Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “Mudwoman” as Want to Read:
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating
Open Preview


3.2 of 5 stars 3.20  ·  rating details  ·  1,725 ratings  ·  380 reviews
A riveting novel that explores the high price of success in the life of one woman—the first female president of a lauded ivy league institution—and her hold upon her self-identity in the face of personal and professional demons, from Joyce Carol Oates, author of the New York Times bestseller A Widow’s Story

Mudgirl is a child abandoned by her mother in the silty flats of th
Hardcover, 448 pages
Published March 20th 2012 by Ecco (first published January 1st 2012)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about Mudwoman, please sign up.

Recent Questions

This question contains spoilers… (view spoiler)

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 3,000)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Gary  the Bookworm
Photobucket Pictures, Images and PhotosThis is an engrossing but unsettling psychological tale about an accomplished academic who begins to unravel after long-repressed memories from early childhood engulf her. Oates blends gothic horror with behind the scenes politics in the rarified world of an ivy league university. That she can so effectively convey this world, and a depiction of life in a sleepy city in upstate NY, is not surprising given her storytelling gifts. What makes this so compelling is that you aren't sure if what you ...more
Lolly LKH
I got a hold of a rare edition advanced release read. So time to dig in.


This novel is darkly disturbing and I love it. As with many Oates novels, it begins slowly and creeps along until you feel as if you are experiencing M.R.'s life. I am in awe of the writer that can make me feel what the character is feeling. After I finished Mudwoman, I felt anxious and just thought 'whoa'. I know other people have said that it 'goes nowhere'. I suppose if one's goal in reading literature is to
May 12, 2012 Juta rated it 1 of 5 stars
Recommends it for: No-one
Shelves: tried-to-read
I felt like I'd been reading this book for hours when I first wanted to give up on it. I told myself to give it fifty pages and got past seventy, but it was hard going. Every. Single. Sentence. is overwritten. I felt like the author wanted to say after each paragraph, "Did you see how poetic my prose was? Huh? Huh? Did ya? Did you see how chock full of meaning it all is? Huh? Which is a pity, because I felt that the story itself was going somewhere. But the writing stopped me caring about where ...more

I intentionally waited several weeks to attempt to review JCO's Mudwoman: it left me with a really empty feeling inside, realizing that one of my favorite brood-meisters has quite possibly reached the end of her career, and I so hoped I could show it some Goodreads love and let it percolate its way into a 5-star rating. Um...nope...the 3.11 cume (so far) doesn't lie: it's a creaky mess. And all the more saddening if you realize it was written after her husband of 45+ years passed away, and seems
Monica Casper
As an academic and a (former) administrator, there was much that I truly loved about this book. Oates perfectly captures the interior life and exterior "performance" of academic administration; I saw in Meredith many recognizable qualities, and occasionally, I saw myself. The first third of the book is lovely as we come to know Meredith and her childhood counterpart, Merry. There were times I thought, this could be Marya all grown up (referencing an earlier Oates book that defined my college yea ...more
There is almost nothing more exciting than finding a new Joyce Carol Oates book on the library shelves. Her newest, Mudwoman, shines with her usual brilliance on every page, captures a kind of personal and social essence that is rarely achieved in literature. I know the word ‘visceral’ is so overused but the actual sensation of reading this book can be described no other way. Mudgirl, Mudwoman, M.R. – an abandoned child, an adopted teenager, president of an elite university. Within her, we see t ...more
I usually love (or at least like a lot) Joyce Carol Oates's work. This one, however, was too ambiguous for me. Her prose is very poetic, and I admire her fluid style, as if words just pour out of her. But this tale of the disintegration of "M.R. Neukirchen", the president of a Princeton-like university, was too fraught with horrific dreams and seemingly fugue-like states to fully engage me. The question of whether something was really happening to M.R., or was she just dreaming or having psychot ...more
Linda Flood
I didn't really like this book and was surprised given how much I usually enjoy this authors work. I found the book confusing, unclear and depressing. I am still not sure which of the musings are real and which are the alter persona Mud Woman's delusions and confusion. Apart from the late connection with her father the main character seems to have no personal ties to anyone and seems to connect on more than a superficial level to no one. I wish that the moral decision regarding accepting or decl ...more
I really want to write a good review of this book. I really do. But, I just can't. This was my first Joyce Carol Oates attempt and I was initially enthralled with the book's premise: the story of a now successful woman who, as a child, was left for dead in a mud flat by her insane mother.
The story of her fight for survival(and eventual success) could have been a heart wrenching and compelling one. Instead, it was confusing and lacked the emotional dynamism I would expect from such a story.
Mar 04, 2012 Don marked it as to-read
I wonder why everyone who commented on this page appears to be female. Don't men read JCO too (they should)
Sian Lile-Pastore
I couldn't decide it it was a four or five star... but have gone for five.... maybe it's a 4.5er though.
I really love Joyce Carol Oates's books, she is a genius and writes incredibly diverse and believable characters. I really love her writing style as well (although I can see that it would not be to everyones taste)the way she uses italics and repetition - in Mudwoman the word 'brackish' comes up over and over again.

Mudwoman is about a woman who becomes president of a university and how her tra
This was not the kind of book I read for entertainment. Very poderous and slow to develop. I am surprised that so many people found it engrossing. I was not prepared to finish the book
This novel was just so-so. The peripheral characters were enjoyable, sometimes even remarkable (The foster family, the adoptive parents, and the high school math teacher were really well done.), but M.R. Neukirchen (aka Mudwoman) never quite seemed real to me. Obviously, she is deteriorating psychologically as she is placed under stress and starts to remember her supressed and tormented past, but Oates fails to distinguish reality from dream or psychotic episode, and leaves the reader as confuse ...more
Every time I read a Jonathan Franzen novel I get pissed off on behalf of Anne Tyler. She covers many of the same themes that Franzen seems obsessed with. And while she is highly praised, she pales next to the rock star Franzen has become (this inequity is encapsulated by trade terms: Tyler's fiction is "domestic" while Franzen's is "literary.")

Along those lines, I am now going to cry for Oates every time Jeffery Eugenides' name is mentioned. Both authors share a faux-jaded worldview and seem to
Sunny Shore
I wouldn't recommend this book to everyone....only to people who want to read something different or are die-hard Joyce Carol Oates fans. I loved it and that's the bottom line for me because of the personal connection each person has to a particular book. Mudgirl is left as a very small child to die and we watch as she rises to become a Cornell and Harvard graduate and eventually president of an Ivy League university, after being adopted by a caring couple. You know that her psychological scars ...more
Joyce Carol Oates is amazing. I've just finished Mudwoman and I'm breathless. I've been reading her books since the'70's. How does she reinvent herself in so many way? M. R. is not Ms. Oates; yet her protagonist's voice is so strong and pleasant and charismatic that I tended to mix them up as M. R. tended to confuse herself. How many of us retell our lives; if only I had done this or that. Perhaps he was threatening me or flirting with me...or ignoring me....he wasn't there.
As I came to the last
JCO spins a fine web for this story, lures us in, goes in for the kill, but then leaves us hanging in a Poe-like fashion. Excellent craftsmanship and a brashly confident use of language. In this story as is often the case in JCO's writing, the main character rises up from the direst of circumstances to a level so high that it feels undeserved; no matter how hard she works, she can never merit the acclaim she receives. The past comes to haunt her and tears at the roots of her success. In this cas ...more
Oh how I hate to say I did not like this. I struggled from the first page to the last, often skimming to get through. I so wanted to like it as Oates is such a recommended author. This was my first novel of hers and while I was prepared for something "different", I was not ready to find this a book that I wanted to put away, and yet I kept on. While the writing at times was beautifully descriptive, I found so much repetative narration that did nothing for me. I felt I was being led to something ...more
Laura Planton
A girl abandoned from her mother is rescued from the mud she is left to die in. She survives, goes to a foster home and then is adopted by the Neukirchen's - a couple looking to replace their child who has died. The even name the mudchild the same name as their deceased child, Meredith Ruth Neukirchen, MR for short. MR becomes in later life the president of an Ivy League college. Repetitive, confusing and a plot that goes between sanity and insanity left me wondering what I was reading.
Ms Oates' writing was lovely, poetic almost. The pace of the story was very slow and somewhat disjointed. It was difficult to tell which parts of the narrative were actual and which were part of M.R.'s breakdown. Nothing was resolved in the end, which was terribly abrupt. Two and a half stars - I enjoyed the writing but I don't feel that there was any resolution at all in any of M.R.'s personal relationships, in her own self awareness or in her career.
It's a terrible book. The plot is an unredeeming effort. It is all madness and the antiheroine right to the end. Feels like a bad dream wherein you are trying to flee but can only move in slow motion. I do not recommend this. Why did Oates write this? What is she trying to say? Getting old must really be depressing her.
I really didnt care for for it...wanted to finish to see how it would was too drawn out and some parts you didnt know if it happened or was her imagination...the ending didnt seem to finish the story..
I was intrigued by the "Poe-ness" of the plot but I couldn't force myself to care about MR, her past, or her shaky future. I abandoned this around the time that Mudgirl is saved by "the King of Crows."
What a bizarre tale Ms. Oates has spun. I believe JCO is a very gifted writer, however, this story was a little to weird for me.

The Protagonist is a highly intelligent woman who became the first female Presidnet of an ivy league University.

She may be an intellect, but she is also a social misfit and seems to be very awkward & uncomfortable around pepole. Her life begins to unravel as she remembers and focuses on her tramatic childhood in which her mother tossed her out "in the mud" to die. S
Tina Cipolla
This was my first Joyce Carol Oates book and I thoroughly enjoyed it. This main character, M.R., is a fascinating character. She is left for dead as a 3 year old in a mudflat and she is saved by a animal trapper. The story details the rest of her life which by almost all accounts is a fabulous success. She is adopted by parents who adore her--even though she has been adopted as a replacement for their own biological child who has died. She is a star student her entire life and goes on to an Ivy ...more
I love Joyce Carol Oates! And with the subject matter of this novel I knew (thought) I would be in for another Oates woman rising from the muck to live out a twisted adult fairy tale, and I got that. But I also was left somewhat unsatisfied. The novel begins in the usual Oates fashion, pulling you down into the depths of a deeply damaged character, who you root for, and or at the same time admire, feel empathy for, and become engrossed in their journey. But in the end I was left unsatisfied beca ...more
Lara Kleinschroth
JCO is the reigning Queen of contemporary American literature and after such a prolific career, she just keeps getting better. No one alive today captures the seething, Gothic underbelly of every day America the way she does. This is a horror story rooted in fairy tale about a very modern woman, and yet it is so much more. Themes of love and loss, twins and opposites, politics and morality, philosophy, paradoxes and magic in our every day lives, nightmare and reality, secrets and demons... And t ...more
Sam Sattler
Mudwoman is dark even by Joyce Carol Oates standards. Oates is well known for novels featuring female leads that do not sense the physical jeopardy they are in before it is almost too late to escape it. Suddenly, these women - as intelligent and accomplished as they may be – recognize that they have wandered into a situation that could cost them their lives. The threat usually comes from an evil or deranged man but, in the case of Mudwoman, all the damage is done by a little girl’s own mother.

Surprisingly, I really liked this book and didn't find it at all difficult to read, as some of my friends had indicated. I loved Oates writing style, as it is so very descriptive and full of symbolism. For example, she uses various names for the protagonist to indicate different stages of her life/struggles: Jedina, Jewell, Mudgirl, Mudwoman, M.R., Meridith, Merry. These were used throughout either to be historical or to indicate when M.R. was slipping back into her past (into the "mud", so to s ...more
I really enjoyed it as a whole; an accomplished adult dealing with childhood trauma(s). I think it was delightfully accurate in the portrayal of creeping madness and inaccurate memory recall. I agree that it was a bit tedious during the scenes of M.R.'s academic life and that as a reader I was more interested in mudgirl than mudwoman. I think that was part of the point---we get only a glimpse of the trauma that Jedina/Jewell suffered b/c "You don't have to understand why anything has happened to ...more
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 99 100 next »
topics  posts  views  last activity   
andre 1 6 Dec 07, 2013 09:08AM  
heidemann 7 35 Aug 12, 2013 09:40PM  
Konrad 2 12 Aug 12, 2013 09:17PM  
  • Noah's Ark
  • What They Do in the Dark
  • Love and Shame and Love
  • Drowned
  • Shade
  • Burning Bright
  • The Magnificent Spinster
  • The Last Warner Woman
  • The Emergence of Judy Taylor
  • After Life
  • English Music
  • Ghost Lights: A Novel
  • Days of the Bagnold Summer
  • Absolution
  • My Dirty Little Book of Stolen Time
  • Hidden Lives: A Family Memoir
  • Strangers at the Feast
  • King of the Badgers
Joyce Carol Oates is a recipient of the National Book Award and the PEN/Malamud Award for Excellence in Short Fiction. She is also the recipient of the 2005 Prix Femina for The Falls. She is the Roger S. Berlind Distinguished Professor of the Humanities at Princeton University, and she has been a member of the American Academy of Arts and Letters since 1978. Pseudonyms ... Rosamond Smith and Laure ...more
More about Joyce Carol Oates...
We Were the Mulvaneys The Falls The Gravedigger's Daughter Blonde Foxfire: Confessions of a Girl Gang

Share This Book

“Paradox: how do we know what we have failed to see because we have no language to express it, thus we cannot know that we have failed to see it.” 9 likes
“The challenge is to resist circumstances. Any idiot can be happy in a happy place, but moral courage is required to be happy in a hellhole.” 8 likes
More quotes…