Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “Baby's in Black: Astrid Kirchherr, Stuart Sutcliffe, and The Beatles” as Want to Read:
Baby's in Black: Astrid Kirchherr, Stuart Sutcliffe, and The Beatles
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating
Open Preview

Baby's in Black: Astrid Kirchherr, Stuart Sutcliffe, and The Beatles

3.73  ·  Rating Details ·  1,488 Ratings  ·  249 Reviews

A fascinating, exhilarating portrait of the Beatles in their early years.

Meet the Beatles . . . right at the beginning of their careers. This gorgeous, high-energy graphic novel is an intimate peek into the early years of the world's greatest rock band.

The heart of Baby's In Black is a love story. The "fifth Beatle," Stuart Sutcliffe, falls in lo
Hardcover, 208 pages
Published May 8th 2012 by First Second (first published October 1st 2010)
More Details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about Baby's in Black, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about Baby's in Black

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  Rating Details
Mar 04, 2012 Jo rated it really liked it
“Love me tender, love me true, all my dreams fulfilled. For, my darling, I love you and I always will”.

I am ambivalent towards the Beatles.
It’s not that I don’t like them, I just don’t love them.
Throughout my life I seemed to have attracted Beatles fans as best friends. It’s like they flock to me. Whether it’s my friend who knows every single world to every single song and whose mum once nearly got arrested outside one of their gigs, to the friend who has her picture up in the pub a young Mr
Aug 03, 2012 Mariel rated it liked it
Recommends it for: something important died screaming
Recommended to Mariel by: eight cans deep in the same damn seat
Black turtlenecks. That's what I've got on this. Okay, cigarettes dangling from arms that dangle from turtlenecks that are plucked out of someone's idea of 1960s European cool. Stick your arms inside the hidey hole sleeves and wait it all out. Smoke chains and hair tendrils of girl chic short 'dos and dont's of Hamburg night life in the 1960s. Hooting and clubs you aren't going to. Yawn. That's what I've got. Okay, stretch your arms over the backs of the movie theatre seat and you can't cop a fe ...more
Eunice Moral
Jan 03, 2016 Eunice Moral rated it really liked it
Beautiful and Heartbreaking

That ending crushed my heart. It was nice to know this part of history that not a lot of people know about. To be completely honest I didn't know about Astrid and Stuart or the original members of The Beatles for that matter, and this is the excellent book to explain the beginning of the legendary pop icon. Their struggles as musicians and the people behind their humble beginnings. I loved the fact that this graphic novel isn't solely focused on Astrid and Stu's love
May 03, 2012 Michelle rated it it was amazing
Recommended to Michelle by: Jo
This is an absolutely gorgeous, heartbreaking book detailing the love of Stu Sutcliffe and Astrid Kirchherr. Stu was the real fifth Beatle, the original bass player of the band and best friend to one John Winston Lennon. During their time in Hamburg Stu and Astrid meet and fall in love, but this book is so much more than that. It is a tale of love, loss, friendship and a band at its beginning.

“I think of her, but she thinks only of him, and though it’s only a whim, she thinks of him…”

Astrid and
Jan 25, 2012 Lisa rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition

Baby's In Black is the true story of Stuart Sutcliffe and Astrid Kirchherr. If you haven't heard of Stuart Sutcliffe, he was in a little band called The Beatles. He was one of the original band members. The original line-up was Paul, John, George, Stuart and Pete Best(the drummer before Ringo). This was the line-up who went to play in Hamburg in the early 1960's, before they became big. This is where Stuart met a beautiful photographer named Astrid Kirchherr and they quickly fell in love and bec
Jan 06, 2017 Paige rated it it was amazing

If you follow me on Tumblr or Twitter, or have had the misfortune of interacting with me on any social capacity, then you know I have an obsession with this little band called The Beatles (sorry by the way to all the people I’ve tried to push their music on).

Anyways, when I found this little graphic novel about Astrid Kirchherr and Stuart Sutcliffe (he was the original Beatles bass player and Astrid was his fiancee/the one who inspired a lot of the Beatles’ early looks and a kick ass photographe
Ryn McAtee
Honestly, I found myself disappointed with this book. I'm quite familiar with the story of the Beatles in Hamburg, as well as the story of Stuart and Astrid, and I was hoping that this book could expand it, show it in a new light, whatever. No? Well, that's okay; even if I didn't learn anything new, it still would have been nice to see a good, literary interpretation of my favorite people. Except that was not delivered either. Most of the characters were quite two-dimensional (with the exception ...more
Before I read this book, I had only the vaguest possible awareness of Astrid Kirchherr, or even of Stuart Sutcliffe. I knew there had been some changes in the lineup of the Beatles in their early days, of course - and I knew that they had played in Germany.
I didn't realize how long they were playing in Hamburg, or the kinds of gigs they were playing.

This graphic novel (translated from its original German form) chronicles the time between October 1960 and April 1962 while the Beatles were basica
Jul 25, 2016 Jenna rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
I received an advanced reader's copy through a Goodreads Giveaway

As stated, I got this gem of a book through a giveaway, and lucky me! I can't say that I would normally buy this type of book, but I would definitely be up for it after reading this one.

This book tells the story of "the fifth Beatle", long before Ringo Starr ever entered the picture. However, this isn't the story of Pete, the drummer before Ringo, this is about Stuart who played the bass before Paul took over the role. The book tak

Seth T.
Mar 30, 2012 Seth T. rated it really liked it
Shelves: comics
Baby's in Black by Arne Bellstrof

There's no two ways about it: adaptations of non-fictional stories are a tough beast to approach—and doubly so when the non-fictional account revolves about a tragic death. The trick, see, is the fact that anyone who's aware of history, of the story being unveiled, will know how the retelling will end. When we watched The Perfect Storm, most of us were well aware that George Clooney and Marky Mark wouldn't make it to the film's credits (save perhaps through some kind of treacle flashback montage
"Then these five musicians slowly shuffled onto the stage. No one in the crowd was paying them any attention. They were messing around and didn't seem particularly nervous before their set.

They were all dressed the same, in cheap jackets, tight flannel trousers, and high, pointy buckled shoes. They looked very odd.

The bassist made me think of James Dean. He work dark sunglasses the whole time and stood completely still on stage.

One of the other guitarists looked like he'd just turned fifteen.
First Second Books
Jun 01, 2012 First Second Books marked it as first-second-publications
We love this book!

First love, music, The Beatles -- what more can you want out of a book? Especially when The Beatles are, as Bryan Lee O'Malley said, "the most adorable Beatles ever." Arne Bellstorf's art really brings the first days of the band to live in a charming and wonderful way.
Christina (A Reader of Fictions)
Dec 22, 2012 Christina (A Reader of Fictions) rated it really liked it
Shelves: netgalley
You can probably tell that I am a huge music fan. Well, what you may not know is that I grew up a child of the 60s/70s so far as musical taste goes. Until sixth grade, I didn't really have a conception of 'modern music,' because I listened to what my parents listened to: oldies CDs and the oldies radio station, which tragically went out of business some time in high school. Although my tastes have diversified, I will always have a soft spot for music of that time period, and some of it will alwa ...more
Richie Partington
Jun 24, 2012 Richie Partington rated it it was amazing
Richie’s Picks: BABY’S IN BLACK: ASTRID KIRCHHERR, STUART SUTCLIFFE, AND THE BEATLES by Arne Bellstorf, First Second, May 2012, ISBN: 978-1-59653-771-5

“And though he’ll never come back, she’s dressed in black”
-- Lennon/McCartney, “Baby’s in Black” (written about Astrid’s mourning over Stuart’s sudden death)

“’He’s got something…Something different from the others…I just wish he’d take off those sunglasses.’” (Astrid talking about Stuart.)

Anyone from my generation who was even a fraction as obsess
Nicola Mansfield
Aug 02, 2012 Nicola Mansfield rated it really liked it
Reason for Reading: I love this publisher. I love graphic biographies. I love The Beatles.

The publisher's summary does a more than adequate job of describing what this book accomplishes, even to the point of telling you how it ends. Of course, this is a true story and many will know the ending before they start to read anyway, but it would be nice for them to have left that off for the few of us new to this part of The Beatles' history. I knew about Pete Best and was vaguely aware of there being
May 14, 2012 Kricket rated it liked it
upon discovering this would be published: !!!!!!!!!!!!

upon reading: disappointing. i love the beatles and i love comics so i was hoping this would be explosively awesome and make all my dreams come true. but it was only pretty okay.

1. i love the cover art and the style of bellstorf's work. i really do. but then, reading the book, it turns out that the characters on the cover are the only characters he can draw. so almost all of the male characters look alike. i kept going "is that klaus, or stu?
Aug 21, 2012 Liz rated it it was ok
I was pretty excited to pick up this graphic novel about Stuart Sutcliffe "The Fifth Beatle", and his relationship with photographer Astrid Kirchherr. I, like almost every single other person on god's green earth, love The Beatles, and I liked the looks of the artwork. It has a very cute '60s feel, but is also very dark - probably partly in part to Astrid's love of the color black. The darkness also fits the sort of 1960s beatnik Germany setting.

What made the book fall flat for me, unfortunately
Sara Thompson
May 09, 2012 Sara Thompson rated it it was amazing
Shelves: netgalley
Wow what a sad and wonderful history. I picked Baby’s in Black because it had something to do with the Beatles (my family are huge fans). This is the story of Stuart Sutcliffe who was the original bassist for the Beatles when they started in Germany in 1960. Stuart did not consider himself a great musician but followed for the sake of his friend John Lennon. He was soon discovered by Astrid Kirchheer. They fell in love and she nurtured the artist that he was meant to be. Sadly, Stuart had an und ...more
Mercedes Flowers
Also, if I had a dollar for every panel in which the characters are smoking, I would have 239433423 dollars.

And that's totally ok, because it's definitely part of the absolute coolness that is "Baby's in Black." I have to admit – when I first started flipping through the book, I was slightly disappointed. When I had read "graphic novel" in the description, I was not expecting the style of art that Bellstorf uses. But that disappointment was quickly dashed away upon my beginning the story.

SO well
I've never thought about the Beatles before they were "The Beatles," nor did I know about the influence of Astrid Kirchherr or the almost-a-Beatle Stuart Sutcliff. But I didn't necessarily find it a great book in and of itself -- the art was okay, but there was little character development, which made connecting to the story and the tragic turn at the end difficult. Likewise, NOT being a big Beatles fan, I didn't necessarily come to the story with enough to understand the significance of Astrid ...more
4 stars because I'm partial towards The Beatles. <3

As a Beatles fan, it is very exciting to read the chronicle of "pre-Beatles" era (okay, maybe more like the "German era") being told in graphic novel format. The book focuses on Stuart and Astrid's story so some details - like the Beatles' conflict with the club owner's in Germany, for example - is not explored too deep.
Oct 21, 2015 Samantha rated it it was ok
Recommends it for: Beatles fans
I liked the art. But graphic novels need to have a good balance of dialogue and illustration telling the story and I thought there was too much dialogue and not enough illustration. It was also kind of hard for me to tell the men apart. I found the story to be informative about the Beatle's early career but otherwise kind of boring.
Edward Sullivan
Feb 20, 2012 Edward Sullivan rated it it was amazing
Love this graphic novel story about the romance between German photographer Astrid Kirchherr and the legendary "fifth Beatle," Stu Sutcliff who died in 1962. This is also a good portrait of the Beatles in Hamburg before they hit the big time.
lucy by the sea
sweet love story of original indies and the 1960s hamburg scene. I liked the tenderness and creative passion. sometimes it was abit hard to tell the blokes apart but other than that the art was lovely.
Nov 13, 2014 P. rated it liked it
Shelves: comics, nonfic
all the smoking depicted here made my throat start to hurt. which means that I really got into the story! the Beatles look like themselves and ALSO still fit in with Bellstorf's style. this is a subtle, sad, love story that happens to have something to do with the Beatles.
Caroline Fosse
May 05, 2016 Caroline Fosse rated it it was amazing  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: graphic-novels
Heartbreakingly beautiful. The artwork, the story, everything.
Clara Eddy
Apr 17, 2015 Clara Eddy rated it really liked it
so cute ;-)
Tito Quiling, Jr.
Jan 16, 2017 Tito Quiling, Jr. rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: graphic-novels
Despite being a last minute addition to my purchase, I found myself putting this book ahead of my reading pile and even ended up finishing this title in one hour. Arne Bellstorf details an important chapter of The Beatles' life before their worldwide fame. It was photographer Astrid Kirchkerr's relations with Stuart Sutcliffe which traced the whirlwind gigs of the young band [with its original five members] when they were performing in the basement of a bar in Hamburg.

Following a rather excited
Ariel Caldwell
Oct 14, 2016 Ariel Caldwell rated it really liked it
I loved the art and the love story - I expected it to be darker and harsher for some reason, but it was relatively light and fluffy. The characters are cute, although I couldn't always tell the boys apart. Astrid was an interesting character - I suspect this was just the tip of the iceberg, however, and she must have had some inner workings of steel to get the boys out of jail, and convince her mother to let Stuart live with them. I liked the way her professional life was worked into the story. ...more
Donna Davis
This graphic novel will best serve a niche audience, one that is either interested in Kirchherr and Sutcliffe specifically, or everything that pertains to the Beatles including musicians with whom they worked before they morphed into the incredible, historical musical entity that the world knows well.

I received this graphic novel courtesy of the Goodreads first-reads program. Thank you for the book. However, if I had known how little it really had to do with the Beatles, I think I would have pas
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
  • The Fifth Beatle: The Brian Epstein Story
  • Annie Sullivan and the Trials of Helen Keller
  • The Silence of Our Friends
  • Marathon
  • Sumo
  • Kiki de Montparnasse
  • The Year of the Beasts
  • The Beast of Chicago: An Account of the Life and Crimes of Herman W. Mudgett, Known to the World As H.H. Holmes
  • Tina's Mouth: An Existential Comic Diary
  • Tune: Vanishing Point (Tune, #1)
  • Bloody Chester
  • Andre the Giant: Life and Legend
  • Neil Flambé and the Aztec Abduction (The Neil Flambé Capers #2)
  • Ivy
  • Johnny Cash: I See a Darkness
  • Ichiro
  • A Game for Swallows: To Die, to Leave, to Return
  • The Carter Family: Don't Forget This Song

Share This Book

“You know I wanna stay with you, right? I mean forever... we agree on that, right?

Are you crazy, Stuart?

No, I'm in love... but maybe that's the same thing.”
More quotes…