The Crisis of Zionism
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating

The Crisis of Zionism

3.91 of 5 stars 3.91  ·  rating details  ·  235 ratings  ·  54 reviews
Israel's next great crisis may come not with the Palestinians or Iran but with young American Jews

A dramatic shift is taking place in Israel and America. In Israel, the deepening occupation of the West Bank is putting Israeli democracy at risk. In the United States, the refusal of major Jewish organizations to defend democracy in the Jewish state is alienating many young l...more
Hardcover, 304 pages
Published March 27th 2012 by Times Books
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about The Crisis of Zionism, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about The Crisis of Zionism

The Almond Tree by Michelle Cohen CorasantiMornings in Jenin by Susan AbulhawaGaza Writes Back by Refaat AlareerFast Times in Palestine by Pamela J. OlsonThe Ethnic Cleansing of Palestine by Ilan Pappé
Books on the Israel Palestine Conflict
44th out of 184 books — 475 voters
State of Wonder by Ann PatchettThe New Jim Crow by Michelle AlexanderIn the Night Kitchen by Maurice SendakTwilight of the Elites by Christopher L. HayesMoonwalking with Einstein by Joshua Foer
Colbert Report Book List
49th out of 65 books — 22 voters


More lists with this book...

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 689)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Tucker
With his usual sharp analysis, Peter Beinart identifies several reasons why young American Jews tend to avoid pro-Israel activism. They may not be deeply committed to or involved in Judaism in the first place, and they may resent being expected to express agreement with every policy of the Israeli government. In The Crisis of Zionism, Beinart gives special elucidation to one interesting reason: for people born 30, 40, or 50 years after the liberation of Auschwitz, who have grown up in a United S...more
Jeremy
Of the dozens of books I have read about the Middle East and the problems between Israel and Palestine, this is by far the best. I am stunned by Beinart's ability to write with passion and with clarity. He marshals an enormous amount of information, organizes it brilliantly, and tells a complex story with great insight.

The book's central theme is how can Israel be saved as a democracy? Time is running out, Beinart argues, because the settlements continue to expand, and this will leave Israel wit...more
Elliot Ratzman
Apr 29, 2012 Elliot Ratzman rated it 5 of 5 stars
Recommends it for: American Jews, activists
Beinart’s book is an important intervention and should be a topic of conversation between American Jews about our relationship with Israel and our own undemocratic elites. Non-Jews would benefit from listening in, especially since a Liberal Zionist view is so rarely taken seriously by The Left. Meanwhile, the reviews from The Right are the same petty sequences of denials, double-standards, subject-changing and bigotry we’ve heard before, from The Israel Lobby book to J Street’s moderate Zionism....more
Mark
Peter Beinart may not be saying much that is new in his book, but he put it all out there, well researched and noted. There is much that is wrong with Zionism of today: Liberal Zionism, which was responsible for the building of the state, has been eclipsed by the Revisionist Zionism of Vladimir Jabotinsky. Revisionist Zionism seeks to rebuild the Jewish nation based on the notion that Israelite heroes were brute warriors (e.g. Samson), and that the moral vision of the prophets was an exilic dilu...more
Alex Nagler
I wanted to like this book more, but my issue is more an issue with myself than with the author. It's clear from the first page that this author supports Israel, in spite of some of the negative things it has done over the past three decades. Beinart is reasonable the entire book, but in his conclusion he comes back to the emphasis of Jewish education as a way to make younger Jews identify more with Israel. I can't help but feel that's ignoring the problem. We (and I'm adding myself to this grou...more
Lewis Weinstein
Feb 14, 2012 Lewis Weinstein marked it as to-read
Shelves: non-fiction
OP-ED COLUMNIST ROGER COHEN (NYT 2/14/12) ...

Peter Beinart’s “The Crisis of Zionism” is an important new book that rejects the manipulation of Jewish victimhood in the name of Israel’s domination of the Palestinians and asserts that the real issue for Jews today is not the challenge of weakness but the demands of power.

What Netanyahu and major American Jewish organizations miss is that, in Beinart’s words, “the less democratic Zionism becomes in practice, the more people across the world will...more
Lois
A well-written, well-researched and insightful book by the man
who called Barack Obama the “first Jewish president”, Beinart offers ideas towards
effecting peace in the Middle East along with
strengthening the Jewish community in the U.S.
The author’s main premise is that both Israel under Netanyahu
and the conservative Jewish leadership in the U.S., have used the rationale
of the Holocaust to justify a deepening of the occupation. In his view, they
have abandoned the democratic, egalitarian Zionism of...more
Beth
This book makes a passionate case for liberal American Jews to take seriously and act to combat the erosion of liberal values in the governmental policies of today's Israel. He makes a persuasive argument that the country has strayed dangerously from the principles upon which it was founded, and that, through relative indifference and inaction, the liberal majority of American Jewry has ceded the community's voice on the matter to a wealthy right-wing minority that powerfully influences American...more
Rich Mcallister
I've liked Beinart's writing I've read on the web, and this book is well constructed. It's a little more aimed at what American Jews are or should be thinking and doing about Israel and American policy toward Israel than it is aimed at Americans in general, so I'm not quite the target audience. I did appreciate reading his perspective on the generational divide among American Jews and how it affects their attitudes toward Judaism as a religion, Jewish culture, and Israel.

As usual in a political...more
Joshua
A thoughtful look at the challenges facing Israel and American Jews.
Genevieve
As one of those young American Jews Beinart is talking about, my feeling is that he doesn't go far enough. I mean, I do appreciate him pushing himself and bringing this conversation into the consciousness of the 'center.' But it annoys me that getting this far seems to be such a huge, difficult breakthrough for him, and he really loses me with the lecture at the end where he bemoans intermarriage and suggests everyone should send their kids to Jewish day school as the solution (or something like...more
Pearl
Peter Beinart is active in his synagogue, an adherent of Judaism. He defines himself as a Liberal Zionist. In today's world that seems a contradiction in terms. But that is his anguish. In his clearly written and well organized book, Beinart argues for being able to maintain and, indeed, embrace both ideologies. It's not easy and may be impossible. That's why this book is his cri de coeur.

As its title declares, he sees Zionism in crisis, that is, the Zionism of Israel's founders - true Zionism...more
Kristine Brancolini
I read The Crisis of Zionism for my Jewish book group and as I suspected, it caused quite a ruckus. The younger and more liberal members of the group were more open to Beinart's message. The book makes it clear that conservative American Jews have fueled and funded the controversy. For me, the book illuminated the historical and political issues that underlie much of the emotionalism around the occupation of the West Bank. I attended graduate school with a woman from the West Bank and she helped...more
Luis
This is a superb book that speaks the truth to entrenched interests in the US and in Israel. Israel is in crisis and it is mostly of its own doing. In the bible, God punishes the Jewish people on several occasions, usually because they strayed away from the moral and righteous path; because they forget to be compassionate towards others. It is in that tradition that Peter Beinart has written this pressing and timely book.

Zionism, as Beinart defines it, was supposed to be a movement to create a...more
Stephen
An impassioned plea by a liberal Jewish Zionist for the survival of Israel as a both a liberal and Jewish state, and the need for liberal American Jews to reforge their commitment to both Judaism and Zionism in order to assure that survival. Combined with this is a scathing critique of the Obama administration's utter lack of backbone in standing up to illiberal Israeli politicians, and their increasingly illberal supporters in the US. While Beinart gives some reason to hope, I am not optimistic...more
Edwile Mbameg
Apr 18, 2013 Edwile Mbameg added it
Shelves: politics
The Crisis of Zionism is a good book in many respects though the author's attempt to reconcile Zionism with liberal democratic ideals is, at best, tortuous. Zionism by definition is an ethic pursuit which reemerged around the 19th Century in response to antisemitism with the aim of (re)establishing a Jewish homeland in Palestine - it happened at the expense of Palestinians- while a Liberal Democracy is a form of government based on universal ideals; equality of all humans before the law, human r...more
Ray
Criticism of Israel or Israeli policies is something which tends to bring swift rebuttals and charges of being anti-Semetic if from a gentile, or of being a self-hating Jew if Jewish. So Beinart's book, "The Crisis of Zionism" is somewhat provocative in nature by stating that the Zionist dream of a Jewish state under democratic ideals is being challenged by the on-going settlement policy in the West Bank. Beinart looks at the West Bank as "non-democratic Israel", separate and distinct from the g...more
Joe
Normally I don't do a book report for GoodReads, but there are no spoilers here. It's non-fiction.

We know that Israel faces a contradiction: its role as a Jewish state is threatened by dilution by non-Jewish Palestinians, but denying basic rights and citizenship to the Palestinians threatens Israel's role as a democratic state. Beinert's thesis is that it's okay to have a contradiction, but expressly not okay for Jews to do to Palestinians what they're doing today.

He doesn't try to paint the Pal...more
David Toub
I've been familiar with Peter Beinart's writings since he wrote a very important piece in the New York Review of Books a few years ago that noted that younger Jews were becoming less and less concerned about Israel, He argued that this was in large part because Israel was no longer seen as an endangered nobel country, but rather as one that was an occupier that has amassed a very powerful military force insulating the country from any neighboring threats. Beinart also had once supported the Iraq...more
Roy Klein
If you're interested in the Israeli predicament and you're not a Jew nor an Israeli, I would hesitate recommending this book for you. The book speaks within the Jewish "tribe", evoking its world views and shared memories, and I imagine that it would feel like an alien and exclusive environment to outsiders.

If you are an Israeli or a Jew, though, this book is something you should definitely read. Peter Beinart, a self proclaimed Jewish Partisan, is connecting the fate of the world wide Secular Je...more
John
Zionism refers to support for Israel as the Jewish nation state. I have long been interested in Israeli / Palestine relations. In 2000 I carefully followed the conflict called the Second Intifada. This conflict resulted in the deaths of an estimated 5,500 Palestinians and 1,100 Israelis. What was so astonishing was that Palestinian suicide bombers were targeting Israeli civilians (buses, coffee shops, random rocket attacks). Israel would respond with a heavy boot to the neck of the Palestinians...more
Ernesto
It's a wonderfully written book. Concise and to the point.


It deals with 3 things:
1) The split between democratic and autocratic Israel through the green line
2) Obama being an enormous coward
3) The future of American Jewish community.




What's missing is the obvious conclusion. Beinart narrates the parable of the pagan king that scoffed at his Jewish advisers when they claimed their religion forbade them violence. If they could, the king replied, they would.

Now we know the pagan was right. Beinart

...more
Jamie VW
One of the best books I have ever read on the subject and the closest any scholar on the subject has come to my own personal view on the conflict. Smart, brave and firm, Beinart has opened the door to an essential argument that must take hold in mainstream American Judaism if there is to be meaningful change in the way we as a community approach Israel.

The book suffers from two flaws that make me unable to fully celebrate it, despite my excitement at Beinart's articulation of his thesis. For one...more
The American Conservative
'The Crisis of Zionism is in part a meditation on the present “golden age of Jewish power,” a critique of the American Jewish establishment, and a less than optimistic view of the increasingly Orthodox religious attitudes that will replace it; in part a history and analysis of Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s tactical success in undermining the Oslo accords and his shocking humbling of President Obama.

While most of Beinart’s arguments are not novel, they are presented with unerring p...more
Eric
Excellent, thoroughly outlines the problems of right-wing Judaism in North America and how pervasive this group is the determination of how funds are distributed in Israel. The book is a reminder of the necessity of seeking out grass roots, left organizations like "The New Israel Fund" to learn at the very least about some of the positive changes that are taking place.
Georges Dib
Very interesting read, and very insightful author. He defends his case quite clearly and in a balanced approach.
I am glad to see liberal American Jewish still trying to be unbiased and speak up against injustice.
I endorse almost all his points, except maybe at the end where he endorses the American government subsidising Jewish schools. As a secular guy I do not like the sound of this solution ...
Bonniecco cco
This is a terrific discussion of the current situation in Israel, and an analysis of how so many Jewish organizations in the USA came to be uncritical endorsers of Israeli government policies. The writer explains clearly the impossibility of Israel remaining a liberal democratic nation while it is a occupying power. Chapters on President Obama and current Prime Minister Netanyahu explain well how they came to hold the views they do today. Beinart is also concerned with the dilution of "jewishnes...more
Jonathan
This is an excellent read - a must for any Jew concerned with the polarized rhetoric about Israel. This book speaks in a calm, passionate but diplomatic tone, and appeals to the basic human values that we as Jews profess to adhere to. With so many authors writing about this conflict based on pure ideology, Beinart relies on reason, logic, and compassion for both Jews and Palestinians.

My only complaint about the book is that he relies a little too much on religious arguments towards the end, and...more
Avi Shmueli
This book is required reading for any involved American Jew. I also strongly recommend it to the general public.

Excellent analysis and exposition. As an Israeli turned American, it fits brilliantly with what I know about Israel, the Palestinian-Israeli conflict, America's role and American Jewry's role in this. And it tells the story well to those who should know, passionately yet crisply.

Israel cannot be all three: big, Jewish and democratic; it must, but seems unable, to settle on only the rig...more
Dan
To quote Beinart "As I write this, I cringe. When I see a Jew - any Jew - I feel a bond. No matter his politics, he and I share a people, a people whose members have often had little to rely on but one another."

It is for this reason that I felt indebted to read this book. I actually care and value what Beinart says about Judaism and the state of Jews in the diaspora. With that said, every single sentence he writes on politics is cringe worthy. Nearly every statement is misleading, while accompan...more
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 22 23 next »
topics  posts  views  last activity   
The Crisis of Zionism 1 9 Feb 14, 2012 11:39AM  
  • The World America Made
  • A History of Zionism: From the French Revolution to the Establishment of the State of Israel
  • Strategic Vision: America and the Crisis of Global Power
  • Red Ink: Inside the High-Stakes Politics of the Federal Budget
  • Goliath: Life and Loathing in Greater Israel
  • A History of Israel: From the Rise of Zionism to Our Time (Second Edition, Revised and Updated)
  • Strange Rebels: 1979 and the Birth of the 21st Century
  • Confront and Conceal: Obama's Secret Wars and Surprising Use of American Power
  • Going to Tehran: Why the United States Must Come to Terms with the Islamic Republic of Iran
  • The Victory Lab: The Secret Science of Winning Campaigns
  • The Holocaust Industry: Reflections on the Exploitation of Jewish Suffering
  • The Dictator's Learning Curve: Inside the Global Battle for Democracy
  • Choosing a Jewish Life: A Handbook for People Converting to Judaism and for Their Family and Friends
  • Shut Up, I'm Talking: And Other Diplomacy Lessons I Learned in the Israeli Government--A Memoir
  • The Iron Cage: The Story of the Palestinian Struggle for Statehood
  • The New New Deal: The Hidden Story of Change in the Obama Era
  • Rule and Ruin: The Downfall of Moderation and the Destruction of the Republican Party, from Eisenhower to the Tea Party
  • A Capitalism for the People: Recapturing the Lost Genius of American Prosperity
142602
Peter Beinart is the author of The Crisis of Zionism and The Icarus Syndrome: A History of American Hubris and The Good Fight. A former editor of The New Republic, he is an associate professor of journalism and political science at the City University of New York, a senior fellow at the New America Foundation, and the senior political writer for The Daily Beast. He lives with his family in New Yor...more
More about Peter Beinart...
The Icarus Syndrome: A History of American Hubris The Good Fight: Why Liberals - and Only Liberals - Can Win the War on Terror and Make America Great Again The Good Fight: Terror and the Liberal Spirit The Good Fight: Terror and the Liberal Spirit The Good Fight: Terror and the Liberal Spirit

Share This Book