Analýza vraždy (Freud #1)
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating

Analýza vraždy (Freud #1)

by
3.48 of 5 stars 3.48  ·  rating details  ·  7,815 ratings  ·  910 reviews
Jed Rubenfeld ve své napínavé detektivce úspěšně spojuje historická fakta s fiktivním příběhem zrůdných zločinů, k nimž došlo v kruzích metropolitní smetánky. Díky autorovu poučenému líčení se čtenář nejen dozví mnohé ze zákulisí psychoanalýzy (děj se odehrává v době návštěvy Sigmunda Freuda a Carla Junga v USA), ale zakusí i atmosféru bouřlivě se rozvíjejícího New Yorku p...more
Hardcover, 460 pages
Published 2008 by Knižní klub (first published 2006)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.
This book is not yet featured on Listopia. Add this book to your favorite list »

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 3,000)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
karen
im pretty neutral about this book. it was a fine sortof historical mystery with all the requisite elements like red herrings and dubious intentions and misread signals and girls tied up and whipped, but... eh. and im torn, because it is a perennial table book, but i think i might have to regulate its inclusion from now on, because in my opinion, it is all right but no great shakes. maybe people who are really into freud would like it more than i. this is me being too early for class and writing...more
Coy
Mar 19, 2008 Coy rated it 1 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommended to Coy by: Kenneth
When I sit down to what I hope will be a great meal, I look forward to the side dishes, but it's the main course that is central. Don't get me wrong, I love potatoes, but give me the steak! Interpretation of Murder is a side dish and not a potato side dish, more like peas or carrots or something.

Reading the author's notes at the end of the book gave me a better appreciation of the novel. I respect that it was well-researched, but to borrow from the same analogy, I like a little history with my s...more
Kitty
I did not just like this book, I LOVED it. And on so many levels. I found it clever, informative, well written and even humorous at times. The characters were interesting and I was kept guessing even when I pretty much decided I knew what was going on. This was really a page turner, especially when they were down in the caisson. I could so visualize that. This is my new "You gotta read this book" recommendation. The Freud, Jung and Shakespeare inclusions was an added bonus. Loved the early 1900...more
Laura
Sigmund Freud, along with his protege Carl Jung, arrives in New York for a series of lectures at Clark University in Massachusetts. A young woman is murdered, apparently by a serial killer. Another young woman, Nora Acton, is suffering from amnesia after another attack by the same criminal. Dr. Stratham Younger, a high society Freud acolyte, undertakes a psychoanalysis of Nora, in the hopes of unraveling the mystery.

I wanted to like The Interpretation of Murder. I really did. It had an intrigui...more
Arun Divakar
Quite a long period of time had passed since I read a whodunit. It was more of an impulse that made me pick up this book while walking the shelves at the library. I remember reading the blurb on the back page and thinking back to Caleb Carr's Alienist and then deciding on giving this one a try.

It is an extremely light and breezy read. I was juggling three books at the same time and could only get to this by late Friday and even then could finish it by a Sunday evening. Contrary to my own prej...more
Meghan Cooper
This book was difficult and slow to read. I liked the whole idea of the story, but I did't feel like I connected with any of the characters in the story. When the author started a new chapter and brought in a different character with it, I kept not even knowing who they were talking about. I had to go back and refresh my memory of who was who. To be honest the characters descriptions were really bad. The author did his best to add tension to the whole book but half the time this tension just wou...more
Rowland Bismark
SWEET GREEN HELL

Her entire body glistened in the unbearable August heat. Her long legs were bare, as were her arms. Her elegant shoulders were nearly bare as well. The girl’s consciousness was fading. She tried to speak. There was a question she had to ask. It was there; it was gone. Then she had it again. ‘My name,’ she whispered. ‘What is my name?’

"... So, is Nora still a victim when she is empowered by a sympathetic listener?"

Feel like there's class conflict in the book: psychoanalysis versus...more
Aretha
Very disappointing...last time i listen to blimin' Richard and Judy!!!
minnie
Is it possible to be totally gripped and bored rigid at the same time ? That’s how I was for most of this book, the writing style I found stilted at first but the murder plot kept me going. Ultimately this was a bit of a let down as the plot was so convoluted, all the loose ends were tied up ‘Columbo’ style at the end. The best character was detective Littlemore, he was the only one I had any feeling for, in fact Littlemore and Younger as a detective duo were great. This book is to Psychoanalysi...more
Anjali
Jed Rubenfield’s book borrows quite a few things from the famous non-fiction book The Interpretation of Dreams by Sigmund Freud. To start with, the title is intentionally made to look like a spoof on the original book. The author and psychologist, Sigmund Freud is one of the characters in Rubenfield’s book. Several real characters like Carl Jung, Abraham Brill and George McClellan, Mayor of New York City appear in this fictional book.

To begin with, I liked the idea of creating a fictional story...more
Jen
This book's summary is a bit misleading in terms of Freud's overall role in the events of the book. In any case, I still really liked the story.

The main character of the book (there actually are two, but since his story is told in the first person, I'll label him as the lead,)is a young psychiatrist who is an avid follower of Sigmund Freud. He is charged with hosting Freud and several of his followers in New York before bringing him to Boston for a lecture at the university he teaches at.

During...more
Anita
This novel is about a murder mystery of Elizabeth Riverford, a young socialite in the impressive Balmoral Hotel, Manhattan and the reputedly accurate recounting of a visit made by Dr Sigmund Freud and Carl Jung to New York in 1909 to speak at American Universities in an age when psychoanalysis is in it's infancy.

Although not directly involved in the murder, Dr Freud offers advice to the budding psychoanalyst, Dr Stratham Younger, as to how to treat one of the murderer's surviving victims. The yo...more
Catherine
Wow! I finished this, and wrote the review below, on the day I started it.

Books based on historical figures can fall into two camps: having so much speculation and fiction that one cannot always relate it to the person from the history books or their work (sorry Ms Gregory, but I think your Henry VIII is a bit like this), or making such an effort to base their conversation on things the person actually said that the dialogue becomes stilted or the person comes across as a pompous oaf, rather too...more
Phoebe
What a disappointment! I really thought I'd like this because initially it looked like it might be a blend of history, psychology, literature, & criminal investigation. Those things did provide some satisfaction, but at times it read as if the author had simply copy/pasted his college papers on Freud or Hamlet into the text, resulting in a dry, disjointed lack of continuity.
Mostly what ruined this story was the unnecessarily detailed descriptions of the sadistic sexual assaults, described in...more
Jill
Sep 19, 2007 Jill rated it 4 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommends it for: Alienist lovers
Shelves: book-club-picks
First off, in my defense, I took such a long time to read this book for a reason. I only read at the gym. And lately, I have become rather, bouncy, while on the elliptical machine. When I'm bouncy, I can't read because I get seasick. So at first I'm doing ok on the machine, reading away, really into the book, and then suddenly, a bout of bounciness strikes, and I'm forced to close the book and put on my ipod. But tonight I persevered and pushed through said bounciness and kicked this book's ass!...more
Angela
This probably should get about 2 and a half stars. More than 2, because it did keep my interest. Less than three, because next to the Alienist it's a bit of a disappointment. The plot doesn't hang together like it does in the Alienist, the characters aren't as interesting, and it's too easy to figure out who did it. On the other hand, I did enjoy it, and it is worth the read.
Tom Pearson
Seemingly mixed reviews below... Firstly this book was not what I expected. Secondly this does not make it a bad thing. I have an understanding of Freud's work and suggestions and maybe that allowed me to read the book in a different way. It was a little slow to start, but essentially this becomes a murder mystery over a book about Freud, and that is what draws you in. There's a nod to those damned 50 shades of grey books in here, possibly more so than is required, but following the aetiology if...more
Karen maslen
Experienced readers of crime and thrillers tend to stifle a yawn these days when they encounter a mountain of hype about a new book or author. But the fevered word of mouth that has been generated by Jed Rubenfeld's The Interpretation of Murder is, for once, justified. This is a remarkably ambitious book, taking on a powerful suspenseful narrative, assiduously researched historical detail and a brilliant evocation of time and character. It's not surprising that the book has already been sold in...more
Devilyn (Emily)
Coinciding with Sigmund Freud’s first and only visit to the United States, there is a murder of a young debutante and the attack of another. Although Freud and his companions are in the US for a series of lectures, his American disciple Dr Younger is called on to help get to the bottom of the attack that left a young girl unable to speak or remember anything. With pieces of the investigation coming from all sides, we are lead on a trail through the human psyche.

Freud has always been an interest...more
Suzie
Murder mystery thriller set in early 1900s NYC including Freud and friends. Pacing is good. Historical research is good. Plot is convoluted, and if you think about it too hard at the end, you will find plot holes, and you will think it is dumb. One character randomly has 1st person narration, while the rest have 3rd, for no good reason. Everyone is not quite what they seem, except not so much. For example, the main detective is less dumb than he seems, which should be obvious if you read his dia...more
Rosey
hhhmmm, what to say.....

There are 2 stories running through this book. The first is a gothic murder mystery, a jolly good boys own story with enough twists and turns to keep you interested, more than one heart thumping, read faster bits, and a couple of "wow, i didn't see that coming" moments.

Sadly, there was the psychoanalysis theme as well *YAWN*. Now, i studied psychology at university, and i find the workings of the mind absolutely fascinating and criminal psychology is my bit thing BUT the...more
John
This was the second book in a row that I read to have a cover blurb comparing it to Caleb Carr's The Alienist; the other was Harold Schechter's Nevermore, about Edgar Allan Poe and Davy Crockett ratiocinating together. In this instance the comparison is a little more apt, since the detection is set early in the 20th century and involves not just one but a bunch of mentalists -- in this instance psychoanalysts, among them Freud, Jung and Ferenczi, visiting the US so that Freud could deliver a ser...more
Anthony
This is the first novel in a series by Jed Rubenfeld. His second, The Death Instinct, was a historical mystery thriller which I thoroughly enjoyed. So I decided to read his first, and I was not disappointed.

Set in New York City in 1909, Rubenfeld introduces his main characters, NYC Police Detective Littlemore and a doctor in the new field of psychoanalysis, Stratham Younger, who is fascinated by the new theories of a doctor from Vienna, Sigmund Freud.

According to the author, he based this novel...more
trav
This was a good vacation read. Nothing fancy, just solid writing, fantastic period detail and good pacing. The story never slowed down, not even on the parts that I didn't really enjoy.



I enjoy a good who-done-it. And this has a very satisfying twist to it and a great "reveal" of the why, when, where, etc.



The hook of the book is that Sigmund Freud himself has been called in to help solve some murders in New York City. The story is based on enough fact to make it really enjoyable. Much like some o...more
Brenna
This one was pure entertainment. When I read the description of this novel, I knew I was going to have to read it: a murder mystery involving Sigmund Freud! And the fun and intriguing background to the novel: Freud visited the United States just once, in 1909, to deliver some lectures at a New England university. When he left, he said many disparaging things about the U.S., and never returned. So the premise for this novel: something awful must have happened during Freud’s visit that gave him su...more
Nancy Oakes
Basically, the story was good and it did hold my interest so that I didn't want to put the book down.As a mystery story, there are many elements that had me thinking "hmmm....he did it," or "no, it couldn't have been him..." and this was a good thing. And really, you have to read to the very end which is surprising.

Sigmund Freud has arrived in New York on the same day that a beautiful woman is found dead in her apartment, obviously strangled. A second woman is found, who almost met the same fat...more
Lourdes Fernandez Venard
In the book’s beginning, the author tells us the story is loosely based on Sigmund Freud’s real-life visit to the United States, where he was invited to speak at Clark University. The author says something traumatic happened to Freud during his visit; afterward, he referred to Americans as savages and blamed them for his lifelong ailments, many of which he had before his trip. Using that, the author spins a fictional murder case. A young heiress is found bound and strangled in a New York City pe...more
Lea
Having just read & enjoyed Jed Rubenfeld's second book, The Death Instinct, I had to read this book too.

The Interpretation Of Murder features Dr. Stratham Younger, a doctor & psychiatrist, & Jimmy Littlemore, NYC detective, both of whom are also in the author's second book. One thing I really appreciated about Rubenfeld's writing -- which was especially obvious when read out of order -- was the change in the characters over the 10 years between their appearances. Both Stratham &...more
Sheena Lambert
I love a good murder mystery, and throw in a bit of love interest and a semi-factual background and you've written the perfect book for me. But this book wasn't perfect.

The premise of a murder investigation happening under the watchful eyes of Sigmund Freud is a great one, and worked really well. The fact that there is a lot of fact behind this novel makes it intriguing, and the well-described setting of turn-of-the-century New York added to my enjoyment of the read.

However, I found the murder...more
Abdul
The Interpretation of murder is a story shrouded in mystery, ill will, and love. It's about an up-and-coming detective pairing with a band of infamous psychiatrists and psychoanalysts such as Sigmund Freud and Carl Jung. This book is not your usual crime novel; it's synopsis does not do it justice.

My initial reaction from reading this piece of literature was pure fascination. This novel has a multitude of stories within it; the plot divides into a number of miniature plots, each working to hook...more
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 99 100 next »
  • The Last Days of Newgate (A Pyke Mystery, #1)
  • The Genius
  • A Death in Vienna (Liebermann Papers, #1)
  • A Quiet Belief In Angels
  • Relentless
  • Random Acts Of Heroic Love
  • The Book of Q: A Novel
  • Critique of Criminal Reason (Hanno Stiffeniis, #1)
  • The Resurrectionist
  • The American Boy
  • The Pirate's Daughter
  • Sovereign (Matthew Shardlake, #3)
  • The Visible World
  • The Medici Secret
  • Grantchester Grind (Porterhouse Blue, #2)
  • Brother Grimm (Jan Fabel, #2)
  • The Evil Genius
  • The Conjurer's Bird
46709
Jed Rubenfeld a summa cum laude graduate of Princeton University and magna cum laude graduate of Harvard Law School is the author of the hystorical and psychoanalytical novel Intepretation of Murder.

His experience in both Shakespearean Plays and his thesis on Sigmond Frued helped him to make an anlytical yet fictional work; Intepretation of Murder.

A master in the field of Law, he has proved himsel...more
More about Jed Rubenfeld...
The Death Instinct (Freud, #2) Freedom and Time: A Theory of Constitutional Self-Government The Triple Package: How Three Unlikely Traits Explain the Rise and Fall of Cultural Groups in America 殺人者は夢を見るか 上 殺人者は夢を見るか 下

Share This Book

“Disgust is so reassuring; it feels like a moral proof.” 15 likes
“Unhappiness is caused when we cannot let go of our memories.” 15 likes
More quotes…