49th out of 68 books
—
16 voters
Thrall
The stunning follow-up volume to her 2007 Pulitzer Prize–winning Native Guard, by America’s new Poet Laureate
Natasha Trethewey’s poems are at once deeply personal and historical—exploring her own interracial and complicated roots—and utterly American, connecting them to ours. The daughter of a black mother and white father, a student of history and of the Deep South, she i...more
Natasha Trethewey’s poems are at once deeply personal and historical—exploring her own interracial and complicated roots—and utterly American, connecting them to ours. The daughter of a black mother and white father, a student of history and of the Deep South, she i...more
Hardcover, 84 pages
Published
August 28th 2012
by Houghton Mifflin Harcourt
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
595)
The opening poem, Elegy, for her father, is one of many powerful pieces in this collection.
How the Past Comes Back
Like a shadow across a stone,
gradually --
the name it darkens;
as one enters the world
through language --
like a child learning to speak
then naming
everything; as flower,
the neglected hydrangea
endlessly blossoming --
year after year
each bloom a blue refrain; as
the syllables of birdcall
coalescing in the trees,
repeating
a single word:
forgets;
as the dead bird's bright signature --...more
How the Past Comes Back
Like a shadow across a stone,
gradually --
the name it darkens;
as one enters the world
through language --
like a child learning to speak
then naming
everything; as flower,
the neglected hydrangea
endlessly blossoming --
year after year
each bloom a blue refrain; as
the syllables of birdcall
coalescing in the trees,
repeating
a single word:
forgets;
as the dead bird's bright signature --...more
I purchased my copy when Ms. Trethewey read at the main New Orleans Public Library in December of 2012. I didn't buy the book simply because I was impressed by the way she read the collection (I was) or because of how cool it was to get a book signed by the current Poet Laureate of the United States (it was pretty cool). I got Thrall because I was intrigued by the conceit behind it: a "mixed race" person dissects the historical attitudes of western culture toward such people and, occasionally, u...more
In this slender collection of poems, Trethewey takes us backward and forward in time, establishing Thrall as a collection as much about past as it is about present---or rather, how the two are inextricably linked through history, through identity, and in discovering truth and self and meaning. The collection’s first poem, “Elegy,” reflects the poet’s longing---a sometimes ruthless longing---to make sense of and (re)discover the world.
As the child of a black woman and white man, Trethewey boldly...more
As the child of a black woman and white man, Trethewey boldly...more
A beautiful collection. However, there is one theme that bothers me and prevents me from giving this 5 stars. In "Enlightment" the author writes, " a mans pursuit of knowledge is greater/than his shortcomings, the limits of his vision," and in other poems she describes the earlier eras of science such as anatomy ("Miracle of the Black Leg," "Knowledge," and "The Americans," but despite the supposed insight that cooler, objective pursuits would render, the reader is left with more of a visceral,...more
A radio interview I heard with the newest U.S. Poet Laureate caught my attention so I approached this slim book eagerly even though I am not a regular reader of poetry. In spite of my inexperience Natasha Trethewey’s poems often moved and in some cases captivated me. Many of the early poems in the book explore the historical contexts of Trethewey’s mixed race heritage by detailed and nuanced examinations of colonial era paintings with multi-race families, paintings that were designed to illustra...more
I got to read an advance copy of Natasha Trethewey's upcoming book Thrall by signing up on NetGalley.com. Thanks to Mark Letcher for telling me about the website.
* * *
Natasha Trethewey, the newest U.S. poet laureate, uses Casta paintings and ekphrastic poetry to examine what it means to be mixed race, to be wanted and forgotten, accepted and disowned, in her forthcoming collection, Thrall. Throughout this slim volume she also reflects on the relationship with her poet father, who now lives in Ca...more
* * *
Natasha Trethewey, the newest U.S. poet laureate, uses Casta paintings and ekphrastic poetry to examine what it means to be mixed race, to be wanted and forgotten, accepted and disowned, in her forthcoming collection, Thrall. Throughout this slim volume she also reflects on the relationship with her poet father, who now lives in Ca...more
Natasha Trethewey, Thrall (Houghton Mifflin Harcourt, 2012)
Full disclosure: this book was provided to me free of charge by Amazon Vine.
Politicized poetry—and when I say “politicized”, I'm not just talking flat-out political poetry here, but also what one might call “the poetry of social consciousness”—is always a problematic thing. One hundred percent of the time. So much so that back when I was still a working poet and thus entitled in some small way to comment on such things and offer advice t...more
Full disclosure: this book was provided to me free of charge by Amazon Vine.
Politicized poetry—and when I say “politicized”, I'm not just talking flat-out political poetry here, but also what one might call “the poetry of social consciousness”—is always a problematic thing. One hundred percent of the time. So much so that back when I was still a working poet and thus entitled in some small way to comment on such things and offer advice t...more
Natasha Trethewey, the Timeless Poet
2007 Pulitzer Prize winning poet Natasha Trethewey gifts us with this rather extraordinary collection of poems that explore relationships between parent and child in a marriage of two people from different cultures: Trethewey is the mixed race progeny of a white father (a poet) and a darker skinned Mexican mother. This platform provides a complex stage setting for discussions of heritage, depth of cultural bonds and influences, and a particularly fine examinat...more
2007 Pulitzer Prize winning poet Natasha Trethewey gifts us with this rather extraordinary collection of poems that explore relationships between parent and child in a marriage of two people from different cultures: Trethewey is the mixed race progeny of a white father (a poet) and a darker skinned Mexican mother. This platform provides a complex stage setting for discussions of heritage, depth of cultural bonds and influences, and a particularly fine examinat...more
I would have to say that this is among the best collections of poetry I have ever read. I loved NATIVE GUARD, but THRALL is even better.I devoured it on the way home from the Decatur Book Festival, where I had the good fortune of hearing Tretheway read. (She was the keynote speaker.) I don't think I paused for breath during the flight, and the work has stayed with me like a vibrant force resonating beneath my skin.
The collection is in many ways a memoir of linked poems, many ekphrastic explorati...more
The collection is in many ways a memoir of linked poems, many ekphrastic explorati...more
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
Thrall by Natasha Trethewey examines the lines between father and daughter and the African-American experience through a set of personal and analytical poems focused on race and culture. In “Miracle of the Black Leg,” Trethewey examines the juxtaposition of white and black men in paintings and other artwork in which the leg of one man is taken and attached to the thigh of another man. There are similarities in pain stricken faces in some images, paralleling their similar situations, but there ar...more
"Thrall" is marked by luxurious language, intensity of intellect, and troubling insight. It is a disturbingly gorgeous collection of poems that assaults cliches on race, family, history, personhood. The language is so sparse, it's like a stallion: sleek and muscular and instantly admirable. Some examples:
"mist at the banks like a net / settling around us"
"the boy's mother contorts, watchful / her neck twisting on its spine, red beads / yoked at her throat like a necklace of blood / her face so b...more
"mist at the banks like a net / settling around us"
"the boy's mother contorts, watchful / her neck twisting on its spine, red beads / yoked at her throat like a necklace of blood / her face so b...more
The title of this book is appropriate. Poetry is a way to work things out, and Trethewey has been in thrall to her mixed race (Black mother, white father) heritage from the beginning of her highly successful (for a poet)career. The book begins with an elegy to poet's father. Like Rita Dove and Elizabeth Alexander, Trethewey has a knack for discovering curious anecdotes and legends of Black history, through which she can view current race relations and her inner identity. "The Miracle of the Blac...more
4.5 stars
Thumbed through this when it came into the library. I originally just wanted to check out "Miracle of the black leg", which recounts several paintings of a 14th century account of 2 doctor-saints who transplanted the leg of a dead Ethiopian onto a white amputee. Her analogies and imagery were enchanting and I got drawn into the rest of the book.
The author is US Poet Laureate, and the poems are all short reads with some variety in format. Many of the poems are inspired by, or are about c...more
Thumbed through this when it came into the library. I originally just wanted to check out "Miracle of the black leg", which recounts several paintings of a 14th century account of 2 doctor-saints who transplanted the leg of a dead Ethiopian onto a white amputee. Her analogies and imagery were enchanting and I got drawn into the rest of the book.
The author is US Poet Laureate, and the poems are all short reads with some variety in format. Many of the poems are inspired by, or are about c...more
"it is the typology of taint, / of stain: blemish: sullying spot..."
- The Book of Castas
"... When I think of this now, / I see how the past holds us captive, / its beautiful ruin etched on the mind's eye:"
- Enlightenment
I think this line strongly sums up the theme of these poems: a gallery of pieces depicting the complicated history of multiracial America. Natasha Trethewey's poems disentangle the mappings of "purity" and "taint" in racial identity, with repeated motifs of scientific terms, exo...more
- The Book of Castas
"... When I think of this now, / I see how the past holds us captive, / its beautiful ruin etched on the mind's eye:"
- Enlightenment
I think this line strongly sums up the theme of these poems: a gallery of pieces depicting the complicated history of multiracial America. Natasha Trethewey's poems disentangle the mappings of "purity" and "taint" in racial identity, with repeated motifs of scientific terms, exo...more
Dear Natasha Trethewey,
I write poems. And still, I didn't know you could DO that: write a series of poems inspired by a series of paintings, as if you we were walking through a museum with you, hearing you recount your memories, while taking in art in another form. I didn't know you could take one moment from your past - a powerful one - and make it the punchline, when what inspired the memory was the setting, the place. I didn't know a person could expertly mix high-intellect verse and every da...more
I write poems. And still, I didn't know you could DO that: write a series of poems inspired by a series of paintings, as if you we were walking through a museum with you, hearing you recount your memories, while taking in art in another form. I didn't know you could take one moment from your past - a powerful one - and make it the punchline, when what inspired the memory was the setting, the place. I didn't know a person could expertly mix high-intellect verse and every da...more
The first half or so of this collection is a tough read--focused on art and stories from times past of multiracial events, which slowly throughout the book combine with the author's own mixed race background.
Some of the historical poems made me cringe with their power; the personal poems resonated deeply, the author clearly delineating for the reader that complicated place where as adults we both love our parents and yet can see the truth about them and begin to face the complicated ways in whic...more
Some of the historical poems made me cringe with their power; the personal poems resonated deeply, the author clearly delineating for the reader that complicated place where as adults we both love our parents and yet can see the truth about them and begin to face the complicated ways in whic...more
I'm not sure if this collection is slightly less exquisite than Native Guard, or if it was just a more difficult collection for me to read. It touches on Trethewey's relationship with her father, which seems more fraught than that with her mother, and it also has even more historical background than Native Guard did.
Many of the poems in Thrall are inspired by paintings, and I wish prints of all the paintings could have been included. Themes of race and racism definitely continue.
Poems from this...more
Many of the poems in Thrall are inspired by paintings, and I wish prints of all the paintings could have been included. Themes of race and racism definitely continue.
Poems from this...more
This 2012 book of poetry by the current Poet Laureate is I think brilliant.
There are several historical renderings of paintings that display white
masters with their Indian or Black children. Trewethey is also mixed race
and meditates on what that has meant in times of empire. Spanish
conquistadors with their mestizo children and so forth. She has an easy
touch with this serious topic of being in-between races. There are also
childhood poems about her parents; her father was white and she idolized
hi...more
There are several historical renderings of paintings that display white
masters with their Indian or Black children. Trewethey is also mixed race
and meditates on what that has meant in times of empire. Spanish
conquistadors with their mestizo children and so forth. She has an easy
touch with this serious topic of being in-between races. There are also
childhood poems about her parents; her father was white and she idolized
hi...more
AMAZING!! Trethewey covers, with almost academic skill and depth, the depth and mazes not only of race in the Americas ( some of her most brilliant poems are set in Spanish colonies, addressing the Spanish "system" of classifying race and mixed race) but of personal emotional narratives as well. She also pulls from art history brilliantly throughout the collection, at one point describing the painting on the book's cover in a poem addressing the 'mestizo/a', the now-outdated term a mixed child b...more
Thrall is stunning; the poems themselves, the theme and collection, the voice, the ekphrasis, the personal – everything just works with Trethewey’s latest book. In contrast to Domestic Work’s rigidness and telling-style, Thrall is alive within its ekphrastic constraint; even Native Guard, which I felt was fantastic, does not quite stand up to the completeness I feel when reading this collection. As a reader, I feel included and intimate with the speaker (something that was missing from DM), as w...more
The most recent collection by our current Poet Laureate explores America's and the poet's history, through art and through her reminisces about her father. The poet's mixed race identity is vital to the poems and she is a brilliant choice for Poet Laureate in the age of Obama. The poems are full of thoughts and ideas that bear repeated reading. Highest recommendation.
This is the follow-up volume of poetry to Trethewey's 2007 Pulitzer Prize–winning Native Guard and it clearly shows why she is the new Poet Laurette of the United States.
She beautifully blends her personal family history into the history of America, especially the deep south. She is an interracial child, when a black woman and white man marrying was not only dangerous but illegal in her parents home state. She uses her poetry to show the struggles of not only southern America but of many forgot...more
She beautifully blends her personal family history into the history of America, especially the deep south. She is an interracial child, when a black woman and white man marrying was not only dangerous but illegal in her parents home state. She uses her poetry to show the struggles of not only southern America but of many forgot...more
This collection is wonderful -- possible better than Native Guard. Tretheway moves the reader through complex issues of race, from the castas of colonial Mexico to her own childhood experiences. In addition to the excellent craft of the poetry, the book itself is a work of art, one of those rich volumes that reminds us why we need real books in life, rather than digital everything.
These very accessible poems reveal two stories that of Natasha's family life (if we believe the poems are autobiographical and I trust they are) and the intersection of the interracial relations. I learned from these and want to read them again next year or so. Her images and metaphors fit well so I gave this five stars.
This is an excellent, provocative collection of poetry by our current poet laureate, Natasha Trethewey. In it, she ruminates on colonialism, race, and her relationship with her white father. It is a perfect collection to mirror many of things that we, as a county, are also reflecting on. Highly recommended.
Read my review on Five Points, (the blog). Thrall.
| topics | posts | views | last activity | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Poetry Readers Ch...: Thrall by Natasha Trethewey | 3 | 16 | 27 sett. 19:30 |

Loading...





















31 gen. 06:50