Shadows Before the Sun (Charlie Madigan #4)

Aug 15, 2012 TheArgopelter rated it 5 of 5 stars · review of another edition Recommends it for: everyone who love urban fantasy and great writing!

Shelves: amazing-female-character, heartbreaking, original-concept, romping-good-fun, sexual-chemistry, urban-fantasy, wonderful-story, kick-ass-chicks, dark-and-gritty, kelly-gay

Shadows Before the Sun proves that Kelly Gay’s talent as a writer is neither a fluke nor to be taken lightly. Gay is a master story teller and this chapter in the Charlie Madigan series, Shadows Before the Sun, delivered on all that was promised at the end of The Hour of Dust and Ashes – a violent, heartbreaking, intense ride crowned by beautiful resolution and a screaming need for MORE!!!

Shadows Before the Sun’s feel is grander that the prior books as we follow Charlie Madigan to Elysia as she...more Shadows Before the Sun proves that Kelly Gay’s talent as a writer is neither a fluke nor to be taken lightly. Gay is a master story teller and this chapter in the Charlie Madigan series, Shadows Before the Sun, delivered on all that was promised at the end of The Hour of Dust and Ashes – a violent, heartbreaking, intense ride crowned by beautiful resolution and a screaming need for MORE!!!

Shadows Before the Sun’s feel is grander that the prior books as we follow Charlie Madigan to Elysia as she attempts to rescue her partner Hank Williams, after his kidnaping and return to the siren city of Fiallan for the murder of their king. Joined by the ancient oracle Alessandra, Charlie makes deals, forges alliance and unlikely friendships, suffers and embraces her fractured nature as she attempts to save Hank from a fate worse than death. Charlie, Hank and Alessandra’s experiences in Fiallan change them in ways that are unexpected and leave room for some pretty cool possibilities for future books.

Having waited almost a year for this puppy I read the whole thing in one sitting, completely absorbed by the tapestry of Greek myth, rich imagination, complex characterisation, and a rip-roaring plot. If the other books in the Madigan universe have a strong theme around family and growing up, Shadows Before the Sun radiates love, loyalty and sacrifice - so strap on your big girl panties, because there are some scenes that will break your heart. Script writer God and Big Daddy of Urban Fantasy Joss Whedon once spoke about how writers have to make real sacrifices with loved characters for a story to truly resonate – well, Kelly Gay takes this concept and runs with it. Shadows Before the Sun has a body count which shocked (and delighted) me with its brutality. There are no kid-gloves here. Gay re-forms her characters through a baptism of violence, death and pain.

I adored this book, I just didn’t want it to end so soon. Kelly Gay officially rocks the urban fantasy genre – the Charlie Madigan books are fresh, well written, beautifully characterised and the plots kick-ass

If you love urban fantasy, first class writing and kick-ass chicks you MUST read these books. Further, because I have no shame when it comes to a good read I’m begging Kelly Gay and her publishers Simon and Schuster for lots more in this series. There aren’t nearly enough original, well written UF books out there that the Madigan universe can end anytime soon.

I’m giving it 5 out of 5.

(NOTE: review amended 02.08.12 to remove gripes - Author has advised on her Facebook page that the Charlie Madigan series will be continuing... Which removes reasons for aforementioned gripes. Yay!)
(less)

4 likes · like · see review

Jan 28, 2013 Veronica G. rated it 4 of 5 stars · review of another edition

Shelves: other-things-that-go-bump-in-the-ni, urban-fantasy, female-protagonist, fantasy, favorites

Book four continues to cement my enjoyment of this series. I had a concern in the first book that Charlie maybe came into too much power too soon and I think that has largely played out BUT it doesn't really bother me here whereas in another series it might. The main reason is because of Charlie herself. She doesn't take her powers for granted and she never just assumes that she's going to win, or hell, even to survive.

Book three took us to the world of Charbydon and in this installment we head...more Book four continues to cement my enjoyment of this series. I had a concern in the first book that Charlie maybe came into too much power too soon and I think that has largely played out BUT it doesn't really bother me here whereas in another series it might. The main reason is because of Charlie herself. She doesn't take her powers for granted and she never just assumes that she's going to win, or hell, even to survive.

Book three took us to the world of Charbydon and in this installment we head to Elysia with Charlie as she sets to rescue Hank. This translated into not as much page time for some of the other secondary characters that I've come to love *cough*Rex*cough, but in exchange we get to meet some new characters and that proved to be worth the trip. We meet Alessandra, Atlanta's 2000 year old Oracle who was briefly mentioned way back on page one of book one, and we also meet Leander. I'm not sure who or what he is yet but I'm certain we haven't seen the last of him.

We learn more about Hank, his past, and his present and it's truly heartbreaking. While this series has always been told in Charlie's first person POV, this book deviates just a bit by giving us Hank's thoughts in third person every once in awhile. I'm not sure there would have been any other way to adequately understand what he endures in this book otherwise so I think the author made a good decision in taking this route.

I hear from the author that a decision has yet to made about any future books. I'll be very sad if there are no more books to come but I will say that this book, while leaving some avenues open for future storylines, did at least wrap up one major story arc from book one. Additionally, every character ends in such a place that I can easily see a positive outcome for them in the future. In the meantime, while I wait for news on the fifth book I'll be sure to read Carniepunk. Kelly Gay has included a short story involving Rex (yay!), Emma, and Brimstone (the family hellhound) on an adventure that takes place during the events of this book while Charlie is away saving Hank. So, while I will keep hope alive that this won't be the end of the series, I'm grateful that the characters ended on an upbeat note and I'm glad for having had the chance to meet them.(less)

1 like · like · see review

Aug 06, 2012 Ami rated it 5 of 5 stars · review of another edition

Shelves: urban-fantasy-paranormal-futuristic, 5-stars_rating

After her partner, Hank, is taken into The Siren City of Fiallan to receive punishment for being a traitor, Charlie is determined to go there and save him, with the help of Sandra, the Oracle. No matter the cost. But Hank is not just being held, he is being tortured by the three Circes (Arethusa, Calliadne, and Ephyra) under the spell of NecroNaMoria -- which tethers a soul to a body that has died and forces Hank's soul from going to the Afterlife and returns for sessions of torture. On top of t...more After her partner, Hank, is taken into The Siren City of Fiallan to receive punishment for being a traitor, Charlie is determined to go there and save him, with the help of Sandra, the Oracle. No matter the cost. But Hank is not just being held, he is being tortured by the three Circes (Arethusa, Calliadne, and Ephyra) under the spell of NecroNaMoria -- which tethers a soul to a body that has died and forces Hank's soul from going to the Afterlife and returns for sessions of torture. On top of that, Charlie's power that combines those from Elysian and Charbydon has attracted Sachâth, an assassin for First Ones, also known as Death. Can Charlie saves Hank and destroys Sachâth forever?

----------

In what might-or-might-not-be the final installment of the series, it is simply THE BEST and MY FAVORITE book of this series.

The story pulls me in straight from the beginning, when for the FIRST TIME, we get chapters written from Hank's point of view (using 3rd person). The story opens with him being tortured beyond belief, and it breaks my heart completely, and I want Charlie to save him quick, guns blazing. Though unfortunately, that doesn't happen until around 2/3rd of getting into the story (hugs Hank tight).

However, that gives a lot of other fantastic storytelling ... I learn more about the myth of First Ones, their Disciples, as well as the origin of Sachâth. And I still get to read Charlie kicks some Circe's asses, with her combined power that makes her, simply, one of divine beings.

Hank isn't simply a prince in distress, though ... once Charlie is able to break his chain, he makes his own havoc, with an amazing show of power never seen before in previous three books. Then the lovely reunion *sigh*. If I have any doubt about my wanting Hank for Charlie, well, this book erases it all.

The secondary characters also shine ... most notably, Charlie's daughter Emma (who gives Charlie the solution to defeat Sachâth), the ex-revenant/Jinn, Rex (who amuses me to no end with his antics, he's definitely Charlie's best friend, even with Will's body), as well as the Oracle, Sandra ((view spoiler)).

Most of the action happens in Fiallan, and only the last 1/3 part or so, Charlie and Hank brings their fight against Sachâth in Atlanta. That's my only complain, I think, that the fight against Sachâth ends a little to soon. I guess I just don't want to say goodbye for these characters just yet.

It's electrifying, captivating, mesmerizing, with such a perfect happy ending. I don't know if this is the final book, but if it is so I hope Kelly Gay will come up with new fantastic series soon ...

PS: I totally don't recognize Chris McGrath's 'signature' on this cover!! I thought it was done by someone else. I guess book #3 is my favorite cover from the series.(less)

3 likes · like · see review

Apr 16, 2013 Kathy Davie rated it 4 of 5 stars

Shelves: urban-fantasy

Fourth in the Charlie Madigan urban fantasy series revolving around a detective who is no longer human. Most of the action takes place in Fiallan, the city of the sirens.

My Take
Oh, wow. This was so intense with some incredibly, godawful torture. Oh. I just can't… How people can be that power-hungry, I'll never know. So awful that I almost got too caught up in these events, but then towards the end, all the new possibilities popped into view. There's Leander with the "promise" of what he fears. W...more

like · see review

Apr 29, 2013 Lise rated it 4 of 5 stars · review of another edition

"Shadows Before the Sun" is the 4th installment of the Charlie Madigan series. Whether it is the final one remains to be seen but it did represent an ending to me.

Charlie needs to go to Elysia to find Hank. She did promise him that at the end of The Hour of Dust and Ashes. Their friendship is too important to leave anything to chance and the words of ambassadors. Right now Hank needs a friend who is willing to break the rules to get to him. Charlie and Allessandra, the Oracle, end up as travelli...more

like · see review

Dec 31, 2012 drey rated it 4 of 5 stars · review of another edition

Shelves: 2012-reads, urban-fantasy

Wow. Charlie sure has her hands full in this fourth installment of Kelly Gay’s fab urban fantasy series! At the conclusion of The Hour of Dust and Ashes, Hank’s apprehended and taken back to Fiallan for the crime of leaving the Circe’s towers. Now in Shadows Before the Sun, Charlie’s told that Hank was executed…

She doesn’t believe it. So she does the only thing she can – take a trip to Fiallan to find Hank. Armed with her magic sword and trademark sass, Charlie’s surprised when the Oracle hersel...more

like · see review

Sep 14, 2012 Kathy rated it 5 of 5 stars · review of another edition

Best One Yet!

I strongly suggest you read the previous books in the series (The Better Part of Darkness, The Darkest Edge of Dawn and The Hour of Dust & Ashes) prior to reading this installment.

This is one of the best dark urban fantasy series I've ever read! This series is on my top five favorite series of all time.

This was by far the best installment to date and I love the direction the series is taking. You gotta love a woman who can rescue her man, kick some major ass and still care for h...more

1 like · like · see review

Aug 16, 2012 Alexia Chantel rated it 5 of 5 stars · review of another edition

Gay has done it, with Shadows Before the Sun she manages to surpass the the action and emotional connection the previous books had. Who would have thought it was possible!

The end of book three leaves you hanging just a little. Death is stalking Charlie, her sister is safe but still addicted to ash, and Hank has been taken back to his home to face the wrath of three powerful beings. You can breathe a sigh of relief, well not once you start since there are plenty of bombs dropped on Charlie right...more

2 likes · like · see review

Aug 10, 2012 Melissa rated it 5 of 5 stars

Leaving this world after The Hour of Dust and Ashes I was totally bereft. I needed to know what happened right after. I needed this book!

OMG. Can I say it again? OMG! This book was everything I waited for and more. Yes, my favorite UF mother is back (I mean that literally... her daughter is so adorable and smart). My fave characters were back as well. Oh and the conclusion to what happened at the end of The Hour of Dust and Ashes totally fulfilled me (don't worry, I'm not going to spoil anythin...more

1 like · like · see review

Nov 01, 2012 Van rated it 5 of 5 stars · review of another edition

Shadows before the Sun is the fourth installment in the Charlie Madigan series by Kelly Gay. The book starts out with a murder in the Druid King’s territory, one of his enforcer was apparently murdered by a Jinn, or so he thinks. Charlie combs the crime scene but eventually passes it over to another detective, as she prepares to leave to Elysia to retrieve her partner Hank. Hank was taken back to Elysia as a traitor to the government for escaping (the grid) when he was younger. The day before Ch...more Shadows before the Sun is the fourth installment in the Charlie Madigan series by Kelly Gay. The book starts out with a murder in the Druid King’s territory, one of his enforcer was apparently murdered by a Jinn, or so he thinks. Charlie combs the crime scene but eventually passes it over to another detective, as she prepares to leave to Elysia to retrieve her partner Hank. Hank was taken back to Elysia as a traitor to the government for escaping (the grid) when he was younger. The day before Charlie is to leave to Elysia, she gets word that Hank been executed. Charlie doesn’t believe it for a second and sets out to find the truth and bring Hank home.

You guys know that feeling when you been on a trip for days and right when you get home you’re fill with joy, so relax and comfortable being back in your own house? That’s what it feels like jumping back into the Charlie Madigan series. Even though it’s been a year or more since I read the last book in the series, once I open the book and immerse myself in the world and characters that Mrs. Gay created…it felt so good like I never left. I postponed reading the book right when it came out because I heard many of the original characters didn’t have much page time as previous books. Although, I was bummed about not seeing more of Hank, Rex, Emma, Brimstone, and Pen, readers got to know more about Sandra the Oracle. The majority of the book involved the Oracle tagging along with Charlie on her mission to save Hank, saying that her fate is intertwined with the two of them. I really enjoy the budding friendship between Sandra and Charlie.

The book is told from Charlie’s point-of-view, but there were occasionally snippets of Hank’s third person point-of-view scattered throughout the book. I thought this was interesting, but I prefer only one pov. This was an awesome addition to the series, and each book just gets better and better. This book had me laughing and crying from start to finish. This is one of my favorite UF series around, with one of the best world-building and characters ever written. I always look forward to a Charlie Madigan book, and hope that there will be more to come. This was truly an AMAZING-emotional novel; I can’t wait to see where Mrs. Gay will take Charlie and the gang in the next book.

I highly recommend everyone to pick up this series, you won’t regret it. If you enjoy the Elemental Assassin series by Jennifer Estep, Kate Daniel series by Ilona Andrews, Horngate Witches series by Diana P. Francis, or the October Daye series by Seanan McGuire…then you’ll definitely enjoy this series! (less)

1 like · like · see review

Aug 30, 2012 Brenda rated it 5 of 5 stars · review of another edition

Shadows Before the Sun is the fourth book in the Charlie Madigan series and I must say it's the best one yet. Charlie has been through some tough times in this series, but she keeps going because of her daughter, and the other people she loves. In the first three books she's fought her feelings for her partner Hank for many reasons. We were left hanging at the end of the third book due to his arrest by officials from his home world. Will they act on their feelings? Will Charlie be able to bring...more

1 like · like · see review

Aug 13, 2012 Madame X rated it 3 of 5 stars · review of another edition

Shelves: heroine-can-kick-ass, heroine-to-hang-out-with, paranormal-urban-fantasy, romance-spans-multiple-books, superior-worldbuilding

I'm really only medium-invested in the Charlie Madigan series. I like it. I'll keep reading when the new one comes out next year, for sure. But, as much as anything else, Shadows Before the Sun reminded me why Kelly Gay hasn't broken through into my top tier of favorite authors.

The first half/two-thirds or so of the book follows Charlie on her mission to rescue Hank. Hank has been captured by the other sirens and dragged back to Elysia to face punishment for having escaped the Malakim towers. Wo...more I'm really only medium-invested in the Charlie Madigan series. I like it. I'll keep reading when the new one comes out next year, for sure. But, as much as anything else, Shadows Before the Sun reminded me why Kelly Gay hasn't broken through into my top tier of favorite authors.

The first half/two-thirds or so of the book follows Charlie on her mission to rescue Hank. Hank has been captured by the other sirens and dragged back to Elysia to face punishment for having escaped the Malakim towers. Word filters through to earth that Hank has been executed, but Charlie doesn't believe it - she has to go see for herself.

We get occasional snippets from Hank's point of view, so we know he's alive and suffering terrible torture. This adds a lot of urgency to Charlie's mission, though she can't feel it as keenly as we do. In any case, we get a minute-by-minute, hour-by-hour account of Charlie's inter-dimensional travel, her impressions of Elysia, her exploration of Hank's hometown.

The rescue itself is pretty epic, and a lot of stuff happens. Major, major stuff. I'm going to do my best not to spoil anything, but most of my problems with Shadows Before the Sun have to do with the aftermath of this epic rescue.

After the first two-thirds, which are so focused and tightly plotted, Kelly Gay rushes us through events that could easily take up whole books; characters make decisions that, if properly handled, would mark major turning points in the series. I found myself almost shouting at my Kindle: "Wait...wait...what about all those lives you've just turned upside down? Can I get some closure? And I'm not buying this moment that ought to be touching! Shouldn't we save this for the next book? I can't believe you just threw away that opportunity!"

Because Gay failed to stick the landing, the whole book felt unbalanced and unsatisfying to me. I was pretty irritated when I turned the last page.

(view spoiler)[Beware - these are real spoilers.

So after Charlie rescues Hank, they end up in the sea goddess' underground grotto and have sex. There's no flirting or lead-up; quite the opposite, actually. Hank's sanity is in question, his soul is shredded and battered, and he's recovering from some serious injuries. But instead of a scene that deals with all this baggage he's acquired, Hank pretends to be normal, his usual self, and Charlie lets him. Personally, I was really disappointed to have waited so long for a consummation based on dishonesty and pretense. It felt so wrong to me.

Then, a whole slew of important things happen that barely merit a paragraph or two in the text: Hank gets some nifty new powers, he turns down the crown of his hometown, we have no idea what actually happens in his hometown after the entire government collapses, how the people or ruling elite react to the discovery of the Circe's wrongdoings.

Having spent a good 30% of the novel getting to know this city, these people, I wanted closure! Instead, Charlie and Hank just zoom on home, no passing GO!, no collecting $200.

There's also the subject of Alessandra. A lot of the latter part of the book hinges on the belief that Sandra and Charlie have bonded while traveling through Elysia together. But I didn't see it. Did I see the potential for a friendship? Sure. But it was so tenuous and new, nothing like the bond that the book tried to convince me had formed.

I continued to be annoyed by the fact that Hank kept acting totally normal while assuring everyone that he was, in fact, totally broken. If he's so broken, I need to see at least a crack in the armor - but I didn't. He and Charlie fall back on their old routine, no changes, and that was another let down.

And then - and then! - during the big final battle at the end, Hank is seriously wounded. And I'm sitting there thinking: okay, here it is, the first time Hank has been wounded after that terrible torture. He'll have a breakdown, his reaction will really drive home the deep and lasting effects of his experiences with the Circe.

Nada.

Hank cracks jokes and banters a bit with Charlie. That's it. No deep wounds seeping out to the surface, just same ol' Hank.

This battle, by the way? Another huge epic conflict that, in my opinion, could have been the subject of the entire next book - instead of a rushed coda to this one. I wasn't ready to switch gears and focus on a new villain, and I had no opportunity to savor the victory or what it meant.

In short, the final 25% of this book kinda ruined the first 75%.
(hide spoiler)](less)

5 likes · like · see review

Aug 13, 2012 Bastard rated it 4 of 5 stars · review of another edition

http://bastardbooks.blogspot.com/2012...

When you go to Hell and back, the very least you want as a reward is a piece of Heaven. Charlie just got her wish, and she's quickly finding out it's not all it's cracked up to be. Shadows Before the Sun is the fourth novel in the Charlie Madigan series by Kelly Gay, which has been one of my favorite urban fantasy series in the past few years. Previously we joined Charlie in the world of Charybdon, this time we're taking a trip to Elysia whether she's we...more

2 likes · like · see review

Aug 13, 2012 Michelle rated it 4 of 5 stars · review of another edition

Shadows Before the Sun is the fourth book in the Charlie Madigan series by Kelly Gay and a Pocket Books Urban Fantasy.

Blurb:

Between life and death lies a chasm of pain beyond imagining. . . .
Elysia may be a heavenly off-world destination, but beyond it, in the siren city of Fiallan, the Circe have punished Charlie Madigan’s partner, Hank, into a torturous state between life and death. With all the proper legal channels cleared, Charlie heads to Elysia, not knowing what she’ll find, or if she’ll...more

like · see review

Mar 19, 2013 William Bentrim rated it 5 of 5 stars · review of another edition

Shadows Before The Sun

Charlie Madigan, a female cop, is back kicking butt. This time she is out to save her alien partner Hank from a fate that truly is worth than death. Again Gay provides plenty of action in a good mystery with scifi and urban fantasy co-mingled.

Anyone who reads my reviews know I like butt kicking female protagonists. I have missed several books between this and My Review of The Better Part of Darkness which was the first Kelly Gay book I read.

Gay develops her story but focu...more

like · see review

Sep 09, 2012 Ria rated it 5 of 5 stars · review of another edition

Shelves: aliens, druids, dragons, cops, crime, magic, sci-fi, urban-fantasy

The Hour of Dust and Ashes ended in such a traumatising way, I was very concerned that Shadows Before the Sun would leave me in a sobbing heap in a darkened corner somewhere. Fortunately, five bright shiny stars were on the horizon...

Charlie Madigan's world is just so cleverly realised. Creatures of heaven and hell are grounded in realism and with such rich cultures that each book continues to explore in vivid detail. We spend most of our time with the Sirens in this book and the society is care...more

like · see review

Jan 28, 2013 Cindy rated it 4 of 5 stars

Oh Kelly....WOW! I was floored by the story line this time. Our kickass heroine is on a hunt for the man she loves. Her partner/and would be lover if he hadn't been kidnapped and returned to his home world to be executed for a crime that is falsely purveyed by 3 witch sisters that are so power hungry they enslave a whole town and make them happy to be their unknown slaves. Charlie Madigan has been told by her government that a rescue is not possible because Hank has already been killed. Charlie...more

like · see review

Oct 03, 2012 Karissa rated it 5 of 5 stars · review of another edition

This is the fourth book in the Charlie Madigan series and it was one of the best books in the series yet. We learn a ton about Hank and his history and Charlie takes a trip to Elysia.

When Charlie hears of Hank’s supposed death she immediately makes plans to set out to Elysia to try and track him down. To her surprise she is accompanied by the Oracle. In addition to this she is being hunted by Ahkneri (Death itself) whenever she tries to use her powers. Added to this is a mysterious attack in the...more This is the fourth book in the Charlie Madigan series and it was one of the best books in the series yet. We learn a ton about Hank and his history and Charlie takes a trip to Elysia.

When Charlie hears of Hank’s supposed death she immediately makes plans to set out to Elysia to try and track him down. To her surprise she is accompanied by the Oracle. In addition to this she is being hunted by Ahkneri (Death itself) whenever she tries to use her powers. Added to this is a mysterious attack in the Druid’s Grove that the Lord of Druids wants Charlie to solve and quickly.

Absolutely stunning addition to this series. The majority of the story focuses on Charlie going on a quest to save Hank. Her quest to save Hank uncovers some amazing secrets along the way . She learns how to control her powers and faces off with Death itself. Charlie has grown a lot as a character in this series, she is finally getting her powers under control and learning how to use them. With the disappearance of Hank, Charlie is forced to face some truths about her feelings for him.

The addition of the Oracle, Sandra, to the story is awesome. Sandra is a fun character and adds a lot of dimension to the story. The things that happen between her, Charlie, and Hank in this book leave room for some interesting developments in future books.

As for Hank we learn a ton about him in this book and a lot of it isn’t pretty. There are scenes in here that are so heartbreaking involving Hank and the changes he goes through as the story progresses are hard to deal with. It gives his character even more depth and has me eager to see what will happen next to him.

As with previous books the plot was fast-paced and action-packed. Gay’s writing style is easy to read and very consistent; I really enjoy reading her books. This book has an excellent balance of story, world-development, character growth, and action. Some of the larger plot points that have been left hanging are wrapped up here as well.

Overall I loved this book. I read it pretty much in one day. There are so many great things going on in this series; great world-building, a great plot, wonderful character growth and awesome action scenes. This book has everything you could want in a great urban fantasy. This series just keeps getting better and is highly recommended to fans of urban fantasy.(less)

1 like · like · see review

Sep 10, 2012 Nikki Brandyberry rated it 5 of 5 stars · review of another edition

I am a new lover of this series! Meaning I found it (well, it found me) just after this book was released. I under took the job of reading the first 3 books so I could catch up before I dove into this one. As with every urban fantasy series I’ve ever read, I highly recommend reading these in order and NOT starting with this one. If you start in this one I guarantee you’ll have no idea what is going on and will end up DNFing the book. Trust me.

I can’t say enough wonderful things about this series...more I am a new lover of this series! Meaning I found it (well, it found me) just after this book was released. I under took the job of reading the first 3 books so I could catch up before I dove into this one. As with every urban fantasy series I’ve ever read, I highly recommend reading these in order and NOT starting with this one. If you start in this one I guarantee you’ll have no idea what is going on and will end up DNFing the book. Trust me.

I can’t say enough wonderful things about this series, author, book….seriously, I fell in love. Charlie Madigan is just an awesome female character. She’s fierce, loyal and loving to a fault. She’d do ANYTHING for those she cares about, which is the main theme in this book from the continuing story arc of the last book. Charlie’s partner, Hank, has been taken back to his home planet (the version of heaven in this world) to face treason charges. They have been circling around each other for the past three books and FINALLY Charlie is mostly willing to admit she cares for Hank as more than just a partner. I rejoiced immensely at her realization LOL. Those of you that like a little romance in your urban fantasy will enjoy their evolving relationship throughout the series. Charlies growing powers and the realization that she alone plays the most vital role in saving not only her city in Georgia but also the world is the central theme. She is a hybrid, the only being with all three bloodlines running through her veins. Not even the oldest beings in existence know what she is capable of doing but they are all banking on the idea that she doesn’t know how to wield her new abilities. She’s the wildcard for humanity and she is constantly at odds with herself on whether to embrace the light or dark side of her powers. Her internal struggle focuses a lot on her humanity and how it plays a role in helping her see her path. Had she not had her humanity I don’t think she would stand a chance against the forces. Her love and loyalty ground and center her. I loved the progression of her personality in the series that comes to a head in this book.

The whole host of secondary characters fill out the book nicely. That along with the witty writing and snarky commentary make this a fast paced read. I especially loved Rex in this one. He’s been a character since very early in the series who was a spirit that inhabited the body of Charlie’s ex and father of her daughter. He’s been a constant companion to Charlie and a reminder to her that even though her and her ex had substantial problems, she still loved him and he deserved her forgiveness. I was glad Rex became a fixture to Charlie and her daughter along with the hellhound they adopted. I liked how Gay continued to make his presence integral to the story.

The in depth world building and lore within the series are unrivaled by anything I have read to date. Completely original and thought provoking even touching on religion a bit in an abstract way. I am really hoping that more from the series gets written even though it seems to be all wrapped up nicely at the end of this one. I’d love to learn more about the dragon Fae king…that’s my romance book lover coming out. He’s YUMM-O. All big and mostly naked with tattoos down his entire side….shudder…..He also is commanding and has complete loyalty from his subjects but not a lot of his history was talked about. The author has a wealth of characters she could build on and I have to wonder if she did that for the purpose of possible future books. At this point I will buy anything with her name on it. In a sea of books that I’ve been having a hard time with, Kelly Gay showed me the light! Fantastic writing and phenomenal series!

I give Shadows Before The Sun by Kelly Gay 5 stars! (less)

like · see review

Sep 08, 2012 Mihir rated it 4 of 5 stars · review of another edition

Full Review originally at Fantasy Book Critic

ANALYSIS: For a while I was thinking that Shadows Before The Sun would be the last Charlie Madigan book and after the events of the last book, anticipation was high in regards to how it would all end. The author has been kind enough to point out the egregious nature of our assumptions and this helped a bit.

The premise of this book needs a brief recap of the events of The Hour Of Dust and Ashes, wherein Charlie, Rex and Hank had to go to Charybdon an...more
Full Review originally at Fantasy Book Critic

ANALYSIS: For a while I was thinking that Shadows Before The Sun would be the last Charlie Madigan book and after the events of the last book, anticipation was high in regards to how it would all end. The author has been kind enough to point out the egregious nature of our assumptions and this helped a bit.

The premise of this book needs a brief recap of the events of The Hour Of Dust and Ashes, wherein Charlie, Rex and Hank had to go to Charybdon and figure out a way to save Charlie’s sister life. This trip while being utterly dangerous was doubly difficult due to actions of the jinns. While the book had an explosive climax, a particular event left Charlie and the readers severely troubled. This book deals with Charlie’s efforts to go to Elysia and figure out a way to get someone back. Thus after their hellish ordeal Charlie will have to find her strength and gather her friends and make an attempt to enter Elysia and find out what is going on there. Her first attempt goes wrong thanks to the bureaucratic nature of relations between her world and Elysia however she soon discovers new allies in the form of an oracle and makes the trip to save her friend from his ultimate fate.

Where do I begin with this book, only does it outdo the events and excitement caused by its predecessor, it also sets up some terrific things for the future books. While The Hour Of Dust and Ashes was my favorite book so far, it easily gets displaced by Shadows Before The Sun. Firstly lets talk about the unique nature of this book, for the first time ever we get a POV other than Charlie and it’s a third person narrative from Hank. This move makes this book even more unpredictable and adds in a unique look into the actions occurring in the story. Secondly the action and violence in this book makes all that has come before truly child’s play, this book seriously has some dark corners and the twisted imagination of the author inflicts heavy loads on all characters especially on the major duo.

We get a resolution in Hank & Charlie’s relationship status and that heralds a different direction from the next book and also the reader gets a resolution to the plot arc about what was found beneath the lake a couple of books ago. With so many character and plot arcs being resolved, this book can be said to an end of the first series arc in the Charlie Madigan world. The author plans to write another book with Charlie and Hank and perhaps a one from the Druid King’s perspective. That is something that makes me giddy with anticipation.

Shadows Before The Sun is a cracker of a book and easily the best of the series toppling The Hour Of Dust and Ashes. For all readers shying away from urban fantasy thinking it to be too much like paranormal romance, give Kelly Gay’s dark series a try, you surely will be surprised by the violence and lack of sparkly vampires ensconced within these pages. How can I be so sure, simply because I was a skeptic like you a few years ago before I read the first book!(less)

like · see review

Aug 12, 2012 Rose Wilde-irish rated it 5 of 5 stars · review of another edition

Love this series more and more with each book. Charlie Madigan is a terribly human character, believable and capable of making mistakes. This novel picks up almost directly after the last, which was a relief; the last one ended on a cliffhanger that made a friend of mine go, "Really? She ended it there?!"

The plot was good and moved the story along; we got glimpses of things that, IMO, hint at plots and storylines to come.

I initially picked up The Better Part of Darkness for a reason one should n...more

like · see review

Aug 14, 2012 Michelle Cummings rated it 5 of 5 stars · review of another edition

Shelves: urban-fantasy, favorites

Update to my review:

Apparently this is not the conclusion of the series, but there is no information yet on future releases. My review still stands, but I thought I should clarify!

I loved this conclusion to the Charlie Madigan series, an interesting foray in the urban fantasy world. If you have read the first three you should jump on this right now. I will give one caveat though, if you have been reading the books as they are published, I would highly recommend a re-read. Book 4 continues pretty...more

like · see review

Aug 29, 2012 Teri rated it 5 of 5 stars · review of another edition

Charlie Madigan begins her week optimistic in her abilities of her government and the heads of several groups helping to get her partner Hank released from the custody of his homeland of Fiallan, but as she soon finds out, the net that Fiallan casts upon its people is more deadly and cunning than ever before. Kelly Gay returns to Atlanta and beyond with Shadows Before The Sun, and this series has never been more heartwrenching or hotter than before. With death and destruction all around her Cha...more

Charlie Madigan begins her week optimistic in her abilities of her government and the heads of several groups helping to get her partner Hank released from the custody of his homeland of Fiallan, but as she soon finds out, the net that Fiallan casts upon its people is more deadly and cunning than ever before. Kelly Gay returns to Atlanta and beyond with Shadows Before The Sun, and this series has never been more heartwrenching or hotter than before. With death and destruction all around her Charlie Madigan plays a hard heroine who just wants her life back and she will fight to keep everyone close to her safe.

Shadows Before The Sun is a powerhouse of awesomesauce. I cannot begin to explain how thrilled I was with this book even though it carried with it a complicated slew of emotions as Charlie and Hank are pushed to the brink of their survival and their feelings for each other. Charlie is walking a tightrope of obligations and following rules to find and save her partner, even as everyone tells her to give up she pushed forward and uncovers a horrifying history subduing and entire race to the evil plots of a few old mystical hags. Charlie is looing friends she did not even realize that she had as she digs deeper into the workings of the siren city called Fiallan but finding and rescuing Hank is more important than propriety.

If voices can seduce, then looks can kill as Charlie is strapped for time in saving her partner Hank from terrible magics in a far off world. A new case is building up back at Atlanta as a death has happened in the Grove and the Druid King Pendaran is looking for answers. Charlie soon has to face off Sachath, the killer of the First Ones, and as magic is building up all around Charlie will she be able to tame all three elements of magic in time to fend off death so that she can have a future in her world? Shadows Before The Sun will delight readers known to this series. Just as the world looks dark it can easily turn bleaker around every turn and only the strong and perseverant can survive the coming storm and their destinies.
(less)

like · see review

Aug 04, 2012 mlady_rebecca rated it 5 of 5 stars

Shelves: fiction__speculative, fiction__part_of_a_series, author__kelly_gay, genre__urban_fantasy, genre_sub__demons_or_angels, genre_sub__witches_psychics, pov__first_person_female, 2012

Although there is a minor sub-mystery -- the case Charlie passes off to a co-worker before heading off to Elysia -- the main mystery thrust of the story is saving Hank from being punished by the Circe.

Like most series that continue to follow the same characters, books like this -- where one of the main characters is so intimately involved in the mystery -- are my favorite. All the characters and all of the events are part of the core story. There is no "filler", no excess.

The story starts on a s...more Although there is a minor sub-mystery -- the case Charlie passes off to a co-worker before heading off to Elysia -- the main mystery thrust of the story is saving Hank from being punished by the Circe.

Like most series that continue to follow the same characters, books like this -- where one of the main characters is so intimately involved in the mystery -- are my favorite. All the characters and all of the events are part of the core story. There is no "filler", no excess.

The story starts on a sour note. The ambassadors to Elysia have been told that Hank was killed immediately upon arriving back in Fiallan. Since Charlie already has the time off and permission to enter Elysia, Emma and Rex convince her to go anyway. And, of all people, Sandra the oracle is waiting to accompany her.

With Sandra along, Charlie plays security guard and companion, while Sandra negotiates an audience with the Circe directly. An invitation is so much easier than sneaking around the city hoping that the mark Hank gave her will warm.

This is possibly spoilers, so if you're sensitive, avert your eyes.

I was happy that Charlie found Hank before the end of the book. I was worried about either another cliff hanger or a rushed ending. But she found him early enough in the book for us to see some of the consequences of his imprisonment. Not to mention a goddess blessed oasis for the both of them to recover.

We also learn a lot more about the shared history of Elysia, Earth, and Charbydon. We learn of the First ones and their Disciples, who were seeded onto the three worlds, and the indigenous people who were in their "cave man" phase when the Creator seeded the worlds. The sirens, fae, and nymphs of Elysia, as well as the jinn and ghouls of Charbydon were all born of "the primal deities and energies that emerged in those worlds' infancy".

All and all, an excellent example of urban fantasy. Unique and fascinating world building. A seemingly impossible quest. Self-sacrifice on a number of fronts. A budding friendship (with Sandra). A partnership that is on the verge of something more. A satisfying ending that leaves possibilities open for the future. A tease of romance. (And, yes, I wanted more.) All signs that romance won't end the firm foundation of friendship that came first.

A delightful morsel.

Oh, and a technical point I wanted to make. The book is written in first person from Charlie's point of view, with some brief passages from Hank's point of view. I really appreciated the italics used to identify Hank's point of view. I frequently get lost between narrators when the POV switches too often, but this was smooth as silk.

I'm back to "no complaints except the next book isn't available immediately", and a tad bit of "wish there was more on the sexual front". But, hey, any more and the book wouldn't be as tightly written.

Kudos to the author. My favorite in the series, thus far. One of my favorite urban fantasy series, at the moment.(less)

2 likes · like · see review

Aug 19, 2012 Blodeuedd Finland rated it 4 of 5 stars

Shelves: urban-fantasy

I have waited and waited for this book. For those who read the previous book you know what I mean. The way it ended broke me and made me crave this one badly, and madly.

I finished the book in a day because I could not put it down. Charlie was going to Elysia to find Hank and those evil bitches who put him back in a hellish jail. Elysia is what heaven is supposed to be but in the Siren city heaven is not what I think of. But Charlie will get an ally, I can't say who, but someone comes.

Through out...more

1 like · like · see review

Jul 26, 2012 All Things Urban Fantasy rated it 4 of 5 stars

Shelves: july-2012-hotp, reviewed-by-abigail

Review courtesy of All Things Urban Fantasy

Who would have thought heaven would be scarier than hell? After venturing to Charbydon in the last book, Charlie is visiting the glorious Elysia in SHADOWS BEFORE THE SUN. While it is beautiful to behold, Elysia is where Hank is being held and tortured beyond human comprehension. Never one to shy away from heavy emotions, Kelly Gay forces her readers to the brink with Charlie and Hank, and then begins to piece them back together in a way that will have...more

4 likes · like · see review

Sep 30, 2012 Melissa Hayden rated it 5 of 5 stars · review of another edition

Shelves: urban-paranormal-fantasy

We start with a Prologue where Hank is being whipped with a special barbed whip for escaping the Circe witches years ago, and learns he is the last of his family line.

Rex and Charlie are on their way to look at a dead body in the Nymph territory. Rex, being of a special decent, will help identify if a jinn was present at the scene as the Druid King says he saw. The First One, Ahkneri, may not be as safe as Charlie had thought. This case that could cause a deadly war between two enemies, all the...more We start with a Prologue where Hank is being whipped with a special barbed whip for escaping the Circe witches years ago, and learns he is the last of his family line.

Rex and Charlie are on their way to look at a dead body in the Nymph territory. Rex, being of a special decent, will help identify if a jinn was present at the scene as the Druid King says he saw. The First One, Ahkneri, may not be as safe as Charlie had thought. This case that could cause a deadly war between two enemies, all the day before she heads to Fiallan in Elysia to rescue Hank, her siren partner. Charlie finds The Federation Representatives sent to find and start Hanks release have returned when she comes back to the office, and not with pleasant news. Hanks not in any of the towers and the Circe claim to have executed him as the traitor they saw him as. Charlie doesn't believe it and is still given the time off with approved passes, to go to Fiallan to see for herself and get closure. Along the way Charlie finds Sandra, the Oracle, waiting for her and her fate is to join Charlie, to help her. Charlie and Sandra enter the heaven of Elysia knowing what torment lays hidden in the beauty of which is only skin deep.

Dark comes to mind first. Kelley has taken us on a dark path through the beautiful world. I LOVE it! The treatment in this one is pure torturous to the characters. I love seeing Elysia and the Sirens. Elysia looks like heaven on the outside, but to charlie, the inside is anything but.

The beginning takes us right into the current story, the murder case of a nymph with Jinn involved (and maybe Sidhe warriors too) and the issues with Hank. But there are brief mentions of important pieces to help refresh what sparks my memories. I know this all will tie together, but left curious about the nymph murder.

The family element is still present. Although not as much, as Charlie is in Elysia hunting for Hank, but when she is home, it is there and strong. Charlies daughter with Brim the hellhound and Rex make me smile with the fun craziness between them. Such family love.

I feel I get more of different races here, once again with visiting another world this expands easily for us the cultures. Slowly we learn more about the Djinn and Sirens, and even of those in Elysia more so with being there. Their weaknesses and in depth with djinn as well as with Rex now. I really like this in the books. Kelley has thoroughly thought out her worlds.

With each book I enjoy this series more and more. Kelley has left a few things open in the end that makes me curious to see what she will bring to us next. There is something else to come, and I want to know who or what it is. What fight will Charlie fight with her friends at her side? What is Leander and what does he know of what's to come? Who is the mysterious being after the First One?

Yes, this is a series I truly will keep an eye on. (less)

1 like · like · see review

Sep 01, 2012 Christen *Goldilox And The Three Weres* rated it 4 of 5 stars · review of another edition

Hank deserves more than you falling down now, Charlie. Stand and fight.

The Charlie Madigan series continues to impress and entertain me with this fourth installment, Shadows Before the Sun.

First of all, let me tell you that the above synopsis really does nothing to tell you what this book is about. In fact, the part of Tennin and Akneri isn't even exactly correct. But have no fear, I will help you out. At the end of the previous book Hank was carted off, back to his home of Elysia. This book st...more

2 likes · like · see review

Sep 07, 2012 Cathy rated it 4 of 5 stars · review of another edition

Shelves: urban, fantasy, elves-fae, magic-users, mythology, paranormal, read-in-2012, romance, twitter-author

Shadows

The worst book in a series is always the travel one. The reason I love a series is the characters and the way they interact. But for some reason so many authors decide to take their characters on road trips where they're totally isolated from the other characters, as though exploring cool settings can make up for the characters that we love. I do understand in this series that the other two worlds are part of the premise that the author wanted to explore from the beginning. But at least i...more Shadows

The worst book in a series is always the travel one. The reason I love a series is the characters and the way they interact. But for some reason so many authors decide to take their characters on road trips where they're totally isolated from the other characters, as though exploring cool settings can make up for the characters that we love. I do understand in this series that the other two worlds are part of the premise that the author wanted to explore from the beginning. But at least in the last book when Charlie went to Charbydon a few of the other characters went with her. This time on Elysia she was completely isolated from everyone in her family. The only person from Earth with her was the Oracle, Alessandra, a very minor character that while somewhat interesting was certainly not someone with whom I felt any rapport previous to this book. I think it worked better than most travel books. The Circe were properly terrifying and the contrast between their cruelty and the beauty of Elysia was effective. And to some degree, Charlie being alone and isolated was also an effective storytelling technique; seeing how she handled doing everything on her own was interesting and helped her develop her abilities. But for a good portion of the book I really missed seeing her interact with the characters that bring out her best qualities.

Early on in the series I sometimes felt like the some of the use of mythology was too heavy-handed, trying to incorporate too many famous myths and religious icons, it just sometimes made it feel a bit cheesy and like it was trying too hard to be cute. But in the last book or two I've liked this aspect a lot more, things have come together better for me. I thought the trip to Elysia was good for illustrating the concept that the author created.

Overall it was an engaging book. I really do like Charlie and the other characters. The author writes a good story and I feel an emotional connection to Charlie, Hank, Emma and Rex. And Brim, don't forget the hellhound!
(less)

2 likes · like · see review

mlady_rebecca The worst book in a series is always the travel one. The reason I love a series is the characters and the way they interact. But for some reason so ma...more
Sep 08, 2012 06:38pm

Cathy I agree, I'm very happy that she got Hank back! It wasn't as bad as most road stories, there was a purpose to taking her to Elysia and the description...more
Sep 08, 2012 09:18pm

Rich Would you call this a paranormal romance series? I can take romance in small doses (it's a guy thing), but I have to draw the line when the main chara...more
Jan 14, 2013 09:45am

Aug 22, 2012 Claire rated it 5 of 5 stars · review of another edition

You know when you read a really great book and you just know that other people will like it too and you want to shout as loud as you can READ THIS SERIES....well this is one of those books. If you like Urban Fantasy please take the time to check out the first book in this series The Better Part Of Darkness you won't regret it I promise.

The Charlie Madigan series is Urban Fantasy but it doesn't contain vampires, were's or Fae. It is unique in that there are two different worlds Elysia and Charby...more You know when you read a really great book and you just know that other people will like it too and you want to shout as loud as you can READ THIS SERIES....well this is one of those books. If you like Urban Fantasy please take the time to check out the first book in this series The Better Part Of Darkness you won't regret it I promise.

The Charlie Madigan series is Urban Fantasy but it doesn't contain vampires, were's or Fae. It is unique in that there are two different worlds Elysia and Charbydon which exist in another dimension. Charlie is a cop who polices the beings from these two worlds who come to Earth to visit and live. Charlie has seen her fair share of trouble. In the first book she is brought back to life when she is injected with the DNA from beings from both heaven like Elysia and hell like Charbydon. We are now discovering that Charlie is getting powers which she doesn't understand or know how to use yet. In the last book The Hour Of Dust And Ashes her Siren cop partner and possible lover Hank was arrested and taken back home to Elysia as a traitor for his desertion some 200 years earlier. Shadows Before The Sun picks up with Charlie travelling to Elysia to find and rescue Hank and to bring him back home.

It has been a long year waiting for this book to be released. The last book had such a massive cliffhanger with Hank being carted away back to Elysia, I was desperate for this book and it did not disappoint me what so ever. All four books in the series are consistently well written, Ms Gay never fails to deliver a first class book. The stories are thrilling, enthralling and a fascinating read and they read a bit more mature than some other UF books. There are some awesome characters in these books from the sexy Siren Hank, to her possessed ex husband Rex but it is Charlie who is my favourite. Charlie is a great character she is a kickass cop who also has a softer more vulnerable side as that of a divorced mum with her daughter. The world building is excellent and quite different to other UF series where Ms Gay creates two worlds with both Elysia and Charbydon. They are literally worlds apart and there is a fair bit of imagination used with how the worlds exist and how we travel to them.

If you have read this series before you will not be disappointed with this book. My only problem was that the ending could read like the end of the series however news on Ms Gay's website does not say that is the end of Charlie however Ms Gay does confirm that this was the last book of her current contract. Please please please can we have more Charlie I'm not ready to give this series up yet. Shadows Before The Sun was magnificent and I am going to give it 5 stars.
(less)

like · see review

title link	preview: Shadows Before the Sun
avg rating	preview: Shadows Before the Sun Goodreads rating: 4.31 (690 ratings)
small image	preview: click here [close]
med image	preview: click here [close]
BBCode	[url=http://www.goodreads.com/book/show/12993854-shadows-before-the-sun?utm_medium=api&utm_source=blog_book][img]http://d.gr-assets.com/books/1326316979l/12993854.jpg[/img][/url] [url=http://www.goodreads.com/book/show/12993854-shadows-before-the-sun?utm_medium=api&utm_source=blog_book]Shadows Before the Sun by Kelly Gay[/url]

Shadows Before the Sun (Charlie Madigan #4)

Friend Reviews

Lists with This Book

Community Reviews

new topic
Discuss This Book

combine
Other Editions (2)

Genres

Readers also enjoyed similar books

About Kelly Gay

Books by Kelly Gay

Share This Book

Share This Book on Your Website

Trivia About Shadows Before th...