Talking to the Dead

Talking to the Dead

3.48 of 5 stars 3.48  ·  rating details  ·  391 ratings  ·  59 reviews
Praised by critics on both sides of the Atlantic for its elegant and sensuous prose, "Talking to the Dead" tells the story of two sisters whose lives are bound by the hidden and surprising truth about the long-ago death of their infant brother.
Paperback, 304 pages
Published June 1st 1998 by Back Bay Books (first published 1996)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 731)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Ant Harrison
I’m not too sure how to construct a review of Helen Dunmore’s Talking to the Dead (1996), except to say that for a so-called ‘literary author’ (whatever that means) it was well-structured, with a forceful narrative that kept you turning the pages. Isabel and Nina are sisters, living an enmeshed life ever since the death of their baby brother, Colin, when he was a few months old. Now adults, the story describes the elaborate dance and rituals of their relationship immediately after the birth of I...more
Mervi
This novel was completely haunting. It wasn’t advertised as a horror story, but by the time the final twist was revealed, it became one of the most shocking novels in print, the more so because what happens could take place in almost any family.

The interest came for me in the gorgeous writing and in the author's ability to sustain a terrible tension, a sense of gathering doom, like a summer storm rolling in slowly, but with stunning force.

I enjoyed imagining Isabel through the eyes of the variou...more
Ali
Helen Dunmore is a prolific and award winning author, yet this is only the fourth of her novels I have read. I now think I really must make an effort to read the rest. This 1996 novel is an impressive family drama with a fascinating psychological slant.
Dunmore’s excellent writing, with its sultry descriptions of place, draws the reader into the Sussex countryside during a scorching summer, and the lives of a group of rather unlikeable characters. There is a kind of chilly sensuality too in the...more
Christie
The events of Helen Dunmore’s beautifully written novel Talking to the Dead take place during a blazing summer on the Cornwall coast. Nina has come to spend time with her sister, Isabelle, who has just given birth to Antony. It is a difficult labour and delivery and Isabelle is having a slow recovery.

"You don’t look very alike, Susan said yesterday. I wouldn’t have guessed you were sisters" (29).

Susan has been hired to care for Antony while Isabelle recovers from the complications of Antony’s bi...more
Amy Meyer
Helen Dunmore has written a riveting story about two sisters and the ties that bond them as well as drive them apart. Isabel and Nina were very close growing up, maybe too close. They know each other better than they know themselves. A painful tragedy in their childhood caused both of them, but especially Nina, to push the past away, choosing to forget much of it. But the difficult delivery and birth of Isabel's first child and the memories that come back to Nina while she is staying under Isabe...more
Stephanie
This review originally appeared at www.readinasinglesitting.com

"We hover on the edge of what used to be said, caught up, as we used to be caught in the histories we made up for Rosina and Mandy. They were always changing. That was the best thing about the dolls. If the storyline didn't work out, we could always erase their pasts..."

Increasingly as a reader I'm drawn to unreliable narrators and ambiguous narratives: perhaps it's a sort of literary knee-jerk response to the tidily spelled out, wra...more
George King
I'd never read Dunmore before. This novel is a psychological thriller with some nice poetic passages. It explores a mystery from two sisters' childhood and the relationship of the two women as adults. The narrative moves along rapidly, and the author's use of language is at times exquisite. There are also some notably frank sexual passages. The denouement didn't blow me away quite as much as I thought it would.
Sandra Lawson
Helen Dunmore never fails to disappoint. She has a way with words and makes you believe you are inside the narrative and able to experience the sensations she evokes. I can always feel, taste, smell and hear a Dunmore novel.

Talking to the Dead is filled with tension and an awareness that something unpleasant will be revealed. The story unfolds through the filter of Nina, the younger of two sisters, who relates in the present tense, adding to the immediacy of the narrative. Although the perspecti...more
Monique
Unfortunately this book was not as suspenseful and drama filled as the synopsis would have one believe. It was actually kind of flat. There were some interesting things happening in the story but Dunmore failed to make me really care. It was all rather boring.

The story is told through the first person perspective of Nina. Nina character could have been interesting but she failed to connect to me. I wanted her to be interesting and exciting but she was as boring as the drama and suspense that was...more
Tim Cole
Reason for reading:
Helen Dunmore had proved twice what a stunning writer she is. With more of her books waiting on the shelf, this seemed an intriguing next read.

About the book:
Sisters Nina and Isabel have been bound together since the cot death of their baby brother when they were both children. They live different lives, Nina in London as a single freelance photographer, Isabel married and in the country. Isabel gives birth to her first child and Nina comes to help look after her, joining Isab...more
Cindy
When I was reading some of the other reviews, I came across one where the person had either read the book before, or she thought she had started it but never finished it. I almost fell on the floor! The same thing happened to me! I actually read this one and totally forgot it and read it again! I kept feeling like I knew the story, but couldn't remember until I would read each part and then I would know I had read it before. Strange! The story explores the relationship between two sisters and ho...more
Sally Whitehead
I hadn't previously read any Dunmore, but bought a handful of hers on offer recently in second hand bookshop. Judging a book by its cover (come on, we all do it...) I assumed she might be in the same sort of realm as Elizabeth Berg, Anita Shreve, Sue Miller et al. And I wasn't disappointed.

This is good "women's fiction". Literary enough to be far removed from the irksome "chick lit" but with a real focus on familial relationships.

A slim novel (only 214 pages) this was a nice, quick read. Helped...more
Sarah Shoemaker
The book had so much potential but I came away wishing I'd not wasted my time. The characters are mostly one-dimensional. I could barely create a clear picture in my mind of what they might look like. Isabel is described as beautiful but you only get scraps here and there of how she looks--the same goes for her sister. I don't understand the point of Edward at all. The motivations of the characters is also not realistic or remotely believable. Things happen haphazardly at some points while other...more
Pat
The book I read was Talking to the Dead by Harry Bingham, but I can't figure out how to change it so I'll write about the one I read. It was about murders that began on the very first page and has some unnecessarily horrid violence involving Russian/Romanian slave trade which I quickly tired of. But, the element that kept me reading was the back story of the young female detective who was back from a nervous breakdown that no one could explain until the last chapter. That was very interesting -...more
Steven Langdon
This darkly shaded novel starts quietly then gradually overwhelms you. Isabel and Nina are sisters, intimately tied together from a difficult childhood, yet starkly different in instinct and character -- controlling and austere vs. creative and earthy. Dealing with Isabel's new baby after a traumatic birth, the two come to confront the much earlier death of their baby brother -- and the sisterly relationship dissolves amidst a compelling melange of new sexual ties, intense personal jealousies an...more
Moira
I don't often mistakenly re-read a book. But it seems that I have done so with two Helen Dunmore books. I can't understand why, as both were excellent and very memorable. But, as with A spell of Winter, I realized about a third of the way through that I had read it before. However, I couldn't remember the end, and in fact, it didn't seem familiar towards the end so perhaps I never finished it - also unusual for me.

Anyway, it was very enjoyable. Dunmore has an amazing ability to describe things...more
Sara
Jan 21, 2008 Sara rated it 2 of 5 stars Recommends it for: gluttons for punishment
This is a terrible book about terrible people who do terrible, nonsensical, and incredible -- and I mean really not credible -- things to themselves, each other and other people. Yet it's all so beautifully described! You just want to go on reading it no matter what, just so you can stay in this garden with these flowers and this hot summer sun, and all this beautiful food.

But before you know it, several hours of your life have been devoured. Then at the end, if you are anything like me, you are...more
Emily
If you set most of the actual events in a novel in the past, thereby focusing everything on the characters rather than a plot, characters need to be more developed than they were here. I found the narrator's obsession with her sister annoying, boring and inscrutable. I will say that the author harped on the fact that the narrator is fat, which led to a lot of writing about food, which I like.

A combination of Mary Higgins Clark + Oprah's book club.
Renee Johnson
Filled with morally bankrupt, selfish people, this book was really a disappointment. I could not sympathize with anyone except the child. The story had poor flow and the characters were contradictions of themselves and had so little depth that I found myself not able to identify with them or even care what would happen to them. This is a less than memorable book.
Barbara
A tale of two sisters together after the birth of the elder's son. Well done hints of horror as they reminisce about their younger brother who died as an infant. The depictions of food are mouth watering and sensual. The book would have been better had I come to care deeply for any of the characters, all of which are flawed in some unattractive way.
Lucy
Oh blimey, Helen Dunmore doesn't half view her characters through a cold, clinical lens! The writing is unfailingly beautiful, but icily so .. even the spontaneous sex scenes in the sweltering summer garden left me feeling a bit chilly! The characters are cool customers indeed. Curiously emotionless. I don't know why I found the novel so readable when the protagonists were so dull. But I think I could make a pretty passable hollandaise sauce after reading this book!
Vanessa
so far so good
A short book
has made me think a lot about family/sister relationships.I have cried reading because it reminded me of how traumatised i was staying with my sister after she had had a casarean.

My favourite style of book:when very important,life changing things happen but they are just dealt with as if they and normal, everyday occurences.
Jenna Mills
I was surprised that this book became unputdownable. Most of the characters were all rather strange, and did react to events how you would usually expect people to. A relief really to be back in the real world! I do, however, fancy having that long, hot summer!
JoAnne
Beautifully written book about disturbing characters and subject manner. Sisters who were unusually close as children because their mother was an distant mother. I did find myself compelled to keep reading, and that is always an extra star for me.
Malla
Superb book. Delicately structured. Intense. Powerful. The underplay of how more powerful personalities play situations to suit themselves - sometimes with very little understanding of the consequences of hurt and guilt. Quite brilliant.
Safron Mitchelson
I registered a book at BookCrossing.com!
http://www.BookCrossing.com/journal/10099692
Gill Balfour
Helen Dunmore is one of my favourite writers and she didn't disappoint with this one. Evocative and moving, it was difficult to put it down.
Catherinerobssister
Romped through this book 'cus it was so damn good! I would've given it 5 * too...but I was a bit confused as to what actually happened in the end though. Fab book and well worth a read...
Elizabeth Desole
The food scenes are almost pornographic but the sex scenes weren't. Hmm. I did enjoy though (esp the porno food descriptions). Nice twist at the end
Kirsty
This is certainly one of Dunmore’s better novels but I still preferred The Siege and The House of Orphans. It began rather interestingly with the main character talking to a recently deceased one. I think the novel would have been more enjoyable if this narrative structure had continued throughout. Aside from a few random words which didn’t seem to fit - ‘jinking’ and ‘jouncing’, for example - it was well written. Some of the interwoven storylines were a little random and described too graphical...more
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 24 25 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
Talking to the Dead (Hardcover)
Talking To The Dead
Talking to the Dead (Paperback)
Terug naar de zee (Paperback)
Talking To The Dead

41542
I was born in December 1952, in Yorkshire, the second of four children. My father was the eldest of twelve, and this extended family has no doubt had a strong influence on my life, as have my own children. In a large family you hear a great many stories. You also come to understand very early that stories hold quite different meanings for different listeners, and can be recast from many viewpoints...more
More about Helen Dunmore...
Ingo (Ingo, #1) Tide Knot (Ingo, #2) The Deep (Ingo, #3) The Crossing of Ingo (Ingo, #4) The Siege

Share This Book

Your website