70th out of 297 books
—
876 voters
Sword of the Rightful King
by
Jane Yolen
The newly crowned King Arthur has yet to win the support of the people. Merlin must do something before the king is betrayed, or murdered, or--worst of all--gets married. So Merlin creates a trick: a sword magically placed into a slab of rock that only Arthur can withdraw. Then he lets it be known that whosoever removes the blade will rule all of England, and invites any m...more
Paperback, 376 pages
Published
August 1st 2004
by Graphia
(first published May 1st 2003)
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
2,582)
LRN: I'm giving this three stars. It was pretty good.
Mum: Didn't you meet Jane Yolen?
LRN: Yes. I met Yolen. I've also got another book from her.
Mum: She's was really nice, right?
LRN: She autographed my book.
Mum: That's cool. So what's this book about?
LRN: Arthur is trying to get his people to love him after he's newly crowned; and Merlin tries to help him by placing a sword into a slab of stone that only Aurthur can withdraw.
You should put the thing with the period and the thing over here. [...more
Mum: Didn't you meet Jane Yolen?
LRN: Yes. I met Yolen. I've also got another book from her.
Mum: She's was really nice, right?
LRN: She autographed my book.
Mum: That's cool. So what's this book about?
LRN: Arthur is trying to get his people to love him after he's newly crowned; and Merlin tries to help him by placing a sword into a slab of stone that only Aurthur can withdraw.
You should put the thing with the period and the thing over here. [...more
I'm a college student in Arthurian Literature right now, and we had to read a modern version of the legends and write a book review for it. I chose this book because YA is the genre I'd like to write in some day, and I wanted to see what other YA writers were doing with the stories. I tried to keep my Arthurian knowledge in mind as I read the book.
Many of the noteworthy characters from the Round Table make an appearance throughout the story, though the story itself does not have a clear main cha...more
Many of the noteworthy characters from the Round Table make an appearance throughout the story, though the story itself does not have a clear main cha...more
I have always loved the legend of King Arthur and the Knights of the Round Table. When I was a kid I read everything I could get my hands on about this topic.
In this retelling, Queen Morgause is deliciously evil and is constantly plotting to overthrow young King Arthur and put one of her sons on the throne.
Arthur is already king when the story begins, but Britain is not united. The whole sword in the stone thing turns out to be a trick that Merlinnus uses to convince the people of Britain that...more
In this retelling, Queen Morgause is deliciously evil and is constantly plotting to overthrow young King Arthur and put one of her sons on the throne.
Arthur is already king when the story begins, but Britain is not united. The whole sword in the stone thing turns out to be a trick that Merlinnus uses to convince the people of Britain that...more
This is an amazing book I would recommend this book to almost all ages. This is another novel of King Arthur, so it takes place in the time of knights and kings and it takes place in Britain. The main characters are Gawen, Merlinnus, Gawaine, and King Arthur. Gawen is a young man of the age of 12 to 13 who has come to King Arthur's kingdom in hope of becoming a night but is rejected and is taken in by Merlinnus. Merlinnus is an old mage who was the one who brought Arthur to the throne. Gawaine i...more
This was an interesting YA/middle-grade take on the Arthurian legends, with several key characters making an appearance: Arthur, Gawaine, Merlin, Morgause, Gwenever, etc. In Yolen's version, Arthur has been high king for several years, but the kingdom is only uneasily united. Merlin comes up with the sword in the stone as a way to convince Arthur's subjects that he is, in fact, King. It's Arthur's idea to let anyone who wants to try to pull the sword out. Morgause's plots against Arthur form a s...more
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
The Sword of the Rightful King is a tale of King Arthur, but takes a more political and less magical perspective on the story. Although Arthur is an honorable and fair ruler and most of his subjects are loyal to him, there are still some holdouts to his ultimate rule of Britain. Most notable of these is the dowager Queen to the North, Morgause, a woman who was underestimated by Merlinnius and has grown strong in black magic and would that one of her sons hold Arthur's throne.
Merlinnius comes up...more
Merlinnius comes up...more
Jul 02, 2012
Nessíma Tavariel
rated it
4 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Recommends it for:
Arthurian fans, historical-fiction fans,
Shelves:
historical-fantasy,
cover-love
Having picked this one up at the used-book store with little previous knowledge about it--I didn't know anyone who had read it, and I seemed to recall reading some mixed reviews on goodreads--, I started reading this with no expectations. Ok, that's not entirely true, as the summary on the back sounded far too interesting for me to have absolutely no expectations. But whatever expectations I did have, this book surpassed them.
Sword of the Rightful King begins with Arthur already king, and unlik...more
Sword of the Rightful King begins with Arthur already king, and unlik...more
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
This was a fun, easy read novel. I love seeing new twists to the Arthurian legend. There was one particular thing, however, I thought could have made the writing slightly stronger: when there was the first allusion to Arthur's bear-like appearance, I thought it was a pity that the author gave away that Arthur means "bear" at the same time. I think just making an allusion to the bear two or three times would have sufficed. It would have been like a wink to the reader. Yolen, I thought, gave away...more
The Book im currently reading now is Sword Of the Rightful King. This book takes place in old england instead of a modern aged setting.The book starts out with a boy named Gawaine and his mom a queen in her own rights. Gawaine doesnt want to be the leader of the land his mom wants to bestow upon him. It is up to Gawaine to make the desicion, but his mom will stop at nothing to make sure he is prince.Also to make sure he'll take over the throne. So in order to make sure he chooses to become princ...more
This is an excellent retelling of the King Arthur legend concerning the sword in the stone, and if you like Arthurian tales, you'll like this. Yolen gives an imaginative understory to the legend and fleshes out the main characters into real people. The blurb on the back of the cover adds tension throughout the book--"King Arthur will draw the blade from the stone (with the help of magic from Merlinnus, of course), and the people will at last rally around the young king. Except someone else pulls...more
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
If I was basing this book solely on the character of Arthur Pendragon, then it would be a 5. If I was rating it on the writing, it would probably only be a 2-2.5. However, Arthur's character in this book is amazing and I want my son to be like him. He is loyal, intelligent, compassionate, fair, humble and truly deserving of the legend that bears his name.
If there were truly a King Arthur, he should be as Yolen portrays him. I also loved the way Gwennivere was written into this version, very cre...more
If there were truly a King Arthur, he should be as Yolen portrays him. I also loved the way Gwennivere was written into this version, very cre...more
This is the most sloppily written confusing excuse for a novel I have ever read. The prose is weak, the POV shifts are confusing, the character development is lazy, and the plot is an unexpected and unwelcome take on the sword in the stone. Two starts, not one, because it means I have an easy final this year, but otherwise was a waste of time and if it weren't required reading I'd have put it down long before the ending.
(view spoiler)...more
(view spoiler)...more
Aug 09, 2011
Amery Xu
added it
Hmm, what can I say about this book? It's certainly an interesting twist of the Arthurian legend. One wouldn't really think that Arthur had problems controlling the hearts of the people. However, I delved into this book with a different plot in mind, having not expecting that the sword in the stone story would take up the entire book instead of immediately introducing the idea. There's a myriad of characters that all add their parts to the story, but the story is somewhat slow. It isn't slowed d...more
The premise of Sword of the Rightful King follows your traditional King Arthur tale, there is a sword in a stone and the rightful ruler will pull it out. However, in Yolen's adaptation, it is not Arthur who pulls the sword out of the stone. The story was told in multiple points of view.
This book was okay. I think my biggest problem was that there were so many cliches. I know that it's a YA adaptation, but there were some things that really wouldn't fit in with the portrayed time period. The mult...more
This book was okay. I think my biggest problem was that there were so many cliches. I know that it's a YA adaptation, but there were some things that really wouldn't fit in with the portrayed time period. The mult...more
Mar 11, 2012
Jeanine Allen
added it
Jeanine Allen
Traditional
Sword of the Rightful King: A Novel of King Arthur by Jane Yolen is a retelling of the traditional legend of King Arthur. Some of the character's names have been changed, but the meaning is very much there. Merlinnus (Merlin) must figure out a way to make the people believe that King Arthur is their rightful king. He devises a scheme that whoever pulls the sword out of their stone is the rightful king, however someone else end up pulling the sword out first. Each chapter...more
Traditional
Sword of the Rightful King: A Novel of King Arthur by Jane Yolen is a retelling of the traditional legend of King Arthur. Some of the character's names have been changed, but the meaning is very much there. Merlinnus (Merlin) must figure out a way to make the people believe that King Arthur is their rightful king. He devises a scheme that whoever pulls the sword out of their stone is the rightful king, however someone else end up pulling the sword out first. Each chapter...more
I really like Jane Yolen and I love the Arthur stories, so this one seemed like a safe bet. However, I wasn't crazy about her Young Merlin trilogy. This one, happily, wasn't really connected with the Merlin stories. It revolved around Arthur, Merlin, Gawain and Morgause and a newcomer to court, the confusingly named Gawin.
Morgause is her normal rotten self, Gawain was a hero as always (he's my favorite, really), and there was much intrigue. I wound up only giving it 3.5 stars though, because the...more
Morgause is her normal rotten self, Gawain was a hero as always (he's my favorite, really), and there was much intrigue. I wound up only giving it 3.5 stars though, because the...more
Feb 15, 2013
Kereesa
rated it
2 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Recommends it for:
Actual Young Adults. Who are like 13
Shelves:
2013,
friendship,
high-fantasy,
historical,
meh,
parodies-retellings,
witches-wizards-powers,
young-adult
Re-read this for my Arthurian Lit class as part of a project.
Hated it the first time around, haven't garnered much respect the second time, but it wasn't terrible.
Definite play on the history of the time with the Arthurian legend, lots of references to things, including religion. (Though strangely the whole Galahad thing isn't at all going on...) Lancelot/Gwen refs, etc... Sadly, no lady of the lake.
Bitch, where my Lady of the Lake at
Gwen and Morgan are played off on one another through cool-b...more
Hated it the first time around, haven't garnered much respect the second time, but it wasn't terrible.
Definite play on the history of the time with the Arthurian legend, lots of references to things, including religion. (Though strangely the whole Galahad thing isn't at all going on...) Lancelot/Gwen refs, etc... Sadly, no lady of the lake.
Gwen and Morgan are played off on one another through cool-b...more
This book provides a fun twist on the classic story of the sword in the stone. The story began building and building, then suddenly it was ending. I thought the ending was going to be too sudden - there wasn't as much adventure or Dan Brown style deep twists as I had expected. Then it ended, and I was pleasantly surprised. The book does contain adventure, but it is not a book to read if you are looking for nothing but adventure. It is more of a story-book story stretched (very effectively) into...more
Issue number one with this has nothing to do with the book itself; it has to do with the summary of the book. Oooo, who pulled the sword out before Arthur!? How is Camelot going to deal with such an occurance?!
Well, they're not, because it happens in the last bloody chapter. The book's summary has nothing to do with the book itself. The actual book is about Arthur's dealings with Morgause and the mysterious young boy Gawen and his interactions with Merlin.
Excalibur plays a part, but it's a side-...more
Well, they're not, because it happens in the last bloody chapter. The book's summary has nothing to do with the book itself. The actual book is about Arthur's dealings with Morgause and the mysterious young boy Gawen and his interactions with Merlin.
Excalibur plays a part, but it's a side-...more
This review originally appeared here
Perhaps it’s not too much of a secret that I LOVE all things Arthurian. I read books about Camelot and the Arthurian legends, I’m PLANNING on reading MORE books about it, and I fangirl the TV show, Merlin. I love how Arthurian stories straddle the line between historical fiction and fantasy with their elements of magic and politics, and I’m on a mission to find a book about this world that knocks my socks right off my feet. I had high hopes for SWORD OF THE RI...more
Perhaps it’s not too much of a secret that I LOVE all things Arthurian. I read books about Camelot and the Arthurian legends, I’m PLANNING on reading MORE books about it, and I fangirl the TV show, Merlin. I love how Arthurian stories straddle the line between historical fiction and fantasy with their elements of magic and politics, and I’m on a mission to find a book about this world that knocks my socks right off my feet. I had high hopes for SWORD OF THE RI...more
Dec 18, 2011
Nicole
rated it
5 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Recommends it for:
Medieval Fantasy lovers!! Anyone who enjoys stories of knights and wizards!
Recommended to Nicole by:
Library
What a wonderful change of pace! To read a book that's a medieval fantasy again! Once upon a time these were the only books I ever read, and though not all of them make the cut in my memories, it's always been one of my favorite--if not the favorite--of my genres! And this book was a WONDERFUL addition into that collection of stories I have so long loved! I admit, I have read little to nothing about King Arthur and his Knights of the Round Table, but who doesn't know the story? While I can't say...more
Sword of the Rightful King is a quick, fun read. It's very much in the Malory/T.H. White tradition, rather than anything more innovative. It's not very subtle -- the little mysteries of the story are fairly easy to work out. It has a very clever Guinevere, though Morgause is sluttish and stupid as usual. (Oh for a story that portrays everyone with psychological realism. Morgause could see Arthur as an usurper and still be a rational human being, y'know.) The whole "weak as women's magic" trope i...more
Everyone knows the story of King Arthur and the Knights of the Round Table. Everyone knows of noble Arthur, beloved king of Camelot. And everyone knows of Merlin, his ancient and wise advisor. There has, of course, been countless books and films on the subject. Jane Yolen's YA novel, however, doesn't merely retell the legend, but recreates it.
Young Arthur, barely 23 years of age, is the High King of Britain, so titled because of the power and influence of the man who put im there, his advisor a...more
Young Arthur, barely 23 years of age, is the High King of Britain, so titled because of the power and influence of the man who put im there, his advisor a...more
I have read a lot of YA books. A lot of them are fun stories but poorly written and make me want to gag. I have also read a handful YA fantasy and despite their good premises are full of too much detail in the beginning and feel slapped together at the end. This was a simple YA fiction but told well and for a simple read I actually really enjoyed it. This surprised me based on the other reviews. I would recommend this book though as an adult I prefer Mary Stewart's Arthurian saga.
Apr 10, 2008
Jackie "the Librarian"
rated it
4 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Recommends it for:
ages 12 and up
Arthur rules, but there is dissent among the clans. To give Arthur more legitimacy, Merlinnus plans a stunt – the sword in the stone that only Arthur will be able to remove. Scheming against Arthur is Morgause, who usees witchcraft to watch and strike against Arthur.
Recently arrived at the court is Gawen, a youth who wants to be trained as a knight, and take revenge against Gawain for her sister, but because of her small stature is instead is taken by Merlinnus as an apprentice.
Gawen is really...more
Recently arrived at the court is Gawen, a youth who wants to be trained as a knight, and take revenge against Gawain for her sister, but because of her small stature is instead is taken by Merlinnus as an apprentice.
Gawen is really...more
"Prince Gawaine took the stone steps two at a time, trying to guess why his mother, the queen, had sent for him."
This was an enjoyable twist on the King Arthur saga. Focusing on Merlin's engineering the sword in the stone for Arthur to pull, and Queen Morgause's evil magic and intrigues to seize the stone for her sons, and therefore herself, this novel manages to delve deep into a small section of the story, and pull off a rather unexpected twist at the end.
This was an enjoyable twist on the King Arthur saga. Focusing on Merlin's engineering the sword in the stone for Arthur to pull, and Queen Morgause's evil magic and intrigues to seize the stone for her sons, and therefore herself, this novel manages to delve deep into a small section of the story, and pull off a rather unexpected twist at the end.
For this book I gave it 4 stars, as it was a very interesting book to read. However, I knocked off one star, as there were too many twists in the ending. I mean, Gawen turning out to be a girl, then King Arthur marrying her? Too much to handle!! If Jane had just ended at Kind Arthur pulling out a sword it would have been much more nicer.
I might think this way, and you might think another, so I advise you to read the book as soon as you can.
I might think this way, and you might think another, so I advise you to read the book as soon as you can.
There are no discussion topics on this book yet.
Be the first to start one »
Yolen was born at Beth Israel Hospital, the first child of Isabel Berlin and Will Hyatt Yolen. She and her family moved to California when she was young but returned to New York a few years later. After her younger brother was born, her father joined the army and served on the European front during WWII. Yolen spent her childhood taking piano lessons, ballet dancing and writing a neighborhood news...more
More about Jane Yolen...
Share This Book
No trivia or quizzes yet. Add some now »

Loading...














![Sword Of The Rightful King[A Novel Of King Arthur]](http://s.gr-assets.com/assets/nocover/60x80.png)













LRN: No. All Aurthur stories are told different though.
and this:
LRN: I would recommend it to someone who doesn't like pictures, because there ar...more
Nov 05, 2011 03:45pm
Yeah, I was trying to figure out if LRN knew that myths like Arthur had different tellings,...more
Nov 05, 2011 07:21pm