Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “By Blood” as Want to Read:
By Blood
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating
Open Preview

By Blood

3.57  ·  Rating Details ·  2,317 Ratings  ·  400 Reviews
The award-winning writer returns with a major, absorbing, atmospheric novel that takes on the most dramatic and profoundly personal subject matter.

San Francisco in the 1970s. Free love has given way to radical feminism, psychedelic ecstasy to hard-edged gloom. The Zodiac Killer stalks the streets. A disgraced professor takes an office in a downtown tower to plot his return
Paperback, 378 pages
Published February 28th 2012 by Farrar, Straus and Giroux (first published February 24th 2012)
More Details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about By Blood, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about By Blood

The Fall by Albert CamusCatch-22 by Joseph Heller1984 by George OrwellThe Trial by Franz KafkaA Clockwork Orange by Anthony Burgess
Concentric Circles
13th out of 150 books — 32 voters
Beautiful Ruins by Jess WalterThe Round House by Louise ErdrichBring Up the Bodies by Hilary MantelBehind the Beautiful Forevers by Katherine BooThis Is How You Lose Her by Junot Díaz
New York Times 100 Notable Books of 2012
53rd out of 100 books — 499 voters

More lists with this book...

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 3,000)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  Rating Details

Please don't judge your reception of this book by my rating. It is a product of the dashing of too many expectations, trends of hope that either concluded too soon or fizzled out after too long a run, and a particular pet peeve. Despite all that, I am keen on seeing more from Ullman, as it is clear from this work that she is not a mediocre writer fulfilling the mediocre, but an author of great potential operating through some caveats.

First off, my loves: the care with which Ullman set up th
switterbug (Betsey)
Sep 21, 2013 switterbug (Betsey) rated it liked it
In 1970's San Francisco, a troubled Classics professor is on mandatory leave from his university position. He rents office space in a building that has period architecture accented by gargoyles and cherubs that appear more sepulchral as the professor's state of mind becomes more questionable. Although he intends to study the scholarly writings of Aeschylus, he spends his days and nights alone, ruminating on his self-worth and taking long walks through the city, recalling his long-ago suicide att ...more
Greg Brown
May 18, 2016 Greg Brown rated it it was ok  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: idle-thumbs
very, very frustrated with the book as a whole. It felt like a good 150-page novella wrapped in a boring therapist plot wrapped in a bad narrator plot, all working to drag the book out as long as she could. The numerous chapter-breaks didn't help things at all, making it very easy to walk away from the book, and padding out the page-length further.

A large part of the frustration is that it felt like Ullman decided how the plot had to be punched up at certain points, and use the most transparent
Mar 11, 2012 christa rated it it was amazing
The premise is simple and surprisingly not considered in more fiction: A man rents a work space in an old building and ends up next door to a psychiatrist. While most of her clients are muted by the doctor’s white noise machine, one patient cannot stand the whooshing unorganized sound and asks that she turn it off.

The man listening in -- and the patient -- in Ellen Ullman’s novel “By Blood” is nameless. But he latches on to the woman’s story as though the sessions are his own personal reality p
Feb 15, 2013 Derek rated it it was amazing
Narrative as poison working in the veins, seductive and benumbing. Reader as addict, greedy and self-interested. History as spectre, prismatic and unsettling. Memory as pathology, compulsive and circular. Family as Stockholm syndrome, insulated and perverse. Therapy as midwifery, hasty and imperilled.

Nabakov and De Palma had a baby.

Martin McClellan
Feb 12, 2013 Martin McClellan rated it it was amazing
Recommended to Martin by: Robin Sloan
Stepping into the language of this book is like entering a warm familiar room. Ullman astutely captures the voice of her narrator from the very first page. For me, the effect was not unlike reading London or Conrad, by a voice unmarked by overt modernism. And yet, it's not antique or unaware of its time. Her control and astute deliberation with language, her comfort in the telling voice, her overall conceptual daring with this story speaks only to her mastery of her craft and art. Simply said, I ...more
John Pappas
Jul 01, 2012 John Pappas rated it really liked it
Maybe it is the setting of this book (San Francisco in the mid-1970s) or maybe it is the novels's exquisite use of aural imagery that reminds me of the film "The Conversation". Like the film, this book expertly dangles bits of a woman's life to the reader, as the narrator eavesdrops through the all-too-thin adjoining door between his office and a psychiatrists office. The narrator (a mentally-ill college professor on leave during an ethics investigation into his behavior) becomes increasing engr ...more
Darcia Helle
I have mixed feelings on this book. If I eliminate the narrator, the story of the nameless patient in search of her birth parents and her origins is a powerful one. The journey is rich in information on Europe during the Second World War, the Nazis and the Jewish people's battle to survive, and what it would feel like to find out you'd been born in this environment.

That being said, that part of the story was far too removed for me. We learn all this through the eavesdropping of the narrator, a
Marty Selnick
Apr 07, 2012 Marty Selnick rated it it was ok
This book got a lot of good reviews but I'm afraid I just didn't like it at all. I found the narrative device to be way too contrived. I found the narrator to be so creepy as to be repulsive to me. Each of the main characters was filled with so much self-loathing that I could not muster up any degree of concern for them. But, I did read the whole thing, so something about it was compelling. It's just that when I finished I was left feeling like I had wasted my time.
Dec 12, 2012 Kathryn rated it it was ok
Recommends it for: No one
I could not put this very unusual book down and then was terribly disappointed by the end. The author presented three characters, each with a boatload of mystery, but left two of them as mystifying as ever. We learn a lot about the patient, a Holocaust survivor who initially starts therapy to deal with the fact that she was adopted and felt as if she belonged to no one. The narrator is a college professor on leave for undisclosed disciplinary reasons. He rents an office next door to the therapis ...more
Bonnie Brody
Aug 04, 2012 Bonnie Brody rated it really liked it
During the year of 1974, a strange and mysterious professor travels to San Francisco and rents a small office in order to continue his research on the third part of Aeschylus's trilogy. He has run into some trouble at his academic job (never made very clear) and is most likely on academic leave or has the possibility of losing tenure lying over his head. Ironically, his small rented office gives him just the fuel to fire off his academic flames.

He doesn't realize it at first, but he can hear the
Feb 09, 2012 Sharon rated it it was amazing
Ellen Ullman's "By Blood" is a slow starter, and I must confess that I almost abandoned the book. However, once it got going, the book had me enthralled.

The first-person narrator, an unnamed male professor, is under investigation at his university during the early 1970s. He rents an office in which to do some writing, on the premise that he will function better by leaving his home for a certain number of hours each day. The office turns out to be next door to a psychiatrist's practice. The walls
Oct 02, 2013 Brett rated it it was ok
Man is suspended from a university for some nameless reason. Man rents an office in a building in San Francisco. Man overhears a therapist's session with a patient. Man becomes obsessed with patient and her story, even though he never sees her or the therapist.
This book does one thing well, and that is building mystery. The patient is adopted, and we learn a little bit about her birth mother, and then a little bit more. Then a little bit more. Then the Man begins to act on the information. One
Larry Hoffer
May 06, 2012 Larry Hoffer rated it really liked it
This is a fantastically written, weighty book, different than almost anything I've ever read. Taking place in San Francisco in the mid-1970s, the country is gripped by Vietnam, the energy crisis, fear of nuclear war, and the panic generated by the Zodiac killer. The book's unnamed narrator is a disgraced college professor suffering from obsessive-compulsive disorder, who is trying to pull his life back together as he is being investigated for an inappropriate relationship with a student. Determi ...more
Tadzio Koelb
May 31, 2013 Tadzio Koelb rated it really liked it
From my review for the Jewish Quarterly:

"One thing that makes By Blood so engaging is how often the narrator’s relationship to the story reflects and exposes the reading experience: he, too, is having an encounter reduced to words and the ideas they provoke in the imagination. There is something arresting about the way he reminds us, half-way through the novel, that he has no idea what the main characters look like – for if he hasn’t, then of course neither can we, who are at his mercy. Whatever
Sep 24, 2013 Cateline rated it it was amazing  ·  review of another edition
By Blood by Ellen Ullman

A fascinating human study on so many levels. The narrator, a disgraced professor, flees to San Francisco, trying to put some form back into his life. We only receive dribs and drabs of reasons for his disgrace throughout the novel, but it is of a stalking nature. He rents an office space in a rather run down section of town, that turns out to be next-door to a psychotherapist's office. With paper thin walls our narrator is able to hear every word that is said in the adjoi
Feb 26, 2013 Ryandake rated it really liked it
what a twisty, gnarly tale. if you're going to read it, start it on a friday and don't make any weekend plans. your life will be on hold til you're done with it.

we have two unnamed protagonists (one i shall call "the snoop", the other is generally referred to as "the patient") and one psychiatrist in the mix here, as well as some dark history, some of which is illuminated and some left in the shadows. all three, in different ways, have significant issues with their parental units.

so the question
Mar 15, 2013 Dorian rated it it was amazing
There's no way my review can compare to Derek Jenkins's.

But I will say that, even though 2013 is yet young, it's hard for me to imagine I'll read many other books this year to top By Blood.

I defy anyone to read the first chapter and not fall utterly under its spell.

Ullman gives us a study in the relation between obliquity and suspense: the novel is driven by a psychoanalytic treatment that the narrator overhears; the patient in that session is eavesdropping on her own past, as it were, and we fo
Apr 21, 2012 Sandie rated it really liked it
It is the 1970's and a disgraced professor has come to San Francisco, awaiting the judgement of his college. A tenured professor, there is an allegation of improper student contact, and now he must wait for the wheels of collegial justice to grind out his fate. Knowing that it will take months, he has fled to another city where he is to work on research and papers. It is an unsettled time in San Francisco. The peace and love generation has given way to terrorists similar to those who kidnapped P ...more
John Norman
Sep 01, 2012 John Norman rated it it was amazing
This is a wonderful novel - great story, a fascinating aesthetic challenge, and a provocative dip into real history.

Set in the late 1970s, The story is about a disgraced academic who, while on hiatus from his university, takes an office in San Francisco to work on a research project. While there, he discovers that he can hear the therapy sessions being conducted by the analyst next door. He becomes fascinated and obsessed with the sessions for a young woman who is excavating her past. The protag
Aug 27, 2014 Judy rated it really liked it
I have wanted to read this since it came out two years ago. It got picked from my list of suggestions by one of my reading groups and most of us liked the intricate plot, though a couple readers found too many improbabilities and one took issue with some of the Holocaust facts.

The setting is San Francisco in the 1970s. The subject matter is closed adoption, identity due to family influence vs lack of identity due to being adopted. Psychiatry, lesbian relationships, the Holocaust and Israel, and
Feb 17, 2013 Ruth rated it it was amazing
I couldn't put this book down. I mean, I have been making waffles and trying to keep reading to get to the end without getting burnt. I can't say whether I liked it, because I admire it so much as a work of art and yet I don't know how to feel about the content. The unreliable narrator is perfect--I can't decide whether he was a maniacal stalker or a kind person. The author exploits his distorted POV so beautifully. I loved the protagonist. I can't decide how I feel about how the author brought ...more
Feb 16, 2015 Mandy rated it really liked it
Shelves: read-in-2015
This book is so very well-written, such compulsive reading, that at times I found it hard to put down. But it isn't a book that I can say that I enjoyed.
We, The reader, have the story related to us by an unnamed man, who himself overhears the sessions between a therapist and her patient.
So immediately I felt a little, well, dirty, as if I was reading something that I wasn't supposed to be, because it should be private.
As the story progressed it did become very interesting. The whole nature versu
Jul 26, 2013 Susan rated it really liked it
I'd maybe even rate this with another half or whole star. Compelling plot points,: sicko voyeruristic expelled college professor trying to rid himself of his demons not only spies on a patient in her therapy sessions with her psychiatrist but becomes so obsessed with the patient's life that he does what he thinks will help her in finding her birth mother. Good read!
Oct 12, 2014 J rated it liked it

There are a couple of reasons that keep me from giving this book four stars and that is the narrator: an unreliable, obsessive compulsive, anxiety ridden, auditory voyeur who is on leave from university due to some unspecified moral failure. Hmmm....

Oh, and the ending. God. The ending. Otherwise, it was a fascinating glimpse in to the life of a young woman seeking therapeutic guidance regarding her need to learn and understand her genetic inheritance.

The characters are well drawn and
Apr 21, 2013 Anne rated it really liked it
This was a gripping story with a MOST unsatisfying ending. Argh!

Ullman has created superbly compelling characters: the nameless woman searching for her origins, a brilliant mathematician and lesbian living in 1974 San Francisco during a time of sexual license and the Zodiac killer; her emotionally distant and withholding adoptive mother; the woman's therapist-a daughter of a Nazi, who wishes for a different family; the birthmother with a wrenching story from the horrors of World War II; and the
Teresa Lukey
By Blood is sort of a play off the main themes in this book. Are we related by blood? Can you be Jewish by blood? In this book a 30-ish woman, whose name remains unknown, knows she is adopted and seeks out her mother. To her surprise, she finds out her mother is Jewish and does not have any idea what to make of it. Here within these pages lies a wonderful story of a daughter finding her birth mother and a disturbing story of what her mother endured as a Jewish girl during the Nazi-reign.

I found
The story is narrated by an older male professor who was put on leave by his university for some sort of sexual deviance. He rents a small office in San Francisco which just happens to have thin walls and be situated next door to a therapist. He becomes obsessed with a woman he knows only as "the patient" who tells the therapist about being adopted and her desire to learn about her birth parents, particularly her mother. The professor obsessively does research of his own in order to secretly hel ...more
Bob Lopez
Mar 18, 2012 Bob Lopez rated it really liked it
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.
Apr 04, 2013 Andrew rated it really liked it
Then all at once I was frightened. How quickly I could come to hate her—she who was moments ago my icon of self-creation. I must be careful, I thought. I have traveled this path before. I must not go there. I therefore forced down my anger; sat still as my annoyance ebbed. It took all my self-control, but I succeeded, congratulating myself that I had changed, that I could be otherwise than I’d been. I turned my ear to the lovely pitch of the patient’s voice, her beautiful whiskey alto, and once ...more
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 99 100 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
  • Fobbit
  • On the Spectrum of Possible Deaths
  • The Book of Mischief: New and Selected Stories
  • The Devil in Silver
  • All We Know: Three Lives
  • Kind One
  • Life Goes On
  • The Right-Hand Shore
  • Radio Iris
  • Shout Her Lovely Name
  • Married Love and Other Stories
  • Middle C
  • The Starboard Sea
  • Ticknor
  • Memory Board
  • Threats
  • Enchantments
  • Almost Never
Ellen Ullman is the author of By Blood, The Bug, a New York Times Notable Book and runner-up for the PEN/Hemingway Award, and the cult classic memoir Close to the Machine, based on her years as a rare female computer programmer in the early years of the personal computer era. She lives in San Francisco.
More about Ellen Ullman...

Share This Book

No trivia or quizzes yet. Add some now »

“But you can't stop knowing something, can you?” 4 likes
“But now what? Is this a ticket to a new understanding of my life, or a bomb that's going to blow up everything?

Consider one more possibility: that you remain essentially the same person you were, neither new nor destroyed.”
More quotes…