184th out of 270 books
—
119 voters
The Jefferson Lies: Exposing the Myths You've Always Believed about Thomas Jefferson
America, in so many ways, has forgotten. Its roots, its purpose, its identity―all have become shrouded behind a veil of political correctness bent on twisting the nation's founding, and its founders, to fit within a misshapen modern world.
The time has come to remember again.
In "The Jefferson Lies," prominent historian David Barton sets out to correct the distorted image of...more
The time has come to remember again.
In "The Jefferson Lies," prominent historian David Barton sets out to correct the distorted image of...more
Hardcover, 304 pages
Published
April 10th 2012
by Thomas Nelson Publishers
(first published January 1st 2012)
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
605)
This writer lied. Don't believe me? Read it for yourself.
Publisher Pulls Controversial Thomas Jefferson Book, Citing Loss Of Confidence
"Citing a loss of confidence in the book's details, Christian publisher Thomas Nelson is ending the publication and distribution of the bestseller, The Jefferson Lies: Exposing the Myths You've Always Believed About Thomas Jefferson.
The controversial book was written by Texas evangelical David Barton, who NPR's Barbara Bradley Hagerty profiled on All Things Cons...more
Publisher Pulls Controversial Thomas Jefferson Book, Citing Loss Of Confidence
"Citing a loss of confidence in the book's details, Christian publisher Thomas Nelson is ending the publication and distribution of the bestseller, The Jefferson Lies: Exposing the Myths You've Always Believed About Thomas Jefferson.
The controversial book was written by Texas evangelical David Barton, who NPR's Barbara Bradley Hagerty profiled on All Things Cons...more
christian-right-historian-david-barton-in-freefall-over-jefferson-lies www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2012/0...
While I'm not a "scholar" (I only have a minor in history and all other "learning" on my part has been autodidactic) I'm not so "fussed" about this book as others seem to be. There has been great consternation since it's publication with people lining up and taking sides (largely along political lines) trying to stifle it or keep it in print.
The book is not as I had been led to believe a "tissue of lies". It's an attempt on the part of the author to counter certain modern ideas that have been bu...more
The book is not as I had been led to believe a "tissue of lies". It's an attempt on the part of the author to counter certain modern ideas that have been bu...more
Started The Jefferson Lies by David Barton. So far, it is a page turner (despite the numerous footnotes that can distract at times).
History is never written by its actors, and when it comes to "accuracy", it is only as good as the research, analysis and referencing done by the author. David Barton is a strong historian. Even if some claim that he has a religious agenda, I find interesting to review historical periods or people using someone else's looking glass: up to me to decide if I believe i...more
History is never written by its actors, and when it comes to "accuracy", it is only as good as the research, analysis and referencing done by the author. David Barton is a strong historian. Even if some claim that he has a religious agenda, I find interesting to review historical periods or people using someone else's looking glass: up to me to decide if I believe i...more
In addition to the historical errors, this book suffers from two primary problems:
First, there is significant weight to the argument that Barton is responding to straw men. While he claims to be responding to the “twentieth-century practices that now dominate the study of American history and its heroes: Deconstructionism, Poststructuralism, Modernism, Minimalism, and Academic Collectivism.” (xvi), an examination of his footnotes tells a very different story. For chapters 3-7, Barton takes a spe...more
First, there is significant weight to the argument that Barton is responding to straw men. While he claims to be responding to the “twentieth-century practices that now dominate the study of American history and its heroes: Deconstructionism, Poststructuralism, Modernism, Minimalism, and Academic Collectivism.” (xvi), an examination of his footnotes tells a very different story. For chapters 3-7, Barton takes a spe...more
I have had a copy of The Jefferson Lies for a while now in a stack of “to read” books, waiting until I had the time to get to it. But after being made aware of the “controversy” over this book last week I bumped it up on my list and have just finished it. As I expected when I bought the book, I found it to be an indispensible volume of historical facts that had been carefully researched and documented—just like I have come to expect from all of David Barton’s books. In this book we get the chanc...more
I sat in Barnes and Noble yesterday and read this book. I wouldn't buy - thank God I didn't.
David Barton isn't an historian. He's a preacher. It shows.
It's obvious that his heroes in history didn't exist - but they are still his heroes nonetheless. He creates his heroes out of the past by picking great deeds and then assigning to those deeds men of character and resilience that he would admire in men of the present. Then he assigns those characters the names of those men in the past who accomp...more
David Barton isn't an historian. He's a preacher. It shows.
It's obvious that his heroes in history didn't exist - but they are still his heroes nonetheless. He creates his heroes out of the past by picking great deeds and then assigning to those deeds men of character and resilience that he would admire in men of the present. Then he assigns those characters the names of those men in the past who accomp...more
You will not find me giving books endorsed y Glenn Beck positive reviews very often. Nor will I buy gold from whatever company he preys on the fears of the elderly for. However, this book recalibrated my views on a central figure in our nations history and would have gotten a fourth star but it was just a little too repetitive for me to give it that one. But every American should read it. I learned some new things, but more importantly, learned things I thought to be true were lies and vice vers...more
Prior to reading this book, I had only surface-level knowledge of Thomas Jefferson. I knew he was an important and central figure in the founding of America, and I also suspected he was an intellectual genius.
There were many things I’d heard about him that troubled me, though, too. I knew he owned slaves. I’d heard the rumors about illegitimate children. Vaguely remembered there was a movie with that premise. (Never saw it.) I also was used to hearing that he was a deist, or possibly an atheist...more
There were many things I’d heard about him that troubled me, though, too. I knew he owned slaves. I’d heard the rumors about illegitimate children. Vaguely remembered there was a movie with that premise. (Never saw it.) I also was used to hearing that he was a deist, or possibly an atheist...more
As Thomas Jefferson's 6th great nephew, I have some interest in the topic and have seen a number of refutations of the Sally Hemings dna "proof" issue in the past few years. But I had not paid as much attention to the charges that Jefferson was a racist, an atheist, that the University of VA which he established was designed as anti-religion, anti-clergy and purely secular. The author takes on each of these assertions, examines them in the context of their time and often in Jefferson's own words...more
Everyone who is interested in history ought to read this well documented book that shows how very UNobjective historians are in their portrayals of historical figures and events. This author shows how so much of the modern view of Jefferson is just plain WRONG. The book documents each lie, quotes modern historians that accept and repeat the lie, quote MULTIPLE documents that show that the opposite is actually true, then shows how the lie originated, quoting letters and contemporary documents and...more
The most interesting part of this book is how he describes the historical malpractice used by historians. The first is deconstructionism. Deconstructionism is the practice of tearing down heroes and institutions. The second practice employed by historians is Post structuralism. Post structuralism is the belief that each individual interprets history by himself using only his/her personal feelings to judge it. The third is Modernism which is judging history in today’s context. The fourth is Minim...more
I know this book has garnered some controversy. That is one of the reasons I wanted to read it. Writing history is always a daunting task. Is an author getting the real accurate portrayal of the person or are things being taken out of context and used to further an author's thesis or agenda? This book hits on several things that are dear to the hearts of Americans regarding Jefferson. Is he an american hero or a villain. So many claims are made about Jefferson and usually to support a current vi...more
I didn't know about the controversy surrounding the book until I got online to write a review. It looks like for political reasons, the publishers gave into pressure and pulled the book. As a result, many now get the pleasure of dismiss this book as a pile of BS without even reading it. On amazon there are multitudes of petty reviews by people who merely got on to bloat over the fact that a book by a Christian author was pulled off the shelf. It really is sad, for "The Jefferson Lies" is incredi...more
As in all of David Barton's books (at least the ones that I've read), EVERYTHING is thoroughly documented, which I appreciate. It does make the reading slightly tedious, but while reading, you know you are truly getting the facts. Even though I thought I knew quite a lot about Jefferson, this book made me realize what a great man he was, not perfect, but a thinker who knew what he believed and why. I especially appreciated the refutation of the Hemmings story, and the reasoning behind WHY Jeffer...more
Jul 26, 2012
Jeff
added it
Premise: Jefferson is maligned by modern historian.
My Conclusion: Jefferson was a brilliant but all too human man. He believed in the philosophy of Jesus Christ, but not in the immaculate conception, resurrection, or divinity of Christ. In his life, he tried to follow the teachings. That, to me, makes him a Christian. To evangelicals he would not likely be considered a Christian. Is it better to believe in the immaculate conception; resurrection, and divinity of Christ and to NOT follow his tea...more
My Conclusion: Jefferson was a brilliant but all too human man. He believed in the philosophy of Jesus Christ, but not in the immaculate conception, resurrection, or divinity of Christ. In his life, he tried to follow the teachings. That, to me, makes him a Christian. To evangelicals he would not likely be considered a Christian. Is it better to believe in the immaculate conception; resurrection, and divinity of Christ and to NOT follow his tea...more
I am listening to as well as reading this book at the same time. There is so much to digest. Mr. Barton's many footnotes are amazing and truly back up his constant reminder to always go back to the original source and not to other people's opinions of what the source says. So far it has been very eye opening and given me a fonder view of Jeffereson than I have had from all I've learned about him. I am anxious to have my two older boys read this and let me know how this compares to what they have...more
Excellent read! The author, David Barton goes straight to the source for information: 1) Thomas Jefferson's own writings, 2) Jefferson family writings, 3) Friends & Acquaintenances of Jefferson, their writings, 4) Newspaper articles of the period, 5) Historical sequences based on fact rather than modern conjecture; this he documents solidly.
No wonder those who want to re-write history (revisionist), especially Jefferson's history are up in arms about this book. It's even more interesting tha...more
No wonder those who want to re-write history (revisionist), especially Jefferson's history are up in arms about this book. It's even more interesting tha...more
In this book David Barton tries to convince the reader that Jefferson was an extremely religious man and that all of his decisions were based on divine intervention (not really, just me exaggerating). It is really disheartening to see this "Jefferson debate" taking place. It seems that the atheists want to paint him with the "I am a secular" brush and the religious fanatics want to pain him with the "I am a Saint" brush. Neither one suits me at this point in time. I believe that Jefferson was a...more
I've seen David Barton live and on TV programs throughout the years. He is an amazing historian. Barton addresses a number of lies that have been spread about Jefferson and addresses them piece by piece. He covers every angle and supports his arguments with actual quotes (imagine that!); this book is well-researched and heavily documented. I am constantly amazed how others in academia get away with excluding documentation and/or simply quote other academics rather than actual sources. Barton is...more
An interesting work. Barton, a Protestant pastor by trade, sets out to refute a set of latter day dogmas about Thomas Jefferson, and, through extensive footnoting and research, adequately hits his mark. Among his targets are the Sally Hemmings "bio-legacy", allegations that Jefferson was at minimum a non-Christian and set up a secular University of Virginia, and wrote his own Bible. The book is apparently considered controversial but the reasonable person can safely take this as a valid point of...more
David Barton isn't a historian. I don't know. This book somehow left me the impression that he just wrote this book to manipulate history. Or mythology. Or maybe both of them. He tried to show off as heroes people that were incapable of achieving something worthy of being read. If all these "heroes" were alive today, they would publicly accuse Barton that he made them look like idiots.
2 out of 5 stars, only because the plot was somewhat interesting. I'd definitely not recommend it to anyone.
2 out of 5 stars, only because the plot was somewhat interesting. I'd definitely not recommend it to anyone.
I just finished this book. David Barton did a great job dispelling many of the myths and lies about Thomas Jefferson. It renewed my faith in "true" history. I am sick and tired of the revisionists who try to change our history to meet their political agenda. This book busts all of their lies about one of our greatest US Presidents, Thomas Jefferson. This book is more of a list of facts and answers to questions, than it is a historical narrative. It was easy to read and follow.
Since I LOVE EARLY AMERICAN HISTORY...I have read many biographies of our Founding Fathers...Over the years...I have found how NEW AUTHORS REWRITE HISTORY...and not with ACCURATE information...What I LOVE about David Barton as an author...he has DOCUMENTS to PROVE his statements...EXCELLENT SOURCE to have on hand...when discussing FACTS regarding our Founding Fathers...
This is one of the most important books that could be included in anyone's study of Thomas Jefferson. Relying heavily upon original source material, David Barton dispels many of the modern myths and rumors surrounding this remarkable individual. A must read for any student of US history, especially those studying the life and character of Thomas Jefferson.
| topics | posts | views | last activity | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| withdrawn by the publisher | 2 | 12 | Aug 11, 2012 08:30pm |
David Barton is the Founder and President of WallBuilders, a national pro-family organization that presents America's forgotten history and heroes, with an emphasis on our moral, religious and constitutional heritage.
WallBuilders is a name taken from the Old Testament writings of Nehemiah, who led a grassroots movement to rebuild the walls of Jerusalem and restore its strength and honor. In the sa...more
More about David Barton...
WallBuilders is a name taken from the Old Testament writings of Nehemiah, who led a grassroots movement to rebuild the walls of Jerusalem and restore its strength and honor. In the sa...more
Share This Book
No trivia or quizzes yet. Add some now »

Loading...










view all 17 comments

























