Wielki dom
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating

Wielki dom

3.41 of 5 stars 3.41  ·  rating details  ·  11,346 ratings  ·  1,955 reviews
Cztery niesamowite historie ludzi żyjących w zupełnie innych realiach i czasach, ludzi, których łączy dojmujące uczucie życiowej straty, będące powodem nieodwracalnych zmian w ich życiu, i... pewien niezwykły mebel, dający im poczucie sensu i oparcie. Podczas II wojny światowej z gabinetu ojca Georga Weisza w Budapeszcie zostaje skradzione biurko, należące niegdyś do Feder...more
Paperback, 323 pages
Published 2011 by Świat książki (first published October 12th 2010)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.
This book is not yet featured on Listopia. Add this book to your favorite list »

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 3,000)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Joel
So I say again: writing a book of short stories, fitting them together Tetris-like, and calling it a novel DOES NOT MAKE YOUR BOOK A NOVEL. Also telling your publisher to put "a novel" on the cover after the title DOES NOT MAKE YOUR BOOK A NOVEL. If you write a collection of short stories, IT IS OK TO CALL IT A COLLECTION OF SHORT STORIES. Because you are Nicole Krauss, especially, because you will probably STILL BE NOMINATED FOR THE NATIONAL BOOK AWARD.

***

(EDIT: But YOU WON'T WIN, thankfully!...more
Caris
This book has the wrong cover. I knew that when I first laid eyes on it. It was out of sheer luck that I bothered to glance at the author.

Look at it. This silly image. It looks like a lopsided cake. It reminds me of all of the books the major publishing houses churn out, with their horrible, forgettable, literal covers. I get it. It’s a house. And the house is toppling over. How thoughtful of you, Lovedog Studio.

Let’s start over. We’ll be requiring a cool color palate. All of these whites, reds...more
Stuart
Nicole Krauss' novel The History of Love was a fine effort by a young writer. I was hoping this new book would be even better. But Great House was a tedious read for me. The quality of the writing is very good, but there is no real story here. Like The History of Love, this novel is built on multiple narrations, but here the narrators are not the least bit interesting. They are a dreary, prissy lot, self absorbed to such a degree that they are just plain annoying.

Then there is the engine that d...more
Kemper
I’m more a genre guy than a literature reader, but I’ve been trying to branch out lately. I’m glad I did because I’ve read some amazing things that I probably wouldn’t have tried otherwise. However, it only takes one book like this send me running back to the mystery or sci-fi section for comfort. It wasn’t bad, but it’s just working so damn hard to be an ‘important’ book that it really isn’t much fun to read. And maybe all books shouldn’t be fun, but they really shouldn’t feel like this much wo...more
Kim
This book is not about a house, great or minute. It’s about a(view spoiler)

Okay, so maybe metaphorically speaking it could be about a great house, like as if we all live in the ‘great house’ of life blah blah blah but, really, it’s about a(view spoiler)

I’m not complaining. I really really like the (view spoiler) (aside: you can actually click on those... It's not a real spoiler, I just wanted to test that feature out.) It sounds l...more
Ursula
This is the worst book I've read in years! The narratives are incredibly disjointed and confusing. None of the characters is interesting enough to warrant the energy required of the reader to piece together their stories in a meaningful way. The writing itself is trite and one gets the feeling that one has read similar stories by better writers. By far the worst flaw of the book is the lack of propulsion. I'm amazed that I read the entire book as there was nothing driving the book forward. Witho...more
Eh?Eh!
There are books that are the right ones at the right time. This one was a book at a certain time, maybe not just right, but with rough hewn edges that generally fit, squint the eyes a little, hold a thumb sideways, good enough. Life has thrown me from a moving vehicle and since I wasn't wearing my seat belt, the resulting scrape has left all these exposed nerve endings to be once again scraped by this book.

It wasn't the best read to have on the commute, the jerking of the bus and other people ca...more
Jana
It is no doubtfully a beautiful book. And it has something that I’ve never seen before: sentence by sentence of this novel are thoroughly poetically contemplated and moving. It is one big explosion of wonder, how did Krauss do it? I was overwhelmed with her writing style.

But her four short stories are a bit confusing although they intertwine all the time. I don't know what really happened to all of them in this book. As one reviewer wrote, I as well wanted to draw a picture of how they are conn...more
Beth
I loved this story, I identified with so many of the characters. How a person can fold into themselves so much and not realize they are blocking out the rest of the world. How you can live with someone until death do you part and not really know them. How one decision changes someone's world. How we are all entitled to our secrets, to tell our secrets or to hold them till the grave. How the person holding the answer, to a question they never knew they had, has a choice, do they open the folded p...more
Jennifer (aka EM)
Moments of soaring, heart-shattering prose. Krauss has the ability with one sentence - the gaps between the words, really (what you're expecting, more than what you are reading) - to imply and evoke the depth of emotion from the tragedies of life. It doesn't hurt that her characters have undergone or are experiencing the greatest contemporary tragedies of our times - the Holocaust, war, political persecution, sickness, death, deep and unreconciled domestic splits.

Much of this is about writing a...more
Elise
Every once in a while I will read something that affects me on a personal level. It becomes so intense that it is like a relationship, a secret relationship that I have with the characters of the story. It is not only that I can relate to the characters, feel their pain, happiness, anger, and fear it is that the author allows me to feel that way in a very subtle and almost sneaky sort of way. There are only a couple books that have made me feel that way in the past, The World According to Garp,...more
Liz
I almost made it to page 100. I was thinking that the narrative was quite loose, plot developments subtle with a heavy focus on the characters' inner lives, a bit more intellectual than I typically choose, but I was soldiering on, trying to prove my literary merit as a reader. Hey guys, wait for me, I could have been an English major too! But when I read the following sentence, which occupies half of page 95, I gave myself permission to hang it up:

"But they didn't come, and so I continued to sit...more
Blair
Great House is both a novel with an overarching theme, and a collection of short stories - most of which are told in two parts, and all of which have loose connections with the others. In All Rise, a lonely writer in New York is haunted by the memory of a Chilean poet she met many years ago. In True Kindness, an elderly man in Israel, close to death, is both infuriated and pained by recollections of his difficult relationship with his youngest son. In Swimming Holes, a man is consumed with jealo...more
switterbug (Betsey)
An imposing wooden desk with nineteen drawers floats through this book like a buoy, and sometimes with shackles, loosely uniting four disparate but interconnected narrative threads. The desk is largely a monument to Jewish survival, loss, and recovery, and mirrors the dissolution, pain, and dire hope of each character. Additionally, it is a covetous object, given a poignant and existential significance by the chorus of voices that are bound to it by their memories.

"Bend a people around the shape...more
Annie
i'm embarrassed to say i actually sat down and drew out a diagram trying to sort out how all the characters were connected! then, in a fit of desperation, i logged on and google-d it, trying to find a post that would decipher it for me! so maybe i'm a simpleton, but it seems as though this type of book should not be so laborious. someone tell me, please, and put me out of my misery - the judge that nadia is addressing, is it his son, the melancholy soldier/would-be writer that she hit with her c...more
Andy Miller
The novel consists of four stories, three of which are connected by possession of an antique desk. The desk belonged to a Jewish family in Europe that was stolen when the Nazis too the family, the son who survived the war spends his life putting finding his family home's furniture and that of other Jewish families. Through that story we learn of the Holocaust's effect on generations born after its end by seeing the impact on the furniture dealer's children.

The desk is taken to London and ends u...more
Elaine
Nicole Krauss is an accomplished writer. Of that, there is no doubt. Her prose flows, even in a so-so work like this one. The problem here is that, although the prose flows, it just flows. This novel has multiple narrators speaking to an unspecified you, a Your Honor,and a son. However, the tone, no matter who is speaking or about what, remains the same. There are no distinguishing features between the narrators. Since the chapter titles don't include the narrator's name, that doesn't give the r...more
Michael
Nicole Krauss, a literary wunderkind, is married to another literary wunderkind, Jonathan Safroen Foer. For my money, Nicole Krauss is twice the writer Foer will ever be; her novel The History of Love was a mulitcontinental sprawl with only a few occasional lapses into melodrama and sentimentality. Great House is a gimmick book, with multiple narrators linked by a giant wooden desk, and Krauss takes a few mis-steps here as well, but if you're willing to put up with a bit of pretentious babbling...more
Abby
Nicole Krauss has taken a theme that in lesser hands would be a cliché and written an original and meditative novel. An inanimate object, often a piece of jewelry or a musical instrument, passes through many hands over many years, changing lives and assuming disproportionate importance. I've read it before but not this time.

There is a desk that figures prominently in the four stories here – a huge, almost monstrous thing with nineteen drawers of various sizes – but the desk isn't the point, is...more
Dolors
If you are looking for a light and simple story where there's a plot developed in the classic structure, this is not your book.
This is a tough novel, it requires guessing and work on your part, it's like a puzzle that somehow the reader has to put together. And for me, what makes it a great reading, is that you are not conscious of getting close to solving that puzzle, but when you turn the last page everything makes sense in a strange and singular way, like remembering your own memories, throug...more
K
May 01, 2011 K rated it 3 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommended to K by: M
My sister is visiting (yay!) and we were discussing what it is we want from books. For her, beautiful language is most important; characters, also important, are secondary; plot is almost irrelevant. For me, it's characters and then plot, although if the characters are sufficiently interesting and the language particularly compelling, plot is less critical. This is why she loved this book and I was decidedly less enthused. The language was beautiful, yes, which is why I'm generously adding a thi...more
Michael
As an avid fan of Nicole Krauss’s first two novels—A History of Love and Man Walks Into a Room—I hoped for great things from Great House. To a point, it matches these expectations, knitting an intricate tale of loss and repercussion. After three books, her themes remain consistent: Memory, solitude, loss, and the investment of personal meaning of everyday objects. In History, this was a book; in Great House, it is a writing desk. In both, she presents diverse narratives that eventually weave tog...more
Lisalisa2
Magnificent book of love, loss,loneliness, despair,regret, forgiveness, relationships and at times the lack there of. Certain lines were not only poetic but memorable and were jotted down. I found certain viewpoints existentialist. Krauss's words were so weighty that at times I felt shaken and reminded that we do have various check points to re-aquaint ourselves that we can CHOOSE life and yet quite masterfully she expressed as she was typifying the absence of it with so many characters.
Admitte...more
Judy


Nicole Krauss is one author I wish wrote more novels because I enjoy reading her so much. Yet for some reason I have not ever read her first novel, Man Walks Into a Room (2002), which I must remedy right away. And I did not get around to Great House until it was picked by one of my reading groups. Her second novel, The History of Love (2005), was one of my best loved novels ever. I feel a bit abashed for allowing novels of much less quality to crowd out Ms Krauss. It is almost as bad a watching...more
Jane
Sometimes a book stay in your head long after you have finished reading and put it down, not allowing you to let go and move on to something else.

You have to recall passages, theme, images. You have to think about the questions it left you with. Maybe you even have to pick it up again, because you know there will be things you missed, more that will reveal itself on subsequent readings.

Great House has been one of those books for me.

It wasn’t a book I rushed to read, but as time went on I became...more
Rita
Disappointment is my biggest reaction. I had really high expectations after History of Love.

I felt like I was slowly walking through mud while I was reading this. The sentences were thick and hard to move though.

Take this one (from page 98):

"I felt something one from time to time experiences with those one is intimate with, when the distance that all the while has been folded up like a Chinese paper toy suddenly springs open between you."

The characters were cold and murky, several addressing u...more
Felice
I was thrilled to have the opportunity to read this novel because I thought The History of Love was a wonderful book. Love is a book within a book about great loves, lost loves and finding love all wrapped around a fifty year old lost novel. Krauss's new book uses the provenance of a 19 drawer desk in order for her to string together some good short stories and call it a novel. The past and present owners of this huge desk are diverse only in the events that cause their sufferings. They are at t...more
Licklitblogspot
After I started college, in the fall of 1995, my mother began asking if she could send over my possessions. What hadn't fit into two suitcases, after two months in New York, bore surprisingly little sentimental value now, frighteningly little, as if my dorm had a celebrity whose fame protected me from contact with my previous life.

The truth was anything but glamorous. "Mom, I can't wear that stuff right now. New York is cold." She persisted, digging out green fleece pants from the gym drawer. "...more
Kata
Nicole Krauss had me at hello with her first novel, The History of Love. She is a true story weaver. She sits at her computer and looms a story together so intricately that you cannot imagine how her mind must function day to day. Is it like that always? The story centers around a desk. Oh it's not an ordinary desk, but the most elaborately carved hulking piece of furniture you can possibly imagine and yet it has this sense of intimacy with each owner. It virtually takes on a persona or swagger....more
David
If only Nicole Krauss had learnt the skill of brevity. Her complex and literate book "Great House" is possibly the most tangled and confusing novel I have read for a long time. I liked the idea of the story being told by four separate characters (well five actually, but that is what I mean) at different times and in different places and this is challenging enough without being so oblique. We eventually find out who the narrators are talking to, except for the fourth. Is Isabel just talking to us...more
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 99 100 next »
topics  posts  views  last activity   
Win an ARC of Great House! 11 76 Feb 17, 2013 03:10AM  
Clarksville, TN B...: New Book Suggestion 1 11 May 23, 2012 04:01PM  
readers from the ...: December 2011: Great House 3 17 Feb 04, 2012 07:00PM  
Orcapod Sunday Bo...: Meeting this Sunday 1 6 Nov 10, 2011 03:51PM  
  • How to Read the Air
  • Foreign Bodies
  • To the End of the Land
  • Lord of Misrule
  • I Hotel
  • Bound
  • Memory Wall
  • Sourland
  • The Lovers
  • The Free World
  • The Tragedy of Arthur
  • Mr. Peanut
  • Binocular Vision: New and Selected Stories
  • The London Train
  • Grace Williams Says It Loud
  • The Birth of Love
  • American Subversive
  • The Seas
2633
Nicole Krauss is the author of the international bestseller The History of Love, which was published by W.W. Norton in 2005. It won the William Saroyan International Prize for Writing, France’s Prix du Meilleur Livre Ėtranger, was named #1 book of the year by Amazon.com, and was short-listed for the Orange, Médicis, and Femina prizes. Her first novel, Man Walks Into a Room, was a finalist for the...more
More about Nicole Krauss...
The History of Love Man Walks Into a Room An Arrangement of Light Zusya on the Roof Best European Fiction 2012

Share This Book

“One of us had loved the other more perfectly, had watched the other more closely, and one of us listened and the other hadn’t, and one of us held on to the ambition of the one idea far longer than was reasonable, whereas the other, passing a garbage can one night, had casually thrown it away.” 78 likes
“I've reached the age where bruises are formed from failures within rather than accidents without.” 59 likes
More quotes…