part of life. Of course this is from Bellevue Hospital in New York. Along with Bellevue's great successes and happy moments there is indeed much from the other end of the spectrum.

Early in the book the comparisons between U.S...more
Gina
Interesting stories about the patients who come in to Bellevue Hospital, which is not just a mental hospital anymore. Somewhat depressing at times. There is often not a happy ending.
Got a little tired of the author's constant harping on how America (specifically, the war on drugs) has screwed up Mexico, Central and South America. Uh, I think those in charge of those countries themselves share some responsibility. America can't control everything.
His case study of an obese woman in a family full...more
AJ
This book was written by the doctor who served as the head of Bellevue Hospital for about 15 years. I was really looking forward to reading it. Though I did enjoy it, I was a bit disappointed. It wasn't as good as I was expecting.

Each chapter addresses different social ills that society is facing, filtered through the patients and situations encountered at Bellevue which arguably sees most of these issues first hand because of its status as a public hospital in the biggest city in the country. I...more
Karen
The author, a former medical director, uses 12 patients (he's one of them; he was diagnosed with cancer and underwent chemo and radiation) as "windows" into 12 different systemic and ethical problems--illegal immigration, the foster care system, alcoholism, compliance, organ donation, etc. The writing is uneven at times; he ostensibly quotes patients, but their voices sound surprisingly like his own; and sometimes stories/chapters end with a strange abruptness. But I like this sort of book for t...more
Tami
Really 3.5 stars.

Dr. Manheimer chose 12 stories from the potentially hundreds, maybe even thousands, of patient stories he could have told from his time as the medical director of Bellevue Hospital in NYC. In his own words: "... I chose the patients that illustrated different aspects of what are arguably among the critical contemporary issues in are society — those with global implications."

And so he did. Each of the tales he tells are infused not only with the medical details you'd expect, but...more
Terry
Dr. Manheimer has his heart in the right place in writing this book, but overall, I was disappointed with it for several reasons.

First, I had the Audiobook version, and that led to a great degree of my disappointment. Dr. M reads his own book which is a disaster if you do not have the right voice to keep readers engaged. He doesn't. I found myself drifting away from it while I was listening because of his monotone voice and lack of expression. He sounded as if he was reading a bedtime story to h...more
Ariel
I was so looking forward to reading this book but the execution did not live up to my expectations. I thought that twelve really fascinating House style cases would be laid out. The reality was more convoluted. The stories meandered and often included a lot of personal information about the author's own life, like his fight against cancer. He also likes to detail his food choices. It seems like every other page has a description of some food he's eaten or brought to a patient. A more competent e...more
Zach
This is a great book, for medical people and anthropologically or sociologically interested folk as well.

Dr. Manheimer talks in great detail about a variety of patients and their deeper lives which do in fact represent a microcosm of the greater US medical population.

There IS a story behind every patient. Everyone you see in a hospital is in the throws of some life altering event and this warrants consideration.

This sums up my review...

"The past day was reverberating in my head and my body as I...more
Sheryl
I don't remember what list I originally found this on, but I thought it would be like reading the New York Times' "Well" column - clever and interesting anecdotes about a doctor at a large city hospital with quirky characters.

Not even close.

Manheimer is the Medical Director at Bellevue hospital, which is the oldest public hospital in the country, and yes, the one that has the psych ward featured on Law and Order. The stories he tells are much more complex politically and socially than I expecte...more
Anna Kasm-tykhonova
Very thought provoking. The author views the patients as people, not as patients or clients ( which is sadly so common nowadays in healthcare). I wish more healthcare providers viewed their patients from such a humanistic, non judgmental perspective in order to help them more effectively. The author also does a fine job shining light on the recent changes in healthcare caused by the sluggish economy and the way it effected people's lives. Highly recommended.
Bob Cook
Having interned at Bellevue many years ago, I was interested to read this account by the doc who was medical director for a dozen or so years. Aside from his tidbit droppings of a Renaissance Man, which were mildly annoying, I found it to be a fascinating examination into the state of medicine today. Taking the stories of twelve of his patients at Bellevue as the outline, the author fills in that outline with his own observations on the beauty and the shortcomings of medicine.
Rachel
I loved moments of this book-- some images and lines that Manheimer shares, and the lives he gives us access to. Unfortunately, he includes too much of himself along the way, and often in a self-aggrandizing manner that takes away from the content of the book, people's stories. He also preaches, and while I agree with his views and often learned from what he shared, the liberal morsels lacked cohesion and often summed up things too quickly or broadly. And the typos and poor sentences and excess...more
Cathymw
The author used the stories of 12 different patients to highlight various societal issues ranging from immigration to obesity to addiction, etc. I didn't always agree with his take on these various issues, but I did appreciate that he looked beyond possible stereotypes to discover what these patients' stories and lives were really like. That said, his writing style left some things to be desired. The stories seemed to ramble quite a bit, with a lot of extraneous details. He interjected himself i...more
Peggy
Great concept but the writing was too monotonous for me. Most sentences follow the exact same structure of subject-verb-object. Others were just badly constructed. The author is obviously an extremely intelligent doctor. There's no need for him to also write brilliantly, but there is a need for his publisher to hire an editor who can eliminate all the misplaced and dangling modifiers.
Amy Dix
The stories themselves are compelling and for that reason I stuck with this book. However, the author isn't a great writer, which given his profession seems like an unfair critique. His editors should have helped him a bit more there. Additionally, at times I felt as though he painted his characters in a light that made them seem unrealistically wonderful or alternatively terrible. Given that the work is non-fiction, I take this aspect as his own interpretations of the patients and families he e...more
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 46 47 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
  • Blue Collar, Blue Scrubs: The Making of a Surgeon
  • Singular Intimacies: Becoming a Doctor at Bellevue
  • The Nazi and the Psychiatrist: Hermann Göring, Dr. Douglas M. Kelley, and a Fatal Meeting of Minds at the End of WWII
  • My Beautiful Genome: Exposing Our Genetic Future, One Quirk at a Time
  • Sweet Hell on Fire: A Memoir of the Prison I Worked In and the Prison I Lived In
  • Confessions of a Surgeon: The Good, the Bad, and the Complicated...Life Behind the O.R. Doors
  • Direct Red: A Surgeon's Story
  • County: Life, Death and Politics at Chicago's Public Hospital
  • White Coat: Becoming A Doctor At Harvard Medical School
  • Match Day: One Day and One Dramatic Year in the Lives of Three New Doctors
  • One Doctor: Close Calls, Cold Cases And The Mystery Of Medicine
  • Brooklyn Zoo: The Education of a Psychotherapist
  • Madness: a Memoir
  • The Intern Blues: The Timeless Classic About the Making of a Doctor
  • The First Book Of Calamity Leek
  • Screw Everyone: Sleeping My Way to Monogamy
  • Breakthrough!: How the 10 Greatest Discoveries in Medicine Saved Millions and Changed Our View of the World
  • Over My Head: A Doctor's Own Story of Head Injury from the Inside Looking Out
Islam: Evolution and Development

Share This Book

“finally, I couldn’t tell a patient’s story in front of two hundred nurses in one room without including a doctor’s number one lesson: We all have to listen to our nurses. Listen to the people who spend all of their time at the bedside. You really don’t need gray hair to figure that one out. But you will get it prematurely if you don’t!” 0 likes
More quotes…