The Last Temptation (Tony Hill & Carol Jordan, #3)
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating

The Last Temptation (Tony Hill & Carol Jordan #3)

4.0 of 5 stars 4.00  ·  rating details  ·  2,746 ratings  ·  175 reviews
The third Dr. Tony Hill mystery pits the deliberative psychological profiler against a devious and demented serial killer. If Hill seems to be taking this case personally, he has good reason: The gruesome mass murderer is preying on psychologists!
Hardcover, 431 pages
Published January 1st 2002 by HarperCollins Publishers
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.
This book is not yet featured on Listopia. Add this book to your favorite list »

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 3,000)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Ângela Costa
Este livro veio trazer uma lufada de ar fresco à minha leitura, que esteva a tornar-se desmotivante devido às minhas ultimas escolhas como livros. Val McDermid foi como um presente para encerrar 2013, com a sua inabalável qualidade literária.
De um lado temos um serrial killer, cujo alvo são psicólogos, de outro o desmantelamento de uma operação de tráfico de droga, armas e imigrantes ilegais, liderada por um homem que opera nas sombras. Embora a policia secreta alemã tenha conhecimento da sua id...more
A compulsively readable mystery which provided a vivid sense of place as Carol Jordan goes undercover in Germany to catch a corrupt smuggler. I was, however, annoyed by some illogical and reckless behavior that brought Carol and the profiler she admires so much, Tony Hill, into danger. It did not seem plausible that they would act so carelessly when they are usually highly intelligent (and don't they know they always nearly get killed?!) and when they knew they were likely under surveillance.
Can we just say *** PLACEHOLDER *** to all her books now? Um. Quick recollection: apt, echoing title on many levels. Multi-layered plot set in Europe, mostly Berlin. A serial killer whose own suffering might just have been a bit worse than the one he later inflicted. A modern high-flyer criminal who is actually worse, and yet had been done wrong by those supposed to uphold justice. A fate worse than death for one protagonist, and an annoyingly stupid carelessness by T+C that I could only forgive...more
This is a game-changer for the series. Eager to boost her career, Carol takes an undercover assignment in Germany to bust a major drugs, guns, and human trafficker. At the same time, Tony leaves his retirement from profiling to work on a case in Germany as well, where a serial killer seeks revenge on experimental psychologists, who he believes are responsible for his abuse at the hands of his grandfather.

As Carol and Tony begin to navigate their relationship into more intimate waters, Carol's s...more
The problem reading a series out of order is that sometimes the outcome of the plot and story line are already known. Despite this,I was engaged and surprised as the novel unfolded.

Chief Inspector Carol Jordan undertakes a covert assignment in exchange for a promotion in a new unit when the case reaches its end. The target is a drug dealing, people trafficking killer. Unbeknownst to her, she has been chosen for more than her detection skills but the leaders of this sting have deliberately chosen...more
Sometimes when my synapses are raw and sore I need to relax into a soothing bath of Val McDermid or Rankin. Just the job this one, as usual the pages turning themselves while I relax....
...but then, in the last third my brain started working again. McDermid's instinct was surely right not to turn the two stories in this novel into two separate books. She was wrong trying to squeeze them into one. While I look forward to exoskeletal plots in this genre, it becomes a bit much when the characters d...more
Wow! I really disliked this book...what a shock since I liked the first two so much. The entire premise of the story was so forced and the undercover scenario was ridiculous. It was like the author had an idea in her head and although everyone tried to talk her out of it, because it was utterly DUMB, she went ahead and wrote it anyway. What a piece of crap.
Jenny Hilborne
This dark and twisted thriller is not an easy read. Two in-depth plot lines play out side by side, both of which are good and would perhaps be better written as two separate books. The subplot is as involved as the main plot and, at times, the switch between them is jarring for the reader.

In one of the plots, Chief Inspector Carol Jordan undertakes a dangerous covert mission to bring down a European crime boss known for trafficking drugs and illegal immigrants. The fact she bears such a strikin...more
As McDermid creates a new psychopathic mystery for her readers, Tony Hill and Carol Jordan are back to test their wiles and personal chemistry. Seeking a new position, DCI Jordan interviews for a job with Europol, in hopes of using her skills to help those all across the continent. Handed an interesting file, whereby she must infiltrate the depths of a human smuggling ring, Jordan goes undercover to weasel her way right to the top. Stationed in Berlin and working with a German cop, Jordan seeks...more
Could be convoluted with the various characters and their bits, but a great flow.... compelling observations as we the reader walk through this plot........another book that kept me involved and attentive........after too many i didnt even finish...

Coming to terms over her breakup with criminal profiler Dr. Tony Hill, Chief Inspector Carol Jordan plunges into a risky undercover sting: track down a European drug trafficker and gain his confidence. But she's being tracked as well-by a serial kille...more
Ishmael Seaward
Okay read if you are slugabed with illness, bored with TV, and need something mildly stimulating. The story takes place in northern Europe. If you are a bit of an armchair traveler, this takes you on an abbreviated tour of some of northern Europe's waterways; it tempts the reader to dig out the Atlas and do some independent reading on the places mentioned.
It is two major plotlines that easily could be / should be two separate novels, doing better justice to both. Carol Jordan goes undercover to...more
At her best, McDermid can enthral me with her crime fiction, but I find her work very uneven and, while diverting enough, this novel was not amongst the best of hers I've read.

Realism is never one of McDermid's core strengths, but when reading this novel, I didn't so much have to willingly suspend my disbelief as hang draw and quarter it. There's the usual problem that Tony's "incredible psychological insights" seem to amount to a couple of superficial deductions that a five-year-old could have...more
Kirsty Darbyshire

Short version: just as good as I'd hoped it would be.

Long version:

I was disappointed in McDermid's last standalone book and so I was really worried that this one was going to miss the mark for me as well. This is the third story to feature Carol Jordan and Tony Hill (the previous two books were The Mermaid's Singing and The Wire in the Blood). I read both of the earlier books a while ago now and loved them both. There were plenty of elements in this book that could have made it a dreadful expe

aPriL meows 'n growls TLDR
This was terrible, as in in a friend baking you a cake for your birthday but she forgot to add sugar.

However. It's book 3 in a mystery series and I can tell the events will be referred to in following Tony Hill/Carol Jordan adventures. I can't recommend skipping it, but I wish I could.

For the record, the book's plot is too spread out, there are huge plot holes (too many and frankly, I'm too depressed to talk about it), Petra Becker is introduced (in case you missed them, there are Petra Becker m...more
These books are definitely located within the crime suspense thriller genre, but they stand out because of McDermid's ability to do two key things: create and manage a complicated plot with multiple characters handling several investigations *and* develop strong characters who aren't simply good or bad guys. In many ways she hits her stride with the two main characters. The end felt a little rushed, but I expect to see more discussed and resolved in the next book.

This book gives me many reasons...more
Well, the plot kept me engaged, but one has to suspend a bit of disbelief at times. One of the villains was quite interesting, while one other, the Serb lieutenant, was just a stereotypical East European goon straight out of central casting. But my main problem with this story, along with nearly all modern crime fiction, is that authors seem to strive to outdo eachother in the number of murders and the sadism involved in their execution. At least in this case McDermid tried to examine the mind a...more
Colin Guy
I really enjoyed this book, has a great plot with plenty twists to keep you on your toes. Whilst the central characters may not be as well defined as Rankin's Rebus, the tormented serial killer is brought to life with breath taking insights and historical background to make you think McDermid is more at home amongst them than our 'heroes'.
It is the best of the Hill/Jordan series I have read, though I have not yet read any of McDermids novels outside this series so I cannot compare in any real au...more
It is interesting to see how a series of novels (in any genre) develops over the course of time. The quality of the series (which is subjective) is one thing, other things that are of interest include the themes/canvas/setting that the author chooses over the course of the series and any change in them. Some authors seem to be clear right from the beginning about how the series is going to go. For instance, right from 'Faceless Killers', once can sense/see the themes that Mankell would expand up...more
The Crime Scene Scene
The Last Temptation is the third novel in the Dr Tony Hill and Carol Jordan series by author Val McDermid. After applying for a Europol liason job with NCIS Carol Jordan is recruited for an undercover operation to get close to a notorious European gangster because she looks like his recently deceased girlfriend. About to go undercover she discovers that Europol have stumbled onto what seems like a serial killer so she suggests that they recruit Dr Tony Hill to do a profile for them. It is an inv...more
Plot-wise, this novel had far too much going on. It was just over the top and a little implausible, even for Tony Hill and Carol Jordan: evil gangsters dealing in drugs and illegal immigrants and weapons, undercover operations, rescuing an informant's kid, a serial killer, Nazi childrens' psych ward victims, several violent deaths, violent rapes, four protagonists, and two romances. Far too much for a mere 481 pages.
I have about 30 pages to go and have been stuck at this point for quite a long time because I am scared that the main characters are going to get hurt. I'm too emotionally involved to be able to finish reading this book at night.
“Temptation” is the third mystery/thriller to feature psychologist and criminal profiler Dr. Tony Hill and policewoman extraordinaire DCI Carol Jordan. (We read the first but not the second, but wish we had read them in order given the many references to apparently what happened in the prior book…) McDermid shows a lot of plotting skill in running really two different and suspenseful stories concurrently – only connected really by the police principals. In one tale, German and Dutch police offic...more
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.
Minty McBunny
I have enjoyed this series a great deal & I am willing to accept some implausibles in the name of a good story, but this book just went too far.

(view spoiler)...more
Ein Psychologieprofessor aus Leiden wird misshandelt und ertränkt. Weitere, ähnliche Morde geschehen daraufhin in Deutschland und eher zufällig als Serienmorde entlarvt, weil die lesbische Leidener Ermittlungsbeamtin mit einer lesbischen Berliner Kollegin, die sie in einem Chatroom für gleichgeschlechtlich orientierte Polizisten kennen und lieben gelernt hat, darüber reden. Tony Hill übernimmt den Fall und reist nach Berlin, weil Carol Jordan dort einen neuen Auftrag hat. Sie soll als Undercover...more
Julie Griffin
This is not a book for the queasy. I picked it up at a Half-Price bookstore because I loved the BBC series Wire in the Blood which is based upon McDermid's books about profiler Tony Hill and police detective Carol Jordan. The series is sometimes a bit too dark for me, but nothing compared to this book. The third in the Hill/Jordan series, this book picks up with Hill and Jordan living in different cities. Previous cases have left them battered and scarred and distant from each other. Jordan is o...more
In what is probably the best book in the Tony Hill/Carol Jordan series, Carol is recruited for a very difficult undercover operation in Germany, in an effort to get close to a dangerous, yet charming, drug kingpin and his human smuggling operation, because, apparently, she closely resembles his late lover. At the same time, a killer is preying on research psychologists in Germany and the Netherlands, and the case is being worked by one of Carol's police contacts in Germany and her lover in Holla...more
Andy Bird
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.
Wendy Kobylarz-Chouvarda
Not much in the mood to write a review, but I found this one actually quite dull, boring and tedious. The supporting characters were annoying. This is vague, but the book was a huge letdown after the first one I read. I also despised the implication of animal rights activists as potential murderers of scientists (psychologists) - it was the thing that popped into the police's heads even though a well-researched policewoman would know that no AR activist has ever killed anyone, and of course the...more
Caroline Barker
This book was absolutelt brilliant. It was on a much larger scale than the first two as Carol and Tony were working to solve large cases in Europe.

I found the story to be more intense and the psychology of the book was profound. It is very obvious that Val McDermid has done her research thoroughly of certain areas of Europe (as she also focuses on a nearby country in the first book) and she has researched a great deal of history within these countries.

The book comes across as very believable wit...more
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 99 100 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
  • Telling Tales (Vera Stanhope, #2)
  • Above Suspicion (Anna Travis #1)
  • Ruling Passion (Dalziel & Pascoe, #3)
  • The Treatment (Jack Caffery, #2)
  • Lazybones (Tom Thorne, #3)
  • Blind Eye (Logan McRae, #5)
  • Dancing With The Virgins (Ben Cooper & Diane Fry, #2)
  • A Dedicated Man  (Inspector Banks, #2)
  • Disordered Minds
  • Service of All the Dead (Inspector Morse, #4)
Val McDermid was born and schooled on the east coast of Scotland and then Oxford University after which she became a journalist.

Her first book, Report for Murder was published in 1987 and since then she has gone on to have 25 more books published.

She lives in Manchester and Northumberland with 3 cats.
More about Val McDermid...
The Mermaids Singing (Tony Hill & Carol Jordan, #1) The Wire In The Blood (Tony Hill & Carol Jordan, #2) A Place Of Execution The Torment of Others (Tony Hill & Carol Jordan, #4) Fever of the Bone (Tony Hill & Carol Jordan, #6)

Share This Book

“You are Tadeusz Radecki? I am in the right place?' 'I know who I am. What I want to know is who you are.” 0 likes
More quotes…