Green Heart (Green Angel, #1-2)

Green Heart (Green Angel #1-2)

3.85 of 5 stars 3.85  ·  rating details  ·  552 ratings  ·  143 reviews
A two-fold tale of grief and hope, loss and love, told as only Alice Hoffman can.

When her family is lost in a terrible disaster, 15-year-old Green is haunted by loss and the past. Struggling to survive in a place where nothing seems to grow and ashes are everywhere, Green retreats into the ruined realm of her garden. But in destroying her feelings, she also begins to destr...more
Paperback, 259 pages
Published January 1st 2012 by Scholastic Paperbacks
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.
Practical Magic by Alice HoffmanHere on Earth by Alice HoffmanThe Probable Future by Alice HoffmanThe Ice Queen by Alice HoffmanTurtle Moon by Alice Hoffman
Best Alice Hoffman Novel
27th out of 36 books — 187 voters
Scott Pilgrim's Precious Little Life by Bryan Lee O'MalleyFire by Kristin CashoreWildefire by Karsten KnightDivergent by Veronica RothThe Disreputable History of Frankie Landau-Banks by E. Lockhart
list to be deleted
91st out of 100 books — 4 voters


More lists with this book...

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 3,000)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Elizabeth
Jun 30, 2012 Elizabeth rated it 4 of 5 stars Recommends it for: Tommie, Ceridwen, Abigail, et al
I've been disappointed in Alice Hoffman for a long time. Practical Magic is one of the few books that isn't as good as the film. I read another one of her books, giving her the benefit of the doubt, and found it just terrible. (I'm withholding the title; it may just be me). Both times, the problem was simple disappointment. The book wasn't as good as I thought it should be. It didn't go deep enough, the magic wasn't lush enough, the descriptions were there but somehow the characters never came...more
Kirstine
This is a lovely book. It's fragile, it's tender, it's soaked in colours and emotion. The writing unfolds like a feather floating through the air, a slight touch of skin against skin, someone stroking your hair as you fall asleep. I don't know how to describe it - that's how I felt it.

It reads like a fairytale and a poem.
There are people who will read it and dislike it for this, I know, and that saddens me. It's not a book in our modern-day understanding of books, it is not a story the way we'...more
Jennifer
I've said this before, but I used to adore Alice Hoffman. Every once in a while she still puts out a book that I like ("The Story Sisters" is a good example), but this book, while a quick read and engaging on certain levels, was ultimately just annoying to me. It's a compilation of two novellas, "Green Angel" and "Green Witch," and both are meant to be modern-day, post-9/11 fairy tales. The language is very stylized, like a fairy tale, as is the movement of both stories. The problem is that I fo...more
Penintime
I love many of Hoffman's books and I wanted to love this... And I enjoy magical realism and post-apocalyptic stories so I thought the combination would be awesome. But they don't mix, or should I say that they don't mix well in this story. This was pretty dreadful, badly written compared to her other works that I have read. But mainly, it is a really really stupid story. Nothing makes sense, which drove me nuts. The city burns and glowing embers fall from the sky. The main character gets them in...more
Larissa
Aug 29, 2012 Larissa rated it 5 of 5 stars
Shelves: own
Green Angel is a beautiful, tender and heartfelt story of a girl who lost everything and everyone she loved, and then she lost herself. This is the story of the dreams of the past that haunted her, the lives of those touched by her and all that she gave up and found once again.

Green Witch is an enchanting story of magic, love and witches. When so much of the past was lost all that was left were the memories of what had been. Learning to live again, to love again, was the only hope for a future,...more
Kelly
This was truly one of the most beautiful YA novels I've had the pleasure to read in a very, very long time. Hoffman's writing style is lyrical, poetic, and even somewhat haunting. It's the kind of story that slowly meanders it's way through your heart, wending and winding to touch you unexpectedly. Her writing style reminded me a little of Susan Fletcher's Corrag, which I found to be really beautiful too. Granted, this particular type of writing will not be everyone's cup of tea; some may find i...more
Aria
Review can also be found here.


Green Heart by Alice Hoffman is actually two books; Green Angel and Green Witch, put into one. This book made me breathless when I read it. The writing is realistic. It is simple yet complex—which had me confused at the beginning for a moment—and it is also very beautiful like poetry but far better.

I agree with what Booklist has said about Alice Hoffman. She certainly writes in a lyrical, stripped-down poetic way that distills both magic and elemental experience int...more
Brittany Rehage

Green Heart is two books in one. The first book is Green Angel, the second is Green Witch. I thought about trying to write this review without separating the two, but that wasn't working. They are two very different stories wrapped up in one another and it's lovely.

The first, Green Angel is about Green's journey through loss and grief and finding herself again. She loses her entire family in a horrible, devastating way. She crumbles and has to put herself together again. She feels guilty, regret...more
Miki
Again - one of those books I'd probably give 3.5 stars to, if we could do fractions. This is clearly Hoffman's post-9/11. Green, a 15-yr old girl loses her family in a cataclysmic event in The City and must rebuild her life and rediscover her purpose and identity. The writing is spare and elegant, with parts that are nearly like lines from a poem, meditating on life, loss and love. I found her depiction of The Horde (the group that caused the explosion/devastation) uncomfortably skirting close t...more
Jennifer Rayment
The Good Stuff

The writing is absolutely beautiful and lyrical as with most of Hoffman's works
Descriptions of grief are so honest and realistic
Fabulous character development especially for Green
A nice message of hope and being able to make it through the grief of losing so much
Hauntingly beautiful
Unique take on the whole dystopian / post apocolyptic (people please simply explain the difference to me) genre - honestly I was imagining a 9/11 sort of devestation had happened
Thinly veiled disgust fo...more
Dianais
I was very enthusiastic about this book since I like the author very much. I was however slightly disappointed. Although the story is interesting, it seems to me that it lacks substance and I felt like it was unfinished. I was of course fascinated by the magical details and the author's style and writing is perfect as expected. But I would have loved a more elaborate story, more details, just...more. The story would have benefited from a more elaborate plot and action.
It is however a young-adult...more
Michele Harrod
As I am an avid Hoffman fan, I thought I would check out some of her YA novels as well. Needless to say, I was in no way disappointed. Green Heart is a combination of Green Angel (written in 2003) and Green Witch (2010) following the life of Green after a disaster (somewhat unspecific beyond a 'fire in the city'). This novel takes you through the grief process of Green herself, many of her neighbours, and injured animals left behind in the aftermath of this tragedy. As usual her rhetoric simply...more
Jessica Fortunato
This book, a stunning conclusion to Green Angel, combines Green Angel with Green Witch resulting in Green Heart.

The book is beyond touching, and riddled with the magic that is love, and life itself.

For Green, traveling the town and writing down people's stories is her mission, especially the stories of the so called Witches in her village. She fights to preserve a life that otherwise has been demolished. To tell the stories of the people who are ridiculed the most, yet carry the most wisdom.

Ali...more
Shannonb_n_az
I checked this book out based on a short review through the Library. Though an adult by law, I still enjoy reading from the Young Adult genre(i.e. Hunger Games, Matched, Harry Potter). This quick read did not disappoint. The book speaks of magic, but it isn't in a "spells, potions and incantations" sort of way, but in a hearts and feelings sort of way. I read it as a story of loss, grief, recovery, and healing. I loved the writing, and the growth of the story. It truly is a fairy tale in a moder...more
Alena
This was two books in one, both very short, and worth the read. I liked the first book better than the second. The first book was like a poem and a fairytale wrapped into one. It was sad and haunting, uplifting, moving and beautiful. I personally didn't feel like the continued story/wrap-up of the plot in book two was necessary, and it didn't have the same impact on me as the first one, but I didn't dislike it either. There were still some lovely things, like how she made her own paper to write...more
kari
Apr 03, 2012 kari rated it 3 of 5 stars
Shelves: 2012, ya
While I liked the overall story here, I wish it had been fleshed out much more than it is. There is little to no dialogue and most of the story is what Green/Ash does, thinks, feels. I felt disconnected from this story, not sure why. Maybe because Green feels that way, but then again, in the second half, she is connecting with the world and I still didn't feel anything.
The writing is beautiful, but almost too sparse. There are magical elements to the story which were well woven into the plot.
It...more
Rebecca
In Green Heart Alice Hoffman is at her magical best. This fantasy delves into the harsh truths of ignorance and hatred, of the healing power of love of others as well as of one's self. To me it is a barely veiled story of the destructive power of blind religious hatred of all things different. It brings to mind the mindless acts of suicide bombers and religious leaders who imprison, maim and murder those who do not submit and blindly follow. Yet she shows these forces can be overcome by the simp...more
Holly
I knew nothing about this book before I began reading it. I learned it is two books in one. The first book, Green Angel, is about Green's journey through grief and finding herself again. She loses her whole family one awful day and she has to rebuild her life without those she loves most.

Green Witch is another journey, but one about finding your strength and figuring out who you are. There are little sub-stories about each woman who talks about the love they had lost.

This book was wonderful --...more
Monique
Oct 23, 2012 Monique rated it 5 of 5 stars Recommends it for: Females of all ages
When fifteen-year-old Green’s family go out to the city and are nowhere to be found after a fire set the city alight, she learns to become an independent young woman, who eventually discovers herself in ways she never knew after a journey of meeting some peculiar people, realising how much her family mean to her and realising what the true meaning of love is. And for Green now, her calling is to write down the stories of the people of the village, fight to keep the memories that would have disap...more
Sarah
This is a story about magic, about the physical and emotional manifestations of grief and healing, about war and peace, love and loss. This was a spare, poetic story with rich emotion and language, and I enjoyed it for the beauty of it. Some of its imagery will definitely stay with me, though the story itself may or may not, I'm not sure about that.

I'd recommend to to Francesca Lia Block fans, obviously Alice Hoffman fans, and fans of the verse novel (this isn't a verse novel, but it feels like...more
Kim
Jul 17, 2012 Kim rated it 4 of 5 stars
Shelves: 2012
When I was in middle school I read the first half of this book, Green Angel, and it was one of the most beautiful books I had ever encountered, and I'm happy to find that it is still as wonderful as I remembered. The second half of the book, Green Heart, is still beautiful, but I'm not sure how I sit with it. In many ways Angel was great as a stand alone book, but that isn't to say that Heart shouldn't have been written. In it's own way it is great, and it discusses new themes not shown in the f...more
Lauren
I won this book in a goodreads giveaway.

To be honest, I didn't expect much out of this book. The cover was cheesy, the type font was huge, and it was obviously meant for a much younger reader. However, I am so very glad that I gave it a chance- this novel definitely deserved it.

Green Heart was originally published as two separate novels titled Green Angel and Green Witch. It tells the story of a teenage girl who lost her entire family along with everything familiar about her world in a tragic fi...more
Victor Carson
Green Heart is really two short novels, one written in 2003 and the other in 2010, as a sequel. These two books are unlike any of the other novels by Alice Hoffman that I have read. Ms. Hoffman is one of my favorite authors, and I have read more than a dozen of her books. The setting for this two-part story is post-apocalyptic, or, perhaps, just post-September 11. A city, if not the whole country, has been heavily destroyed by fires set by people who came down out of the mountains to destroy our...more
Maryanne Balles Grabo
Green Heart
Two Novels: Green Angel and Green Witch by Alice Hoffman

I received this book as a winning in a Goodreads give-away. It really caught my attention, so I took the chance and entered my name. This is the first book I have ever won!

This is why I read it: The synopsis drew me in right away; a struggling fifteen-year-old girl left on her own after her family dies in a terrible disaster. She retreats into the ruined realm of her garden. She searches for the truth about love, hope and magic....more
Kristi
At first I couldn't get into this book and kept urging myself to read it, but as I went along I actually really started to enjoy it. The wording and scenery is like a Grimm fairy tale.
A very different YA dystopian novel but enjoyable none-the-less.
I think if I could give this 3.5 stars that would be a better fit.
The ending is done rather quickly and much too smoothly for all of the buildup, so that was a little disappointing, but it also made the book the perfect length and a quick read.
Warren
Green was not with her family when the disaster hit. She was at home tending the garden. Ash is everywhere. She is scared and sad and doesn't want to do anything. She gradually starts to live again. She find a stray Greyhound, two fledgling sparrows, a lost boy she names Dimond. She builds three monuments for her mother, her father, and her sister Aurora. A very compelling, eloquent story filled with grief, hope, loss, and survival and told as only Alice Hoffman can tell.
Alicia
These two books are both beautifully written with rich, descriptive words. The first has a great story line for someone who never really strays from where her home is. I love how descriptive Green is towards her family, mainly her younger sister, Aurora. Throughout the first book, it is very easy to comprehend how deep her despair is, and how greatly connected she is to her beloved garden.

Throughout the second book, the author starts to create a more poetic way of telling the story. This time wh...more
Jean Kelly
Just a delightful fantasy of a girl named Green who is the sole survivor when Hordes destroy the city where her parents and sister had gone to sell vegetables from their village garden. This is a story of love,magic, warmth. My favorite part was that when Green is making paper from scratch so she can collect the survivors stories she makes it of things that are special to bring out the individual's story.
A fun book with a real message about love and community.
Evelyn
Read this on a whim. Lovely, lyrical writing. The ending did not satisfy me (view spoiler)[(use violence to prevent more violence/kill all the bad guys: great message) but, given the time in which the book was written (shortly after 9/11), it makes an interesting look into the prevailing mentality. I'm probably extrapolating too much with that last statement.

Well-written post-apocalyptic fairy tale. Just the thing for a quiet afternoon at the library. (hide spoiler)]
Aubrey
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 99 100 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
Green Heart (Kindle Edition)
Green Heart: Green Angel and Green Witch (Hardcover)
Green Heart (ebook)
3502
Alice Hoffman was born in New York City on March 16, 1952 and grew up on Long Island. After graduating from high school in 1969, she attended Adelphi University, from which she received a BA, and then received a Mirrellees Fellowship to the Stanford University Creative Writing Center, which she attended in 1973 and 74, receiving an MA in creative writing. She currently lives in Boston and New York...more
More about Alice Hoffman...
The Dovekeepers Here on Earth Practical Magic The Ice Queen The Red Garden

Share This Book

Your website

No trivia or quizzes yet. Add some now »

“She was disappearing a little more each day, so thin, so frail, a wisp of smoke. One day she would surely vanish altogether, and there was no way to stop her.” 5 people liked it
“The frightened walk away when love is difficult. I know that now. You have to be willing to give everything away. You have to be willing to end up with nothing. Only then will your heart be whole.” 3 people liked it
More quotes…