122nd out of 156 books
—
212 voters
Birthdays for the Dead
De kranten noemen hem 'Birthday Boy'. Al twaalf jaar kidnapt hij meisjes vlak voor hun dertiende verjaardag. Hij eist geen losgeld en laat geen enkel spoor na. Tot de gedupeerde ouders een jaar later een zelfgemaakte verjaardagskaart ontvangen met een foto van hun vermiste dochter ? gekneveld, vastgebonden en gemarteld. Elk jaar stuurt Birthday Boy een nieuwe kaart om de o...more
Hardcover, 472 pages
Published
January 5th 2012
by HarperCollins
(first published January 1st 2012)
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
1,907)
Ash Henderson is a tough cop who doesn't follow the rules. He owes some bad people a buttload of money.
Alice McDonald is a "delightfully quirky" (her own words) superintelligent psychologist who talks. A lot.
Some 13-year-olds get kidnapped, abducted, and photographed into birthday cards for their parents. It's up to Alice and Ash to--
Fuck, dude! How did MacBride get this premise past the drawing board? The most interesting part of the story was my mental image of a girl who'd been decapitated an...more
Alice McDonald is a "delightfully quirky" (her own words) superintelligent psychologist who talks. A lot.
Some 13-year-olds get kidnapped, abducted, and photographed into birthday cards for their parents. It's up to Alice and Ash to--
Fuck, dude! How did MacBride get this premise past the drawing board? The most interesting part of the story was my mental image of a girl who'd been decapitated an...more
Ahhhh, Stuart. You have to give the reader something to hold on to, and your dark-to-laughs ratio has to be even. If you kill your protagonist's older daughter, you have to leave the other one alone. Got about a third through and couldn't keep going. In saying this, it is with a heavy heart because I LOVE Stuart MacBride and have read all of his Logan McRae novels. He is a brilliant writer and usually has an amazing mix of dark and humor. His Inspector Steele is without literary peer.
To call the main character of this book, DC Ash Henderson, an anti-hero or loose cannon would be a vast understatement. He's on the trail of a serial killer known as the Birthday Boy. The killer abducts young girls a few days before their 13th birthday and tortures and kills them. Then every year on the victims birthday he mails a birthday card to the parents along with a photo of the victim showing them bound and gagged as he was torturing them. Henderson's daughter, Rebecca, was also a victim...more
This is a relentlessly dark book featuring a very flawed protagonist. A serial killer is stalking twelve-year-old girls in Scotland. He abducts the children a few days before their thirteenth birthdays, then tortures them over a period of days, killing them on their birthdays. Every year thereafter, he sends a "birthday" card to the parents, with a Polaroid photo attached, showing their daughter's progressive torture and ultimate death.
The newspapers call the killer the "Birthday Boy," and DC A...more
The newspapers call the killer the "Birthday Boy," and DC A...more
If you've read and liked MacBride's Logan McRae series, you will no doubt find yourself at home here. Ash is another downtrodden policemen with dubious morals, bucking the well-meaning but often ineffective policing structure. Unlike Logan, who has decent morals but is often compelled by circumstance (and superiors) into compromising situations, Ash is a darker characters, a gambling, cheating ex-bare knuckle fighter who it's implied worked for a local hood, and who isn't above shaking down susp...more
This is my first Stuart MacBride book, but it won't be my last. First, a caveat: this book is not for the faint of heart. It is grim. Hardcore grim. Some may even say bleak. And it's got the scariest serial killer ever. (Because who DOES that? Who sends parents pictures of their daughters being tortured to death? On their daughter's BIRTHDAY? For YEARS?!
But it's also incredibly funny (it helps if you have a dark sense of humor).
Ash Henderson is the very definition of anti-hero. He's not a very n...more
But it's also incredibly funny (it helps if you have a dark sense of humor).
Ash Henderson is the very definition of anti-hero. He's not a very n...more
Stuart MacBride is another author whose name I was familiar with, but hadn't sampled yet. Well, that's all changed. I just read Birthdays for the Dead and I am hooked.
MacBride grabs you by the throat in the opening prologue and only eases his grip long enough to let you take a breath and then the pressure is back on. Non-stop.
The day's mail includes a birthday card for Detective Constable Ash Henderson's daughter Rebecca - she would have been eighteen. Rebecca went missing days before her thirte...more
MacBride grabs you by the throat in the opening prologue and only eases his grip long enough to let you take a breath and then the pressure is back on. Non-stop.
The day's mail includes a birthday card for Detective Constable Ash Henderson's daughter Rebecca - she would have been eighteen. Rebecca went missing days before her thirte...more
It's every parent's worst nightmare. A serial killer is abducting girls just prior to their thirteenth birthdays, killing them, and then sending their parents pictures of the torture and murder every year on their birthday. Detective Constable Ash Henderson doesn't just want to solve the mystery; he wants to find the body of his daughter. Unfortunately, time does not seem to be on his side, as his younger daughter is approaching her thirteenth birthday.
First, just let me say that readers who are...more
First, just let me say that readers who are...more
I read a lot of crime and psychological thrillers−there are a lot out there! These days most have flawed characters, and I’m referring to the heroes not just the criminals. This is no expectation, but it is different to the others I’ve read. It took a little while for me to get into it. The hero, DC Ash Henderson is to be blunt, a brut. I do wonder at what real cops think about this sort of representation of solving problems with fist first, ask questions later (a real issue as he often beats up...more
Stuart MacBride’s writing has been called “gritty,” and “brilliant.” Understatements both.
In his new standalone mystery/thriller, the author introduces DC Ash Henderson of the Oldcastle Police, formerly DI Ash Henderson – he was busted down to Constable following a particularly horrific phase of an investigation into murders committed by a killer dubbed by the tabloids the “Birthday Boy,” an investigation now eight years old. The victims have all been young girls, abducted within a few days of t...more
In his new standalone mystery/thriller, the author introduces DC Ash Henderson of the Oldcastle Police, formerly DI Ash Henderson – he was busted down to Constable following a particularly horrific phase of an investigation into murders committed by a killer dubbed by the tabloids the “Birthday Boy,” an investigation now eight years old. The victims have all been young girls, abducted within a few days of t...more
Sep 07, 2012
Judie Holliday
rated it
3 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
guilty-pleasures,
scottish
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
This review was originally posted on Cozy Up With A Good Read
I have to say Stuart Macbride is a genius with his writing. This is one of the best crime novels I have read! Stuart is such a gritty writer, there were times I wanted to put this book down because I was a tad disturbed but found myself so enthralled with his writing. I also really love the setting of this book (I really enjoy books that take place in other countries, especially the UK) it's fun getting around a new area and getting us...more
I have to say Stuart Macbride is a genius with his writing. This is one of the best crime novels I have read! Stuart is such a gritty writer, there were times I wanted to put this book down because I was a tad disturbed but found myself so enthralled with his writing. I also really love the setting of this book (I really enjoy books that take place in other countries, especially the UK) it's fun getting around a new area and getting us...more
Dark, VERY dark. Gripping... with more twists than the highland coastline.
This review was originally posted on Up All Night Novels
MacBride takes us on a race against the clock, the good guys versus a mad-man in this novel. While this book isn't my preferred genre, I decided to give it a fair shake.
The characters were enjoyable, if a bit over exaggerated. The dialogue was witty. The plot was solid and well thought out. Even the psychology was mostly on point. But the biggest hang-up for me pers...more
This review was originally posted on Up All Night Novels
MacBride takes us on a race against the clock, the good guys versus a mad-man in this novel. While this book isn't my preferred genre, I decided to give it a fair shake.
The characters were enjoyable, if a bit over exaggerated. The dialogue was witty. The plot was solid and well thought out. Even the psychology was mostly on point. But the biggest hang-up for me pers...more
The first few sentences are stunning!
The author manages to set the mood by putting himself in the head of one of the victims, aged of twelve, facing a serial killer who kills little girls the day of their 13th birthday.
Then, the reader is following an investigation lead by Ash, a detective whose daughter was also removed. Unfortunately in order to stay on the case, he never revealed the disappearance of his own daughter preferring to say she had fled. Because the killer is sadistic enough, he s...more
The author manages to set the mood by putting himself in the head of one of the victims, aged of twelve, facing a serial killer who kills little girls the day of their 13th birthday.
Then, the reader is following an investigation lead by Ash, a detective whose daughter was also removed. Unfortunately in order to stay on the case, he never revealed the disappearance of his own daughter preferring to say she had fled. Because the killer is sadistic enough, he s...more
Was looking for some relaxing reading, and decided that rather than continue Strange Things and Stranger Places, I'd pick up MacBride. Because apparently gritty and rather gruesome Scottish crime fiction is my go-to when I'm stressed and need to unwind.
Some day I will figure this out. Right now I'm just going to kick back and enjoy it working.
========
Finished reading this this morning. It was actually grimmer than I expected, and yes, that's saying something. I was sort of staring at the page,...more
Some day I will figure this out. Right now I'm just going to kick back and enjoy it working.
========
Finished reading this this morning. It was actually grimmer than I expected, and yes, that's saying something. I was sort of staring at the page,...more
My First Macbride... Will not be my last!
I've been a fan of Lee Child and his Jack Reacher novels for a few years, but Birthday's for the Dead is the grittiest crime novel I've read in a long time. With Jack Reacher you often get interaction with the FBI, or other government agencies, ultimately in some nice part of the world. Birthdays for the dead is a totally different kettle of fish. Think gloomy glaswegian skies, heroine junkies and cops that didn't know a rule book existed, let alone read...more
I've been a fan of Lee Child and his Jack Reacher novels for a few years, but Birthday's for the Dead is the grittiest crime novel I've read in a long time. With Jack Reacher you often get interaction with the FBI, or other government agencies, ultimately in some nice part of the world. Birthdays for the dead is a totally different kettle of fish. Think gloomy glaswegian skies, heroine junkies and cops that didn't know a rule book existed, let alone read...more
Feb 18, 2012
Kell
rated it
3 of 5 stars
Recommends it for:
Fans of crime thrillers and Scottish fiction
Shelves:
read-in-2012
Ash Henderson isn't a bad cop; he's one of the good guys, but if there's a bad way to do something for the right reasons, he'll find it. He'd never take a bribe, but it's not unusual for him to put the squeeze on the bad guys to get something out of a situation for him, and he tends to mix with a crowd that means he's permanently in a sticky situation. In short, he's a complete screw-up. Despite all this, there's something very likeable about this train wreck of a man. He's fiercely loyal and pr...more
It's not McBride's best. It's significantly more readable than the last two of his I've read (*Halfhead, (which I absolutely loathed) and *Dark Blood) because unmanageable levels of graphic violence are less endemic. However, the book's written in the first person and the net effect is that the characters are more blurred than in the Logan McRae books - with the narrator the most indefinite because his narratorial style (e.g. the kinds of descriptions he gives of weather/places) sits uneasily wi...more
I started disliking this book right away, but I was determined to give it a chance and read the whole thing. I wish I hadn't. It was just a very difficult read. Not because of the subject matter (which was incredibly dark and depressing), but because the book itself was just difficult to pay attention to.
My main criticisms:
1. There was not even one character I liked or felt invested in.
2. The writing was disjointed and I had a hard time paying attention to the story and keeping track of what was...more
My main criticisms:
1. There was not even one character I liked or felt invested in.
2. The writing was disjointed and I had a hard time paying attention to the story and keeping track of what was...more
This all seems a bit odd to me. If Stuart Macbride was going to write another gritty murder novel from the policeman’s point of view, setting in the North East of Scotland, making it follow the same general pattern as he normally uses, then surely it would make sense to make it another Logan McRae story? I didn't care for it being set in a fictional city just outside his usual hunting ground, as all this did was make me pine for Logan McRae to appear and help out the main character. Having said...more
I actually preferred this book to the later Logan McRae novels. Ash Henderson is as ruthless as the criminals he hunts. In debt to some nasty people, dating a pole dancer, and pretty quick to maim anyone he suspects of harming his daughter, this was a gritty standalone. The Birthday Boy is so called because he abducts girls before their 13th Birthday, then on their birthday, sends a birthday card to the parents with a picture of the girl being tortured on the front. It doesn't stop there, the pa...more
This book has been suggested to me quite a lot recently so I was very keen to try it.
I felt the story for my liking had too many characters, I got a bit lost and confused as to who was who and had to back track quite a bit. The story just didn't flow well for me and I found his style/prose complicated and at times the story was all a bit over the top.
I did like the grittiness,action and plot twists of the book and the ending was very good.
I can tell MacBride is a good crime writer and now wish...more
I felt the story for my liking had too many characters, I got a bit lost and confused as to who was who and had to back track quite a bit. The story just didn't flow well for me and I found his style/prose complicated and at times the story was all a bit over the top.
I did like the grittiness,action and plot twists of the book and the ending was very good.
I can tell MacBride is a good crime writer and now wish...more
In my rush to order this new Stuart MacBride i hadnt read anything about it & presumed it was the new Logan book so i was bitterly disappointed when i soon realised it wasnt .... however, that feeling didnt last for long ... Ash Henderson is another brilliant character, superb story .. i was surprised at some of the reveiws on here which thought the book was too violent ... if you are a fan of Mr Macbride you should know & if you are a newbie you need to know that his main characters sta...more
This book is gross. The hero is a violent jerk and the main female character is a caricature. Adorable and all, but a caricature. I've read most of the Logan McRae books and liked them, but the portrayal of Dr. McDonald made me realize that I've gotten more and more tired of the portrayal of McRae's boss - also a kind of caricature. And I don't mind violence - but this crossed some kind of line for me. I guess I expect the "hero" to be someone I empathize with and root for, but Ash Henderson mos...more
I had a hard time even finishing this book.
The main plot about the serial killer is remotely interesting, but all the subplots are superfluous, when not completely unbelievable. The main character (narrator) is entangled in a lot of complex stories, but he remains shallow and is absolutely not credible. Other characters are caricatural, and none of them is likable either.
A lot of the times, you don't even understand what's going on in the story, it is so messy!
I finished it in a hurry just to k...more
The main plot about the serial killer is remotely interesting, but all the subplots are superfluous, when not completely unbelievable. The main character (narrator) is entangled in a lot of complex stories, but he remains shallow and is absolutely not credible. Other characters are caricatural, and none of them is likable either.
A lot of the times, you don't even understand what's going on in the story, it is so messy!
I finished it in a hurry just to k...more
I was really hooked by the concept of this and found it a quick, easy read despite crime fiction not being a genre I generally have any real interest in. The tension built well after a bit of early waffle, but I never felt it really reached its full potential, and a whole segment about the protagonist being sidetracked to Bath felt needlessly tacked on, as if Macbride needed to up his word count a bit.
That said, everything more or less ties up well at the end, including the jaunt to Bath, but ev...more
That said, everything more or less ties up well at the end, including the jaunt to Bath, but ev...more
Rather violent and nasty, and the narrator is quite the same. He does indeed get treated pretty roughly himself. He also drives a crap car. The only character who appealed to me was Alice MacDonald, the forensic psychologist. Like to see her as a narrator someday.
Rule on villains seems to be to trot them out as very minor characters earlier in the book, so that when we discover that they are the villains we readers cannot complain that they came out of nowhere. But as we are given no clues that...more
Rule on villains seems to be to trot them out as very minor characters earlier in the book, so that when we discover that they are the villains we readers cannot complain that they came out of nowhere. But as we are given no clues that...more
EVERYTHING about this book was awful, absolutely everything!
- The plot is... unplausible is far too weak to describe its craziness. I seriously don't expect crime books to be 100% real but this was so totally out-this-world... I mean, if Ash had at some point been abducted by aliens, I'm not sure I would have raised an eyebrow.
- Too many side stories. One or two can be nice, but not so many... at some points, all names start to blur in.
- Too much unnecessary violence. I read and enjoy dark, go...more
- The plot is... unplausible is far too weak to describe its craziness. I seriously don't expect crime books to be 100% real but this was so totally out-this-world... I mean, if Ash had at some point been abducted by aliens, I'm not sure I would have raised an eyebrow.
- Too many side stories. One or two can be nice, but not so many... at some points, all names start to blur in.
- Too much unnecessary violence. I read and enjoy dark, go...more
Feb 06, 2013
Tori smexys_sidekick
added it
DNF-I was a huge MacBride fan when I was younger. Crime/Mystery fiction was my genre. Birthdays for the Dead doesn't seem like it was written by the same author. The dark and forbidding premise is what drew me in but we get little of the actual mystery and more of day to day lives of the two protagonists and their thoughts and the various what nots involving the mystery. I wasn't able to connect with either of them and it made it hard to continue with the story. I'm pushing it off to the side fo...more
The cover attracted me in the bookshop and then after reading the blurb, it sounded right up my street so I bought it, and I wasn't disappointed.
The premise that there is a serial killer out there who snatches girls and then every year sends a birthday card with a torture photo to the parents is interesting enough, but Ash, the Detective on the case is what made this book, along with Dr Alice McDonald, who for a lot of the book is like a babbling child.
Ash's oldest daughter Rebecca, is an unkn...more
The premise that there is a serial killer out there who snatches girls and then every year sends a birthday card with a torture photo to the parents is interesting enough, but Ash, the Detective on the case is what made this book, along with Dr Alice McDonald, who for a lot of the book is like a babbling child.
Ash's oldest daughter Rebecca, is an unkn...more
| topics | posts | views | last activity | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Kindle English My...: December 2012 Group Read - Birthdays For The Dead by Stuart MacBride | 5 | 20 | Dec 06, 2012 08:28am |
Aka Stuart B. MacBride
The life and times of a bearded write-ist.
Stuart MacBride (that's me) was born in Dumbarton -- which is Glasgow as far as I'm concerned -- moving up to Aberdeen at the tender age of two, when fashions were questionable. Nothing much happened for years and years and years: learned to play the recorder, then forgot how when they changed from little coloured dots to proper music...more
More about Stuart MacBride...
The life and times of a bearded write-ist.
Stuart MacBride (that's me) was born in Dumbarton -- which is Glasgow as far as I'm concerned -- moving up to Aberdeen at the tender age of two, when fashions were questionable. Nothing much happened for years and years and years: learned to play the recorder, then forgot how when they changed from little coloured dots to proper music...more
Share This Book
No trivia or quizzes yet. Add some now »

Loading...

































Nov 19, 2012 02:17pm