my rating:

add to my books

The Luxe (Luxe #1)

by Anna Godbersen

3.72 · rating details · 7,523 ratings · 1,550 reviews

A big, sumptuous tale of catty girls, dark secrets and windswept romance unfurls in this compulsively readable novel of late-19th-century New York City socialites. Godbersen weaves a tenuous web of deceit, backstabbing and pretense that follows four teens: Elizabeth Holland, a prim and proper lady of old-money society, is betrothed to one man, though furtively loves anothe ...more

Hardcover, 433 pages

Published November 20th 2007 by HarperCollins

more details... edit details

WorldCat | More…

There is a good chance some of your friends read this book. Sign in to see!

friend reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

lists with this book

The Hunger Games (Hunger Games, #1) by Suzanne Collins

City of Bones (The Mortal Instruments, #1) by Cassandra Clare

Vampire Academy (Vampire Academy, #1) by Richelle Mead

Books That Should Be Made Into Movies

40th out of 3115 books — 7465 voters

A Great and Terrible Beauty (Hardcover) by Libba Bray

The Witch of Blackbird Pond (Mass Market Paperback) by Elizabeth George Speare

The Book Thief (Hardcover) by Markus Zusak

Number the Stars (Mass Market Paperback) by Lois Lowry

Teen Historical Fiction

3rd out of 196 books — 554 voters

More lists with this book...

community reviews

(showing 1-30 of 12,554)

filter | sort: default (?) | rating details

Feb 27, 2008

Nian rated it

Recommends it for: love triangle readers

Shelves: 2008

The Holland sisters, Elizabeth and Diana, are at the top of the social ladder. When their father dies, the girls move away to get educated about being a proper lady and when they come back, they find out that things don’t look too good for the Holland family. They’re broke. But if Mrs. Holland has anything to say about it, they won’t be, not for long. If Elizabeth can marry Henry Schoonmaker—a man who’s so handsome he has the hearts of all eligible females—their family name won’t b ...more The Holland sisters, Elizabeth and Diana, are at the top of the social ladder. When their father dies, the girls move away to get educated about being a proper lady and when they come back, they find out that things don’t look too good for the Holland family. They’re broke. But if Mrs. Holland has anything to say about it, they won’t be, not for long. If Elizabeth can marry Henry Schoonmaker—a man who’s so handsome he has the hearts of all eligible females—their family name won’t be smeared. But Elizabeth already has her heart set on Will, who is just a mere stable boy, and Penelope, Liz’s supposed best friend, wants Henry. And where’s Diana all this time? Falling in love with Henry, of course. Rich girls always get what they want, but there’s just one Henry to go around.

Plenty of reviews I’ve read had it labeled as a cross between Pride & Prejudice and Gossip Girl. I think not. The concept about rich girls leading scandalous lives in Manhattan, though set in 1899 for The Luxe, and how marriage was just beneficial for status upholding, is the same. Everything else, not really.

I think this is even worse than Gossip Girl. Just like I didn’t see the point in the latter, I failed to see this book as none other than a boring read with underdeveloped characters who basically whine and never take control. Take Elizabeth, for instance. Right from the beginning she’s introduced as this beautiful and proper young lady who’s involved with a servant but is engaged to the most set-forth bachelor, Henry. The parts written about her fall bland shortly after she’s engaged. She does absolutely nothing except to look blank and regretful. I find it very hard to reach some level of sympathy for a character that’s mostly just a background face because the author failed to incorporate some kind of human being qualities to her. It’s like this: Anna Godbersen wanted to portray a perfect girl that didn’t have a perfect life after all (the most common storyline ever beside the love-hate relationships type) and rather than making Elizabeth her main character, she made her into a depressed girl. Everything that happens in the novel surrounds Elizabeth’s life and her actions, but I just don’t see her as a focus. Sure, she finally finds the strength to do something towards the end of the book, but that’s because Penelope was there to help her. Can’t she do anything by herself? She’s just a horrible protagonist and if that’s the message—get your own independence—then the author’s done a poor job of relaying that.

Take notice that this book has 433 pages. 433 pages of slow action and mindless characters that just appear and disappear so they can serve in certain parts of the story. A story isn’t supposed to be like that—everything has to connect somehow. And the most unflattering character is Diana. From the start, I never saw that kind of bond between her and Elizabeth that’s made Diana so sobby at the last minute. She’s been portrayed as this whinny, kind of unusual sister. But later, she does all sorts of things that contradict the personality she’s been given, which I find very inconsistent. If there’s character development involved, there has to be a turning point for that to happen, but I didn’t see it.

All in all, not something I would ever pick up again. I thought GG had been a reminder that I should stay away from stories about rich girls with nothing to do but have sex and steal other people’s boyfriends. I like books with some kind of message, with development, with strong-willed protagonists that makes everything better, but I found nothing of the requirements here. I’m just glad I gave up halfway but decided to read the ending chapters anyway. Two words: so predictable.

But if you actually like the endless, unrealistic love triangles (why would anyone like Henry, anyway? He’s such an arrogant ass) between Elizabeth-Will-Lina and Diana-Henry-Penelope, or the fact that the girls wear gowns and everyone rides horses, then this probably is the book for you. I mean, at least some of the history was nailed pretty accurately, thought most facts were just mentioned in passing. (less)

like 11 likes add a comment

Jan 04, 2009

Shannon rated it

· review of another edition

Recommended to Shannon by: Julie

Shelves: 2009, historical-romance, mystery-suspense, ya

It's September 1899 and the Manhattan season is starting off with a bang. Elizabeth Holland, the darling of the high society set, has returned from her year in Paris in time for the first ball of the season, held at her best friend Penelope Hayes' newly finished and incredibly vulgar mansion. Penelope is all about showing herself to the best advantage, and has her sights set on young rake Henry Schoonmaker - but his father has other ideas. Intending to run for mayor the following year, he wants ...more

like 15 likes add a comment

Jan 18, 2008

Jessica rated it

Shelves: youngadult

Hmmm. This is an interesting book. It is, as the name implies, very luxe. The gown descriptions are sumptuous, and all the characters are gorgeous, with thick curling hair and full pouty lips. However, I had a hard time figuring out who to root for, as it were. You don't really get deep insights into Elizabeth, ostensibly the heroine, and her handsome lover's thoughts are never known at all. The villainess bitchy girl, the little sister, the rich cad, all get more detailed character develo ...more

like 6 likes add a comment

Mar 30, 2009

Misty rated it

Recommended to Misty by: Ashley

Shelves: cover-appeal, disappointing-or-excited-for-nothin, historical, juvenile-ya, read-in-2009, recommended, ya-challenge

I would maybe go as high as a 2.5 for this, but really no higher (sorry Ashley and Jenn).
The Luxe is about turn of the century New York socialites falling in love and misbehaving. New York's darling debutant, Elizabeth Holland is poised to marry one of the most eligible (and debaucherous) bachelors in the city, but her perfect life is not what it seems.
The Luxe reads like Gossip Girl meets Edith Wharton. Sadly, it has all of the shallowness and poor writing of the former, with l ...more I would maybe go as high as a 2.5 for this, but really no higher (sorry Ashley and Jenn).
The Luxe is about turn of the century New York socialites falling in love and misbehaving. New York's darling debutant, Elizabeth Holland is poised to marry one of the most eligible (and debaucherous) bachelors in the city, but her perfect life is not what it seems.
The Luxe reads like Gossip Girl meets Edith Wharton. Sadly, it has all of the shallowness and poor writing of the former, with little of the intelligence and power of the latter. Godbersen does her best to make the time period interesting and appealing to today's teen girl audience, but the result is predictable, flat and strange. It really is as if the GGs had put on costumes and were playing at The Age Of Innocence: their actions and dialogue is not well-suited to the time or the story. This isn't to say that they can't be scandalous; I don't buy into a white-washed history. I know people always have skeletons in their closets, regardless of the mores of the time. More so, even, in a repressive society. Wharton demonstrated that expertly. But the actions of the characters in this book seem too careless and intentionally shocking, and as such seems silly. It's hard as well to feel for the characters. They have very few redeeming qualities, and I was torn between wanting them to have the happy ending that was (obviously-parading-as-stealthily) coming and seeing them get what they actually deserved.
The structuring was a bit weird for me as well, especially when it came to conversations between the characters. One character would say something, and then Godbersen would spend a whole nice-sized paragraph describing something (the rich scene, someone's dress, some incident from the past, whatever), and then the character who was spoken to would respond. By that point, I was completely out of the flow of conversation and had no idea what had been said in the first place and had to look back to follow the thread of dialogue. It was a strange choice on her part and her editor's. And though some description of finery and scene were necessary, they were a bit overdone and tended to overwhelm the story (or maybe mask a lack of it); if I had had to read about 'pocket doors' one more effing time, I may have had a fit of hysterics like some of the characters were prone to.
This is not to say that teen girls won't find this book just heart-flutteringly terrific. If Godbersen set out to write a soap opera dressed up as historical literature, she succeeded at that, and there is a market for it. For me though, it's a shame it didn't live up to its pretty cover.

Various bonus goodies here> (less)

like 11 likes 8 comments

Dec 29, 2007

Karin rated it

Shelves: 2008-reads, youngadult

If you didn't think the nineteenth century was full of drama then think again. Life in New York in 1899 was very eventful. At least it was for the very wealthy. Elizabeth Holland has been a perfect daughter her entire nineteen years of life. She has been groomed for years to be perfect - to talk when she was supposed to, to receive visitors on Sundays, and always appear happy no matter when she was feeling on the inside. People in New York expect her to marry well and continue the tradition ...more If you didn't think the nineteenth century was full of drama then think again. Life in New York in 1899 was very eventful. At least it was for the very wealthy. Elizabeth Holland has been a perfect daughter her entire nineteen years of life. She has been groomed for years to be perfect - to talk when she was supposed to, to receive visitors on Sundays, and always appear happy no matter when she was feeling on the inside. People in New York expect her to marry well and continue the traditions of high society.

Life for Elizabeth isn't easy though, even though all she has to do is sit around and look beautiful. It turns out, since the death of her father, her family is having financial problems and aren't able to keep up the type of lifestyle they are used to living. One thousand dollar gowns, priceless works of art, and trips abroad are a thing of the past unless something can be done to secure the family's place in society before everyone learns of their trouble. Mrs. Holland thinks Elizabeth can save the family by marrying Henry Schoonmaker – New York's most eligible and most sought after bachelor.

The news of her impending engagement is a surprise to Elizabeth. She has always held out the hope that she would marry for love and in fact, has been in love for quite some time. Elizabeth has been having a secret relationship with Will Keller for many years. The relationship must be kept a secret because Will is an employee of the Holland family. He works in the stables and drives the carriages for them and carrying on a relationship with someone of lower status would be something that would ruin Elizabeth's reputation and the Holland family name. Word of her engagement puts a strain, understandably, on Elizabeth's relationship with Will.

Elizabeth's secret relationship with Will isn't the only thing that becomes more difficult after the wedding becomes public. Henry doesn't want to get married any more than Elizabeth does. He resents the fact that he is being forced to wed and give up his freedom. Penelope, her supposed best friend, is infuriated by the news of the wedding. She expected to marry Henry herself and is planning to break up the wedding by any means necessary. Elizabeth's personal maid, Lina, finds out about Elizabeth and Will's relationship and is hurt because she has grown to love Will herself. Even more problems crop up when Elizabeth's younger sister, Diana, begins to have feelings for Henry. Finally, and most devastating to Elizabeth, Will tells her he is leaving New York and heading west to California. How can a proper girl deal with all of these problems and be expected retain her poise?

THE LUXE is a fascinating look at life at the turn of the century. It is historical fiction at its best. For those of you that fall in love with the book like I have can look forward to the fact that the author is currently working on a sequel.
(less)

like 6 likes add a comment

Jan 09, 2009

Angie rated it

Shelves: bibliocrack, good-uns

Another Christmas gift, and one I wanted to read very much when it first came out, but shied away from somewhat after reading several reviews comparing it to the Gossip Girl series and stating that the writing left rather a lot to be desired. Oh, I thought sadly. That's too bad. It looked better than that. So I just admired the cover from afar, and that of the sequel Rumors. I probably would have just gone on ignoring the series if my mom hadn't given me a copy of The Luxe. I'm glad she did.
...more Another Christmas gift, and one I wanted to read very much when it first came out, but shied away from somewhat after reading several reviews comparing it to the Gossip Girl series and stating that the writing left rather a lot to be desired. Oh, I thought sadly. That's too bad. It looked better than that. So I just admired the cover from afar, and that of the sequel Rumors. I probably would have just gone on ignoring the series if my mom hadn't given me a copy of The Luxe. I'm glad she did.

The prologue begins with Elizabeth Holland's funeral. The darling of upper crust Manhattan society, her sudden and inexplicable drowning in the Hudson shocks everyone from her frozen fiance Henry Schoonmaker to her scornful maid Lina Broud. The story then immediately jumps back several weeks to show us how events came to such a strange state. You think Elizabeth is going to be the main character, but she's not. She's not even very likable. Quiet, passive, perfect. Perfectly boring. That's Elizabeth. And that's why her best friend Penelope Hayes hates her. Everyone assumes Henry and Elizabeth would be perfect together, while Penelope is determined to have him for herself. And if you're wondering right now if the whole thing is as Peyton Place as it sounds thus far, the answer is yes. Yes it is. It's a roiling sea of love, despair, social climbing, and backstabbing. In perfectly lovely period costumes. It's hypnotic.

The story spends time going back and forth between five Victorian teens: Elizabeth, Henry, Penelope, Lina, and Diana (Elizabeth's younger, much more likable sister). And for awhile I kept thinking, Why am I reading this? These characters are perfectly awful. But then Diana became cool. Or rather I could tell she was going to become someone who was going to be cool. So I was reading it for Diana. The others I could take or leave. But then Henry started showing some good sense and just the slightest hint of a backbone, despite his apalling sense of entitlement. So I was reading it for Diana and Henry. And the dresses. Oh, the dresses. And because I enjoyed seeing Penelope swallow her own tongue when she finds out a certain couple are engaged. And, in the end, it was like watching a train wreck. A beautiful, awful train wreck. And I couldn't tear my eyes away from it. I had to run to the library to get a copy of Rumors to see What Happens. That review to follow shortly. (less)

like 6 likes 2 comments

May 06, 2008

Jennifer Wardrip rated it

Shelves: trt-posted-reviews

Reviewed by Julie M. Prince for TeensReadToo.com

One of the elite, one of the daughters of New York society, is dead.

In life, the lovely and fair Elizabeth Holland is everything a young, turn-of-the-century girl of her position ought to be. But, it's not easy to be proper and mannerly all the time, and a handsome servant who lives in the stable gets to see more of her than anyone else -- much, much more.

No one knows of their secret affair, except Miss Holland ...more Reviewed by Julie M. Prince for TeensReadToo.com

One of the elite, one of the daughters of New York society, is dead.

In life, the lovely and fair Elizabeth Holland is everything a young, turn-of-the-century girl of her position ought to be. But, it's not easy to be proper and mannerly all the time, and a handsome servant who lives in the stable gets to see more of her than anyone else -- much, much more.

No one knows of their secret affair, except Miss Holland's personal maid, Lina. Why did Elizabeth Holland have to go and pick Lina's love interest to treat as her personal plaything? Isn't it enough that the wealthy and admired young lady is betrothed to New York's most eligible bachelor?

Henry Schoonmaker doesn't even want to marry the prim and boring Miss Holland. He's having too much fun living a carefree life and having a secret affair with his fiancé's best friend, Penelope Hayes. But, that sister of Elizabeth's, she is truly spirited. Yes, maybe Diana is the Holland sister for him. Maybe he should defy his father's wishes and forget about Elizabeth...and Penelope.

But, Penelope simply will not be forgotten. Henry Schoonmaker belongs to her. It should be her name linked with his in all the society papers. She'll do whatever it takes to get him back.

The twists and turns readers navigate throughout this book are staggering. With so many different perspectives to balance, the story could become difficult to follow, but author Anna Godbersen deftly guides her readers through the tale.

It can be unclear at times where loyalties should lie, with so many scandalous doings underway. However, this only further adds to the big picture of New York's upper crust society and the games its elitist members must play in order to stay on top.

The mystery of Elizabeth Holland's impending death will keep readers riveted, and by the story's end, they will be crying out for a sequel. I join their ranks in hoping this debut novelist will comply. (less)

like 3 likes add a comment

Jul 13, 2008

Alea rated it

Two sisters, a servant girl, a best friend, and a hot mess of a boy. Throw in two-ish love triangles and you've got The Luxe. I kept reading and reading about this book, just like I had done with Twilight and then decided I just better read the darn book. I'm sure glad I did. What a fun book. It's set in 1899 New York City and alternates the five main characters points of view. I think the alternating viewpoints really made this book for me. I just can't get enough of that. The book ends not unl ...more

like 4 likes 4 comments

Nov 10, 2008

Kathryn marked it as to-read

Recommends it for: NOBODY

Recommended to Kathryn by: The Cover

I hate, hate, HATE books that are suppose to be set in one time period but they have the behavor of someone in a different time period. If I didn't know better, I would have thought that this books was set in the present time. I won't ruin it for anyone who wants to read it... but I was disappointed. I thought "How could such a pretty book not be good?" I always thought that not judging a book by its cover was about ugly books being good, but now I know better.

However, if ...more

like 5 likes 1 comment

Dec 10, 2009

Tatiana rated it

Recommends it for: fans of "Gossip Girls" and such

Recommended to Tatiana by: self-inflicted out of morbid curiosity

Shelves: annoyed-the-crap-out-of-me, graveyard-of-spoiled-or-bad-series, why-is-this-popular, ya

Sorry, but I can't go on reading this drivel. Maybe I am too spoiled by Edith Wharton and know too much about Gilded Age mores to enjoy this book. I know that young men and women of that time simply do not behave, talk, or live the way Godbersen portrays in her books. If you take the historical setting out of the story, what's left is a who-will-hook-up-with-who kind of trash. If I ever want to read that, I'll pick up Gossip Girls.

Beautiful cover though...

like 2 likes 32 comments

Jul 22, 2010

Derek rated it

The Luxe is a story of high society girls who aren't as nice as they seem. Back when NYC still had horse drawn carriages as the main mode of transportation and Van Wyk was the mayor not a highway in Queens. Love triangles add to secrets that may bring to the demise of the social lives of some of the characters. I thought this book was immensly entertaining. At first it went slow for me but after the first three chapters I was into it. I was caught up in the lavish descriptions of their dresses ...more

like 1 like add a comment

Oct 08, 2009

Heather rated it

· review of another edition

Recommends it for: Lovers of Bad Boys and Gossip Girl

Shelves: 2009, historical-fiction, ya

Well, Godbersen is no Edith Wharton, but who is? I went into this book expecting it to read like historical fiction with a bit of scandalous intrigue, but got Gossip Girl in a Victorian setting instead.

Godbersen mentions clothing and internal decoration about a thousand times too many for my taste. I really don't care to know every detail about every outfit the characters are wearing, but I allowed it as these women are just sad little cutouts, and it would seem natural for their t ...more

like 2 likes 2 comments

Apr 25, 2009

Courtney rated it

Shelves: favorites, historical

One big love triangle between Henry Schonnmocker, Diana Holland, Will Kellar, Elizabeth Holland, Penelope Hazes, Lina Broad, and Teddy. Elizabeth is having an affair with her coachmen, Will. Naturally their forbiden love is kept a secret. The Holland family begins losing money, forcing Elizabeth into an engagment with the charming casanova, Henry Schonnmocker. There's a few problems with that however:Penelope has a delusional infatuation with Henry but Henry is having a love struck affair with E ...more

like 3 likes 2 comments

Sep 09, 2008

Josie rated it

Shelves: historical, young-adult

Nineteenth century Manhattan has never been portrayed so catty or dissolute as it is in this young adult novel. Like Gossip Girl, but with bigger frocks, Anna Godberson’s The Luxe tells the story of the beautiful Holland sisters, their Queen Bee friend Penelope Hayes, and the man they all seem to revolve around, the eligible Henry Schoonmaker. The Hollands are bankrupt, and the only way to save their fortunes before their situation is known, is for the eldest daughter Elizabeth to marry money. ...more

like 2 likes add a comment

Jul 13, 2008

Kristi (The Story Siren) rated it

Shelves: books-i-own

Beautiful Elizabeth Holland, lovely, prim, proper and of course a lady. Too bad she is dead. The story opens to a dreary day in late 19th century New York at the funeral of Miss Elizabeth Holland, the exact day in which she was to be wed.

Then time flashes back and we are taken through the events that ultimately lead to the death of Elizabeth.

Sisters Elizabeth and Diana couldn’t be more different. Elizabeth, the oldest, has always had the most pre ...more Beautiful Elizabeth Holland, lovely, prim, proper and of course a lady. Too bad she is dead. The story opens to a dreary day in late 19th century New York at the funeral of Miss Elizabeth Holland, the exact day in which she was to be wed.

Then time flashes back and we are taken through the events that ultimately lead to the death of Elizabeth.

Sisters Elizabeth and Diana couldn’t be more different. Elizabeth, the oldest, has always had the most pressure put on her to be a proper lady, to watch everything she says, does, and even wears. Diana is of course the opposite. She is the romantic, and she is wonderfully eclectic and confident in her ways.

When Elizabeth learns that her family’s welfare is in jeopardy she agrees to wed Henry Schoonmaker, a well-known playboy and heartbreaker, even though she loves another. Henry himself agrees to marry Elizabeth only so he will not be disinherited of his father’s fortune. At the night of her engagement announcement, her "best friend" Penelope Hayes reveals that she, herself is in love with Henry. This is the start of Penelope’s jealousy and betrayal to take down her biggest and only rival. Not to mention, Diana, who finds herself smitten with the elusive Henry, as well. Henry of course finds himself falling in love, finally, but not with his betrothed. Elizabeth struggles with her own happiness and the welfare of her family.
Throw in a jealous maid that knows too much and you have yourself a full-blown scandal!

I loved The Luxe. It had everything a good story should. Mystery, humor, romance, and fun! I felt for Elizabeth and her constant struggle within herself, and having nowhere to turn. I loathed Penelope and only wished she had been the one to fall in the Hudson. The Luxe was enjoyable and entertaining. If you like Gossip Girls or even A Great and Terrible Beauty, I think that you would enjoy this book. Even more good news. It seems that Anna Godbersen will be releasing a sequel to The Luxe in the summer of 2008 entitled Rumors.
(less)

like 4 likes 1 comment

Mar 14, 2008

Elizabeth rated it

Recommends it for: teen girls

Shelves: recentlyread, ya

I've seen this book compared to Gossip Girl, and I don't think that's an entirely fair analogy. I can see where it came from; the main characters are well-to-do New Yorkers, and there is an emphasis on beauty and backstabbing. However, it was much better written than GG.

I admit I've only read one GG, inspired to do so because I like the show. I've marveled, in fact, at how the writers of the show managed to get such a well done show out of the source material, because the one that I ...more I've seen this book compared to Gossip Girl, and I don't think that's an entirely fair analogy. I can see where it came from; the main characters are well-to-do New Yorkers, and there is an emphasis on beauty and backstabbing. However, it was much better written than GG.

I admit I've only read one GG, inspired to do so because I like the show. I've marveled, in fact, at how the writers of the show managed to get such a well done show out of the source material, because the one that I read was BAD. The Luxe manages to keep the perspective consistent within chapters, and to have an actual, realized plot (building action, climax, denoument). It also had characters that were more than just caricatures. GG had none of that- the perspective jumped around within a single scene, and seemed more focused on titillating its audience with sex, drinking, drugs, and high end clothing that with telling any sort of story or developing characters in any way beyond what they were wearing and who they were screwing. I suppose it could be said the The Luxe resembles the show, if it were set at the end of the nineteenth century, but I have to give credit where credit is due, and The Luxe surpasses GG, the novels.

That said, while the story is complete and decently written, it's hugely predictable. I had the end figured out pretty much by the time all the main characters were introduced. The prologue, while serving to add a sense of suspense to lure the reader into the story, also makes it painfully obvious where things are headed once the reader is given all the puzzle pieces. I've seen the same sort of plot laid out in countless historical romances- the good girl who has more beneath the surface; the wild, independant young lady; the rake who is ready to be reformed by the right woman; the jealous, villainous spurned mistress. That's not to say the book isn't worth reading; I have the benefit of being nearly 30, and having been exposed to all the romance novel plot devices under the sun. For its intendend audience, teen girls, The Luxe would be a fabulous introduction to that genre of writing. It's got a dab of history, a fun plot, and a twisty love story. Moreover, it's "clean" (which is another thing that separates it from GG)- there is some sexual behavior, but it's handled with a tasteful fade to black, and there is a some drinking, but in the two instances of someone becoming drunk, there are negative consequences. I'm not a prude (I like my smut good and smutty), but I do think there is a difference between writing for 13-17 year old girls, and for adults.

Overall, I'd say this book isn't one that's going to cross the generation gap well, but it's a fun, appropriate read for teens looking for something that has all the best things about GG and none of the worst. (less)

like 5 likes 1 comment

Dec 30, 2007

Rebecca rated it

unfortunately, I left this at home over the weekend, so progress is stalled.
here are my thoughts half-way through, and I don't expect them to change:

1. every review I caught of this made it out to be "gossip girl, 1899"--it's not. the comparison is obvious enough (rich kids, new york...1899...there are even some amazingly parallel characters that would make me mad if I were Cecily von Ziegesar), but it's inaccurate. Gossip Girl, while trashy, and fraught with gross m ...more unfortunately, I left this at home over the weekend, so progress is stalled.
here are my thoughts half-way through, and I don't expect them to change:

1. every review I caught of this made it out to be "gossip girl, 1899"--it's not. the comparison is obvious enough (rich kids, new york...1899...there are even some amazingly parallel characters that would make me mad if I were Cecily von Ziegesar), but it's inaccurate. Gossip Girl, while trashy, and fraught with gross materialism and brand-dropping, actually has some interesting things going on in the story. The Luxe is slow-moving and predictable; there's no playing around with the idea of narrator,the characters are flat and it's hard to identify with any of them... It's much more like Austen/Bronte/Thackeray fair, but with dumbed down contemporary writing. Despite the simpler writing, it takes just as much determination to press through the text (because it's dull); and for that, I think most Gossip Girl readers are going to be baffled when people recommend this book to them. My guess is they'll give up before they get to the first coy tilt of the head and mild cloakroom romp.

1a. some reviews I read suggested this for fans of A Great and Terrible Beauty...I think that's just cover-confusion. Fans of the cover of A Great and Terrible Beauty will also probably like the cover of The Luxe. I do think it's a striking cover.

2. every review I caught also praised The Luxe/Godbersen for terrific historic facts. Really? I'm doubting that. I mean, I don't know enough to know for sure, but I have a running list of things to check. For one thing, even if Holland was a common name in late 19th century New York City, I feel like an author could trust her readers to interpret a more subtle name (van der Woodsen, say), instead of being so heavy-handed with the "old Dutch Family" thing. There are some neat tidbits of new york history, things to make it fun...mention of farms, the old age of gramercy park, fifth avenue starting to be developed...but I'm not sure it's enough history to merit all the history-praise.

3. it's fun enough. and the cover might be powerful enough to lure some unsuspecting YA readers. (less)

like 1 like 1 comment

Dec 30, 2008

Denise Smith rated it

First, I can't believe that this is considered Youth Fiction! It definitely read like it was written for a teenage audience, but there was way too much sex, even if it was only ever implied. It was incredibly predictable and the characters were extremely unlikable. Beware, moms of teenage girls, this book was recommended to me as the "next big thing".

like 4 likes 5 comments

May 21, 2008

Adriana rated it

Shelves: ya-friendship, ya-historical-fiction-romance-socia

This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.

like 1 like 2 comments

Sep 23, 2009

Julia rated it

Shelves: 2009, youngadult

I have been trying to resist this book for awhile now, but I just can't. The cover looks like a big piece of deliciousness. I want to both eat that huge cupcake-lookin' dress and be wearing it. Look at it, seriously! How do you not want to fall asleep. I love rich historical details, but I'm not really a gossip girl fan, so we'll see how this goes. But right now I think I'm completely up for some sweet-frosted-angel-food-cake-dress wearin' society ladies up to no good.

like 2 likes add a comment

Aug 17, 2009

Katherine rated it

Shelves: ya-fiction

Modern day Manhattan materialism meets a clunky and inconsistent interpretation of the late 1800's. Cool cover though.

like 1 like add a comment

Oct 12, 2008

Sarah rated it

Shelves: 2008, young-adult

It took a while to really get into this book, but about halfway through, it happened. For the most part, Godbersen was clearly influenced by my favorite American author, Edith Wharton. And Godbersen uses Wharton's world, almost, in her novel. It's turn of the 19th century New York, and it's high society complete with love and betrayal and lies and ... everything. In fact, Godbersen even pays homage to Wharton by including a very close likeness of Wharton herself in the book. Looking forward to t ...more

like 1 like 1 comment

Feb 18, 2009

Emily rated it

Looking for a page-turning mystery/romance/turn-of-the-century-social-commentary? You have found it. While it is definitely a teen novel, and Godbersen makes no pretense of subtlety in her mimicking of Edith Wharton's 1899 New York, I really enjoyed the story and the writing.

Her sentence structure and word choice are carefully crafted. (Her writing occasionally feels as corseted as the girls she writes about; and while the historically accurate details prove she has done a lot of r ...more

like 1 like add a comment

Feb 16, 2009

Jaime rated it

· review of another edition

Recommends it for: fans of Gossip Girl

This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here. Summary:

Five teens living in turn of the century Manhattan face difficult decisions when it comes to love and duty. When the Holland sisters find their family in sudden poverty, one sister must decide whether to remain destitute and marry for love, or marry to maintain their family's wealthy reputation.

Characters:

Elizabeth Holland- A quiet, polite girl who falls for her family's coachman, Will, but is forced to be engaged to Henry so that her family may have m ...more

like add a comment

Jan 24, 2009

Jenn rated it

Think Gossip Girl meets turn of the century. All of the fabulous balls, gorgeous gowns, gossip, scandal and secrets that you love in early 1900s New York City.

The story starts out with Elizabeth Holland's funeral. She was the "it" girl and all of the who's who has come out in fabulous style to see and be seen. (and to grieve of course) There is Penelope Hayes. Penelope is the exotic, nouveau riche best friend of Elizabeth. We are also introduced to the very rich playboy H ...more

like add a comment

Jul 16, 2007

Angie Ungaro rated it

Recommends it for: Romance, Historical Fic, & Gossip Girl readers

Shelves: book_club_books-ya-industry, ya_books

Indeed. Godbersen brings sexy back to 19th century New York. It's like Paris (and Perez!) Hilton but with corsets and quadrilles. High society has never been so scandalous or scandalized. Added bonus, the "love-making" in this book is way more gratifying than any Jane Austen novel. Yum! Can't wait for the follow-up.

Also, it must be said that the packaging is absolutely brilliant. Everything from the cover art/design to the typeface inside is impeccable. Elizabeth ...more

like 1 like add a comment

Aug 19, 2010

Katri rated it

Shelves: historical-novel

A fun, exciting piece of historical fluff about turn-of-the-century New York high society where most people wear a double face or two and are less innocent and virtuous than they look. It's kind of historical chick lit with lots of intrigue and fun characters who aren't too perfect and feel refreshingly real (though not particularly original; most of them draw on very familiar types). My only complaint is that I couldn't really like Elizabeth; I don't know why, I just found her a bit too hypocri ...more

like 1 like 2 comments

Jul 26, 2010

David rated it

This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.

like add a comment

Jul 25, 2010

Sandra rated it

From the cover of this book I knew I was about to travel back in time. I knew that the book would be about the high society and I was looking forward to the mention of the balls that the characters would attend. I guess you can say that I have a liking for the Victorian, high society, romantic stories. I don't know why but the cover also made me think of the movie Marie Antoinette, which had a way of intermixing old fashion stories with a modern twist.

I for some reason was not pr ...more From the cover of this book I knew I was about to travel back in time. I knew that the book would be about the high society and I was looking forward to the mention of the balls that the characters would attend. I guess you can say that I have a liking for the Victorian, high society, romantic stories. I don't know why but the cover also made me think of the movie Marie Antoinette, which had a way of intermixing old fashion stories with a modern twist.

I for some reason was not prepared for the story to take place in turn of the century New York. As I was reading this book I couldn't help thinking that there were a lot of allusions to the style of Henry James. Washintong Square Park, one of Miller's more well known novels, also discusses the high class in NY at the turn of the century. And I felt like Diana was a lot like the main character in Henry Miller's Daisy Miller. In Daisy Miller, Daisy also tries to defy all the rules set upon her by soceity. I also felt like this novel had a flare for the Jane Austen novels where many of her characters had to marry for money.

My favorite character in this whole novel was Diana. I felt like although she was the odd one, in terms of her "misconduct" in public, she actually truly loved her sister. I also came to like Henry a lot. Underneath his rough exterior he really did have a good heart. And of course I was ready to tear the overly embelished dresses off Penelope.

I personally liked the Victorian setting. I don't know how teenagers would react to that particular setting just because I don't know how much they can understand the rules of soceity at that time, unless they are a dork like me. I probably would have read this in high school, but not until my senior year when real literature seemed to make sense, probably because I had learned the art of reading between the lines. This was also the time I started reading Henry James.

I never personally made the connection between The Luxe and Gossip Girl. After reading a couple of reviews both herer on Good Reads and on Barnes and Nobles' website, I realized that painting a likeness to Gossip Girl would actually be a very good push for book talking this novel. However, I still would find it a hard sell unless it is for the right audience. And my right audience would have a liking/understanding of the Victorian era and a higher reading level. (less)

like add a comment

Jul 01, 2010

Shelbie Mali rated it

Okay, before I review I usually do a little blurb about how I came across this book, this is a complicated one so bear with me... I was recommended this from amazon.com like 9 million times a really long time ago and i finally bought it before my first trip up to chicago with J, how long ago was that? Oh like a year and a half ago. I read like the first 100 pages and for some reason wasn't interested and put it away and "temporarily misplaced" it (aka lost it). Well, yesterday, a good ...more Okay, before I review I usually do a little blurb about how I came across this book, this is a complicated one so bear with me... I was recommended this from amazon.com like 9 million times a really long time ago and i finally bought it before my first trip up to chicago with J, how long ago was that? Oh like a year and a half ago. I read like the first 100 pages and for some reason wasn't interested and put it away and "temporarily misplaced" it (aka lost it). Well, yesterday, a good friend of mine C.D. was talking to someone else about it and I was like "that sounds so complicated what are you talking about?" and she's like "Oh its this book called The Luxe its sooo good!" and I happened to find my copy the very same night and started reading. I. Was. Hooked.

Rich girls always get what they want. That was the saying to live by in 1899, until seemingly everyone of upperclass New York got caught up in an epic love triangle. One thing I enjoyed about The Luxe was the characters, I could relate to Elizabeth being so trapped by needing to impress her family to the point where she couldn't get out of her engagement with Henry, even if they both loved another. I feel like I'm the only one who really likes Henry. I thought he was very spicy and spunky, and I really liked him! I hated Penelope, and her little minion Buck, but that's how the story was supposed to work. I loved Diana, this rebellious teenager where the last thing you ever wanted to do was stand out. Lina annoyed me, she was way too obsessed with Will, everytime a chapter was about her she was whining or doing something stupid. Who else? Will was okay, there wasn't really a story about him so I couldn't really say if I liked him or not. The plot was awesome! Kept you moving at a fast pace and wondering what was going to happen next, even though you knew... similar to Romeo and Juliet style. I loved the little news article clippings at the beginning of each chapter, I thought that was a really neat idea and THE PLOT TWIST AT THE END! Oh my gosh I did NOT see that coming... (see look, now you want to read it and know what I'm talking about) ;) well you definitely should! Check out The Luxe by Anna Godbersen! (less)

like add a comment

« previous 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 … 418 419 next »

new topic
discuss this book

topics	posts	views	last activity
Paranormal Romance: September 2010 Reading Challenge	299	349	5 minutes ago
South African Boo...: 100 books for me too!	70	29	17 minutes ago

polls

What would you like to read in September?

Kiss me deadly:13 tales of paranormal love

1 vote, 33.3%

The Luxe (Luxe, #1)

1 vote, 33.3%

Flecks of Gold

1 vote, 33.3%

A Game of Thrones (A Song of Ice and Fire, #1)

0 votes, 0.0%

Daughter of the Forest (Sevenwaters, #1)

0 votes, 0.0%

Lily of the Nile

0 votes, 0.0%

The House of the Scorpion

0 votes, 0.0%

3 total votes

2 comments

More...

recent status updates | recommend it | share

combine
other editions (17)

More editions...

popular shelves

to-read

4,018 shelves

young-adult

331 shelves

historical-fiction

262 shelves

currently-reading

258 shelves

169 shelves

romance

134 shelves

historical

108 shelves

series

101 shelves

More shelves...

about Anna Godbersen

Anna Godbersen was born in Berkeley, California, and educated at Barnard College. She currently lives in Brooklyn with her husband, where she is at work on the sequel to Envy.

More about Anna Godbersen...

more books by Anna Godbersen

More…

trivia about The Luxe

10 trivia questions
1 quiz

See trivia...

quotes from The Luxe

"There was no pleasure like being envied on a mass scale." — 70 people liked it

"As she always did on any really important day, Penelope Hayes wore red." — 54 people liked it

More quotes…

groups that shelved The Luxe

Twilight Addicts Anonymous

36 members

last activity Jul 20, 2010 12:19am

shelf: currently-reading

Teen Reads

2 members

last activity Jun 10, 2010 04:35pm

shelf: currently-reading

Young Adult Fiction for A...

2201 members

last activity 25 minutes ago

shelf: read

title link	preview: The Luxe
avg rating	preview: The Luxe Goodreads rating: 3.72 (7523 ratings)
small image	preview: click here [close]
med image	preview: click here [close]

The Luxe (Luxe #1)

friend reviews

lists with this book

community reviews

new topic
discuss this book

polls

share this book

share on your blog

combine
other editions (17)

popular shelves

about Anna Godbersen

more books by Anna Godbersen

trivia about The Luxe

quotes from The Luxe

groups that shelved The Luxe