A Boy and A Bear in a Boat
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating

A Boy and A Bear in a Boat

3.36 of 5 stars 3.36  ·  rating details  ·  425 ratings  ·  136 reviews
A boy and a bear go to sea, equipped with a suitcase, a comic book, and a ukulele. The bear assures the boy that they are traveling a short distance and it really shouldn't take very long. But then they encounter "unforeseeable anomalies": turbulent stormy seas! a terrifying sea monster! and the rank remains of The Very Last Sandwich. The odds are pitted against the boy an...more
Hardcover, 304 pages
Published June 12th 2012 by David Fickling Books (first published January 1st 2012)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 803)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Anna
This is a book aimed at 8-11 year olds, and I suspect, boys. However the essentially existentialist narrative may attract an older audience who would see it as a metaphor for life and experience. In simple terms it is about a boy and a bear on a boat. There is no explanation why, where or when and the ending is left open. The bear, (the captain) does not always inspire confidence, they experience various anomalies and unexplained problems but, but together they struggle on. For me the strongest...more
Sam
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.
Chris
It seemed to be just one episode of a longer story so it didn't have a proper beginning or ending, it was all just part of the middle. There was no way of knowing what had gone on before or what would happen after. And, actually, the boy didn't have much of a clue about what was going on now.

Is it possible to write a simple, abstract fable largely about a character being bored that is not itself boring? That's the question I kept asking myself as I read this book. For a large part of the story n...more
Susan
waiting for godot meets the little prince. I love it so much I can't even tell you.
Kaethe
Jul 17, 2014 Kaethe marked it as abandoned
It's hard not to be bored by a book that keeps telling us how bored the boy is. I can't be bothered to try, no matter how much I liked the cover.
Ms. Yingling
A boy approaches a bear in a boat and asks how long it will take to get "just to the other side". Well, apparently longer than a three-hour tour, because the bear runs into "unforseen anomalies". The duo drift for days and days, subsisting on bizarre sandwiches and, since this is a British author, tea. They run into storms and giant sea monsters, have to catch fish, and end up on a weirdly antique ship after their smaller boat floats away. When that, too, is destroyed, the two sail off into the...more
Caren
I loved this book, although it is about as quirky as they come and, I suspect, will not appeal to everyone. Just as the title says, it is about a boy and a bear in a boat. Nothing more, nothing less. Why they are in the boat, where the boy was trying to go, why a bear is piloting this boat....well, none of that is explained. Even though this is a children's book, I think many adults will enjoy it as much, if not more, than the middle grade readers at which it is aimed. As an adult, I kept lookin...more
Karen
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.
Ben Babcock
There’s a boy, and a bear, and they are on a boat. No, not “on a boat”. Actually, more kind of in a boat. A rowboat. Named Harriet.

Bears are not cuddly. They are ferocious wild animals that really just want to be left alone, to roam through the wild and eat fish and have bear sex. So I’m not quite sure how we went from bears mauling people to teddy bears and anthropomorphic bears who wear boots or hang around with that Christopher Robin kid. I wonder if there is a middle, transition state out th...more
Joss
One of the most debated books on this year's Carnegie shortlist! I was familiar with Dave Shelton from his excellent comic Good Dog, Bad Dog so looked forward to reading it and I loved it. Yes it's beyond weird and I'm not sure how it would go down with children (am currently testing with a colleague's grandchildren) but I loved it.
A boy wants to go "just over to the other side" and gets into a boat captained by a bear who at first appears to be a competent seafarer, though fairly rapidly we re...more
Doug
This is an odd little book for sure. Shelton's illustrations have some of the whimsy of Peggy Fortnum's classic drawings of Paddington Bear, but the story of this unnamed ursine and lad, though grounded in a wealth of specific physical detail, is almost certainly too amorphous for most children's taste. The book plainly operates at a symbolic level, but it's not as obvious about at it as, say, Jonathan Livingstone Seagull or The Old Man and the Sea. It's like an unlikely meeting of Paddington an...more
Jean-Marie
3 1/2 stars. This book is aptly titled. "Waiting for Godot" came to mind as I read it aloud to my 9 year old. While the plot is thin on excitement, the story does offer up some very good dialogue between the boy and the bear. And the bear had some great one-liners that made us laugh out loud. ("Do you think it was something he ate?" said the bear.) Funny stuff. We really liked some parts but not enough parts to give it 4 stars. And we were left wanting a little bit more of an ending. It was hard...more
Lauren O'Farrell
Utterly lovely, odd and really rather magical. This book is firstly drop dead gorgeous at first sight (and was winner of the 2013 Kitschies Inky Tentacle cover award).

The insides don't disappoint either. The story is simple, slow and loveable (a bit like the bear himself) and draws you into its own little world effortlessly.

The purposeful lack of detail gives it a dreamlike quality and a feeling of being as lost as the characters in the story. All floating on a sea of well-chosen words and gor...more
Rebecca
I don't know what it was about this story, but I just couldn't get into it. The illustrations were awesome and the humor was great, but I just had to push myself to finish it. Maybe it was too existential for my personal taste or I wasn't in the right place for it, but I just was not feeling this book. I would normally put it at 2 stars, but in this case I don't think it's fair to the author. This book just may not be my cup of tea...
Ela
Really sweet book. I loved how the spirit of it was so positive. They didn't always know where they were going or what they were doing but they just ploughed on. I had fun finding possible metaphors for what the adventures represented. In contrast I also thought that the brutalness and cruelty of life was expressed really well.
A great adventure story for children, and a lovely book for older readers.
Mehsi
This was a wonderful book, however, it might not appeal to everyone, and I think kids might not enjoy this book fully.

The book all starts when a boy steps in a boat with a bear as captain and asks to get taken to the other side. The whole book is about this journey, as everything that can go wrong, will go wrong. They get into storms, find a big sea monster, and many other things happen.

That might all be fun and all, but mostly between all that, there is conversation, there is chatting, there i...more
Jennifer Darrouzet
The kind of book you can put down and pick up after a few weeks for another chapter with a kiddo. My 9yo had to stop reading a couple times tonight because he giggled so much that he got the hiccups. So that'll be worth some stars right there.
Judy
Fantastic book. 'Life of Pi' crossed with 'Waiting for Godot' for children. Possibly the coolest kids' book cover design ever on this hardback edition. Not surprised they chose a different approach for the paperback though :-)
Library Maven
Perhaps because I read it as a digital ARC without illustrations, I found this book quirky and strange.
Maria
One of the weirdest books ever. If you haven't read it, put everything else aside and read
Edward Sullivan
Existential adventure for middle grade readers. For those not yet ready for Life of Pi.
Monica Edinger
Not sure what to make of this one.
Erica
Have you ever been on a roadtrip that seemed like it would never end? Well, at least there was a road to travel down and places to stop and get food. No such luck for this boy. He is stuck on a boat in the middle of nowhere with no land in sight, with only a bear who is probably lost and possibly completely insane. 'I spy' gets boring pretty quickly when the only things to see are the sea and the sky, and the only comic book on board isn't even in English. Through monster attacks and ghost ship...more
Stephen
[Note: this is a children's book, but I wouldn't let that put you off]

Loved this book - an existential comedy, for inquisitive, imaginative kids. A very simple concept - which is summed up exactly by the title. The plot is fairly (deliberately) slight, but through the tribulations he and the bear suffer, it you see the boy maturing and learning to appreciate the important things. I thought Shelton judged this just beautifully - sometimes I thought things would work out a bit too conveniently, bu...more
Jennifer
The title of the book sums up the plot. A boy hires a bear to take him across a body of water on the bear's boat, the Harriet. Things do not go as planned. The bear's questionable competency as captain, or as he says, 'unforeseeable anomalies' in the currents result in the Harriet drifting to the middle of nowhere. It does not take long for the boy to become bored and pessimistic. Though the bear remains confident that things will work out fine, all evidence points to the contrary. The boy and t...more
Becky
A Boy and a Bear in a Boat is a seafaring adventure story. It’s a quirky book with charismatic illustrations for younger readers.


Boy steps aboard Bear’s boat. He’s going somewhere but we don’t know where. The Bear is the ship’s captain and he rows the boy across the sea. It’s a long way but how far, we don’t know. Boy is in a hurry to get there but Bear understands the beauty of the wide open sea. As they journey across the sea, they experience the joys and difficulties of friendship and a great...more
Barb
When I saw this title, I immediately thought of the book, Life of Pi Luckily, this book's only similarity is a boat. The boy and the bear had a very interesting relationship in this book, it was one of a teacher and a student, or more fittingly as a captain and passenger. The lessons learned and taught were of patience, creativity in solving problems and working together.

I really enjoyed the writing style of Dave Shelton His voice and word choice for the characters were excellent. I think A Boy...more
Sharon Tyler
A Boy and A Bear in a Boat by Dave Shelton is a children's chapter book that leaves me unsure as to how I feel about it. As the title suggests, there is a boy, a bear, and a boat. The book opens with the boy approaching the bear on the boat and, when asked, saying that he just wanted to get to the 'other side'. The boy and the bear set off and the journey does not go as planned; thanks to 'unforeseeable anomalies', a storm, and a sea monster. Will they ever reach their destination, will the boat...more
Candy Wood
What a strange little book, on both the 2012 Guardian longlist and the 2013 Carnegie shortlist. The title sums it up, and there's never an explanation of any kind for how the boy and bear get there: with the lovely opening, "'Welcome aboard,' said the bear, standing and turning to face the boy," we're off on what starts as a sort of river crossing but turns into a sea journey, complete with storms, shipwrecks, and a sea monster with lots of eyes and tentacles. The bear has brought sandwiches, bu...more
Rachel
A Boy and a Bear in a Boat is an approximately three hour read and a further three hours of puzzlement. It features a boy (never named) and a bear (also never named) in a boat (named Harriet) travelling across a vast expanse of ocean with only each other for company. There are moments of mystery and peril but they are few and far between. Such an odd little book - why on Carnegie I wonder?

There is a plot of kinds, but it takes a long time to lead anywhere. I'm not really sure what this writer wa...more
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 26 27 next »
topics  posts  views  last activity   
Carnegie book war...: A Boy and a Bear In A Boat 18 13 Jun 17, 2013 11:18AM  
  • Citizen Scientists: Be a Part of Scientific Discovery from Your Own Backyard
  • The Unforgotten Coat
  • Jimmy the Greatest!
  • Goblins
  • The Prince Who Fell from the Sky
  • Chuck Close: Face Book
  • Jazz Age Josephine
  • The Boy Who Swam with Piranhas
  • I Lay My Stitches Down: Poems of American Slavery
  • Plunked
  • The Abominables
  • Shiver Me Timbers!: Pirate Poems & Paintings
  • The Town Mouse and the Country Mouse
  • Little Bird
  • Brief Thief
  • Dead Man's Cove (Laura Marlin Mysteries, #1)
  • Chickadee
  • Shadow of the Minotaur (Legendeer #1)
Good Dog, Bad Dog Book 1. Thirteen Chairs DFC Library: Good Dog, Bad Dog 2 Brain Explosion: A Collection of Thoughts, Verbiage, Assorted Quotables and Profundities Sophie and the Locust Curse

Share This Book

“The boy shivered. The bear sniffed the air.
"What do you smell now?" said the boy.
"Danger!" said the bear.
The boy looked alarmed. The bear sniffed again.
"Or maybe marmalade," said the bear.
The boy gave him a dubious stare.
"Possibly both," said the bear.”
5 likes
“And they disappear over that flat blue horizon and onto another.” 2 likes
More quotes…