The Light Between Oceans

Dec 04, 2012 Jeanette rated it 4 of 5 stars · review of another edition

Shelves: all-fiction, domestic-and-relationship-fiction, four-star-fiction, the-land-down-under

"Sometimes life turns out hard, Isabel. Sometimes it just bites right through you. And sometimes, just when you think it's done its worst, it comes back and takes another chunk."

Remember when you were four years old, and your mother was just about your entire world? If you can remember that long-ago feeling of attachment to a parent, or if you have a child, or if you have longed for a child of your own, your heart will break for little Lucy. And it will break for all the grown-ups who loved her,...more

81 likes · like · see review

Oct 22, 2012 Brenda rated it 5 of 5 stars · review of another edition

Shelves: 2012-release, aussie-authors, own-read

What a wonderfully complex and morally riveting story! I literally could not put this down, and read for a solid 3 hours last night, until 1am, when I finished this book!

When Tom Sherbourne returned from WWI, he was a shattered man. He needed a quiet place to gather his thoughts, to calm himself, as he didn’t believe he should have survived the war, when his mates did not. So he became a lighthouse keeper, and over the next few years, he did his job, and learned his trade, until he accepted the...more

39 likes · like · see review

Dec 26, 2012 Gabe Vazquez rated it 5 of 5 stars · review of another edition

Shelves: favorites

The Light Between Oceans was an incredible moving novel about what happens when good people make bad decisions. The story takes place in the town of Point Partageuse, Australia during the 1920s. The story begins when a light house keeper (Tom) and his wife (Isabel) find a life boat with a dead man and live baby in it on the beach and have to make tough decisions regarding the baby's future.

This book was an incredible quick read, but never once did I feel it was forced or lacking in anyway. The s...more

87 likes · like · see review

May 09, 2013 Kristalia rated it 5 of 5 stars · review of another edition

Shelves: adult, own-physical-copy, got-this-book-as-a-gift, favorites, reviewed, sob-fest-its-just-so-sad, be-my-hero-plz, cut-my-heart-out, they-are-so-cute-its-unbearable

FINAL RATING: ★★★★★/★★★★★

“...or I can forgive and forget...Oh, but my treasure, it is so much less exhausting. You only have to forgive once. To resent, you have to do it all day, every day. You have to keep remembering all the bad things...we always have a choice.”

One word: Beautiful. And also beautiful. and beautiful. and beautiful....

I cannot even begin the review properly. This book crushed my feelings, brought them back together and did it all over and over again. I smiled and i cried....more

18 likes · like · see review

Nov 10, 2012 Lou rated it 5 of 5 stars · review of another edition

Shelves: literature

Just added today saturday 10th some long needed excerpts that I was meant to add a while back.

A wonderful moving heartfelt story.
The lighthouse has a new occupant a veteran who soon finds himself amongst the quaint beautiful surroundings in need of company and finds love then eventually as the tide passes and the seasons change they have need for children like many couples do. They fear one day this passage of joy and happiness will be swept away from them for very good reasons. In the course o...more
Just added today saturday 10th some long needed excerpts that I was meant to add a while back.

A wonderful moving heartfelt story.
The lighthouse has a new occupant a veteran who soon finds himself amongst the quaint beautiful surroundings in need of company and finds love then eventually as the tide passes and the seasons change they have need for children like many couples do. They fear one day this passage of joy and happiness will be swept away from them for very good reasons. In the course of having and raising a child they go though a process of emotions and feelings that go with love, loss, betrayal, regret, shame, and love all over again. The harrowing journey the characters go through in the light that started in the oceans has your heart in your throat at times and you are guaranteed to have thoughts on love, betrayal and forgiveness remain for some time in your mind. This was a great accomplishment for a debut a love story that deserves all the praise it has received from Goodreads to Oprah's Magazine.

Excerpts

"There are times when the ocean is not the ocean-not blue, not even water, but some violent explosion of energy and danger; ferocity on a scale only gods can summon. It hurls itself at the island, sending spray right over the top of he lighthouse, biting pieces off the cliff. And the sound is a roaring of a beast whose anger knows no limits. Those are the nights the light is needed the most."

"The oceans never stop. They know no beginning or end. The wind never finishes. Sometimes it disappears, but only to gather momentum from somewhere else, returning to fling itself at the island, to make a point which is lost on Tom. Existence here is on a scale of giants. Time is in the million of years; rocks which from a distance look like dice cast against the shore are boulders hundreds of feet wide, licked round by millennia, tumbled onto their sides so that layers become vertical stripes."

"It's like being in a different world, out there, and a different time: nothing changes except seasons. There are dozens of lighthouses all around the coast of Australia: plenty more fellows like me, trying to make ships safe, keeping the light for whoever might need it, even though we'll mostly never see them or know who they are."

"Quite the war hero, too. Military Cross and Bar. I've read your citations: captured a German machine-gun nest single-handed. Carried four of your men to safety under sniper fire. And the rest." Sprang let a moment pass."You must have killed a lot of people in your time."
Tom remained silent."

Review and author video and trailer @ http://more2read.com/review/the-light-between-oceans-by-m-l-stedman/(less)

14 likes · like · see review

Jan 12, 2013 Rob Mango rated it 5 of 5 stars · review of another edition

Light Between Oceans. (Stedman)

Much has been written about the conclusion of counselor Stedman's impressive debut. Prepare to encounter a plot in which one is held suspended until the final chapter,the author skillfully engages the template of the irresolvable outcome.We who require fiction, know this perilous path.Not unlike her characters there is vulnerability for her along this intrepid heading, dividing the readers into camps of wanting ,needing a particular resolution,in order to avoid the...more Light Between Oceans. (Stedman)

Much has been written about the conclusion of counselor Stedman's impressive debut. Prepare to encounter a plot in which one is held suspended until the final chapter,the author skillfully engages the template of the irresolvable outcome.We who require fiction, know this perilous path.Not unlike her characters there is vulnerability for her along this intrepid heading, dividing the readers into camps of wanting ,needing a particular resolution,in order to avoid the abysmal disappointment which awaits(in itself courageous). Many will judge the quality of the writing by the fate assigned to their preferred character. To those who arrive at the final page deflated,and will regard the book harshly,I address my review.
Clearly this work is a confrontation between moral truth and human instinct,wrapped in a beautiful location, unfamiliar hemisphere,in an earlier epoch few alive today have witnessed.
The back stories in themselves more than justify the time invested and compelling emotion aroused. One such resume takes us into the trenches of Tripoli and the ensuing nightmares of the man who inhabited them.The backgrounds and set-up of the three primary characters are informative,economic and laced with subtle relevancy. Descriptions languidly unfold of feminine manor and costume,nautical forces,unique Aussie marsupials and the optical dynamics of a turn of the century lighthouse.Together they assemble a picture in the minds eye that last well beyond a divisive plot resolution.
The character representing moral truth is of opposite gender to the author.Tom is rendered thoughtfully with an empathy and insight that impressed me greatly.I found the handling of the lighthouse keeper,a WWI vet a distinctive strength of the novel.The two women represent unchained human instinct;the maternal variety,arguably the strongest force among living things,easily stronger than the conscience of one man who ultimately could not sustain their deception. Their personalities are rendered uniquely different with purposeful detail but animated by the same need.One senses with foreboding their inevitable clash which steadily increases our anxiety and empathy.Explosive emotions generated by their conflicting claim,result in a head on encounter of the feminine imperative,to which they cling through the fateful conclusion and beyond.
(less)

23 likes · like · see review

Nov 05, 2012 Barbara Williams rated it 2 of 5 stars · review of another edition

Shelves: war-what-is-it-good-for, what-a-twist, why-do-you-let-me-down, dumb-ass-heroine

I am going to start with review with a disclaimer. This review is subjective, from my point of view etc. I thought this book was terrible, bad, no good. You don’t have to agree with me, and you could think that this was the most AMAZING book and your eyes almost exploded from all the awesomeness that traveled through them to reach your brain which leapt in your skull with every sentence you read, and that is fine. I do not think that you are inferior to me.

Now on to my review. Stop here for spo...more I am going to start with review with a disclaimer. This review is subjective, from my point of view etc. I thought this book was terrible, bad, no good. You don’t have to agree with me, and you could think that this was the most AMAZING book and your eyes almost exploded from all the awesomeness that traveled through them to reach your brain which leapt in your skull with every sentence you read, and that is fine. I do not think that you are inferior to me.

Now on to my review. Stop here for spoilers (although you might regret it! It’s an awesome review.)

I am not one to judge books by their covers, although a good cover is always a bonus, and this book has a excellent one. Props to the graphic designer. Combined with being on the New York Times Best Seller list, and having an first rate premise, I thought this one was a winner. But I was wrong. DEAD WRONG (ok that is a little dramatic.) If I was describe my reading experience like the ocean tides, sometimes I would be fine, floating near the shore, but other times it would sweep me out to sea with its ridiculousness. The conclusion didn’t help the novel’s case. It left a distinctly bitter taste in my mouth.

So basically the premise is that a couple, Tom and Isabel, living on a island in a lighthouse in Australia, find a dead man and baby ashore. Isabel, filled with grief from her last three miscarriages, begs her husband to kidnap the baby and bury the dead man in a ditch so she can be fulfilled as a woman and finally have a child. She assumes that the mother is dead, so I mean, is she really doing anything wrong? It’s like when you find a stray dog and it has a collar. What if the dog was being abused, so that’s why it ran away? It’s your duty to keep that cute dog and love it forever. Except…. This is a BABY. Now I have never had a miscarriage, nor have I ever had children, so I guess this is why I hated Isabel so much. I don’t understand her point of view AT ALL. I agreed with Tom, and was pretty mad when his sympathies got the better of him. I mean really, it’s a BABY people. It is a human life you're messing with!

So Tom and Isabel visit the main land like every three years, and this time they bring the baby, who they have named Lucy, for her christening and to show off to everyone. Now here comes the twist: the mother is alive! Shocker I know. So Tom once again is like, “Hey, this is kidnapping now, and the mother is literally insane with grief. Maybe we should give back her baby.” And Isabel is all like, “No! I can’t have babies. And I am a selfish person who is pretending to be a good person by saying it is better for the baby if she stays with us. We can’t confuse Lucy!” For me, I have always thought love was doing what is best for the person you care for. Apparently, this is not what Isabel thinks love is, so this makes her the villain of the story in my perspective.

So of course, Tom and Isabel are found out eventually, all by Tom’s doing, so he takes the blame for everything. This is the point where I want to give up on the book, and it’s not because I hate Isabel for letting Tom take the blame to make him suffer for taking Lucy away. The story is full of pointless dialog and characters (and not even Jane Austin style with enjoyable pointless dialog.) It is like Stedman’s publisher was like, “This novel has to be 300+ pages so, get on that and write me some more!” I think I would have enjoyed this story much more if it was a short story. I skimmed the last chapters, just so I could be done with it.

Now there are some redeeming factors to this novel ( I mean it’s not like this is 50 Shades of Gray terrible, I gave it two stars) . Stedman is a great writer when it comes down to descriptions of the island of Janus and little antidotes about the 1920’s in Australia. I just didn’t like her characters, NOT one of them.

So my conclusion is read this book for yourself and make up your own opinion. As for me, I still need to learn that “judging a book by its cover” is a phrase for a reason.
(less)

71 likes · like · see review

Feb 07, 2013 Averil rated it 5 of 5 stars · review of another edition

My very first book for 2013, and one I spent the latter half of last year just longing to get my hands on.

Well, I finished The Light Between Oceans in only two sittings, in one single day! And this novel - a heartbreaking exploration of right and wrong, and the lonely windswept grey island which lies between the two - has completely wrung me out on only Day One of a brand new reading year.

How I wept. I mean absolutely WEPT. No parent could bear such sorrow, on either side of the swirling misery...more

19 likes · like · see review

Oct 07, 2012 Jennie Walters rated it 3 of 5 stars · review of another edition

I enjoyed this book, particularly towards the end, which was more subtle and unexpected than I'd predicted. My reservations were largely that some of the dialogue seemed a bit clunky, and at first the relationship between Tom and Isabel, the main protagonists, didn't quite convince - the scene where Isabel imitates the other dinner guests, for example, didn't succeed for me. But by the end, I had really warmed to Tom, the hero of the book, who although damaged by his experiences in the war, is s...more

34 likes · like · see review

Jan 26, 2013 Rose rated it 5 of 5 stars · review of another edition

Shelves: group-local-book-club

I have been in a deep reading slump and "The Light Between Oceans” was so very refreshing for me. I could almost feel the sea spray and smell the sea air. The details about isolated living on the tiny island really grabbed my imagination. The story swept me up like an ocean wave and kept me tumbling until the end. You can see the train wreck coming but have no idea how or when it will happen and how the characters will deal with it, you can't look away. This is a wonderful story about the fragil...more

11 likes · like · see review

May 15, 2013 Tania rated it 5 of 5 stars · review of another edition

Shelves: favorite-books, best

"We live with the decisions we make".

I absolutely loved this book. It did not want it to end, but could not put it down. It was beautifully written and the characters were all very well developed. I felt for all of them. The setting was interesting, I've never thought about living in a lighthouse, on a small island, hundreds of miles from everything else. Most of all though I was riveted by the story. It touches on so many moral issues, without being judgmental. This is also one of the best lov...more

7 likes · like · see review

Mar 21, 2013 Barbara rated it 5 of 5 stars · review of another edition

Recommended to Barbara by: Debby and Rose

Shelves: historical-fiction

I frequently give thought to what appeals to us in our reading. Certainly,appreciation of a book is influenced by our life experiences, but there must be more. The effort that an author takes in writing has to contribute to the many dimensions of telling her tale. With all of that in mind, I have come to the easily reached conclusion that M.L. Stedman has achieved her goal. It is not difficult for me to give her my rare 5 star rating.

This is an unique, stirring tale of a young Australian couple...more

13 likes · like · see review

May 19, 2013 Michael rated it 5 of 5 stars · review of another edition

Shelves: top-rating-books, ozzie-gems

The Light Between Oceans is a thought provoking read about how decisions made can have grave consequences in the future. The story goes of Tom Sherbourne who after 4 years fighting in Europe during WW1 returns to Australia a different man. After the horrors he seen he needs a complete break from reality and finds it as a lighthouse keeper on a remote Island of Western Australia Janus Rock. For a while it is just him and the lighthouse and that is just the way he likes it. but after being ashore...more The Light Between Oceans is a thought provoking read about how decisions made can have grave consequences in the future. The story goes of Tom Sherbourne who after 4 years fighting in Europe during WW1 returns to Australia a different man. After the horrors he seen he needs a complete break from reality and finds it as a lighthouse keeper on a remote Island of Western Australia Janus Rock. For a while it is just him and the lighthouse and that is just the way he likes it. but after being ashore on a few times and the only human contact being supply ships that come every six months Tom starts to ponder what it would be like to share his life with someone else. That someone will show herself in name of Isabel Graysmark.

Isabel is a fun loving and adventurous women and after a few chance encounters it's clear to all there is more than just friendship there between the two. What concerns Tom though is how Isabel would adapt to living on Janus with the isolation and harsh weather but Isabel assures Tom things will be fine and they will be happy. Those thoughts are tested after two miscarriages and one stillbirth that rock Isabel to the core and leave Tom seemingly helpless on what to do. Just when the couple have resigned themselves to the thought of never being parents then a boat would be found washed up onshore. Inside is a dead man and a baby girl. Tom wants to inform the mainland of there finding but Isabel convinces Tom otherwise and the two will soon raise the child as there own a decision that will come back to haunt them later in life.

This was an amazing read that had me constantly questioning what was right and wrong and how in this case the line was alot finer than is normally the case. The two main characters were so likable and even with there choices i didn't begruge them wanting happiness after years of despair. Tom inparticular was great as a tortured soul who just wanted to make Izz happy and would sacrifice himself to ensure her wellbeing. While the other characters all played significant roles in the decisons that are made. The characters all had parts to play and made it feel like a community albeit one struggling to do the right thing. Janus was also memorable with Stedman's writing making me feel like i was there experiencing the isolation and how this was for Tom. The best thing about the book was it made me think what would i do faced with the situation Tom And Izz found themselves in? Yes putting yourself under the microscope might seem uncomfortable but it is also enlightening. This would be a perfect read for book clubs and one i would gladly recommend the everyone.(less)

4 likes · like · see review

Apr 27, 2013 Parvathy rated it 5 of 5 stars · review of another edition

Shelves: broken-characters, family-drama, informative, historicals, movie-material, living-vicariously, please-pass-the-tissues, thought-provoking, tower-read, tower-team-d

It is true that they say that it is the little things that make a book memorable. Little moments that stay with long after the book has ended which culminates over that years and make you think that you have stumbled upon a master piece. This book is full of such moments.. moments so poignant that I don't think that I will be able to forget them no matter how hard I tried. I never really have given much thought to the life of a lighthouse keeper. May be because I live in this age and far away fr...more It is true that they say that it is the little things that make a book memorable. Little moments that stay with long after the book has ended which culminates over that years and make you think that you have stumbled upon a master piece. This book is full of such moments.. moments so poignant that I don't think that I will be able to forget them no matter how hard I tried. I never really have given much thought to the life of a lighthouse keeper. May be because I live in this age and far away from any ocean that the whole concept is kind of foreign to me. Recently When I think of beach or ocean all I can think of is sand and getting dirty so I try to avoid trips to the beach as far as possible. But having read this book and being introduced to the ocean in a whole new light I am about to change my attitude. The magic of
the sea that was woven into this book and the intricacies of a life left to its own devices have made me realize that there is a whole new world out there that is unexplored and inexperienced. Feelings left unexplained and untouched.

After having lived through a war and being discharged with all the honors that a military officer like him could have Tom wants nothing more than to live the rest of his life tending to the light that saves the life of those who are drift in the ocean. When he gets and opportunity to become the lighthouse keeper at the isolated Juan Islands he accepts it without a second thought. Then he meets
Isabel a happy go lucky girl who takes an instant liking to him "his other half of the sky". From there we take a journey with the couple as the struggle through life, the happiness the find in each other at that isolated island with the lighthouse that has become the center of their life, the miscarriages that Isabel suffers that turns her in to the desperate woman, the baby who washes up on a boat and the choices that each of them make portray a very moving story. But the story itself is not which makes this book work. It is the characters their emotions, their fears, their longing all makes this story as real as anything you have experienced. The moments when Isabel washes her still born child and cries holding the child in her arms, the scenes were Isabel's mother Violet reminiscences about her dead sons. Coming to know of her son's death when a box of his belongings is delivered to her, Tom consoling Isabel after each of her miscarriages and Isabel lashing out at him for her predicament as he is the only person on the island with her with Tom saying nothing in return holding on to his own despair, Isabel looking at the markings on the wall and thinking her of her dead brothers words saying that they will be back when she grows this tall, making her realize that she has never really grew up to that height, every time Tom calls the child he found "littlie" and ever time she calls him Dadda and promises that she will love him forever and ever and ever...... There are many more of these moments that make this book a worth while read and brings tears to my eyes but I can't divulge all of it without giving up the story. So I will leave it up to you guys to read and find out. All in All a moving tale about choices and sacrifices persons have to make in life and the consequences of those actions.(less)

6 likes · like · see review

Aug 17, 2012 Robert rated it 3 of 5 stars · review of another edition

Shelves: first-reads

A woman’s love for her child never falters, never truly manages to say goodbye. It’s a powerful message, and one certainly worthy of an entire novel that spans decades. Based on this theme, the timespan seems appropriate, even if there’s a lot of back and forth between the past and present, at least initially, before the theme really takes hold, and the story takes off a bit.

Isabel was a hard character for me to like, but then I’m not a mother, and I have absolutely no context for what it’s like...more A woman’s love for her child never falters, never truly manages to say goodbye. It’s a powerful message, and one certainly worthy of an entire novel that spans decades. Based on this theme, the timespan seems appropriate, even if there’s a lot of back and forth between the past and present, at least initially, before the theme really takes hold, and the story takes off a bit.

Isabel was a hard character for me to like, but then I’m not a mother, and I have absolutely no context for what it’s like to lose a child to miscarriage. And in her case, it wasn’t just one child that met this fate, but two children. Even though she’d given up what amounted to a normal life to live with her husband, I still viewed the world in black and white and thought it was wrong to take Lucy and raise her as her own. It’s a decision that affects more than just her and her husband. In some ways you could say a whole town was affected by her decision, just as she was affected by Tom’s decision to be a lighthouse keeper. In the end, though, I grew to like her a bit as a character, and I came to understand, at least on some level, why she had made the choice that she did with Lucy. I attribute that at least in part to M.L. Stedman’s abilities as an author. She’s a writer with talent, and I can see why Amazon has chosen the book as its book of the month for August. It’s a book that would do well with book clubs, especially book clubs with a large feminine presence, as Isabel’s decision can be debated back and forth for longer than just a mere cup of tea.

I struggled with how to rate this novel. Throughout most of the book, though, I was ready to rate the novel with three stars. In the end, I’ve decided to stick with this rating, as it seems the most accurate. Being an author myself, and knowing the journey that most writers face to publication, especially those that seek out large and small traditional publishers, it’s hard for me not to find some redeeming quality in the writing, some spark that helps guide me toward the end. This book certainly had that spark, but I’m not sure I can say I really liked it. I certainly came to like many of the characters, and it certainly proved a quicker read than I expected, although it’s certainly not a light read, not with the themes that are flowing through this novel. It’s a book that will slowly digest over time, and I suppose that’s why it’s a bit hard for me to commit to a rating right now. If you’re looking for a book to debate, or to think about long after you’ve closed it, then this is a book you’ll probably want to add to your reading pile.

I received this book for free through Goodreads First Reads.(less)

7 likes · like · see review

Apr 15, 2012 Shelleyrae at Book'd Out rated it 4 of 5 stars · review of another edition

Shelves: other-reviews, aussie-author

The Light Between Oceans is a compelling debut from Australian born author M.L. (Margot) Stedman. Set on a tiny island off the coast of Western Australia, where the the Indian Ocean meets the Southern Ocean, this novel explores the haunting consequences of love and desire. Tom Sherbourne is the lighthouse keeper at Janus Rock, a position that has afforded him some measure of peace after the horrors of World War One. During his infrequent visits to the mainland at Port Partageuse, he develops a r...more The Light Between Oceans is a compelling debut from Australian born author M.L. (Margot) Stedman. Set on a tiny island off the coast of Western Australia, where the the Indian Ocean meets the Southern Ocean, this novel explores the haunting consequences of love and desire. Tom Sherbourne is the lighthouse keeper at Janus Rock, a position that has afforded him some measure of peace after the horrors of World War One. During his infrequent visits to the mainland at Port Partageuse, he develops a relationship with the spirited Isabel Graysmark whom he eventually marries and the two create a life together on Rock. Their bliss is marred only by Isabel's repeated miscarriages so when a boat drifts ashore carrying a dead man and squalling infant girl, Isabel convinces Tom that they have been granted a gift. Lucy becomes the light of their lives but Tom's unease with the situation never dissipates and when he learns the devastating truth he is torn between right and wrong, guilt and innocence, love and duty.

With stunning sensitivity, Stedman explores the grey, murky waters between the absolutes of right and wrong. Decisions made with good intentions, with love, prove ultimately to have consequences that cause irreparable harm. A heartbreaking tale that has strong emotional impact I found myself equally torn as the story unfolds, my sympathies lay with all the protagonists, two grieving women and a man who wants to do right by both of them. Joy is often juxtaposed by a sense of dread and tension seeps from pages.

Tom is a complex man, shaped by tragedy and war, he clings to the ideals of love, honour and duty. He knows how the lines between right and wrong can blur given circumstances and strives to do the right thing always. In this instance he fulfils his obligation to his wife, to love and honour her, by allowing himself to be persuaded to keep the child. When he discovers the consequences of that decision he is torn when honour and duty call for the child to be returned to the mother who still grieves her loss. I admired Tom for many reasons, not the least being his genuine emotional turmoil and strength of character.
Isabel is quite young when she marries Tom and moves to the Rock. She is feisty and headstrong but has a naivete and vulnerability that is endearing. I could not help but sympathise with her as she mourned her lost children, having experienced several miscarriages myself, and identified with her joy over the miraculous gift of Lucy. When Isabel's world falls apart I was horribly torn for Hannah is equally, perhaps even more, as deserving of sympathy. Isabel's violent reaction to Tom is shocking, if understandable and her final choice is a brave, if heart rending one.
It is rare that young children have well formed character in novels but Stedman achieves this in The Light Between Oceans. Lucy is as skillfully created and whole as the adult protagonists.

Stedman captures the unique atmosphere of time and place. Set in the aftermath of World War One her characters are reeling from the losses of the war. In the tiny town of Port Partaguese many of the boys and men who went to fight never returned and those that did, were forever changed. Isabel grieved her adored brothers and her miscarriages compound her sense of loss. She senses what proves to be true, that a grandchild will help heal her own parents broken hearts. For Tom, the memories of war, of death and destruction, are soothed by life on Janus Rock and Isabel's love, but are never far from his mind.
The author creates a spectacular atmosphere on Janus Rock, the tiny island that houses the lighthouse cared for by Tom and Isabel. The isolated splendour of the place is vividly described but Janus Rock is both an idyllic haven and a lonely outcrop. Tom and Isabel have contact with the outside world only once every three months and can return to mainland only once every few years.

The Light Between Oceans is a stunning novel, evocative and lyrical. Rich with emotion, extraordinary characters and story, this is a wonderful read, I happily recommend.

Reviewing for The Circle (Channel 10)(less)

5 likes · like · see review

Apr 14, 2013 Kara Thomas rated it 4 of 5 stars · review of another edition

Wow, what a moving book. I was in tears at the end. I really identified with all of Hannah's emotions and actions, even when I knew that they weren't the "right" things to be doing. Tom reminded me of my husband too. A rule follower who would give anything to make me happy and would pay a huge cost so I wouldn't have to pay for my own mistakes. I also loved the way the author wrapped up the story. Excellent novel! Looking forward to more from this author.

4 likes · like · see review

May 18, 2013 Kathryn rated it 5 of 5 stars · review of another edition

Recommended to Kathryn by: Bets On Bookreporter

Shelves: bets-on, 2012, national-blue-ribbon-book, favorites, indie-next-list

I was planning on giving this book four stars until the last 30 pages or so. The author brought the story together and eventually to a close so beautifully, so wisely, so touchingly. I must say I've never cried while reading a book, but I came awfully close with this story. It's going to take me some time to move on to another story. Please read this story and see what you think.

3 likes · like · see review

Nov 08, 2012 (Lonestarlibrarian) Keddy Ann Outlaw rated it 5 of 5 stars · review of another edition

I was totally mesmerized by not only the characters, setting (an island off Australia) and plot, but best of all, by the author's use of language. Examples: A boardinghouse landlady is "as stout as a pepper pot." Another character is described as having "a bulldog scowl." It wasn't long before I knew I was in the hands of a talented writer.

Another appeal factor is the suspense involved when the lighthouse keeper, Tom Sherbourne, and his wife Isabel decide to keep a baby that washes ashore in a b...more

11 likes · like · see review

Nov 08, 2012 Elaine rated it 5 of 5 stars · review of another edition

Shelves: favorites

This book was amazing. Totally heart wrenching. Probably one of the best books I've read this year. For the last 140 pages I could not put it down and I could not stop crying. I just bawled my way right to the end!!! Brilliant first novel.

15 likes · like · see review

May 19, 2013 Suzanne rated it 2 of 5 stars · review of another edition

Shelves: did-not-finish

I just can’t do this. Halfway through, but cannot go on. There are people waiting for this library copy, and the library is calling it back in, so I am going to relinquish it to someone who actually wants to read it.

Given the moral choices that form the heart of the plot, this could have been a much better book, if it were, you know, well-written. Apart from the fairly good initial characterization of Tom Sherbourne as a WWI vet suffering from memories of a troubled childhood and PTSD from war...more

5 likes · like · see review

Mar 12, 2013 Lisa rated it 3 of 5 stars · review of another edition

Shelves: review-copy, australia, historical-fiction

Last night I was in the mood for something light to read at bedtime, so I started The Light Between Oceans, a debut novel from expat Aussie M.L. Stedman, and I finished it this morning. It’s a page-turner.

It was, according to the publisher, the subject of a bidding war, and my guess is that it’s already been optioned for film, too. Probably a three-hankie film.

But that’s because it’s very good at what the story tries to do. It asks the question, who wins, when competing claims for a child’s love...more

7 likes · like · see review

Mar 27, 2013 Veronica rated it 5 of 5 stars · review of another edition

From the very first chapter, I knew I would love this book.

The Light Between Oceans is a stunning debut novel by M.L. Stedman. The entire novel and story unravels beautifully with nary a stutter or stumble.

Tom Sherbourne, a WWI vet is struggling to understand why his life was spared when all his friends have died in the war. Wanting to lead a quiet, lonely life with only his thoughts, he decides to take a post at an out of the way lighthouse. Upon arriving in Point Partageuse he meets and falls...more

3 likes · like · see review

Feb 25, 2013 Aras Redan rated it 5 of 5 stars · review of another edition

Shelves: good-on-my-shelves

Out of all the approximate 300 books I've read, 'The Light Between Oceans' was definitely one of the most emotional and moving ones, and I only have around 5 of those including this one.

Tom Sherbourne decides to become a lighthouse keeper in hopes of escaping his past as a soldier in WW1, and he is soon joined by his wife Isabel, who suffers through three miscarriages until the 'miracle' happens. One day, a boat washes up onto their shore, bringing with it a body of a dead man and more remarkab...more

4 likes · like · see review

Jan 23, 2013 Owen rated it 5 of 5 stars · review of another edition

Shelves: australia, australian-lit, historical-fiction, western-australia

Excellent first novel by an Australian writer who has quickly found the knack of combining intricate prose and plot with a realistic natural world. It is a world that we can easily imagine, but never really experience first hand. The story is partly set on a remote island where three of the main characters are isolated for lengthy periods in what is at times an idyll, and at others, a false world bearing no relation to that of the distant mainland. These two worlds eventually clash, giving the n...more

6 likes · like · see review

Apr 07, 2013 Pam rated it 3 of 5 stars · review of another edition

Shelves: fiction, historical-fiction, adult-fiction

The premise and opening have all the hallmarks of a classic. Set on a rocky island inhabited only by a lighthouse keeper and his young wife, a baby is washed ashore. The couple claim it as there own and then thus starts a chain of events that is devastating and heart breaking. Clearly a "WOW" first novel the protagonist, Tom is a well-drawn, sympathetic character who was interesting. Isabel his wife was not nearly as well developed and made her later actions difficult to fathom. The action rushe...more

1 like · like · see review

Jan 01, 2013 Julie Ekkers rated it 2 of 5 stars · review of another edition

Shelves: historical-fiction, fiction

The Light Between Oceans falls short of its promise. It is very plot-driven and thus, keeps the reader flipping the pages, and there is some lovely writing (though also some lengthy expository passages just dropped in instead of woven in). However, I did not find the characters to be very believable. For example, I did not feel Isabel's grief over her multiple miscarriages was expressed such that her belief a baby washed up in a rowboat with a dead man *must* be an orphan was convincing. I wasn'...more

9 likes · like · see review

Apr 06, 2013 Carri rated it 4 of 5 stars · review of another edition

A story of tragedy. A story of the power of young love. A story of right and wrong.

When a young soldier returns home from war he takes a job caring for a lighthouse. Meeting the love of his life things couldn't have been better until that day something washes ashore. The decisions that follow this young couple affect not only them, but many others. As they deal with matters of the heart everything turns and there seems to be no way out.

A tale of courage in telling the truth, pressing on in tri...more

1 like · like · see review

Oct 22, 2012 Chaitra rated it 1 of 5 stars · review of another edition

Shelves: read-in-2012, set-in-1920s, historical-fiction, literary-fiction, set-in-australia, great-cover-crap-book, book-at-wall, banging-heads-on-keyboards, oprah-book-club-crap, orange-prize-nominees

This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here. I first rated this 2 stars, and now, on further consideration, I've come to the conclusion that it's worth no more than 1 star. How much did I dislike this book? Let me count the ways.

First and foremost, the characterization. They're all fairly unlikable. Fairly? Kidding. They are absolutely unlikable. Tom Sherbourne and his wife Isabel have had three miscarriages. They find a baby in a boat along with a dead man, and decide that the baby is God's gift to them, and keep it. This is easy to do, b...more I first rated this 2 stars, and now, on further consideration, I've come to the conclusion that it's worth no more than 1 star. How much did I dislike this book? Let me count the ways.

First and foremost, the characterization. They're all fairly unlikable. Fairly? Kidding. They are absolutely unlikable. Tom Sherbourne and his wife Isabel have had three miscarriages. They find a baby in a boat along with a dead man, and decide that the baby is God's gift to them, and keep it. This is easy to do, because they're in a lighthouse in the middle of nowhere. All they have to do is hide the dead body (of the father) somewhere. They do this without turning a hair. They never ever think to at least make discreet enquiries if the baby had a family. They don't ever think that the father might be missed, that someone might be mourning for the pair of them. If they wanted a baby so much, why could they not have adopted one? There are plenty of war orphans around. Tom half-heartedly brings it up, and Isabel pooh-poohs the notion. The truth is, they do not try. At all.

Cut to two years later, they find that the baby has a living breathing mother. She's still mourning for the loss of her baby and husband, she's gaunt with it. What do our protagonists do (yes, they are protagonists not villains, surprise!)? Do they admit it? Nope. They take the baby and go back to the lighthouse. Isabel even dishes out a platitude to Tom - whose conscience has woken up - life is hard sometimes. What the? In any case, Tom decides to do something even more cruel to everyone concerned. He sends an anonymous letter to the mother that her baby is safe. Never once does anyone say that this was a bad thing. I mean, Isabel does, but only because it leads to circumstances where they have to give up the baby. But never do they even address the fact that Tom was being a bastard cruelly raising the hopes of a grieving person.

Then they do have to give up the baby. Tom takes it all on himself, and Isabel plots revenge! She lets people assume that Tom indeed was the person to blame, and also that he killed the father. She plays grieving mother and put upon wife to the hilt. The baby doesn't take so easily to its birth mother, and everyone around the birth mother to return the baby to these baby stealers! And she agrees! Then she changes her mind, but she doesn't press charges against these monsters. What the (again)?

No one, not a single person (except for a fringe character) takes Isabel to task. The reason: she had three miscarriages. Boo hoo. How does that explain that she stole a baby? That she never tried to at least find out if the baby had any family? That she never stepped into an orphanage to at least try to adopt one of the poor for-real orphans she was so upset about? When faced with the fact that the baby has a mother who's grieving, the lady has the audacity to think that the only reason she doesn't want to part with the baby is because she's thinking of the best for the baby. She never changes this opinion. All that she did was for the baby. Well, kill me dead. She calls the birth mother selfish for wanting her baby back. She calls Tom selfish because he thinks of the birth mother (though he is a moron). But is she selfish? Nope, not her - the most selfless person on earth, the only one that's thinking of the baby. Who is two. I doubt it would be very traumatized if it changed hands at that point in life. The tug of war (which is ridiculous) that ensues is so much more damaging to the child. Yet, we're meant to sympathize with and excuse this lady who carries on about how life has been more unfair to her than to the birth mother, than everyone else on this planet.

Aargh! I hated this so much. The two stars initially was for the writing, until I remembered that I was also annoyed by the CONSTANT use of mixed tenses. Stick to one tense lady! It's 'he did this and he did that' in one paragraph and 'he does this and he does that' in the very next. I get it. It's to distinguish between the specific and the general parts of the plot, but believe me, that can be done and understood by us poor readers with one freaking tense.

I won't be reading anything by this author again.(less)

40 likes · like · see review

Feb 19, 2013 Nola rated it 5 of 5 stars · review of another edition

Shelves: general-fiction

In this stunning debut novel, M. L. Stedman poses the question of how far you will go to shield a loved one from pain. It is 1926 and a young lighthouse keeper and his wife, Tom and Isabel, live on Janus Rock off the coast of Western Australia. They long to have children, but after two miscarriages and a still birth, their dreams are slippng away. One day a rowboat containing a dead man and a live baby washes up on the beach. Isabel believes that God has answered her prayers by sending the baby...more In this stunning debut novel, M. L. Stedman poses the question of how far you will go to shield a loved one from pain. It is 1926 and a young lighthouse keeper and his wife, Tom and Isabel, live on Janus Rock off the coast of Western Australia. They long to have children, but after two miscarriages and a still birth, their dreams are slippng away. One day a rowboat containing a dead man and a live baby washes up on the beach. Isabel believes that God has answered her prayers by sending the baby to her. Torn between his love for Isabel and his sense of duty, Tom agrees to go along with her plan and keep the baby. They haven't yet told anyone about the still birth two weeks previously, the baby's mother is probably dead, and no-one will know it's not their child. However, the truth eventually comes crashing down and they have to grapple with the consequences of what they have done.

This book hooked me right from the beginning. M. L. Stedman writes beautifully and the characters are well drawn. The moral dilemmas really get you thinking. What seems so black and white at the beginning becomes greyer as baby Lucy gets older. How can justice be served while also taking into account what's best for Lucy? I also liked the way that Stedman wove faith issues into the story. Would God really answer Isabel's prayers at the expense of the baby's real mother? How would Tom live with his conscience? Would justice really be served by Tom and Isabel being punished? What role do repentance and forgiveness play? Will their marriage survive? The book also gives an insight into what it was like for the returning soldiers of World War I in terms of their physical and emotional scars and the devastating effects of prejudice. It was certainly a thought-provoking read.

The book could have had a number of conclusions. As you're reading, it's obvious that not all of the characters can have a happy ending, but I wasn't sure which way it would go until the very end. I felt the pacing was slightly off in the last 50 pages, as a couple of events happened a little too quickly. I also felt that a couple of Hannah's actions were inconsistent and I thought there would have been more long-term consequences for Lucy. However, it was a very satisfying read overall. Beautiful, gut-wrenching, and thought-provoking. I would highly recommend it, but be sure to have the tissues handy for the last chapter. (less)

3 likes · like · see review

topics	posts	views	last activity
Am I the only one who think Isabel is stupid and should of listen to Tom ?	12	62	May 23, 2013 07:13pm
Incredible book	2	18	May 20, 2013 01:24pm
Twin Peaks Mom's ...: Buddy Reads "The Light Between Oceans"	1	3	May 12, 2013 06:14pm
discussion	81	486	May 11, 2013 01:37pm

title link	preview: The Light Between Oceans
avg rating	preview: The Light Between Oceans Goodreads rating: 3.99 (38646 ratings)
small image	preview: click here [close]
med image	preview: click here [close]
BBCode	[url=http://www.goodreads.com/book/show/13490654-the-light-between-oceans?utm_medium=api&utm_source=blog_book][img]http://d.gr-assets.com/books/1329589896l/13490654.jpg[/img][/url] [url=http://www.goodreads.com/book/show/13490654-the-light-between-oceans?utm_medium=api&utm_source=blog_book]The Light Between Oceans by M.L. Stedman[/url]

The Light Between Oceans

Friend Reviews

Lists with This Book

Community Reviews

new topic
Discuss This Book

combine
Other Editions (33)

Videos About This Book

Genres

Readers also enjoyed similar books

About M.L. Stedman

Books by M.L. Stedman

Share This Book

Share This Book on Your Website

Trivia About The Light Between...

Quotes from The Light Between Oceans