The Best American Comics 2012
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating

The Best American Comics 2012 (Best American Comics)

3.35 of 5 stars 3.35  ·  rating details  ·  203 ratings  ·  34 reviews
“When I started RAW magazine in the ’80s, there were mostly superheroes, a few children’s comics, and the dirty, intentionally lowbrow, underground comix. And now, comics can tackle any topic.”—Françoise Mouly, from the Introduction

FEATURING Charles Burns, Chester Brown, Joyce Farmer, Chris Ware, Gary Panter, Sergio Aragonés, Christoph Niemann, Adrian Tomine, Sarah Varon,...more
Hardcover, 352 pages
Published October 2nd 2012 by Houghton Mifflin Harcourt
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about The Best American Comics 2012, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about The Best American Comics 2012

Abstract Comics by Andrei MolotiuThe Best American Comics 2008 by Lynda BarrySyncopated by Brendan BurfordThe Jewish Comix Anthology by Steven M. BergsonThe Graphic Canon, Vol. 1 by Russ Kick
Graphic / Comix Anthologies
94th out of 109 books — 2 voters
The Unwritten, Vol. 1 by Mike CareyFatale, Vol. 1 by Ed BrubakerBlankets by Craig ThompsonLocke & Key, Vol. 1 by Joe HillLocke & Key, Vol. 2 by Joe Hill
Graphic Novels I'm Gonna Read
74th out of 77 books — 8 voters

More lists with this book...

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 353)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
It would have been better to give the editorship to someone younger who is actually interested in comics. Many of these selections aren't even comics, regardless of the book's title. And while I love Chester Brown, Chris Ware, Adrian Tomine, and Jim Woodring from way back in the day, there's honestly no one new out there this collection could showcase? Other selections, such as the one by Mad Magazine veteran Sergio Aragones, are simply embarrassing. I may sound like Comic Book Guy ("Worst. Coll...more
there are some gems in here, but for the most part the comics chosen were terribly boring
A mixed batch of interesting stories, confusing stories and boring stories.

Interesting: Charles Burns' "X'ed Out," Sammy Harkham's "Blood of the Virgin." Both excerpts made me want to find the comic and read it in its entirety.

Confusing or "Why was this chosen?": "House of Debt" (really?), "A Month Of..."

Boring: "The Irish Table,"Scenes from an Impending Marriage","Rock Scissors, Paper"

Surprised by the Adrian Tomine piece, as it doesn't reflect his work. Anthologies are pretty much used as...more
Christopher Roth
One thing I have to say about this collection is that it says "Best American Comics," but that doesn't even begin to prepare you for the diversity of voices in this volume. Some of the contributors are from the Park Slope neighborhood of Brooklyn, some are from the Clinton Hill neighborhood of Brooklyn, some are from the Williamsburg neighborhood of Brooklyn, and, some--are you sitting down?--are even from the South Williamsburg neighborhood. In terms of age, some of the contributors are as youn...more
Here's what I liked: "X'ed Out" by Charles Burns, "Jimbo" by Gary Panter, "Frank and the Gut-Worshippers" by Jim Woodring, "The Pilot Learns To Fly" by Anders Nilsen, "The Love Bunglers" by Jaime Hernandez, "Even the Giants Get the Blues" by Jesse Jacobs, and "Read a Book" by Michael J. Buckley. I had already read the Charles Burns selection because I have the complete "X'ed Out" graphic novel. I was so enchanted with "Even the Giants Get the Blues" by Jesse Jacobs that I immediately ordered the...more

Best Brooklyn Comics.
I've read a couple other Best American Comics editions and this was by far the worst.
Leave Luck to Heaven, Charles Burns, and Chris Ware were the best parts.
The children's section, while a noble idea, was just a random selection of children's stories thrown together seemingly without any sorting mechanism involved.
90% of the stories were by dudes who leave in Brooklyn. : /
While not the strongest of the Best American Comics, I did enjoy reading most of these. A number of selections I had actually read the full versions of myself throughout the year, but I was pleased to get some of the few that I missed. The inclusion of comics for kids, though, is way overdue and I'm glad to see it here. Now we just need inclusion of material for teens.

I will say, though, Mouly definitely comes at this from a particular slant. Even the selections of work for kids come from an ind...more
Awesome comp of some awesome comics. I guess "American" comics means comics from U.S & Canada (and one person living in Germany) but not Mexico & South America. Six of the twenty-four featured adult creators identity themselves as living in Brooklyn, New York. Do humanity a favor the skip the Adrian Tomine section. Chris Ware remains the Borg of comics - completely heartless and evil. I've never liked it when pathology becomes confused with art. As the android Ash says of the Alien, "A p...more
My first collection of Best American Comics.

The way these things are set up, we get excerpts from comics (both long graphic novels and short webcomic-styled entries). The comics vary from strongly art-centric, to strongly story-centric, and it's really obvious that there's going to be something for everyone here to enjoy.

The great thing about these comics is that unlike your mainstream superhero comics, these deal with more realistic slice of life topics. Things most of us can relate to. So, it'...more
Standouts for me that I wasn't already familiar with this year were...
1. Dakota McFadzean - Leave Luck to Heaven
Philosophical take on console gaming - and I found his drawing style approachable
2. David Collier - The Irish Table
Artist joins the military for a second time in his forties

I like to read through the new edition of this collection every year to take my comics temperature. Did pretty well this year. :)
David Townsend
Well, some of the best
Jan 10, 2013 Sundry rated it 4 of 5 stars
Recommends it for: Elaine
Shelves: graphic
Bravo to the series editors for moving the artist profiles into the body of the book so they function as little introductions to the artwork. I always read the artist profiles and was glad not to have to flip back and forth repeatedly to link the bios with the art.

Have to admit that I wasn't thrilled by as many of the entries this year as I typically a,, but I discovered a few that I will find in their full version, and that's kind of the point for me. A lot more excerpts from longer works.
I've read all the Best American Comics and found this to be the best so far. It seems like the editor this time out did not purposely go out of their way to find the most outrageous, ridiculous comics, but actually judged the comics on the merits of their work. The addition of the kid's comics was also an interesting addition. Had intended to drop this anthology from my list, but after this issue, I will give it one more try!
Extremely uneven selection. A few good selections mixed in with a bunch of stuff apparently pulled out of a bottom drawer at random. Ranges from kids' stories to... uh... adult-themed stories. A lot of the pieces do not use the graphic medium well. Art is particularly uneven with some great stuff but a lot of crap. If you changed "The Best..." to "Random..." in the title, that would about sum it up for me.
These were the best? I found most of them bizarre and nonsensical. Even a brief excerpt should make some kind of sense. I took away zero comics that I would want to read the complete work.
One of the weaker and less memorable volumes in this annual anthology series. This edition is curated by Francoise Mouly the art editor for the 'New Yorker,' and for various reasons I found the selections to be a real mixed bag. Still, these books are always well crafted and will certainly expose you to new material/authors that makes reading through it in its entirety worthwhile.
Jerry Delaney
As with all in this series, this is a mixed bag, depending on the individual artists. I have a bent for more realistic comics than for science fiction themes, which means I will always like some entries more than others. But that comes with the territory when you pick up an anthology. I use this series to introduce me to new people whose work I can hunt down.
Dana Franklin
I love love love the "Best American" series of books: mysteries, short stories, travel writing, non-required reading, etc. The Best American Comics books are good, and there are some individual authors/illustrators whom I would like to follow, but, to be honest, a lot of these went right over my head, and I don't understand why they were chosen as the "best".
I am really trying to like graphic novels, but it isn't working so far. I loved Adrian Tomine's excerpt from "Scenes from an Impending Marriage" and Christoph Niemann's "Redeye," but they seem more akin to traditional comics or art. Did I really want to read about, much less see, Chester Brown's chronicle of hiring prostitutes? NO. Yuck.
Kris Bernard
Feb 06, 2013 Kris Bernard rated it 5 of 5 stars
Recommends it for:
Shelves: graphic-novels
I really was quite impressed by this edition. There were artists chosen who had wonderful abstract artwork and I definitely closed the book with a list of more books to buy.
Really beautiful collection to commemorate 2012.
Overall, not the best anthology I've read. Maybe this was a bad year for comics, but there was nothing that I thought, "I have to read this!" That said, there were a few things that were interesting and that I will look into.
Edmund Davis-Quinn
Pretty good but very disjointed.

Either you don't have the complete context for the excerpts or you are getting interested and it ends.

My favorite was "Leave Luck to Heaven" by Dakota McFadzean. That one was cool.
Some nuggets of genius amidst a lot of fluff. I was glad to see Charles Burns is still working; I loved the "El Borbah" (world's greatest private eye) stories I read in Heavy Metal back in the 80s.
Jess A
I always enjoy these anthologies although they leave me wishing for more, which I guess is the point. I appreciated the children's section of this year's book.
best one they have done so far. gary panter, jesse jacobs, scott chantler, kupperman, nilsen, woodring, dakota mcfadzean, david sandlin, chris ware. jeepers
A great collection this year. Interesting to see a kids comic section. Dug the brief interview with some of the artists.
Michael Seidel

Highlights for me were Jonathan Bennett, Gary Panter, Leanne Sharpton, and Jesse Jacobs.
could of had better selections but there were some good ones.

Best of the series by a long shot. I've got some shopping to do.
Some were good, some were not comics and a lot were just meh.
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
  • The Best American Comics 2011
  • The Best American Comics 2009
  • The Best American Comics 2013
  • The Best American Comics 2008
  • The Best American Comics 2010
  • The Best American Comics 2006
  • The Best American Comics 2007
  • An Anthology of Graphic Fiction, Cartoons, and True Stories
  • Congress of the Animals
  • The Best American Science and Nature Writing 2010
  • The Best American Science and Nature Writing 2009
  • The Hypo: The Melancholic Young Lincoln
  • The Best American Mystery Stories 2008
  • The Best American Travel Writing 2009
  • The Best American Travel Writing 2010
  • The Best American Mystery Stories 2012
  • Tales of Woodsman Pete
  • Lucille
Blown Covers: New Yorker Covers You Were Never Meant to See Covering the New Yorker: Cutting-Edge Covers from a Literary Institution The New Yorker Postcards: Ten Decades, 100 Covers Little Lit: Strange Stories for Strange Kids Big Fat Little Lit

Share This Book