Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “A Monster's Notes” as Want to Read:
A Monster's Notes
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating

A Monster's Notes

2.91 of 5 stars 2.91  ·  rating details  ·  127 ratings  ·  50 reviews
“A remarkable creation, a baroque opera of grief, laced with lines of haunting beauty and profundity.” —The Washington Post

Now in paperback, the bold, genre-defying book that asked: What if Mary Shelley had not invented Frankenstein's monster at all but had met him when she was a girl of eight, sitting by her mother's grave, and he came to her unbidden?

In a riveting mix...more
Paperback, 544 pages
Published January 17th 2012 by Knopf (first published 2009)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about A Monster's Notes, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about A Monster's Notes

This book is not yet featured on Listopia. Add this book to your favorite list »

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 766)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Meredith
Wow. I blazed through this (twelve hours or so, from the preface to the source notes on page 521, with some down time for watching a movie). This reimagining of Mary Shelley's life and the Frankenstein story was a brilliant idea--albeit a bit clumsy in execution. What I found particularly intriguing was the emphasis upon Cao Xueqin's classic "Dream of the Red Chamber", a story that constitutes a significant section of the disjointed story. This amplifies my desire to read my [ultra-abridged:] tr...more
Hannah
Beautiful. Stunning use of language gives an amazingly unique work of fiction a certain feel of poetry. The writing, the use of language gives off a palpable sense of sadness, not in the actual events of the plot, but in the way the characters speak. There is a certain sad, tragic beauty in it.

It's understandable, the words of a monster such as this would be sad and mournful, he was built from dead, discarded parts, abandoned, and seemingly unable to die. From the first paragraph, the monster's...more
Nika
I grabbed this from the library at the last minute because I LOVED the title and cover art, and the copy on the flap sounded fantastic! The premise is that Frankenstein's experiment actually came to life and met Mary Shelley when she was a young girl, inspiring her to write "Frankenstein" as an adult. The monster is real and kept a diary. Sounds great, right?

Had I thumbed through a few pages first, I would have discovered that this was not going to be a pleasurable read for me. It is formatted...more
Angie
i got 100 pages into this book before I could take it no more. It is almost like reading someone's grocery list.
Josh
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.
Sue Smith
Well - that was a complete waste of time and effort. The best part of this book was the cover - which oh so seduced me with it's suggestion of 'the eye of the soul' and 'an unfinished person' and 'a piece of the whole'...and on and on. I couldn't wait to read this book. What a complete disappointment. By the time I realized that it wasn't going to get any better, I'd already invested too much reading to just quit it. Lordy - the pain to finish it. Nearly did me in.

So what was this book about? Wh...more
Tuck
for !oulipo! fans. very creative fonts, addendas and has the whole gang too, little franky, mary, percy, clair claremont, ol doc victor, and MORE. neat idea too, mary shelley meets frank when she was a little girl of 8, and then the story takes off. frank is the "narrator" and prolific writer on this odd, long, interesting novel.
here's a recipe for you, for what ails ya:

"PRESCRIPTION (from chapter 10)

Ginseng .2 oz
Atractylis (clay baked) .2 oz
Pachyma cocos .3 oz
Prepared Ti root .4 oz
Aralia edulis...more
Adrielle
I did not find this to be a pleasurable read. For all the lovely language and meticulous research, I'm sorry to say that this beast of a book doesn't have much meat.

The reader is continuously and ferociously pounded by same themes. Each section has it's own emotional/philosophical focus and specific imagery which is repeated to the point of inciting eye-rolling and even page skipping. I believe a drastic paring down the the length of this volume could have made it something more meaningful. 520...more
Lee (Rocky)
When I began reading this, I knew nothing about this book other than a 3 sentence summary of the plot. As it turns out, to the extent that there is a plot, it is presented in a piece-meal, impressionist sort of way rather than any sort of straight forward narrative. As the title suggests, the book is composed of the monster's notes, not an actual story as such. Instead the book is made up of a series of notes expressing the monster's thoughts about various things, mixed with letters between vari...more
Carly
I actually quit reading this about half-an-hour in. I was exepcting a re-telling of the classic Frankenstein story, instead the book is a mish-mash of random thoughts categorized by topic. I found it difficult to follow and understand.
Christine
I actually didn't finish this book. Couldn't really get into it.
Matthew Hittinger
I finally finished after savoring this over the past month. So much to say, collecting my thoughts which seems the appropriate thing to do for a book where the word "mind" appears at least once on almost every page.

It's a brilliant and rewarding book for those with patience and those who like a good challenge. The writing style will take some adapting to: between the Monster's note-taking, how he juxtaposes quotes, notes and snippets of his autobiography and the epistolary mode which presents th...more
LeeAnn Heringer
This book started with such promise for me. The opening section with fragments questioning humanity vs machines, the nature of machine intelligence, whether astronauts are still human once they are detached from Earth and then... *sigh* it moved into following the live stories of the original writer of Frankenstein, it moved into talking about the isolation of the Arctic, which was also interesting if less so. And then I hit the section of on the friend of Dr. Frankenstein now living in China ex...more
Bookmarks Magazine
"Comprised of letters, newspaper clippings, journal entries, interviews, dreams, lists, Web pages, and essays, Sheck's demanding, erudite novel eschews a cohesive plot in favor of the monster's growing comprehension of his plight -- an outsider looking in on humanity. Despite the obscure references to long-ago philosophers, poets, and novelists that left the Washington Post ""lurching along about 50 IQ points behind,"" critics were oddly moved by the beauty of Sheck's desolate vision and lyrical...more
Jerry Miller
I read a review of this book which convinced me to read it. I did not like it on page one and my feelings didn't change. I found the styling tedious and the story was not enjoyable. The premise sounded great, Frankenstein's monster actually existed and was the basis for Mary Shelley's novel. Unfortunately, at least for me, this book did not live up to what could have been.
Sofia
I was intrigued by the premise of this book, especially because I've always liked Mary Shelley's "Frankenstein" and I enjoy reading stories from a different point of view. The dust jacket made this sound so promising! Alas, I made it 302 pages into this book and gave up. It's a relatively fast read since most pages aren't filled with text, but I just have too many other books on my shelf that I'd rather try instead.
Gina
Almost done!

This book deeply explores the idea of being an outcast and being shunned by the world through the story of the fictional nameless creature created by Frankenstein and story of the real Mary Shelley. Sometimes the cerebral approach of writing this book in "notes" or inner monologues and the lack of dialogue can make the subject matter overwhelming. However the themes of desperation, loneliness and desire are deftly explored, giving real pause to the reader about human relationships a...more
Stephanie
Written from the perspective of Frankenstein, these are his notebooks. The author Laurie Sheck is also a poet and this is a very lyrical novel. You could really open the book up at any point and find a really beautiful passage. This is what I did. I would never be able to read the book all the way through though. It's way too long and very reflective and philosophical. Not that I don't like reflective and philosophical - I do - just not long ones :) It's kind of like picking up Marcel Proust - b...more
Leslie
I'm undecided as to how i feel about this book. It is obviously painstakingly researched and thought out. I like the idea that it proposes Frankenstein's monster met p with mary shelley when she was a little girl, b/c that's the kind of speculative shit i can get behind. And frankly, the whole Shelley entourage is fascinating. But the fragments... The lack of a strict narrative... The excessive existential philosophy... Ugh. Too postmodern for me, i'm having flashback to that insane class i took...more
Nicole
I loved the concept of this book but simply couldn't get into it. I wanted more of the backstory. How did Mary and the monster meet, why did she write him as she did, why is he obsessed with Claire? Obviously, some of these questions would have been answered if I could force myself to continue turning the page, but...I couldn't.

Fascinating musings and notes taken in small doses but a bit much in novel format. Write a more traditional fiction narrative and I'd be all over it! (Oh jeez, did I real...more
Amy Smith
I was prepared to love this book, but it didn't happen. I thought it was going to be a novel about the friendship between Mary Wollstonecraft Shelley and the monster and how she betrayed him with her book, Frankenstein. It wasn't. It was a bunch of notes that the monster has made about this, that, and the other, over the past 100+ years. He's apparently still alive, since he googled at some point. And in all honesty, I didn't finish it, but skimmed thru most of it, trying to find the story.
Rachel
I think people don't realize that this book is actually closer to poetry than just a straightforward novel is. When you open it, don't expect to get some cute-sy lovelorn story about a beautiful girl and a monster. I almost think the dust-jacket description leads you in the wrong direction. This is a slow-moving, detail-filled, encyclopedia of a story. It can impress you, bore you, or engage you, but just be aware of what it is before you jump in.
Enka-Candler Library
I confess, I skimmed this one a bit, but I still liked it. Hard to define, as it's a collection of writings and musings by "The Monster". It would be best if you knew a little about the history of Frankenstein and the life of Mary Shelley, otherwise it could be super confusing. The author has done a TON of research for this and it definitely shows. Lots of references to classical writings so it could be daunting to pretty much everyone.
--Leisa
Americanogig
Barely even started before I had to turn it into the library, probably because it seems a little daunting, Frankenstein’s monster…in his own words. Think more Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein existential crisis than the bolt-necked horror classic of yore. Another book that required too much of a commitment at that time, but it wasn’t the book’s fault! I lay the blame at my own doorstep.
Liza Gilbert
This book was not to my tastes. The story of Frankenstein's monster, as revealed through the monster's own collection of notes, is a little too abstractly conceptual for me. Sheck seems want to stress the social responsibility that comes with creating a monster. To me, this is something better read in an ethics class than just for the sheer enjoyment of it.
Fran
This was a challenging read for me, but there is something haunting about it that kept me hooked. I liked the monster's connection to Mary Shelley, Claire (her sister), the Clerval character who the Monster murdered in the book. Although I read Frankenstein some decades ago, I want to read it again with the fuel provided by this touching story/poem.
Wendy
Aug 24, 2009 Wendy rated it 2 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommends it for: People who consider themselves deep thinkers
This book was written by a woman who usually publishes as a poet. You will like it if you like rambling sentences and broken-off thoughts. There is no true story line or plot, just a bunch of thoughts interspersed with confusing, rambling letters. I didn't hate it and I read the entire thing but it was a relief to finally be done.
Elizabeth
Sep 11, 2009 Elizabeth marked it as to-read  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: classics
As seen in the New Yorker .

Maybe this book will help me get Frankenstein, which I currently most emphatically do not.
Gina
I had such high hopes for this, after reading the description in EW, but I was disappointed. The third of the book that directly links the monster and Mary Shelley was everything I hoped, but the first 2/3 was rambling and only slightly interesting, even to someone as obsessed with the haunted summer as myself.
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 25 26 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
  • The Language of Inquiry
  • The Body: An Essay
  • The Last Single Woman in America
  • Museum of Accidents
  • The Master Letters: Poems
  • Short Talks
  • Midwinter Day
  • The Dream of the Rood
  • The Plains
  • Sorry, Tree
  • Interior with Sudden Joy: Poems
  • The Man With Night Sweats
  • The Works of Anne Bradstreet (John Harvard Library)
  • Chronic
  • Silence: A Thirteenth-Century French Romance
  • Frankenstein / Dracula / Dr Jekyll And Mr Hyde (Signet Classics)
  • Selected Poems
  • A New Literary History of America
Captivity Black Series: Poems Poem a Day: Vol. 2: A Wide Range of Classic and Modern Poems The Willow Grove Io at Night

Share This Book

“So much of life is invisible, inscrutable: layers of thoughts, feelings, outward events entwined with secrecies, ambiguities, ambivalences, obscurities, darknesses strongly present even to the one who's lived it- maybe especially to the one who's lived it. I didn't seek to find her, wandered instead within and among her fragments of language-notebooks, drafts, journals, fictions, letters, essays, and found there whole worlds like spinning planets, lived in their cold light and burning light, wondering where I was, where they might take me. Curious, I heard a monster's voice and followed-” 1 likes
More quotes…