Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “Breathing Room” as Want to Read:
Breathing Room
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating
Open Preview

Breathing Room

4.06 of 5 stars 4.06  ·  rating details  ·  786 ratings  ·  179 reviews

Evvy Hoffmeister is thirteen years old when her family brings her to Loon Lake Sanatorium to get cured of tuberculosis (TB). Evvy is frightened by her new surroundings; the rules to abide are harsh and the nurses equally rigid. But Evvy soon falls into step with the other girls in her ward. There’s Sarah, quiet but thoughtful; Pearl, who adores Hollywood glamour; and De

Hardcover, 256 pages
Published June 5th 2012 by Henry Holt and Co. (BYR)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.
Wonder by R.J. PalacioThe One and Only Ivan by Katherine ApplegateThe Fault in Our Stars by John GreenLiar & Spy by Rebecca SteadThe Lions of Little Rock by Kristin Levine
Newbery 2013
52nd out of 118 books — 1,167 voters
The Book Thief by Markus ZusakA Great and Terrible Beauty by Libba BrayNumber the Stars by Lois LowryThe Luxe by Anna GodbersenThe Witch of Blackbird Pond by Elizabeth George Speare
Teen Historical Fiction
251st out of 862 books — 2,230 voters

More lists with this book...

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 1,711)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Rachael Stein
Book buzz is a capricious thing. A book gets a starred review or two, a word from the right blogger, and suddenly it's the It Girl of Publishing Year 2013. Last year it was Okay for Now. This year it's Wonder. Sometimes they show up in the Newbery pantheon (oh lovely When You Reach Me), but sometimes the committee looks further afield (Moon Over what?). If this year's committee has been casting about for neglected titles (as well they should be), Breathing Room may be up for discussion.

Sam gave
Breathing Room by Marsha Hayles

Evvy Hoffmeister is a 13 year old girl who is put into Loon Lake Sanitarium in Loon Lake, Minnesota during the beginning of WWII to be treated for Tuberculosis. At first Evvy is afraid of her new, unknown surroundings, but as time wears on, she becomes close friends with her roommates. The 4 girls she becomes very close with are: Dena, a strong harsh young lady who is really quite kind; Pearl, who Wishes to one day escape this sanitarium and become a Movie star; Be
I picked this one to read because the setting sounded interesting: the story takes place in a sanatorium in the early 1940's. 13-year-old Evvy Hoffmeister has to go live there to recover from tuberculosis, and the story focuses on her feelings as she deals with being away from her family and as she makes friends with the other girls in her room. Evvy has a way with words (she loves poetry and later on discovers that she wants to be a writer in some capacity), and there are some really beautiful ...more
4.7 stars
Loved this book! It was so interesting! It's 1940, 13-year-old Evvy lives in Minnesota, and has tuberculosis. She spends time in Loon Lake TB Sanatorium in order to recover.
Sometimes people lived for years and years in the sanatoriums, and so many patients died. Evvy experiences the typical TB care of the time which included lots of rest, lots of food, and strict medical care.
She develops relationships with the other girls in her room, and not everyone has a happy ending.
Be sure and re
Jessica Haight
Eveleyn’s father drops her off at Loon Lake in May of 1940. Although she is thirteen, she is scared to be left at a sanitarium by herself. What is worse is that she is only allowed to bring a few items with her, and her stuffed animal gets taken away from her because it could contain germs. Evvy has tuberculosis and in order for her to get better she must be separated from her family and follow the rules. Because she has tuberculosis breathing isn’t easy. Being alone is hard too, and Evvy has tr ...more
Ellise Moore
Beautiful, moving, realistic. Breathing Room was perfect in pace, voice, and meaning. Hayles' demonstrates incredible skill for a first-time novelist in crafting her story to get a deeper meaning across. She used the word's of William Ernest Henley's Invictus to state that despite any higher forces, man is the captain of his fate: "It matters not how strait the gate / How charged with punishments the scroll / I am the master of my fate: / I am the captain of my soul.". This message was beautiful ...more
Fascinating account of a young girl in 1940 rural America with tuberculosis, who goes to a sanatorium designed to help TB patients. Thank heaven we have passed the day when it was considered part of the treatment of patients to be harsh with them! (Thanks, Patch Adams, NOT part of this story, for your help in that direction!) Part of this story is how kindness went a long way with these already depressed patients, kindness from a nurse, a doctor, roommates, friends...and even how cruelty can act ...more
"Unfortunately, Doctor," Nurse Marshall said with an inpatient firmness, "her nature is as stubborn as her disease."

4.5 stars

Loved this book and getting to know Evvy and the others. Hit all the feels from joy to sorrow to gleeful to heartbreaking.
Evvy is 13 and has TB. She is also known as patient 22781. In Minnesota 1940 if you have TB you get sent to Loon Lake Sanatorium, a hospital for TB patients. Evvy is in a room with a few other girls. There they must be silent and rest. Their bodies will either learn to fight the TB or they will die. Most will die. Evvy misses her twin brother and her parents. She wants to get better but she also wants to enjoy life. Looking around her breathing room she wonders who will go home and who will neve ...more
I thought this a fantastic book and immediately wanted to know if the author had written other books. I listed it as a four star only because I really cannot be called a young adult. But I found it so interesting. It comes in the voice of a child, and explores a time in history not remembered in society. The author covers all aspects and although the novel is fiction, it reads as non-fiction. As a side note--my daughter is learning all about metaphors and onomonopias, and I thought we could go t ...more
This was such a good book! Part of the reason I liked it so much is probably because I'm an RT...But even without that, it was still good. I even learned some new things about TB! Like...I had no idea they used to give TB patients pneumos on purpose, to rest their lungs. Weird. The book was a little slow, but it wouldn't have fit the story if it wasn't. It was a short, easy read, so that made up for the slowness. I also really enjoyed all the old pics. There was a few a tear jerker moments, but ...more
What an expertly-crafted novel. I really appreciate the way Hayles included so many historical photographs, with a lot of research at the end, in an effort to depict what life could have been like in a sanatorium. The misconceptions and eventual successful treatment of TB are explained well.

I can't imagine spending four years at a sanatorium, as Dena did, or going so long without seeing my family.I liked the way the characters were revealed, and how some of them were not what they seemed at firs
Excellent book. Easy reading but interesting to me as an adult. Well researched historical fiction describing life in a tuberculosis sanitarium in 1940 from the viewpoint of Evvy, an adolescent girl who is there to be cured.

Evvy, age 13, is put on a ward with 3 other girls roughly her age and gradually learns to accept the rigors of her cure. Treatment consists of absolute bed rest, fresh air, good food, and no talking. Death is always near and the girls handle it in their own ways. Gradually t
Ms. Yingling
In 1940, Evvy is sent to the Loon Lake Sanitorium to try to be cured of her tuberculosis. The standard treatments of extreme rest (no talking, no coughing, certainly no getting up out of bed for a long time!) are covered, but Evvy does manage to make some friends with the other girls in her ward. There is some buzz about WWII and popular culture at the time, and some people get better and some don't. For a nonfiction title to go with this, try Invincible Microbe. Queenie is another book about th ...more
Jess Myname
This was a great book even though I think it would be an easy read for ages eight and up depending on their reading levels it was still interesting for someone of my age. The story as well told the descriptions are thoughtful and carefully planned. I loved the back of the book where it talked about The research that the author did. I enjoyed the images that were pulled from that time. They added an extra element to the authentic feel of this book. I'm interested in reading some of the books that ...more
Jessica Payne
While this is a book aimed at a reader that is younger, (I would say middle grade or early YA), it was still very appealing. The novel, which is historical fiction, is set in the 1940's and centers around a young girl's experience in a sanatorium to treat her Tuberculosis. There is a cast of interesting characters, a historically accurate setting, and a compelling voice. The book also deals with some fairly sophisticated issues of prejudice and antisemitism, illness and death.

The story was ende
Janet Rundquist
I really enjoyed this story about something I knew little about before - sanitariums and tuberculosis during the 1940s. The experience that Hayles draws for Evvy's year of recovery from this not fully understood disease is bittersweet. Short chapters in a somewhat vignette-style offer a touching glimpse into isolation and friendships formed in the face of illness and death.
Interesting to me, because while I knew a little about TB and its treatment, I didn't know as much as I learned from this book! My biggest glimpse was Cecily from "Avonlea." I liked seeing the different characters and how they coped. There wasn't great depth or development in the characters necessarily, but still a lot of good stuff to be had from the book. I especially loved the information the author included at the end. (I had no idea about poet Henley and author Stevenson! PLUS--I LOVE "Invi ...more
Tuberculosis, formerly known as consumption, has long fascinated me, primarily because of how pervasive and impacting it was during the 19th and early 20th centuries. This story follows a young girl as she lives in a sanitorium, having contracted the disease. The characters are charming and telling. The disease and some people's apathy towards it or fear of it shines through, becoming another type of character in the novel.

Hayles obviously devoted a great deal of time and energy to researching
Wow. I picked this book up a number of times but never quite brought myself to read it ... until now. So glad I did. Evvy is a young teen suffering from TB who is sent away to live at a sanatorium in Minnesota until her illness either takes her or clears up. I was impressed by the real-feel Marsha Hayles gave the book, in particular the back pages about TB, her research, and the illustration plates. Not only did I learn something while reading this piece of fiction, but I was moved to tears, so ...more
Breathing Room is the story of Evvy Hoffmeister, a 13-year-old girl who is placed at the Loon Lake Sanitorium for tuberculosis in 1940 in Minnesota. The author grew up in Rochester, MN and her father was a pediatrician at the world-renowned Mayo Clinic there. Her feel for the area and the topic are evident in the genuineness of Evvy's voice.

With short quick chapters Evvy guides us through her time at Loon Lake from fear and loneliness to friendship, love, loss and healing. Because the novel take
Found this in the YA section whilst pulling books from the picklist. My first reaction "hey, cool, a book about TB sanatoriums in YA. I must read!" So I read it and it was OK. I've read much better books about the sanatorium experience. Betty MacDonald's The Plague and I, for example.

Not The Magic Mountain, though. Euch. After about 400 pages of Magic Mountain and you start to think Naphtha had the right idea in his method of getting the hell out of that story.

"Breathing Room" was rather dull,
In some ways, this book about girls with tuberculosis living in a sanatorium is sort of an odd twist on the traditional boarding school or camp story. Girls from different backgrounds are thrown together and must learn to get along; everyone has a story and isn't always who they appear to be on the surface. There are even the requisite sneaking-out scenes and a midnight-feast scene. But this is a quiet book ... literally, because the main characters are barely allowed to speak. And it is heartb ...more
Set in 1940, it's about a girl named Evelyn Hoffmeister, (Evvy) 13 years old, and she has tuberculosis. Which means she has to leave her family to go to a hospital specializing in tuberculosis. Evvy is not used to her surroundings, but she quickly learns. She has a lot of roommates, all having tuberculosis, and grumpy maids to always come to take care of them.
It's a very good read, maybe a 4th-6th grade reading level. It's good because you can see and visualize the struggles that Evvy has, and
Amazing! I would recommend this to anyone!
Mirele Kessous
OK- I enjoyed this book. I did. It is historically authentic, the heroine has a real voice, and the writing has a quiet beauty. That said, I'm concerned that today's 12 and 13-year-old readers would not relate to Evvy. Evvy is living in a time when childhood extended much longer than it does today. She speaks of carrying a teddy bear, for instance, and she is supposed to be 13. I don't think my students would appreciate or relate to her childishness.
I'm not sure that the morbid content is suited
Evvy has tuberculosis and is sent to the Loon Lake Sanatorium to recover. She is put into a room with other girls her age: Dena, Bethany, Pearl and Sarah. Together they struggle with their disease and the ever present fear that death is just around the corner.

All I have to say about this book is Wow! I loved it. It was such a powerful look and how these girls struggled every day with the certainty that death could take them. There was death around them always. And the author was not afraid to b
Narrated by 13 year old Evvy Hoffmeister, this story tells about her year at the Loon Lake Sanatorium in 1940. Her family sent her there to get cured of tuberculosis (TB). Never having been away from home before and separated from her twin brother, Abe, Evvy is sad, lonely, and frightened. She is put into a room with three other girls her age and quickly makes friends. There are many rules the patients need to follow in order to get rest and get better; no visitors, no mail, no walking, no going ...more
This was a wonderful read! I almost read the whole book in one sitting but a pesky little thing called sleep won out.

Breathing Room takes place in 1940 at a sanitarium for tuberculosis patients. 13 year old Evvy has to leave everyone and everything she knows in order to get well. At Loon Lake Sanitorium in Minnesota, she is housed with other girls her age in a ward where the biggest rule is to rest. This means no talking, walking, or even going to the bathroom. (Can you say metal bedpans?) Stoic
I can't believe I'm the first to have read this book on GoodReads! What a great book--a well crafted story based on such a scary time period for those who suffered with TB. I was totally engrossed and developed a bond with the characters. Tear jerker for sure, as many do not survive TB. Story is about girls living in a sanatorium, in order to heal and to prevent exposure to others as TB was a highly contagious disease in 1940. The boredom that was their daily existence as REST was one of
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 57 58 next »
topics  posts  views  last activity   
Dent Book Challen...: Breathing Room by Marsha Hayles 1 1 Apr 15, 2015 12:07PM  
  • A Thunderous Whisper
  • A Diamond in the Desert
  • Duke
  • Crow
  • The Unfortunate Son
  • Shadow on the Mountain
  • Sylvia & Aki
  • Bill the Boy Wonder: The Secret Co-Creator of Batman
  • Twelve Kinds of Ice
  •  Beholding Bee
  • P.S. Be Eleven (Gaither Sisters, #2)
  • The Great Trouble: A Mystery of London, the Blue Death, and a Boy Called Eel
  • Child of the Mountains
  • Fourmile
  • Every Day After
  • Invincible Microbe: Tuberculosis and the Never-Ending Search for a Cure
  • Chuck Close: Face Book
  • Sophia's War: A Tale of the Revolution
Marsha Hayles is the author of many picture books and now a novel for young people. Her picture books frequently make use of rhyme and playful language, and range in topic from celebrating a day at the beach to suffering sore feet. Her novel Breathing Room is about girls suffering from tuberculosis at a sanatorium in 1940 and reflects her life-long interest in medicine, inspired, in part, by her c ...more
More about Marsha Hayles...
Bunion Burt Pajamas Anytime He Saves the Day Beach Play The Feathered Crown

Share This Book

No trivia or quizzes yet. Add some now »