Gods Without Men
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating

Gods Without Men

3.64 of 5 stars 3.64  ·  rating details  ·  2,220 ratings  ·  392 reviews
In the desert, you see, there is everything and nothing . . . It is God without men.
—Honoré de Balzac, Une passion dans le désert, 1830

Jaz and Lisa Matharu are plunged into a surreal public hell after their son, Raj, vanishes during a family vacation in the California desert. However, the Mojave is a place of strange power, and before Raj reappears inexplicably unharmed—b...more
ebook, 384 pages
Published March 6th 2012 by Vintage (first published August 4th 2011)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about Gods Without Men, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about Gods Without Men

This book is not yet featured on Listopia. Add this book to your favorite list »

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 3,000)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
switterbug (Betsey)
There’s a sense of both turbulence and utter stillness in Kunzru’s latest novel, and a feeling of vastness and confinement. Spanning 250 years, (non-linearly), the story takes place largely in the xeric and sparsely populated Mojave Desert, at the high-energy Pinnacles, or three-fingered rock formations. The people who populate this novel tend to be restive fringe dwellers, a colorful cast of alien, isolated, and even immortal characters. A Franciscan priest, an anthropologist, hippies, drug add...more
The title is lifted from text in a Honore Balzac short story, but the vibration here -- resonating with themes embracing UFO-ology, quant stock-trading models, cultural clashes and all manner of odd latter-day convergences -- is a long way from 19th century France. In another, more recent era, Gods Without Men might have been labeled 'druggy', edgy, Pynchon-like; today, the author Kunzru seems to be saying, we don't need the drugs to induce the drug-induced consciousness: Just start connecting t...more
Gods without men is a very fascinating book though it left me a little dissapointed in the end as I expected more coherence.
It is easier to set up an intriguing premise and throw in more and more complications and tantalizing stuff but harder to either bring some sense of completion or just keep things rolling but performing a magic trick on the reader so he or she is happy enough with the local resolutions.
David Mitchell did it in his masterpiece Cloud Atlas to which Gods without men compares -...more
Ken Feucht
If Hari Kunzru released a sequel to "Gods Without Men," I would read it in a second. I enjoyed reading the stories of several characters across time focused around a rock formation in the Nevada desert. It's just that the stories didn't end. The main story is sold as being about a couple whose son disappears in the desert and returns "changed." The problem is, the son returns in the last sixth of the book. His story is never really explored.

The same is true of a teenaged Iraqi girl whose back st...more
Brenda Ayala
I frankly don't see what the big deal is about this book. I understand the concept Kunzru was saying. I really do. But I hated this book. I finished it and all I could think was I wasted my time. Frankly, I didn't care about any of the characters. His style was stupid. He introduced us to huge amounts of characters, gave them elaborate backstories that explained how they got to wherever they were, then never mentions them again. What's the point? I now know about Dawn, the woman who joined a cou...more
I loved every last crazy component in this one - the hippie cult making drone music to contact aliens, the old Indian legends that may or may not have come to life, the British rock star trying to get the Laurel Canyon thing, the NY family caught between cultures and stock market crashes, the droll parody of an American military base with an Iraqi girl having to play a fictionalized version of her old life ... every story could've been a full novel on its own, but together they create a time-tri...more
"I've been through the desert on a horse with no name, it felt good to be out of the rain."

The lyrics to that song might as well be playing in the background as you read Gods Without Men, because it's all about the desert.

In the middle of the Mojave there's a butte topped by three spires of rock called the Pinnacles. It's the sort of a place that has a power all its own, and the characters in this novel find themselves drawn there. Skipping through time, from Spanish missionaries in 1778 to a...more
James Murphy
You don't often think of Moby-Dick in connection with the Mojave Desert. However, the white nothingness suggested by the whale is present in the vast empty waste of cactus, sand, wind, sun, and sky. The novelist Don DeLillo is present, too, because Hari Kunzru's Gods Without Men touches on many of the same themes DeLillo concerns himself with: a world defined by signs, some of them seen as sacred, paranoia, a connection between earth and sky, a connection between this world and the Land of the D...more

What could a UFO hippie cult, a British rock star, a Spanish Franciscan priest, the son of a Sikh and his autistic son have in common? The Mohave Desert, for one thing. A search for meaning that connects the earthbound physical plane with the spiritual, for another. In his fourth novel, Hari Kunzru confronts head on the quandries of modern life while walking a fine line between irony and emotion, between serious and lighthearted, without missing a step.

He opens with a piece of flash fiction invo...more
Stories within stories, I enjoyed the complexity. Some of the chapters are wonderfully engaging, but I found I had to struggle through others. If you look at the synopsis, you will understand why. Such a diverse cast of characters! So many intricately woven threads which ultimately result in an unfinished tapestry. Recommended for those with the patience, time and willingness to make connections, and the ability to accept being left with unsolved mysteries.
Mark Rice
Gods Without Men was both compelling and frustrating. Hari Kunzru's descriptive writing is emotive and effective, as is his characterisation. My frustration stemmed from the various plotlines and timelines failing to be tied together to a coherent degree. In that respect, the book could be compared to a literary X-Files, as it leaves the reader to fill in substantial gaps with his/her imagination.

The main characters are Raj Matharu (a four-year-old autistic boy) and his parents, Jaz (an American...more
Marxist Monkey
It might be too strong to call this a masterpiece. Yes, that would be too strong. It might be that my experience of this book has been too strongly effected by my own mild experience of alienation and exile over the past four months. It might be that the accident of my having just read Murakami and Eugenides and Riley has led me to exactly the place where this book could hit as hard as it did.

What is it about? The longing for meaning. The anxiety of parenting. The illusion of meaning and the ill...more
William Thomas
Welcome to the brave new world of literature. Hari Kunzru squeezes himself into the Nu-Nu Literati by beat-boxing out what is mostly snippets of the life stories of, well, one too many people and throws in the odd sci-fi quirk for good measure, just so he can be named in the same sentence as Salman Rushdie when we compare this to something like Shalimar the Clown. Is this what you wanted, Hari? For me to put your name in the post-Gaddis, post-Vollman, post-Pynchon elite? Right there next to that...more
The best novel I read in a long time and I doubt it'll be topped by anything else this year. I can't believe this book didn't get more attention. I mean, if you like Jennifer Egan and/or David Mitchell you should not miss this.
Kunzru does the whole novel of ideas across time and continents thing as Mitchell and his writing has the same refinement if you know what I mean. He also reminds me of Egan with his talent for writing multiple characters in unique and pitch-perfect voices. He steers away...more
George Ilsley
With a cover blurb from David Mitchell, it is not surprising that this novel first evokes The Cloud Atlas. However, this novel skips back and forth and around and it can be hard to keep characters in mind. This book also posed a challenge to the marketing department. It is most often described as being about an autistic boy lost in the desert, and yes, this does happen. On page 190. Obviously the novel is about much more than that, and I suspect the marketing department was scared of mentioning...more
Apr 18, 2012 Ms.pegasus rated it 3 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommends it for: anyone seriously exploring our relationship to death; fans of "The Changeling" by Kenzaburo
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.
Aug 15, 2013 Magdelanye rated it 5 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommends it for: everyone,especially lovers of Ben Okri and Thomas Pynchon
This brilliant romp of a novel crisscrosses the centuries,delightfully illuminating the New Age cliche that everything is connected,especially ancient power spots and people who share the same kind of delusions.

I am sure the only reason people everywhere arent raving about this is the conspiracy against intelligent fun.
I'm still struggling to pin down exactly what this book was about, and I think that is perhaps its greatest strength. It's simply too big and ambitious to be boxed into anything so convenient as an explanation.

My first reaction upon finishing was to throw up my hands in frustration at the tangled mess left by Kunzru, but that lasted all of a minute to be quickly replaced by a steady rumination over the many plot lines. It's a thoughtful book with some of the most perspicacious character sketches...more
4.5 I think. There are places where the writing is just what I want. There are places where the story just delivers. Overall, odd, quirky and engrossing.
This is a knock out of a book because he captured the main character of the book, the Mojave Desert in all its contradictions of desolation and consolation, fullness and barrenness, luxuriousness and starkness. It's a novel about misfits attracted to a mystical, hardscrabble place with a power all its own. I can think of only of Cormac McCarthy and Edward Abbey who also have managed to capture the desert in its brilliant extremes. Having grown up within spitting distance of the locale, Twentynin...more
an incredible novel of modern times usa. a filthy rich physicist slash wall street trader and his writerly stay at home wife and their autistic boy take a trip to mojave desert to sort their shit out because family is disintegrating. they end up in what turns out to be a power center of the universe (who knew?) where novel bops back and forth from 1950's cult leader building a communications device to talk with all the helpful aliens who want to tell us earthlings how to live and 1500's spanish...more
A kind of miracle. A plotless masterpiece. Well, no. There is a plot. It involves a rock formation in the desert. And an autistic boy. And some hippies. And, um, some redneck Indian hunters. No. Wait. This is a metaphysical book about our place in the world. About hope and loss. About humans trying to make sense of things. About feeling small in a big world. No. Wait. It's a book about what happens over the course of a few centuries around a rock formation in the desert in California. And God. O...more
Took me a while to plow through this metaphysical contemplation. I actually almost did not make it, but I kept going. Not going to waste a lot of time writing a review, except to say that it was self-indulgent mental meanderings that did not provoke any new insights or thought patterns in this reader. Glad it was a library borrow.
Anne Fenwick
This was so beautifully written and so intense to read, I had to take it in very small stages, but maybe a lot of that depended on personal experience. I know the area where the book is set, I know about intercultural relationships under stress (ouch!), I even know some autistic kids. I've been trying to think how it works to people who don't have those connections with the subject matter.

I was okay with the alternation between the main story thread and other historical bits though I can imagine...more
Oooops....I just wrote a review and did not save, so will try again. I really liked this book but must confess that I quickly went to the "Reading Group Guide" at the end of my Kindle edition to clarify some plot points I think I missed. Can't say the guide helped much. What did help was reading Goodreads reviews from some enlightened and thoughtful readers. Thanks Goodreads reviewers. I really did not catch what was going on with Coyote the Trickster at the beginning until I read someone's revi...more
Gabriel Nita
În ciuda titlului, inspirat din ceea ce scria Balzac despre deșert (“In the desert, you see, there is everything and nothing… It is God without men”), punct central al romanului lui Hari Kunzru, cartea sa e despre oameni, nu despre zei. Dar despre oameni care au nevoie de credință, de manifestarea miraculoasă a unei ființe superioare, fie ea zeu, extraterestru, algoritm, un Dumnezeu sau altul. Asta în primul plan. În al doilea, este o carte despre America, o colecție de puzzle-uri reunind moment...more
GODS WITHOUT MEN. (2012). Hari Kunzru. ***.
This is not a novel in the normal sense of the word. The central character is really a rock formation in the desert around which the author weaves a set of stories that jump back and forth through time. He manages to cover themes from early American Indian history, to Spanish occupation, up to the present time in a hopscotch manner that left me confused as to what the story was really about. The most coherent part of the book was the exploration of the...more
I found this book to be ambitious but ultimately disappointing. I love the premise. I love the setting. I can accept the disjointed/overlapping ensemble of characters and I can accept a narrative that is not fully resolved. I expected some of that. I can accept to some extent that the primary reason for spending so much time on peripheral characters is more thematic and atmospheric than narrative, though I'm not sure that all of the instances of this served that end. Rather than suggesting some...more
Bonnie Brody
Gods Without Men tells about the mystery of the high desert in what is now San Bernardino County, California. Hari Kuzru is a masterful storyteller, weaving legend, Native American culture, hippie life and the disappearance of an autistic child into a compelling weave of interlocking narratives with the power of myth.

The novel features a fantastic cast of characters who run through time from the late 1700's to 2009. What holds them all together is their connection to the mysteries of the high de...more
Definitely Pynchonesque, Gods Without Men weaves different narratives complete with divergent timelines into one big mysterious, yet fully integrated tale. There's a place in the Mojave desert that continues, through time, to have a profound mystical influence on the characters that find it. From Franciscan monks following angels to naturalists encountering glowing ghost indians to hippies speaking with aliens, everyone seems affected in ways that change the courses of their lives. Kunzru change...more
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 99 100 next »
topics  posts  views  last activity   
21st Century Lite...: 4/14 Gods Without Men - Second Half 43 34 Jun 04, 2014 01:49AM  
21st Century Lite...: 4/14 Gods Without Men First Half 17 40 Apr 25, 2014 12:17AM  
21st Century Lite...: April 2014 Moderator Pick 3 61 Mar 12, 2014 12:37PM  
Goodreads Librari...: Combine 2 15 Aug 11, 2012 11:59PM  
What happened to Raj? 3 51 May 27, 2012 05:21PM  
Gwinnett County P...: Gods Without Men 1 16 Mar 29, 2012 06:17AM  
  • Almost Never
  • How the Dead Dream
  • City of Bohane
  • Collected Poems
  • By Blood
  • The Right-Hand Shore
  • At Last
  • Varamo
  • Fobbit
  • Sessiz Ev
  • Middle C
  • San Miguel
  • Three Strong Women
  • Rule and Ruin: The Downfall of Moderation and the Destruction of the Republican Party, from Eisenhower to the Tea Party
  • Red Brick, Black Mountain, White Clay: Reflections on Art, Family, and Survival
  • Mistaken
  • Parallel Stories
  • Shout Her Lovely Name
Hari Mohan Nath Kunzru (born 1969) is a British novelist and journalist, author of the novels The Impressionist, Transmission and My Revolutions. Of mixed English and Kashmiri Pandit ancestry, he grew up in Essex. He studied English at Wadham College, Oxford University, then gained an MA in Philosophy and Literature from Warwick University. His work has been translated into twenty languages. He li...more
More about Hari Kunzru...
The Impressionist My Revolutions Transmission Memory Palace Noise (Pocket Penguin 70's #20)

Share This Book

“What if one were to want to hunt for these hidden presences? You can’t just rummage around like you’re at a yard sale. You have to listen. You have to pay attention. There are certain things you can’t look at directly. You need to trick them into revealing themselves. That’s what we’re doing with Walter, Jaz. We’re juxtaposing things, listening for echoes. It’s not some silly cybernetic dream of command and control, modeling the whole world so you can predict the outcome. It’s certainly not a theory of everything. I don’t have a theory of any kind. What I have is far more profound.’

‘What’s that?’

‘A sense of humor.’

Jaz looked at him, trying to find a clue in his gaunt face, in the clear gray eyes watching him with such - what? Amusement? Condescension? There was something about the man which brought on a sort of hermeneutic despair. He was a forest of signs.

‘We’re hunting for jokes.’ Bachman spoke slowly, as if to a child. ‘Parapraxes. Cosmic slips of the tongue. They’re the key to the locked door. They’ll help us discover it.’

‘Discover what?’

‘The face of God. What else would we be looking for?”
“Driving was almost the only thing that felt natural in America. It was traditional. It was patriotic. When you accelerated, you could almost hear the crowd cheering you on.” 3 likes
More quotes…