A Civil Action
"The legal thriller of the decade." --Cleveland Plain Dealer
Now a Major Motion Picture!
In this true story of an epic courtroom showdown, two of the nation's largest corporations stand accused of causing the deaths of children. Representing the bereaved parents, the unlikeliest of heroes emerges: a young, flamboyant Porsche-driving lawyer who hopes to win millions of dollar...more
Now a Major Motion Picture!
In this true story of an epic courtroom showdown, two of the nation's largest corporations stand accused of causing the deaths of children. Representing the bereaved parents, the unlikeliest of heroes emerges: a young, flamboyant Porsche-driving lawyer who hopes to win millions of dollar...more
ebook, 512 pages
Published
August 10th 2011
by Vintage
(first published 1995)
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
This book is not yet featured on Listopia.
Add this book to your favorite list »
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
3,000)
A gripping and informative saga of a man's resolve to take on a giant corporation for purportedly causing cancer by polluting the groundwater in a residential area (yes, reminds you of Erin Brockovich). What is most amazing about the story is that something happens to the protagonist in the story - some event that appeals deeply to his conscience - that makes him give everything he had in his quest for justice.
The movie inspired by this book is superbly made, especially the protagonist's monolog...more
The movie inspired by this book is superbly made, especially the protagonist's monolog...more
ISBN 0679772677 - A true story, A Civil Action is the story of several families in Woburn, Massachusetts, who find their children - and themselves - suffering health problems apparently caused by the dumping of chemicals by two companies. The Riley Tannery (a subsidiary of Beatrice Foods) and W.R. Grace are accused of negligently, even knowingly, contaminating the groundwater in east Woburn by dumping toxins. Young children are the first and most obvious group to become sick, dying of leukemia i...more
The book this most reminded me of was Class Action but where that focuses on the plaintiffs and their experiences as the lawsuit and trial dragged on, this focuses almost entirely on the lawyers. Jan Schlichtmann accepts the case of families in Woburn, MA, whose children died of leukemia after being exposed to water contaminated by industrial pollution. As the costs of investigating the case and gathering evidence increase, Schlichtmann and his team keep increasing their imagined jury award to c...more
I first read A Civil Action just about 5 years ago exactly. Now that I work in the environmental consulting field, everything makes so much more sense, and, thus, is more interesting. I better understand the plaintiffs' fears and also the enormity of the task facing their lawyers in researching and putting together a case of this magnitude. The amount of money, paper documentation, manpower, and expertise that was needed is mind-boggling, especially considering my current part in that process.
Th...more
Th...more
An inside look at the case that made Jan Schlictmann famous: unscrupulous corporations poisoning the ground water supply, causing deaths and illness in the local community, and working to cover it up. Really sheds light on the adverse effects of litigation on plaintiffs' attorneys (as opposed to Class Action, which sheds light on the adverse effects of litigation on plainitffs). You really have to be able to disconnect and balance, or else a case can eat you alive. And no matter how right you ar...more
When I met the Austrian cycle tourist in the UAE desert he begged me for some reading material and I apologetically told him that I had none to spare. Well once we'd parted I immediately thought of this book as perfect for him, given to me highly recommended by the Austrian couple on my Konkani Coast ride. On the other hand, I'm selfishly glad I didn't hand it over - it was a riveting read. A courtroom drama about an environmental spill possibly causing the deaths of several New England resident...more
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
Jul 21, 2011
Adam
rated it
5 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Recommends it for:
I-wanna-be-a-hot-shot-attorney types
You never quite know what you're going to get when you ignite a firework fuse.
After a few milliseconds, sparks begin to fly and the long thin primer seemingly evaporates before your eyes. As you launch the compact package into a field you inadvertently hold your breath, waiting for the finale.
Light headed, it suddenly dawns on you that maybe there won't be an explosion. Perhaps you read the package wrong. You bought a sparkler, not a popper. Or, maybe it's just a dud.
You take in a breath of air...more
After a few milliseconds, sparks begin to fly and the long thin primer seemingly evaporates before your eyes. As you launch the compact package into a field you inadvertently hold your breath, waiting for the finale.
Light headed, it suddenly dawns on you that maybe there won't be an explosion. Perhaps you read the package wrong. You bought a sparkler, not a popper. Or, maybe it's just a dud.
You take in a breath of air...more
This was one of the best examples of creative non-fiction i have ever read. And it was beyond disappointing. Jonathan Harr recreate the effort of attorney Jan Schlichtmann to sue Beatrice Foods and W.R. Grace company for befouling the water of Woburn Mass, causing clusters of leukemias and children dying.
Sonewhere I read that this book shows how one man can make a diffeence. Obviously I anticipated that would be the case. I couldn't believe that a judge could be as corrupt as the judge who hear...more
Sonewhere I read that this book shows how one man can make a diffeence. Obviously I anticipated that would be the case. I couldn't believe that a judge could be as corrupt as the judge who hear...more
A true story that would probably fit easily into the John Grisham genre. A gripping tale of a small time law firm taking on the big corporations on a case of environmental pollution leading to leukemia deaths. The book brings out the difficulty that a lawyer would face in trying to prove causality in a complex medical case. It differs from fiction in showing the fact that that success is extremely rare. The small law firm faces innumerable difficulties mostly with respect to financial aspects as...more
This is the true story of a nine year legal battle involving flamboyant, obsessed and ambitious lawyer, Jan Schlictmann, and two large corporations accused of exposing a cluster of mostly children to water contaminated by industrial pollution. The town is Woburn, Massachusetts. The time is the 1970's. Children are dying from leukemia. Fast forward to the late 80's and early 90's when Schlictman and his crew try to find a link between very sick and dying people and the dumping of toxic waste whic...more
I have friends who live in Woburn; I think i'll drink bottled water when I go visit.
This is the story of Jan Schlictmann and the litigation that he and his firm brought against two corporate behemoths (W.R. Grace and Beatrice Foods) regarding the seepage of chemicals (TCE notably) in Woburn, MA throughout the 60s and 70s. The book focuses mainly on the trial - on the conversations, on the emotion, on the preparation. It is not, however, a legal piece. This is a story more about the people and s...more
This is the story of Jan Schlictmann and the litigation that he and his firm brought against two corporate behemoths (W.R. Grace and Beatrice Foods) regarding the seepage of chemicals (TCE notably) in Woburn, MA throughout the 60s and 70s. The book focuses mainly on the trial - on the conversations, on the emotion, on the preparation. It is not, however, a legal piece. This is a story more about the people and s...more
As a writer who is planning to become an attorney this book has really changed my views on writing. The context of writing facts and legal issues is the main thing that I took away from this novel. This is based on a real case that happened and changed the litigation world with its verdict. The most interesting part about this story is although it has a lot of elements, facts, and evidence, there is a story that goes on. The author uses the attorney who deals with the major issues as the main ch...more
A Civil Action Book Review
A Civil Action is a nonfiction book written by Jonathan Harr. It follows the story of Jan Schlichtmann, a lawyer who ends up devoting nine years of his life to a legal battle against two behemoth corporations, W.R. Grace and Beatrice. Both companies were accused of polluting the water supply of a small town named Woburn, north of Boston. After several residents die of leukemia and other diseases, a handful of families stand up and sue the two corporate behemoths. A mas...more
A Civil Action is a nonfiction book written by Jonathan Harr. It follows the story of Jan Schlichtmann, a lawyer who ends up devoting nine years of his life to a legal battle against two behemoth corporations, W.R. Grace and Beatrice. Both companies were accused of polluting the water supply of a small town named Woburn, north of Boston. After several residents die of leukemia and other diseases, a handful of families stand up and sue the two corporate behemoths. A mas...more
Dec 04, 2008
Antof9
rated it
3 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
2007-read,
made-me-cry
My lame review from BookCrossing: So I had every intention of writing a brilliant and insightful book review on this book. However, it was book #70 of 2007, and I'm now on book #58 of 2008, and frankly it's not going to happen.
I will say this -- it was fascinating, and I think I appreciated it more after my book club read the famous In Cold Blood. I remember that it was riveting, and I didn't want to put it down. The jury selection, in particular, was fascinating, and kept me on the edge of my s...more
I will say this -- it was fascinating, and I think I appreciated it more after my book club read the famous In Cold Blood. I remember that it was riveting, and I didn't want to put it down. The jury selection, in particular, was fascinating, and kept me on the edge of my s...more
This is some red-meat nonfiction, totally gripping most of the way through. Definitely reminiscent of In Cold Blood, except with many more moving parts. I read Harr's The Lost Painting previously, and I could see why he might have taken on such a low-key project after covering the exhausting affair behind A Civil Action.
Harr's ability to synthesize a seemingly unending case into a readable book of less than 500 pages is a wonder to behold. His access to the inner workings of the case is also inc...more
Harr's ability to synthesize a seemingly unending case into a readable book of less than 500 pages is a wonder to behold. His access to the inner workings of the case is also inc...more
This book is a tremendous read. What impressed me the most wasn't the author's development of Schlichtmann's character (both his magnetism and profound agony come right off the page, occasionally at the same time) but his devotion to documenting the case as it happened over the course of many years. It must have been quite a labor considering the scope and duration of the case.
It's an eye opening account to the flaws in our legal system, especially the autonomy afforded to our courts - they see...more
It's an eye opening account to the flaws in our legal system, especially the autonomy afforded to our courts - they see...more
Good insight on what it's like to be a Boston lawyer and a lawyer in general. It means Princeton sort of life: hard work all the time (w/ adrenaline), big rewards, good reps, good food, nice living, and some losses. Have to be strategic about picking cases to fight for. Otherwise, same old, typical, boring, no rep thing. Like Erin Brocavich but from a lawyer's point of view, and of one who totally loves to spend. Better idea of what it's like to be in a court fighting other lawyers and working w...more
I picked this book as an independent reading book in middle school, and unfortunately I never got myself around to finishing it. I finally did, and I actually really enjoyed reading it. I tend to get absorbed into books which were based on true events, which this book was.
Based off of an actual courtroom trial, we see two sides that try to defend themselves against being accued of polluting the water in the town which ends up ending the lives of many (children in particular). We are taken throug...more
Based off of an actual courtroom trial, we see two sides that try to defend themselves against being accued of polluting the water in the town which ends up ending the lives of many (children in particular). We are taken throug...more
This book taught me a lot about the legal profession and the difficult life of a trial lawyer. The main character, Schlichtmann, did everything he could for his clients, a group of people in a neighborhood probably on the wrong side of the tracks, whose kids contracted leukemia at a rate fantastically above the norm (12 kids died of it, usually 4/100,000 people get it), due to industrial toxic waste disposal that seeped into their city water. There was nothing he could do about the fact that the...more
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
When I saw the movie version of this as a kid, I think I unknowingly was becoming primed to be an environmentally-focused person when I got older. Finally getting around to reading the book a few years ago, the story again resonated with me. The book is obviously more mature and nuanced than the movie was, getting into far more legal and slightly more scientific detail. There are more community stories, and they are presented more objectively than the dramatized film version. The film's "villain...more
Living here in Massachusetts I remember this case vividly. Woburn was formerly a "leather" town and this case involved a tannery whose inattention, greed and lack of supervision to its manufacturing process poisoned the town's water supply and resulted in countless cases of illness, miscarriages and death. A local slick and ambitious attorney, looking for the big payday, takes up this cause and the resultant "Civil Action" becomes national news.
This is a riveting read that was ultimately made...more
This is a riveting read that was ultimately made...more
First of all, as a caveat to this review, I should point out that I was reading this as a required reading as part of my law school's Civil Procedure course. I think in some ways this makes me think of reading the book as more of a chore and therefore may have detracted from my enjoyment of it somewhat, however for the most part, my knowledge of American Civil Procedure probably meant I enjoyed it more than I may have done a year ago.
This book is about a small town near Boston. Some of the child...more
This book is about a small town near Boston. Some of the child...more
A Civil Action is about a court case involving the pollution of wetlands and town water supply by the Grace and Beatrice companies in Woburn, MA with TCE and perc and its connection to a cancer cluster in that town. I enjoyed reading this book because it was extremely thorough in discussing legal proceedings and how the court worked. Having been a 4 year old at the time many of the children in this book became sick, and having lived roughly 40 miles away in NH, it was easy for me to imagine I...more
Well-written non-fiction/memoir of a plaintiff firm's unrelenting pursuit of justice---or at least a really big payoff. The true story of a bunch of partners who take out second mortgages on their houses and hock their prized possessions in order to keep their case afloat is incredible. The men are daring, or foolhardy, but they are so convinced of their position that they cannot be objective about the risks.
The book is better than the movie. Hope I didn't spoil it for you!
Being a defense atto...more
The book is better than the movie. Hope I didn't spoil it for you!
Being a defense atto...more
I picked this up because I had 20 minutes to kill before dinner. Twenty minutes of reading and I was hooked. I had seen the movie twenty-some-odd years ago, so I was expecting the book to track the movie. The book did indeed include all of the courtroom drama that the movie was about, but the book also included a great legal backstory on the lawyer behind the lawsuit, said lawyer's rise to prominence, and then said lawyer's fall from grace following the lawsuit. I really enjoyed the book. The au...more
Feb 27, 2012
Bridget
rated it
4 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Recommends it for:
environmentalists, students
Recommended to Bridget by:
Mrs. Jacobus
Shelves:
school,
non-fiction
Jonathan Harr has written the most riveting non-fiction book I have ever read. Admittedly, I am not what one would call an accomplished non-fiction reader. But I can tell that A Civil Action is unique due to its rather unusual beginnings; the author was present for most of the proceedings. Which I find amazing.
As my teacher predicted, I was prepared at some points to throw my copy in frustration. It is mind-boggling how screwed up the judicial system became during this trial. Not only were the d...more
As my teacher predicted, I was prepared at some points to throw my copy in frustration. It is mind-boggling how screwed up the judicial system became during this trial. Not only were the d...more
A depressing story of injustice and lies and liars. I want to be a lawyer, and I want to be a good lawyer, and I want the best for my clients if/when I may have clients, but I justice to be served. This book had me thrilled until the very end when time after time justice and a sense of right was ignored. I try to look at the judgement in an unbiased manner and I feel like I can, but I still feel a bubble of fury. Just a gross display. I wish the outcome were better, I wish the system caught the...more
There are no discussion topics on this book yet.
Be the first to start one »
Share This Book
1 trivia question
More quizzes & trivia...
“Rich and famous and doing good," mused Schlichtmann. "Rich isn't so difficult. Famous isn't so difficult. Rich and famous together aren't so difficult. Rich, famous, and doing good--now, that's very difficult.”
—
6 people liked it
“Truth is found at the bottom of a bottomless pit." Jerome Facher - A Civil Action.”
—
1 person liked it
More quotes…

Loading...
















:(
mk
Oct 03, 2011 10:46am