Hit Lit: Cracking the Code of the Twentieth Century's Biggest Bestsellers

Hit Lit: Cracking the Code of the Twentieth Century's Biggest Bestsellers

3.43 of 5 stars 3.43  ·  rating details  ·  143 ratings  ·  57 reviews
DISCOVER THE SECRETS OF WHAT MAKES A MEGA-BESTSELLER IN THIS ENTERTAINING, REVELATORY GUIDE

What do Michael Corleone, Jack Ryan, and Scout Finch have in common? Creative writing professor and thriller writer James W. Hall knows. Now, in this entertaining, revelatory book, he reveals how bestsellers work, using twelve twentieth-century blockbusters as case studies—including...more
Paperback, 336 pages
Published April 10th 2012 by Random House Trade Paperbacks
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 701)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Michelle Cristiani
I will admit to being contrary by nature: I get suscpicious of people when they me what to do. That said, I don't really get this book. It is an expansion of Hall's college course where he chose twelve hit novels and analyzed what they had in common. The analysis is completely plot-based; Hall makes clear he doesn't account for advances, publicity tours, or agent efficacy. He doesn't take into account the culture at the time each book broke, and he doesn't touch on writing style, using very few...more
Whitney
A study of twelve of the best selling novels over the twentieth century, Hit Lit had potential, that quickly dropped off. The main issue I had with this book was the large amount of repetition. Not only are the general plot lines described in detail in their own section in the back of the book, but they get rehashed, in even greater detail in each individual chapter.

There were several interesting points raised in this book about common subject matter to be found amongst these 12 best sellers. Th...more
Abbey
First, I think that in order to get a full appreciation of this one, readers need have read at least half, if not all, of the books Hall references and have a wide base of literature of the non-bestselling variety ready for comparison

While I think Mr. Hall is on to something in several of his analyses, I also think it's possible to find several of these elements in most all books published. My sense that some of these of these instances have been boiled so far down to their most basic roots that...more
Ray Bearfield
James W. Hall wrote poetry and taught literature before he ever wrote best-selling Florida-based crime fiction. Reading Hit Lit suggests that signing up for his class in popular fiction would be as big a hoot as finding out what Thorn, his recurring protagonist, is up to.

Hit Lit sums up the analysis, rumination and brainstorming that informed that class, and he graciously credits the students whose interest and curiosity kept his passion alive. Subtitled “Cracking the Code of the Twentieth Centu...more
Jenny Maloney
There are a couple things you need before you jump into this book:

1. A love of reading or writing. If you're not interested in either of those things, you will not find fascinating what I found fascinating.

2. You need to have read at least half of the books Hall discusses (Gone With the Wind, To Kill a Mockingbird, The Godfather, The Exorcist, Peyton Place, Valley of the Dolls, The Dead Zone, Bridges of Madison County, Jaws, The Da Vinci Code, The Hunt for Red October, and The Firm) AND/OR be w...more
Elizabeth B
As with most non-fiction titles, this book has specific audiences to which it will appeal. For students of literature, it provides a good foundation for a beginning survey of popular fiction writing. It compares top books (other reviews list them all so I won’t repeat that information) and the themes that bind them together. Aspiring writers will find this book interesting but, I hope, not take it for gospel and start writing every story to include the themes in the mentioned books. The analysis...more
Cathy DuPont
May 28, 2012 Cathy DuPont rated it 5 of 5 stars
Recommended to Cathy by: Love Jim Hall's writing
Loved it, just loved it. Although this book is not for everyone, it was right down my alley.

When I find a writer I enjoy, even before the end of the book, I'm looking up who he/she is, where they're from, their education and background, other books they've written and anything else I can find out about them.

Knowing this is a personal defect of mine due to my background in newspaper/radio and communications, I enjoy reading about the writer and all the sidebars and backstories I can locate. So...more
Sonia Lal
Hit Lit explains or attempts to explains what American bestselling books have in common. It talks about 12 books:

1. To Kill a Mocking Bird by Harper Lee. 1960. 134 editions, over 140,000,000 copies sold.
2. Peyton Place by Grace Metalious. 1956. 10, 670, 302 copies sold.
3. Valley of the Dolls by Jacqueline Susann. 1966. About 30, 000, 000 copies sold worldwide.
4. Gone with the Wind by Margaret Mitchell. 1936. Close to 30, 000, 000 copies sold in the 1990′s.
5. Jaws by Peter Benchley. 1974. By...more
Elizabeth Quinn
I looked forward to this book -- what novelist wouldn't want to learn the secrets of building a bestseller from a lit prof who doubles as a successful commercial novelist? But I found the book disappointing on a number of levels. The first disappointment was that I found very little new in this book -- no lightbulb over the head insights that prompted me to say, "Ah, hah! That's how it's done." Many good books have covered the same ground. The second disappointment was the selection of bestselle...more
Nic
I admit, I'm initially skeptical when any person - especially a writer, and most especially a writer who also writes fiction but of whom I've never heard - claims to know how bestselling books "work." But a lot of this analysis is interesting and seems legit. And in terms of credentials, it turns out that some of Hall's crime books actually have made the bestseller lists, and students of his class on bestsellers include authors I have heard of, like Dennis Lehane.

The analyses of various factors...more
Sarah Beth
I won this book as a giveaway on Goodreads.

I was intrigued by the premise of this novel - Hall analyzes 12 mega bestsellers to dissect what makes a bestseller a success. However, this novel fell flat for me. First of all, I think Hall took on too many books to discuss in too little space. Discussing the plots, characters, etc. of 12 novels is a lot to cover and puts a lot of burden on the reader to be able to remember 12 separate story lines. I've only read 5 of the 12 books discussed, and I th...more
Birgit
Have you ever wondered why certain books make it onto bestseller lists, or even more so, why some books will rank high in sales for decades? In Hit Lit James W. Hall takes a closer look at twelve such novels from the last century, presenting the common features which propelled them into the realms of bestsellers.
Looking at the selection of American bestsellers of the 20th century, from "Gone with the Wind" to "The Da Vinci Code" the selected books seem to be a rather wild mix and I was curious t...more
Trey
I received a copy of this book through the First Reads program.

After teaching "metafiction and postmodernist" works for 10 years, James W. Hall decided to teach a course in popular fiction (bestsellers), and he liked the results so much that he decided to share his thoughts in the form of Hit Lit. You might think this class (and this book) would be akin to fluff courses like "The Science of Superheroes" or "Simpsons and Philosophy" at one of those California universities (or better yet, a class...more
Rodney Farrell Sr
This book presents an interesting take on 12 of the bestselling novels of the 20th century by identifying 12 themes (hot buttons) within each novel. Robert Langdon may find that fascinating but is not the holy grail of literature. The work is an accumulation of discussion and notes from Hall’s graduate course in popular literature. I would recommend the book as it may stimulate your thinking about what and why you read what you read. There is a section of 17 questions to reflect on the themes an...more
SmarterLilac
Some good insights here--I was fascinated by the observation that the infamous Urban vs. Rural conflict features prominently in many name megasellers--but I did not care for the structure. The way the book skips back and forth between titles was very distracting, and only served to make the whole thing seem pretentious and overdone. Still, James W. Hall gets points for not going anywhere near Stephenie Meyer, (or Harry Potter) and for picking my beloved The Dead Zone for analysis. Even I didn't...more
Courtney
(3.5 stars) An easy little read on what blockbuster novels have in common, using 12 examples from the last 75 years. While it was very interesting, I was hoping for a bit more of a unifying theory, since loads of novels have all right ingredients but still don't have 'it'. I will be reading Peyton Place after this, as it's come up in far too many of the books about books that I've read.

One nice feature of this book is that it does present nice summaries of each novel in the appendix. Of the book...more
J.M. Fisher
James W. Hall's Hit Lit: Cracking the Code of Twenthieth Century's Biggest Bestsellers makes me cheer. At last, the snobery of 'literary' fictio nis exposed in comparison to best-selling fiction. Hall has the soul of a poet and keen insight into the world of fiction. Bless him for treating popular fiction with respect instead of the standard scholarly contempt it usually gets from academia. His novels portray the skills of literary fiction AND the elements of best-selling fiction, so he knows wh...more
Vicki Roberts
I'm only on page 59 of this 200+ page book, but it's worth a mention, and I'll do a final review when I've completed it...we'll see if I change my mind!

In Hit Lit, James Hall dissects 12 American best-selling novels to show readers and writers that while times may change, there are several common features that, when combined, have a better chance than not of pleasing the masses.

The books Hall compares are:
Gone with the Wind, Peyton Place, To Kill a Mockingbird, Valley of the Dolls, The Godfathe...more
Charlotte
In his new book, Hit List, Author James W. Hall takes a look at twelve novels published in the 20th century and shares his thoughts on why they were wildly successful. The books he chose are listed as follows:
Gone With the Wind
Peyton Place
Bridges of Madison County
The Firm
The Davinci Code
The Exorcist
Jaws
Dead Zone
Valley of the Dolls
To Kill A Mockingbird
The Godfather
The Hunt for Red October.
I admit to having read five of these novels and have seen several other of the movies. (lol - does that count...more
Nicki Markus
This is a book that I found hard to rate and review. There was nothing wrong with it as such, but it really didn't inspire me in anyway.

In this non-fiction work, James W. Hall examines twelve bestselling novels, looking at the themes that run through each to determine what makes them so popular. He considers a range of ideas such a country vs. city and ideas of the family unit and there is nothing wrong with any of his arguments - it's just that they are all pretty obvious to any avid reader an...more
Pranada Comtois
Fiction writers may find Hall's book worth a read to identify the key elements shared by the century's bestseller. Nothing particular struck me about the book. It was an easy, fun read. I could see ideas triggering for some writers not for others. Difficult to say if there is a practical takeaway from the book.

Mitchell
Not a bad idea for a book - take a look at the bestselling books in the US of the last 100 books and figure out why they sold. Too bad that's not what this author did. Did he analyze the books, sure. And some ideas for how the books were similar were found - and when they didn't all have the same thing - he'd say they did anyway. Or the same or the opposite. So all the books were rags-to-riches, or riches-to-rags, or riches or rags. Or all the books revolved around a specific sexual incident, or...more
Rebecca Schwarz
A pop lit (instead of pop science) comparative study of twelve all time best sellers. While all the points he makes are solid it did feel a little padded out in the middle. It would have been a better as a long-form essay then a whole book, still his style is breezy and it wasn't hard for even a slow reader like me to knock this one out.
Vera
This was a fascinating look at what the best sellers of the 20th century have in common. I loved the data given about the stats for the various decades, and seeing that the books did have things in common, but not really things you could use to write your own blockbuster. Interesting book about books.
Susan Oleksiw
This is a fun, incisive and thoughtful guide to what makes a best seller. The author examines 12 best sellers, drawing out the common features in them, and discussing why they have such appeal to readers. It's very insightful and worth reading no matter how many books you may have read or written.
Carol
Full disclosure - I received this book as a Goodreads First Read. Yay for giveaways!

This is a really good book for me - I'm an aspiring writer and it's giving me lots of things to think about for my own stories. And by using well known, well written works to explain the various topics, it's giving me new ways to look at literature that I'm reading. What is it about Story XYZ that is keeping me interested? Why did I put down Story ZYX and never pick it back up again? How did author QRS do that th...more
Laura Ellen
Having a good time with this, especially tracking my own narrative instincts against Hall's findings. I might use this as a text in my workshop--along with The Practice of Poetry? Belabors some points, but as an educator I can't argue with the power of repetition.
Mia
Enjoyable analysis of common features in the best selling books of the past century. What do To Kill a Mockingbird and Bridges of Madison County have in common? Gone With the Wind and The Exorcist? Hall explores shared elements in these mega-sellers in a conversational tone I wish some of my lit professors had been able to use.
Tracy Aiello
A great 'research paper' on what makes a best seller, using 12 of the top best sellers in the modern age. Most interesting? I didn't read a quarter of them, and its basically cliff notes for those too!
I wouldn't recommend for anyone NOT writing a book, though.
Thomas Pluck
An excellent look into the conflicts, characters and stories that grip the American reading public. I wished for some more discussion at the end, perhaps a longer wrap-up, but this is a worthwhile read for anyone interested in popular fiction.
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 23 24 next »
topics  posts  views  last activity   
Author Interviews: Hit Lit Interview (Audio) 1 2 Feb 17, 2013 03:43pm  
Author Interviews: Q & A on Hit Lit (Text) 1 3 Feb 17, 2013 03:37pm  
Hit Lit: Cracking the Code of the Twentieth Century's Biggest Bestsellers (ebook)
107144
Librarian Note: There is more than one author in the GoodReads database with this name. See this thread for more information.

James Wilson Hall is an Edgar and Shamus Award-winning author whose books have been translated into a dozen languages. He has written four books of poetry, a collection of short fiction, and a collection of essays. This is his sixteenth novel. He and his wife Evelyn divide...more
More about James W. Hall...
Blackwater Sound (Thorn, #7) Under Cover of Daylight (Thorn, #1) Buzz Cut (Thorn, #5) Mean High Tide (Thorn, #3) Hell's Bay (Thorn, #10)

Share This Book

Your website