18th out of 18 books
—
23 voters
Marilyn: The Passion and Paradox
by
Lois Banner
Like her art, Marilyn Monroe was rooted in paradox: She was a powerful star and a childlike waif; a joyful, irreverent party girl with a deeply spiritual side; a superb friend and a narcissist; a dumb blonde and an intellectual. No previous biographer has recognized -- much less attempted to analyze -- most of these aspects of her personality. Lois Banner has.
Since Marilyn...more
Since Marilyn...more
Hardcover, 528 pages
Published
July 17th 2012
by Bloomsbury USA
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
1,128)
Banner is determined to get to the truth of events, and mostly succeeds. Her ambition with this book is really admirable and she does her best to understand and explain why Marilyn was the way she was. Feminist thoughts very interesting too, worth discussing at length. Full review here: http://littlewordsreview.wordpress.co...
An absorbing look at the contradiction that was Initials MM that contained much information that was new to me. It was also great to read a perspective not preoccupied with that tired trope in which MM is depicted as a victim of Hollywoodland and menfolk. Instead, the book centres more on her psychological make-up and the author's feminist readings of MM as an icon. My only criticism is that there is a degree of repetition (quotes, general information, anecdotes) which I found a little distracti...more
This is an ambitious, scholarly study of Marilyn Monroe, looking both at the narrative of her life and her place in history. While I don't agree with every part of it, I found Banner's perspective to be brilliant at times. She gives the reader a sense of why Monroe is so hard to pin down as a character, and how she seems to embody so many contradictions. This is a thoughtful, provocative read, analysing MM as an American icon. But if you're looking for a more straightforward biography, this may...more
Marilyn Monroe is a bit of a guilty pleasure for me so it follows that I've read everything about her, watched all of her films, etc. I really liked parts of this book such as her raise to stardom, her marriages, her addictions, her mental illness- all of which are examined outside of the male glance. It's so nice to see MM as a woman in today's definition of womanhood. She slept her way to the top? Lot's of actresses do that! She was bipolar/schizophrenic/depressed/unknown mental illness? Lot's...more
This book is so popular that I had to wait several weeks to get it from the library. It is the most recent semi-academic book about Marilyn and Banner is a specialist on her and her politics. Yes, Marilyn as both a woman and an icon was/is terribly political. The book follows the typical biography outline, beginning with Marilyn's grandparents. Slowly, the early years of her development unfold and we learn about the tragic events of her childhood (including her abandonment by her mother and mole...more
If you are looking for a gushy, glitzy tell-all recounting the splendor of Marilyn Monroe's Hollywood existence, this is not the book for you. Rather, it's a moving study of Marilyn's conflicted personality and the effects of her trauma and mental illness. Banner, a Monroe "scholar" of sorts, examines the oft overlooked contradictions separating the woman herself from her movie star persona, and susses out her true character, a figure that seemed to hover somewhere between "Norma Jeanne" and "Ma...more
http://www.cozylittlebookjournal.com/...
Biographer Lois Banner herself admits that there is little we don't already know about Marilyn Monroe. The details of her childhood, her private and public affairs, and her death have captivated us all for decades. So the challenge for anyone writing a new book about her is not in finding enough source material, but in finding anything new to say. Does Lois Banner manage it? Yes and no.
She's certainly done her research. She makes clear which sources (which...more
Biographer Lois Banner herself admits that there is little we don't already know about Marilyn Monroe. The details of her childhood, her private and public affairs, and her death have captivated us all for decades. So the challenge for anyone writing a new book about her is not in finding enough source material, but in finding anything new to say. Does Lois Banner manage it? Yes and no.
She's certainly done her research. She makes clear which sources (which...more
People speculate how much Marilyn would have changed in the turbulent catalyst of the 1960's. Would she have become a feminist? Taken on and ruled over the studio powers and men that left her feeling like a used piece of meat? I think she would have fought to retain her physical beauty until the game was up, then became another Bardot and love the little kitties of the world. Or a recluse. But frankly, with her rampant drug and alcohol use, I don't think she would have survived the '60's. It wou...more
When I first received the hardcover book, I was excited to read it. I was always fascinated by Marilyn Monroe and eagerly looked forward to finding out new details about her. Ms. Banner certainly has loaded the book with a lot of information, but I was a bit disappointed that there wasn't really anything new.
Marilyn was a complicated woman and her experiences in her childhood certainly shaped the woman she became Ms. Banner contends. I was surprised by comparisons the author makes between Marily...more
Marilyn was a complicated woman and her experiences in her childhood certainly shaped the woman she became Ms. Banner contends. I was surprised by comparisons the author makes between Marily...more
Aug 08, 2012
Adam Tschorn
added it
This is the second book on Monroe penned by the USC professor of history and gender studies, and one that she spent a decade researching. It's a dense, detail-packed book, so much so that in recounting Monroe's early years and the people in her life as she was shuttled from home to home, it's easy to lose track of all the players and places.
But Banner's throughline isn't hard to follow: The woman who started life as Norma Jeane Mortenson worked hard at creating and then meticulously honed to per...more
But Banner's throughline isn't hard to follow: The woman who started life as Norma Jeane Mortenson worked hard at creating and then meticulously honed to per...more
Fifty years after her death, Marilyn Monroe remains one of Hollywood's most beloved figures. Born as Norma Jean Mortenson, she grew up in several foster homes, became a model during World War II, and made her mark in movies. But America's biggest sex symbol had a dark side. Her personal relationships were tumultuous, her rise to stardom was costly, and her emotional weakness and physical ailments would plague her to the end.
None of this is very new. After all there are literally dozens and dozen...more
None of this is very new. After all there are literally dozens and dozen...more
Marilyn Monroe is still on of the most recognized sex symbols to come out of America's history and make her way into the world conciousness. This book is an attempt to analyze the different aspects of Marilyn's personality: her troubled childhood, the dueling longings for a successful career and a family of her own, the partying contrasted with the religion, the dumb blonde versus the very smart girl. The author, Lois Banner, takes a feminist approach and treats the material like a slice of wome...more
August 5 will mark the 50th anniversary of the death of Marilyn Monroe and 50 years later the attention on both her life and death is still strong. In Marilyn: The Passion & the Paradox, Lois Banner goes beyond the plethora of material already published about this glamorous American icon. While it might be hard to believe that there is anything left unknown, Banner’s research includes numerous newly discovered and previously unused resources. She also goes to more ancillary sources such as c...more
When I was 14 years old, I bought a book about Marilyn, written by a person I had yet to hear of, Gloria Steinem. It was filled with beautiful, yet painful, images of a woman who I was captivated by. The images were taken in the final months of Monroe's life and, ever since then, I have always had an interest in Marilyn -- especially the inner conflicts of a woman who appeared to have it all, yet suffered from deep anxiety, depression, self doubt, gynecological problems and relational issues.
I...more
I...more
Marilyn is the love of my life, and this is the best birthday gift I could have gotten. After reading this book, i feel like i know so much more about her then i had learned from any other biographies on her. I love the research put into this book, and the amount of material it covers. It really does explain her in a way that seems more real. She really just needed some one to love her for who she was. Unlike other Marilyn biographies, I find she is looked at more as a person, rather then a just...more
Author Lois Banner is a women's studies scholar who wades through all the fluffy glamour gossip layers and presents Marilyn Monroe as two people -- Marilyn the character and Marilyn the actor and all her dreams.
A very good read with interesting, albeit repetitive, every day goings ons.
The index leaves a little to be desired. I've been trying to re-discover Marilyn's dream role, which she never had the opportunity to play. I re-read some of the book in the library stacks and she wanted to play G...more
A very good read with interesting, albeit repetitive, every day goings ons.
The index leaves a little to be desired. I've been trying to re-discover Marilyn's dream role, which she never had the opportunity to play. I re-read some of the book in the library stacks and she wanted to play G...more
Way too long....repetitive throughout the book and boring. In fact, in many places, I would say to myself, "hey wait a minute, did I lose my page?" I just read about this incident or person and the author had moved on...only to return to that person/incident to go into more detail. ehh:(
Back in the 1970's, I remember reading a book about Marilyn, and really enjoyed the read. I wish I could remember which book it was...not that I would want to read the same book again.
Sometimes, I feel as though...more
Back in the 1970's, I remember reading a book about Marilyn, and really enjoyed the read. I wish I could remember which book it was...not that I would want to read the same book again.
Sometimes, I feel as though...more
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
If there were a way for me to give this book negative stars, I would do so. And do so quite happily. This book is vulgar and exploitative. It is speculative, sensationalist, and salacious. It is not an academic let alone a feminist look at Monroe's life. An offensive read from cover to cover. For more:
http://satiasreviews.blogspot.com/201...
Never fear. This book will be put to good use. Normally I give books to friends, family, or the local library. This one will be used for starting fires in ou...more
http://satiasreviews.blogspot.com/201...
Never fear. This book will be put to good use. Normally I give books to friends, family, or the local library. This one will be used for starting fires in ou...more
Even if you have Marilyn Monroe fatigue, you should read Lois Banner's book. She had access to new primary sources--much of it in a filing cabinet that only recently became accessible to biographers. Banner generously mentions that she drew on my research, especially concerning Monroe's study of acting. You will also learn a good deal about the impact of Christian Science on the young Marilyn Monroe. In many ways, this was a woman ahead of her time even as most people thought of her as simply an...more
I have read many books on Marilyn Monroe throughout the years and I do not claim to be a MM expert but would say I have retained quite a bit of information on the subject of Marilyn. I do not always believe everything I've read, especially the many "conspiracy theories" of her death and the differing timelines of her last days but I must say that of ALL the books I have consumed on the subject of Monroe, I found MARILYN:THE PASSION AND THE PARADOX to be the most informative and appears to have b...more
Mandy's Review:
Like many people, I have an interest in Marilyn Monroe. Lois Banner's version of Marilyn Monroe's biography has gone into more depth than any other Marilyn biography that I'm aware of. She has taken the time to join the Los Angeles Marilyn fan club where members shared their collections. She then interviewed Marilyn friends and associates. Researching American and European archives, she was allowed access to never-before-seen collections. She bought many Marilyn items on eBay and...more
Like many people, I have an interest in Marilyn Monroe. Lois Banner's version of Marilyn Monroe's biography has gone into more depth than any other Marilyn biography that I'm aware of. She has taken the time to join the Los Angeles Marilyn fan club where members shared their collections. She then interviewed Marilyn friends and associates. Researching American and European archives, she was allowed access to never-before-seen collections. She bought many Marilyn items on eBay and...more
Excellent ideas but very poorly edited book that repeats information and is rife with misspellings, which unfortunately detracts from the strength of the research work. Banner is a fan with a strong academic background who clearly cares passionately about her subject, so it's especially disappointing that this book is so slipshod at times. There is serious scholarship here that almost gets lost in the mix. I wanted this book to be better than it was and am confident that with proper editing it w...more
Written by a feminist, this book was an interesting account of Marilyn's life. Some of the writing was a little, I don't know, familiar? Like the author would refer to a place she lived, like Hawthorne, and she wrote that it was described as a slum but " I lived there and I know it wasn't like that." I don't know, to me that seemed odd. It was very heavily annotated and I would love to see some of the primary sources used to research this book, like the things Marilyn wrote.
Maybe I have read too much about the subject here, but I really did not learn much from this bio. The author claims to have found new sources and there are a few, but mostly she trashes the work of other Marilyn biographers (except Anthony Summers) and spends way too much time tooting her own horn about being so right when others were so wrong. For a first-time Marilyn reader this might be very good, and maybe I expected too much. I did like the emphasis on Monroe's intelligence, which has been...more
Lois Banner suggests that the sexual abuse and the disrupted home life left a legacy of insomnia, nightmares, troubled sexuality and violent mood swings that affected Marilyn Monroe throughout her life.
"I knew how third rate I was. I could actually feel my lack of talent, as if it were cheap clothes I was wearing inside. But, my God, how I wanted to learn, to change, to improve." Marilyn Monroe
"I knew how third rate I was. I could actually feel my lack of talent, as if it were cheap clothes I was wearing inside. But, my God, how I wanted to learn, to change, to improve." Marilyn Monroe
I'm about halfway through this and I nearly gasped when Marilyn quoted one of my favorite lines from Khayyam about the need for personal independence in relationships.
I also got a bit of a jolt when she cited Abraham Lincoln, saying, "Calling a tail a leg doesn't make it a leg." I once had someone tell me that "just because someone says you have a tail, doesn't mean you have a tail." This book is giving me goosebumps.
I also got a bit of a jolt when she cited Abraham Lincoln, saying, "Calling a tail a leg doesn't make it a leg." I once had someone tell me that "just because someone says you have a tail, doesn't mean you have a tail." This book is giving me goosebumps.
Not sure if I should have picked this one as my initial dive into Marilyn studies. I can't tell if her entire life was in fact defined by endometriosis or if the author is just being a feminist scholar about it. And Banner is super excited about proving how extremely bisexual she was. There's also lots of repetition and some more tenuous conclusions are drawn. On the other hand, it's nice to read about her outside of the male gaze/patriarchal lens. So, I give it a solid meh and will maybe try th...more
This is a perfect biography on the blonde icon. I did not want to put it down! If there is one Marilyn memoir that should be read it is this one. It is told realistically and without bias and touches on all subjects Marilyn, from her rocky beginings to her glamourous rise and her sudden fall. This book was sheer perfection.
I read as much of this as I felt like, and I enjoyed the photos. Banner is a wonderful historian, but even she couldn't get me all that interested in Monroe. I've never understood the mystique surrounding her, and I've never cared much for celebrity bios. Plus I didn't like how Banner used "I" in the narrative. Instead of making the story feel more intimate, I found it alienating.
There are no discussion topics on this book yet.
Be the first to start one »

Loading...





view all 5 comments




















