My rating:

add to my books

The Arrogance of Humanism

by David W. Ehrenfeld

3.86 · rating details · 21 ratings · 4 reviews

Attacks nothing less than the currently prevailing world philosophy--humanism, which the author feels is exceedingly dangerous in its hidden assumptions.

Paperback, 304 pages

Published February 5th 1981 by Oxford University Press, USA

more details... edit details

Get a copy:

More…

There is a good chance some of your friends read this book. Sign in to see!

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Lists with This Book

Rodale's All-New Encyclopedia of Organic Gardening by Barbara W. Ellis

Introduction to Permaculture by Bill Mollison

The Unsettling of America by Wendell Berry

Living on the Earth by Alicia Bay Laurel

Troubadour's book list for self reliance

39th out of 76 books — 2 voters

More lists with this book...

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 46)

filter | sort: default (?) | rating details

Aug 14, 2011

John rated it

Review: David Ehrenfeld, The Arrogance of Humanism, Oxford University Press, 1981

I bought this book when I was a graduate student in Oxford. That must have been rather soon after it was published, though my memory is that the copy I still own was bought second-hand or remaindered. Perhaps this book’s uncompromising message meant that it was far from popular.

One possible conclusion should be cleared up at the start. At that time, many books and articles could be foun...more Review: David Ehrenfeld, The Arrogance of Humanism, Oxford University Press, 1981

I bought this book when I was a graduate student in Oxford. That must have been rather soon after it was published, though my memory is that the copy I still own was bought second-hand or remaindered. Perhaps this book’s uncompromising message meant that it was far from popular.

One possible conclusion should be cleared up at the start. At that time, many books and articles could be found which aimed to mobilize evangelical Christians against what was often described as “secular humanism”, thought of as a kind of established irreligion. Ehrenfeld’s title might make you think this is one of those books. It isn’t. In fact, many Christians (and other religious believers) might be surprised to find themselves among the “humanists” of the book’s title.

So what is the “humanism” that Ehrenfeld identifies? It is “our irrational faith in the limitless power of human reason – its ability to confront and solve the many problems that humans face, its ability to rearrange both the world of Nature and the affairs of men and women so that human life will prosper.” Ehrenfeld perceives this faith as a secularized version of the Greek and medieval doctrine of final causes – the idea that everything exists for some discernible end or purpose, primarily for the benefit of humanity. “Thus the idea of using a Nature created for us, the idea of control, and the idea of human superiority became associated early in our history… It only remained to diminish the idea of God, and we arrived at full-fledged humanism.” And later, “Humanism is at the heart of our present world culture; we share its unseen assumptions of control, and this bond makes mockery of more superficial differences (among us).”

The book aims to demolish these “assumptions of control” by example and argument. The examples range from literature and science fiction to specific recent events, some of which may now not be remembered. Who now recalls the fire in the cable spreading room at the Brown’s Ferry nuclear plant, which was caused by workers attempting to check for air leaks in flammable insulation material using a candle flame, and which revealed a common mode failure possibility that had not been captured in supposedly exhaustive fault tree analysis? After Three Mile Island, Chernobyl, and Fukushima, probably few. But that is exactly the point. “The point is that human-designed systems of great power and complexity will always have accidents, as our emotional judgment rightly warns us, and no application of rational control systems, however carefully and skillfully engineered, can possibly prevent them from happening.”

It is not hard to collect examples of failures of control. Ehrenfeld goes on to argue that total control will always be a myth. Control can be achieved, for a limited time and in a limited arena, but only by expending significant resources outside the controlled arena: these expenditures endure that our solutions will in the end only be “quasi-solutions”, and they will yield their own crop of “residue problems” in due course. The scope over which control must be extended will therefore tend inexorably to widen; and at some point the cost of control may become more than the system can bear. The global trading networks on which so many of us rely for even the basic necessities of life provide a simple example. “In no important instance have we been able to demonstrate comprehensive, successful management of our world, nor do we understand it well enough to be able to manage it even in theory.”

Ehrenfeld identifies as humanistic the idea that all problems can be solved by human reason and ingenuity. To give an example (not Ehrenfeld’s): Many pages of discussion are devoted to the question: How will America supply its future energy needs? One camp points out the political risks, and depletion and pollution issues associated with fossil fuels; another, the intermittency and dubious economics of solar and wind power. But that little word “needs” papers over the fact that the universe is under no obligation to supply us with abundant, persistent, concentrated energy at all. As Enrenfeld says on a related matter, “This is a question which makes no sense outside of a humanist context, because it is predicated on the assumption that we can do as we please… What we want is often a separate thing form what actually happens, and I do not for a minute believe that the two will coincide in the future.”

One of the strengths of the book is its honesty about the psychological power of the “humanistic myth”. Ehrenfeld does not believe that he or any other human being can really walk away from the myths of control. “We will not give them up because we cannot – our egos prevent us.” And so at the book’s conclusion we reach, of all things, a meditation on The Lord of the Rings:

“For when at last it was time for Frodo to cast away and destroy the One Ring, the ring of power, it was impossible for him to do so, despite the peril in which his refusal placed his friends, and despite the failure that his refusal would bring to the dread and determined quest which he had undertaken, without faltering, up to the very edge of doom itself. And in the end it was Gollum, a slave to the dark forces, mindlessly, mechanically obeying the call of the power that held him fast, who was the unintentional but not unexpected agency of the destruction of the Ring. I believe that such an agency is the best we can hope for, other than direct divine intervention, in the struggle to overcome the arrogance of humanism, although there is no knowing whether it will come in time to save many of the things we love on earth.”

(less)

· see review

Nov 26, 2011

Tomek rated it

Not a bad look at the role our obsession with technology and development has had on our species and our interactions with the world. However, this book is rather dated, and the author tends to emphasize Cold War examples. Also, he advocates, what seems to me to be, the precautionary principle, which in its standard form, is incomprehensible in inconsistent and incomprehensible from a logical point of view. Instead of arguing for the precautionary principle, he should have supported the applic...more

· see review

Apr 01, 2011

Julie rated it

My husband gave me this book over 20 years ago. It's one that shifted the way I think about technology and has informed my point of view ever since.

· see review

Jan 09, 2008

Bradford rated it

Opened my mind in the most amazing and memorable "aha!" moment I think I've ever had while reading.

· see review

Feb 03, 2012

Abbie Cianfrocco rated it

Jan 31, 2012

Bob Uhl added it

Jan 25, 2012

Troubadour rated it

Shelves: booklist

Jan 22, 2012

Eden Tessa is currently reading it

Oct 24, 2011

Jason Mierek marked it as to-read

Oct 12, 2011

Brad VanAuken added it

Sep 19, 2011

Stephen added it

Shelves: philosophy, history

Aug 27, 2011

Chris Watson rated it

Aug 14, 2011

Stacia marked it as to-read

Aug 04, 2011

David marked it as to-read

Jul 22, 2011

Brent Harrison rated it

Jul 12, 2011

Seven marked it as to-read

May 14, 2011

Ida added it

Mar 28, 2011

Paul added it

Mar 28, 2011

Paul added it · review of another edition

Feb 16, 2011

Littleorphanammo Rulez marked it as to-read

Jan 09, 2011

Tara rated it

Shelves: how-we-live-now, landscape-politics

Jan 06, 2011

Foy marked it as to-read

Dec 24, 2010

Hatfield marked it as to-read

Shelves: politics, and

Oct 28, 2010

anonymous marked it as to-read

Oct 10, 2010

Tricia marked it as to-read

Shelves: nonfiction, social-thought

Oct 06, 2010

John David marked it as to-read

Shelves: politics

Sep 14, 2010

zerospinboson marked it as home-library

Mar 14, 2010

Dennis Boccippio rated it

Shelves: history

Mar 01, 2010

Bryan rated it

· review of another edition

Jan 18, 2010

Tim rated it

« previous 1 2 next »

History

2 users

Non Fiction

2 users

Philosophy

2 users

See top shelves...

Books by David W. Ehrenfeld

Beginning Again: People and Nature in the New Millennium

Swimming Lessons: Keeping Afloat In The Age Of Technology

Becoming Good Ancestors: How We Balance Nature, Community, and Technology

More…

Share This Book

Facebook Twitter Your website

Pin It

Trivia About The Arrogance of ...

No trivia or quizzes yet. Add some now »

title link	preview: The Arrogance of Humanism
avg rating	preview: The Arrogance of Humanism Goodreads rating: 3.86 (21 ratings)
small image	preview: click here [close]
med image	preview: click here [close]
BBCode	[url=http://www.goodreads.com/book/show/1280748.The_Arrogance_of_Humanism?utm_medium=api&utm_source=blog_book][img]http://photo.goodreads.com/books/1182466992m/1280748.jpg[/img][/url] [url=http://www.goodreads.com/book/show/1280748.The_Arrogance_of_Humanism?utm_medium=api&utm_source=blog_book]The Arrogance of Humanism by David W. Ehrenfeld[/url]

The Arrogance of Humanism

Friend Reviews

Lists with This Book

Community Reviews

new topic
Discuss This Book

combine
Other Editions (1)

Genres

Books by David W. Ehrenfeld

Share This Book

Share This Book on Your Website

Trivia About The Arrogance of ...

The Arrogance of Humanism

Friend Reviews

Lists with This Book

Community Reviews

new topicDiscuss This Book

combine Other Editions (1)

Genres

Books by David W. Ehrenfeld

Share This Book

Share This Book on Your Website

Trivia About The Arrogance of ...

new topic
Discuss This Book

combine
Other Editions (1)