Fantoomliefde
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating

Fantoomliefde

3.83 of 5 stars 3.83  ·  rating details  ·  1,634 ratings  ·  261 reviews
De Engelse psychiater Adrian Lockheart wil afstand nemen van zijn saaie huwelijk en praktijk in Engeland. Hij gaat in het ziekenhuis van Freetown werken, waar hij wekelijks naar het meeslepende liefdesverhaal luistert van de stervende Elias Cole en diens passie voor de vrouw van zijn collega en vriend Julius. Cole is Adrians enige patiënt, want in Sierra Leone gelooft niem...more
Paperback, 576 pages
Published February 2012 by NWADAM (first published January 1st 2010)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about Fantoomliefde, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about Fantoomliefde

This book is not yet featured on Listopia. Add this book to your favorite list »

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 3,000)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Thing Two
I can tell I've finished a moving book when I sit at dinner and explain detail after detail of the book to my non-reading husband, and then HE starts asking about it. This happened to us last night, sharing a sushi boat, sipping our wine, and discussing the civil war in Sierra Leone which lasted from 1991-2002 this time.

To say The Memory of Love is about the civil war in Sierra Leone is to dismiss this as a war novel, but it is much, much more. It's about how war ravishes the minds of its part...more
switterbug (Betsey)
Incalculable grief cleaves to profound love in this elaborate, helical tapestry of a besieged people in postwar Freetown, Sierra Leone. Interlacing two primary periods of violent upheaval, author Aminatta Forna renders a scarred nation of people with astonishing grace and poise--an unforgettable portrait of open wounds and closed mouths, of broken hearts and fractured spirits, woven into a stunning evocation of recurrence and redemption, loss and tender reconciliation. Forna mines a filament of...more
Bruce
The author of this infelicitously named novel lives in London and was born in Scotland, the daughter of a Scottish mother and Sierra Leonean father who was involved in politics in his native country, ultimately losing his life as a political dissident. The Memory of Love has received a number of literary prizes. The story takes place in Sierra Leone. There are a number of ways that a reader can approach a novel that is set in a country and culture about which he knows little. He might focus on c...more
Julie
This novel opens quietly, as if the writer were a doctor, cautiously revealing a wound, warning the reader to look, but don’t touch; as if she were a psychiatrist, probing delicately at the mind, but who avoids coming too close to the main issues, for fear of doing her patient greater harm.

The wounds in Aminatta Forna’s devastating and beautiful novel The Memory of Love (why am I certain the author had another title in mind, but was convinced by her publisher to go with the banal to encourage m...more
Ellie
DNF

The Memory of Love is not an awful book. Most of my book group enjoyed it though they did seem to agree with me that it took 150 pages to get into. I gave up on page 164 (or 36%).

To be honest, I felt uninspired by the book before I even picked it up. A book about love in Sierra Leone. Sounds promising but I didn't engage at all with the characters and I felt it was all a bit unemotional. The group countered that it was more like real life. 1. I get enough real life as it is and 2. I am quite...more
Heledd Davies
As a book set in a period of war and turmoil and based around the concept of love, I felt that 'The Memory Of Love' was oddly lacking in emotion. Reading the reviews on a lot of other books I've read about romance under horrific circumstances, the main criticism seems to be that they are over sensationalised and use cheap tricks to pull at our heartstrings. Well this book doesn't do that. The traumatising events that occur to the characters are told in a largely matter-of-fact way, and although...more
Rashida
Forna is a gifted writer, and I want to make clear at the outset that my stars are not based on my estimation of her talent. If it was just about the way she can turn a phrase, well there would be no reason to give her anything less than 5 stars. She can write, and she does it well in this book. The language is lovely. However, I did not like this book. I just didn't. I liked the broad outline of the story. I did not like the way the details were filled in. It was as though the story is a waterc...more
Fiona
I was given this book several years ago by a gentleman I know with an incredibly exciting job that involves lots of travel, eye-watering anecdotes over dinner and, er, a legitimate favourite Somalian pirate that he knows on first name terms. His daughter is one of my best friends, and he knows my specialism in international and humanitarian law, so he'll occasionally send me interesting articles, white papers - and, once, this book. It sat on my shelf for a long time because I am rubbish, and re...more
Elaine
This is an ambitious novel and Forna clearly can write, and I appreciate her wanting to make it more than a horror story of war-torn Africa, to have varied voices and to emphasize the life around the trauma, not just the vortex within it. But the threads were uneven -- both in terms of plotting and timing, and in terms of compelling-ness. We spend a lot of time with Elias Cole, especially at the beginning, with his flat banality of evil and his not very interesting love story. When his denouemen...more
Jill
Every now and then I read a book that is so powerfully crafted that I am in its spell for days afterwards: The Lizard Cage. In the Company of Angels. The Lotus Eaters. White Dog Fell from the Sky. And to this group, I now add Aminatta Forna’s masterwork, The Memory of Loss.

Perhaps it is no coincidence that each of these works, at its core, is about the survival of the human spirit and the triumphant resurgence of love during the worst times of war and torture. At our harshest times, we become t...more
Emma Deplores Goodreads Censorship
On the one hand, this is a well-written book with good character development and a solid sense of place. On the other, it has some structural issues that make me hesitate to recommend it.

The Memory of Love is set in present-day Sierra Leone, and follows three men: a dying academic, Elias, relates his life story (or a version of it) to a British psychologist, Adrian, who meanwhile befriends a local surgeon, Kai. It is a character-driven book, gradually moving deeper into the characters’ lives as...more
Inge Vermeire
Ik heb er best wel lang over gedaan om dit boek uit te lezen en ik heb mezelf ook moeten forceren om niet op te geven - het verhaal ontwikkelt zich heel erg langzaam en het duurde zeker tot halverwege het boek vooraleer ik eindelijk nieuwsgierig genoeg was om écht door te lezen.

Maar toch is het logisch dat het boek zo traag vooruitgaat want het is de enige manier waarop Aminatta Forna ons duidelijk kan maken dat je over de verschrikkingen van een oorlog als in Sierra Leone nauwelijks kunt verte...more
Megan
Here's what I wish someone would have told me before I started this book: DON'T WORRY, the title's reference to love does not refer to the first relationship introduced in the book, Elias Cole's obsessive, possessive stalking of the happily married Saffia Kamara. Even if Elias was deluded enough to conceptualize his actions and feelings as love, the narrative makes it clear that it wasn't love. By the end of the book, the title was quite fitting, just in unexpected ways.

Other things that might b...more
Lauren
Great plot, bit of a slog to get through. There's a shorter book here struggling to get out! Interesting take on the aftermath of war, the pathologizing of the victim's experience and aid work in general. Lots to think about. I'll definately read more by Forna.
Ann Warner
I received this book as a First Reads.

Had I checked this book out of the library, I might have stopped a few pages in and returned it. Which would have been a shame, because my conclusion when I finished the story was quite different from my initial impression. For me, trimming the first chapter would have better served the story. One example. There's a wonderful line that could have been Elias Cole's first, but it doesn't come until the bottom of page 5: "I saw a woman once, the loss of whom I...more
Trent
Okay, this is a tough one to review. The title doesn't do much for me, but I entered the First Reads giveaway program here on GoodReads based on the blurb and my fascination with Africa. I was pleased to be selected for a free copy, but even more so, pleasantly surprised to be introduced to the work of this wonderful author, whom I may not otherwise have discovered on my own.

Trying to describe what The Memory of Love is about is part of what makes a review tough. Yes, as others have said, it's a...more
George
One of the most beautifully written books I've read in quite a while. But if you're looking for some light summer fare, go elsewhere. This book requires the reader to put some real effort into it, but the rewards are pretty worthwhile by the end of the tale. The book takes place almost entirely in Sierra Leone and the story shifts back and forth in time and back and forth among the major characters. We learn over time just how closely related all of these people are and how their stories are int...more
Joyce
Amazing. Powerful. Though the first quarter of the book didn't do much for me. I had a hard time following the shifts from one character to the other and the present to the past.

Slowly, the book drew me in and slowly the dots were being connected. The characters were complex and their experiences both during the wars and after were unimaginable. Surviving was almost easier than coping afterwards. But hope and love also weaves its way through these hard times and broken hearts and minds. Those ar...more
Matilda
To this book I would apologetically like to say "It's not you, it's me". Objectively I can appreciate the book, but my state of mind was not up to a slow read about people haunted by war. Hence it took me 3 weeks to finish the book which further increased my disconnection from the story. I wish I could give the book 3.5 stars, because I did not enjoy the read that much, but I know that it is a good book.

Sorry, Aminatta Forna. You write beautifully and I promise to select a better moment for read...more
Ekene Chuks-Okeke
Beautiful. I absolutely loved it, and it’s definitely one of my faves. I learnt so much, it made me think about things, it made me feel grateful that I can read, and more grateful that I enjoy reading.

My favourite part of this book was that they stayed. By they, I mean, Kai stayed. Tejani came home. Mamakay wanted to stay and even Adrian almost did. We may wander, we may explore but Africa is ours and the solutions to our problems lie with us. It’s not easy to love a place that has not given yo...more
Cathy
I would say this is 4.5 stars - it doesn't quite make my list of all time favorites, but it comes pretty close and is definitely one of my favorites I've read in the past few years. It's such a wonderfully crafted book.The author has real skill in weaving so many stories together. Not only are there several main characters who are very well developed, the secondary characters in this book are thoroughly developed as well. It's a beautifully written story about a group of victims of the civil war...more
Lisa (Harmonybites)
I just couldn't get into the story or the characters. I think part of the reason was the clogging sensory detail. Often you don't have enough--I've even heard an editor say that density of sensory detail is what separates the amateur from the professional, and such details can ground you in a story, and its setting--in this case post-Civil War Sierra Leone. But it seemed as if Forna had to walk us through the day of her characters in excruciating detail, burying us in minutia like this:

Adrian po...more
Mikey B.
There are some revelations within regarding this book.

Although this book is well intentioned (one of its themes is the effects of post-traumatic stress disorder on an African country) I found the overall result after reading unsatisfactory. There are a number of reasons for this. The pace is at times languid. There are too many conversations in bars and people’s homes that just hang still without much occurring for plot or character development. At close to 450 pages the book is too long.

The mos...more
Darryl
This enchanting novel is set in Freetown, the capital of Sierra Leone, at the end of the country's civil war that lasted from 1991-2002. Adrian Lockheart, a British psychologist who has left his family to pursue a more personally fulfilling career, is at the bedside of Elias Cole, a former university professor and dean who is nearing the end of his life. Adrian encourages Elias to share his story with him on weekly therapeutic visits , and Cole tells him about his career, including his friendshi...more
Isabel
I read this book, because it was given to me and strongly recommended as "incredibly touching".

The reason I finished it, was because I kept hoping for an ending that would turn everything around and leave me feeling touched. Well, that didn't happen. Another reason it was easy to read, was because I found the language good. It was nicely written and pleasant to read, in that sense.

But otherwise, utterly depressing and disappointing. I really don't know what's so touching or honourable about rea...more
Lucinda
This book takes awhile to get going, largely because the narrative at first follows the character of Elias Cole who is a rather unlikeable figure. Forna manages to create some sympathy in / for him though, which, in light of how the story unfolds, is a pretty remarkable feat.
There is one thing I did not like about this novel, however, and that is the tendency for multiple, seemingly unrelated, narrative streams to be tied together. and not in a six-degrees-of-separation kind of way. I dislike th...more
Tonymess
It’s rewarding reading books from the various literary shortlists around the globe, but I can tell you one thing, it is rare you come across a dud. People who read my reviews (and I know there are but a few), must think I enjoy just about everything I read. And I can fully understand when some reviewers slip into criticism of minor plot errors or factual inconsistencies as it becomes harder and harder to distinguish the good from the bad. Recently I have saved my vitriol for journalists in cheap...more
Keija
Forna handles her book's subject matter--the civil war that rampaged through Sierra Leone--with deftness and courage. She unflinchingly depicts the war's aftermath through the eyes of an African surgeon and an English psychiatrist, asking all the while, how does a country cope with the legacy of its crimes? How do the war's survivors make a life in the physical and emotional rubble left in wake of battle? Forna's writing is poetic, but not flashily so, which suits the book's somber themes, and s...more
Wendy Shearer
Brilliant. Found the first half a bit slow moving but enjoyed the variety of characters and alternate voices for each chapter. I didn't like most of the characters but Forna's writing style is captivating. Reviewed at our book club: https://northlondonbookclub.wordpress...
Elizabeth
Mar 02, 2011 Elizabeth rated it 5 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommends it for: romantic cynics with a taste for Africa
Shelves: 2011
this book is along the same lines as that Cutting for Stone book but oh so much better. It takes place in Africa, contemporary Sierra Leone, involves doctors, surgeon and psychologist, and locals and expats. There are multiple story lines that expand and contract. Intersecting at places you may or may not guess. Kai, local surgeon, Elias Cole, local professor during the civil war, Adrian Brit psychologist. Love is obsessed over, deals are made and things happen that will surprise you. It's a rom...more
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 99 100 next »
topics  posts  views  last activity   
La Stamberga dei ...: Il ricordo dell'amore di Aminatta Forna 1 2 Jul 27, 2014 11:56AM  
Great African Reads: Radio programme featuring Aminata Forna 2 12 May 30, 2011 08:09AM  
  • Lyrics Alley
  • Everything Good Will Come
  • Measuring Time
  • The Boy Next Door
  • The Secret Lives of Baba Segi's Wives
  • Beneath the Lion's Gaze
  • An Elegy for Easterly: Stories
  • Grace Williams Says It Loud
  • The Birth of Love
  • The Swimmer
  • On Black Sisters Street: A Novel
  • Black Mamba Boy
  • Changes: A Love Story
  • The Beautyful Ones Are Not Yet Born
  • The Hairdresser of Harare
  • Dust
  • GraceLand
  • Wizard of the Crow
63640
Born in Glasgow, raised in Sierra Leone and the United Kingdom and now divides her time between London and Sierra Leone
More about Aminatta Forna...
The Hired Man The Devil That Danced on the Water: A Daughter's Quest Ancestor Stones Mother of All Myths The Granta Book of the African Short Story

Share This Book

“All liars ... lie to protect themselves, to shield their egos from the raw pain of truth.” 20 likes
“The hollowness in his chest, the tense yearning, the loneliness he braces against, every morning until he can immerse himself in work and forget. Not love. Something else, something with a power that endures. Not love, but a memory of love.” 5 likes
More quotes…