10th out of 50 books
—
152 voters
Astray
by
Emma Donoghue (Goodreads Author)
The fascinating characters that roam across the pages of Emma Donoghue's stories have all gone astray: they are emigrants, runaways, drifters, lovers old and new. They are gold miners and counterfeiters, attorneys and slaves. They cross other borders too: those of race, law, sex, and sanity. They travel for love or money, incognito or under duress.
With rich historical deta...more
With rich historical deta...more
Hardcover, 274 pages
Published
October 30th 2012
by Little, Brown and Company
(first published January 1st 2012)
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
3,000)
-Facebook Page https://www.facebook.com/Thebooknatics --
I received this book through the Goodreads Giveaways, it was one of those books that captivated me from the start and just couldn’t put down at all.
Emma Donoghue has taken real historic stories of people on the run or departed for adventure and love, and turned them into a work of art, almost like behind-the-scenes action. Her imagination takes us for a spin on the untold stories of beloved documented events of everyday people who left an...more
I received this book through the Goodreads Giveaways, it was one of those books that captivated me from the start and just couldn’t put down at all.
Emma Donoghue has taken real historic stories of people on the run or departed for adventure and love, and turned them into a work of art, almost like behind-the-scenes action. Her imagination takes us for a spin on the untold stories of beloved documented events of everyday people who left an...more
This story collection has had a powerful effect upon me and has left a residue such as I have not experienced previously after short story collections.
The epigraph:
Tell us underneath what skies,
Upon what coasts of earth we have been cast;
We wander, ignorant of men and places,
And driven by the wind and the vast waves.
Virgil, The Aeneid,
translated by Allen Mandelbaum (1971)
Contents
Departures 1
Man and Boy 5
Onward 23
The Widow's Cruse 43
Last Supper at Brown's 65
In Transit 73
Counting t...more
The epigraph:
Tell us underneath what skies,
Upon what coasts of earth we have been cast;
We wander, ignorant of men and places,
And driven by the wind and the vast waves.
Virgil, The Aeneid,
translated by Allen Mandelbaum (1971)
Contents
Departures 1
Man and Boy 5
Onward 23
The Widow's Cruse 43
Last Supper at Brown's 65
In Transit 73
Counting t...more
This is a collection of short stories around a few themes (loss, abandonment, etc etc) which are all pretty well summed up by the main title. These are considered "historical" I suppose, because they are based on actual people, letters, places, and so forth. I thought the stories were pretty good. Like most collections, you have a pretty wide range here- my favorite being the one about the two young men panning for gold. So if you are into period pieces, you might wanna check this out.
I did have...more
I did have...more
From the Afterword:
"Unease. Wonder. Melancholy. Irritation. Relief. Shame. Absentmindedness. Nostalgia. Self-righteousness. Guilt. Travelers know all the confusion of the human condition in concentrated form. Migration is mortality by another name, the itch we can't scratch. Perhaps because moving far away to some arbitrary spot simply highlights the arbitrariness on getting born into this particular body in the first place: this contingent selfhood, this sole life."
This quote because I'm strugg...more
"Unease. Wonder. Melancholy. Irritation. Relief. Shame. Absentmindedness. Nostalgia. Self-righteousness. Guilt. Travelers know all the confusion of the human condition in concentrated form. Migration is mortality by another name, the itch we can't scratch. Perhaps because moving far away to some arbitrary spot simply highlights the arbitrariness on getting born into this particular body in the first place: this contingent selfhood, this sole life."
This quote because I'm strugg...more
like emma donoghue's earlier collection the woman who gave birth to rabbits, astray spins stray headlines and fragments of historical documents into vignettes that are sometimes contemplative, sometimes startling, and sometimes quite beautiful. i hesitate to call these stories "historical fiction," because the draw is really in the tension between the historical and the fictional, the known and the speculative.
part of me, too, resists the idea that fiction is somehow more worthy of our (literary...more
part of me, too, resists the idea that fiction is somehow more worthy of our (literary...more
Emma Donoghue has a wonderful ability to "take you there" - to make the almost-unimaginable seem real, tangible, actual. I first experienced this with her novel ROOM - so when I saw this book listed, I ordered it, even though I am not always a fan of short stories. (their scope seems so limited! not true in this case.)
All of these stories are based on real events or circumstances in history: sometimes just a line or scrap she found in a newspaper, sometimes a few bits of correspondence - Donoghu...more
All of these stories are based on real events or circumstances in history: sometimes just a line or scrap she found in a newspaper, sometimes a few bits of correspondence - Donoghu...more
While I am not typically a fan of short stories, Astray showed me how rich this literary form can be in the hands of an excellent writer. Donoghue's Room was such a good read that I was compelled to give this book a try. I'm so glad I did. (On top of being thankful for the kind librarian who let me exceed my book limit to check it out.)
My main complaint with short stories has been the lack of character development. I often read books to get to know the people between their pages. What I found ou...more
My main complaint with short stories has been the lack of character development. I often read books to get to know the people between their pages. What I found ou...more
My first Emma Donoghue book was The Woman Who Gave Birth to Rabbits - a short story collection built on historical tidbits and facts that was released in 2002. I've enjoyed many more titles from Donoghue since - Slammerkin remains a favorite. I was thrilled to see that her latest book Astray was again a collection of short stories with their origins found in obscure historical realities.
In this latest collection Donoghue explores all the ways a life, a person, a path can go astray...." on and of...more
In this latest collection Donoghue explores all the ways a life, a person, a path can go astray...." on and of...more
It is a rare short story that can captivate the reader, present fully developed characters that maintain the reader’s interest, and present a completely satisfying story arch in a limited amount of pages; yet Emma Donoghue’s latest collection of stories, Astray, manages to do just that in all fourteen stories. In each of the stories, the characters have all gone astray; from the homes that they have always known, from the rules of society, from convention and even from the law. Donoghue also tak...more
The latest anthology from the author of "Room" has an intriguing premise —vignettes and very short stories spun out from old news items and historical records —but the stories Donoghue uncovers are often rich enough to support entire novels, and yet she only spins out a few details. In many cases it seems like the real story is starting where she ends her writing, which can make this a frustrating read. Yes, it's interesting that a slave murdered his owner and went on the run with his owner's wi...more
I have loved Emma Donoghue since before Room. Her novel Slammerkin remains one of my favourite pieces of historical fiction. I very much enjoyed this collection of historical short stories. I read it in one day (admittedly much of this day was spent on a plane). I was lucky enough to hear the author speak about the book and where the stories came from. Emma described the freedom of zooming in on a single moment in history, rather than creating a whole novel around it. She described herself as a...more
Donoghue offers an intriguing premise here: a collection of short stories on social outcasts and rebels, inspired by actual people and events. Characters are scattered all over time and space: we have Puritans, slaves and their owners, cowboys, modern artists, Irish immigrants, and even an early transvestite. If you are interested in historical fiction, namely weird historical fiction, there's bound to be something here for you.
A handful of the stories are truly stunning. The Lost Seed and The...more
A handful of the stories are truly stunning. The Lost Seed and The...more
Usually, when I read a collection of stories, there are a few I love, a few I like, a few I could take or leave, and a few I dislike. In this collection, I love almost all of them, and there are only a few I only like, and none I dislike. That's almost impossible for me. But then, Emma Donoghue has always been a sure thing for me, ever since I read Kissing the Witch. This collection of stories about journeys and migrants lives up to its fairy tale predecessor.
Particular favorites include Man an...more
Particular favorites include Man an...more
Not being a huge short story fan I started this book with a little bit of trepidation, especially after having loved “Room” so much. But, despite the format, I enjoyed this book very much. Each story is a vignette taken from history, a newspaper article, a well known legend or a footnote from another source and Ms. Donoghue brings the characters to life. Taking the reader on a trip through different time periods and across North America we get a little taste of everything; love, crime, despair,...more
I read this right after it came out (on my lunch breaks at work) and I highly recommend it. I think Emma Donoghue is pretty amazing and this collection of short stories are well researched and interesting. Each story is based on a real historical occurrences and Donoghue ends each story with a note as to the historical background, including sources. The stories are organized into three sections: departures, in transit, and arrivals. Certainly the characters are all in different points on a journ...more
Donoghue is now on my list of "authors who I'll pick up books by as soon as I see them". This book's another historic collection of short stories, and I'm probably biased because she is essentially doing what I've never had the ability to do, which is take an interesting historical find and make it into an interesting story without losing the heart of what made it worth a second look in the first place. Although I also like her modern-set books too. I think the way she writes relationships is a...more
3.5 stars. I was really excited for this book! Donoghue's "Room" was one of my favorite reads last year so when I heard that Donoghue's Astray was coming out, I knew that I had to read this book. Now short stories are not usually my favorite but because of the writing in "Room," I gave this book a shot. I was definitely pleased and I know that in the future, Emma Donoghue will continue to be on my must read. Now to go back and read her backlist...
This book is all about journeys of all different...more
This book is all about journeys of all different...more
Donoghue takes historical documents--letters, newspaper articles, court documents--and fleshes them out into short stories. I adore her ability to imagine a full story from sometimes the most scant details.
She is very good at adopting a variety of voices. In this collection (I've read an earlier one, The Woman Who Gave Birth to Rabbits), Donoghue brings to life the mind, heart and soul of an elephant trainer, a very earnest prostitute, a pair of gold prospectors, a wild woman of the west, a wom...more
She is very good at adopting a variety of voices. In this collection (I've read an earlier one, The Woman Who Gave Birth to Rabbits), Donoghue brings to life the mind, heart and soul of an elephant trainer, a very earnest prostitute, a pair of gold prospectors, a wild woman of the west, a wom...more
I've never read Donoghue's longer fiction, but I love her stories. In this collection, as in The Woman Who Gave Birth to Rabbits: Stories, she includes detailed story notes. Each piece jumps off from a news clipping or other factual source. It's great fun to try to figure out what the grain of truth is inside each work of fiction. Most of the stories are somewhat bittersweet; after all, who makes the news? A few are from the other type of news, surprising deceptions carried out on an individual...more
When I read an author I admire, I often wonder what inspires their stories. Emma Donoghue provides the answers in this wonderful collection of historical fiction shorts about castaways, immigrants and lost souls. Each story contains an afterward referencing her inspiration -- sometimes a newspaper article, sometimes a moment in history or famous court cases.
I appreciated reading the fiction story first, falling enveloped into the tiny worlds Donoghue created in a few short pages, before I knew t...more
I appreciated reading the fiction story first, falling enveloped into the tiny worlds Donoghue created in a few short pages, before I knew t...more
May 06, 2013
Emrys
rated it
4 of 5 stars
Recommends it for:
Adults reluctant short story readers
Recommended to Emrys by:
coworker
Shelves:
adult
An expertly-written, well-varied selection of 14 short historical fictions, each tied to a real sourced anecdote from 1639-1968, from London to The Yukon. Though the motifs of leaving home and finding new beginnings are woven throughout, it is surprising and thought-provoking from first to last.
Each story is (blessedly) so different from the others, that it is impossible to review the book as a whole, though I could talk at length about each of the fourteen stories individually.I felt that each...more
Each story is (blessedly) so different from the others, that it is impossible to review the book as a whole, though I could talk at length about each of the fourteen stories individually.I felt that each...more
These short stories present vignettes in the lives of outsiders and people who live on the border, whether that means the border of "polite society" as in the case of a young woman who supports her brother and daughter by working as a prostitute; the inter-species friendship between an elephant and its keeper; or the blurry boundaries between genders discovered when a woman in the 1920s discovers after his death that the father she loved was born a woman.
Because they're not connected in any way...more
Because they're not connected in any way...more
Normally, I avoid short story collections; however, I had promised myself after reading "Room" that I would read everything that Emma Donoghue publishes. And I'm glad I did. This collection is not to be missed.
The book is broken into three parts: part 1 is stories about people that are about to embark on a journey, part 2 is stories about people that are in transit of a journey, and part 3 is stories about people that are concluding a journey. The stories are historical in that they are based in...more
The book is broken into three parts: part 1 is stories about people that are about to embark on a journey, part 2 is stories about people that are in transit of a journey, and part 3 is stories about people that are concluding a journey. The stories are historical in that they are based in...more
My taste in literature does not usually include much historical fiction, but I have read Emma Donaghue's historical work anyway and I enjoy it (despite this thing I can't name or put my finger on that sort of just BUGS me about historical fiction. Is that strange?) In this collection, Donaghue takes historical artifacts and write short stories about the journeys they represent. They are good stories, with writing characteristic of Donaghue and encompassing the issues she tends to address. Some o...more
This group of short stories was interesting. At the end of each story Donoghue provides the snippet of historical information that informed the story. Unfortunately, although the audio was very well read, I found that those snippets didn't have enough of a pause, it took me a while to understand that I was listening almost to an authors note. All of these stories were historical and the theme was travel. Donoghue, who reads her afterword, explains in depth, but I can't say that I found most of t...more
I knew it was a collection of short stories but the delicious treat was a short paragraph or two at the end of each one explaining the news clipping or element that prompted the piece. As the title of the work suggests, the characters we meet have gone astray, either geographically or otherwise. Sometimes in several ways.
There is a thoroughly engaging afterword giving the reader insight into Emma's thoughts and philosophies on journeys, emmigrations, and arrivals from the perspective of and by h...more
There is a thoroughly engaging afterword giving the reader insight into Emma's thoughts and philosophies on journeys, emmigrations, and arrivals from the perspective of and by h...more
These short stories had no overlapping characters or places, but the "theme" of each story has a very similar idea behind it. These are all stories of people trying to move on from something, be it a place they no longer belong or a lifestyle they wish to forget. After each of these stories there was a little blurb of the history they were based on, some of them were only based on a single sentence or idea and some were based much more in fact. I had a couple favorite stories..."Man and Boy" the...more
I have to say that I really hated Room, but after making a book discussion guide for it, I had a feeling that I would really enjoy some of Emma Donughue's other work, and I was right.
Astray appealed to my archivist tendencies. She sourced each story from a little snippet of history - a letter, a newspaper clipping, or the mention of a historical figure in a book. While many of the characters were real people, little about them was known. It was completely obvious to me that she delighted in the...more
Astray appealed to my archivist tendencies. She sourced each story from a little snippet of history - a letter, a newspaper clipping, or the mention of a historical figure in a book. While many of the characters were real people, little about them was known. It was completely obvious to me that she delighted in the...more
I'm not usually a big fan of short story collections. I read them if someone suggests it or if they are chosen for one of my book clubs but I like a story to give me a good sense that something has happened and ended well. With some short stories I have felt like there are elements of the story that have been left out or that the author has more to tell but can't - so I avoid them. I liked Emma Donoghue's "Room" so much that I put this one on hold as soon as I heard about it and then finished it...more
Historical fiction for those not sure if they like historical fiction. This was a great find. I'll admit that I wasn't really considering this book when I saw it at the library, but it was so short I thought I should give it a try. It is a bunch of short stories that are written mostly in the17th - 19th centuries all based on some scrap of newspaper article, letters or journal entries. The unifying theme is supposed to be travel though not every story fits this unless you want to get metaphysica...more
| topics | posts | views | last activity | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| AfterEllen.com Bo...: Astray: Thoughts. | 1 | 24 | Dec 16, 2012 11:02am |
Emma is the youngest of eight children of Frances and Denis Donoghue. She attended Catholic convent schools in Dublin, apart from one year in New York at the age of ten. In 1990 she earned a first-class honours BA in English and French from University College Dublin, and in 1997 a PhD (on the concept of friendship between men and women in eighteenth-century English fiction) from the University of...more
More about Emma Donoghue...
Share This Book
No trivia or quizzes yet. Add some now »
“Writing stories is my way of scratching that itch: my escape from the claustrophobia of individuality. It lets me, at least for a while, live more than one life, walk more than one path. Reading, of course, can do the same.”
—
7 people liked it
More quotes…

Loading...










view all 3 comments



















