191st out of 305 books
—
485 voters
Girl Reading
by
Katie Ward (Goodreads Author)
Seven portraits. Seven artists. Seven girls and women reading.A young orphan poses nervously for a Renaissance maestro in medieval Siena. An artist's servant girl in seventeenth-century Amsterdam snatches a moment away from her work to lose herself in tales of knights and battles. An eighteenth century female painter completes a portrait of a deceased poetess for her lover...more
Hardcover, 337 pages
Published
February 7th 2012
by Scribner
(first published May 1st 2011)
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
3,000)
This was an excellent book and you might wonder why I haven't given it five stars. Many people have given it five stars and they are right. I, however, am mean and stingy with my stars. Girl Reading is Katie Ward's first book, and I am quite certain that she will give me some five star material soon. She is probably writing something five-staresque as we speak.
Girl Reading is really a collection of short stories posing as a novel. I think I can see a trend there - does it mean that publishers ar...more
Girl Reading is really a collection of short stories posing as a novel. I think I can see a trend there - does it mean that publishers ar...more
This book took me forever to finish but it was so worth it. Structurally, it’s a collection of stories throughout the years from the 14th century to 2060 (ish) that all share one common theme; these stories were inspired by one or more pieces of art containing a girl and a book. I LOVED Ward’s style of writing; she never uses quotation marks which, while making it difficult to differentiate between thought and speech, actually makes it feel like you were there watching each scene take place. I r...more
Katie Ward writes about seven portraits and artists, and the lives of seven girls and women reading, all living in seven different time periods between 1333 and 2060. Each world is different but so well created that I felt as though I was there, witnessing the lives of the characters created by the writer. There is a depth to the writing which brings worlds and people alive, makes them real and believable. There are clever, subtle links which tie the stories together. Yet each story feels like a...more
Original review at my blog, Writing by Numbers, here.
This so-called novel is really a collection of short stories, which in turn reads rather like a talented writer engaging in a creative writing exercise. Nevertheless, it’s a pleasant and well-crafted read. Ward has created seven stories that span space and time, each based on a piece of art featuring a woman reading. She sets her chapters in chronological order, beginning in Renaissance Siena and ending in an imagined future. In between, she...more
This so-called novel is really a collection of short stories, which in turn reads rather like a talented writer engaging in a creative writing exercise. Nevertheless, it’s a pleasant and well-crafted read. Ward has created seven stories that span space and time, each based on a piece of art featuring a woman reading. She sets her chapters in chronological order, beginning in Renaissance Siena and ending in an imagined future. In between, she...more
Oh dear, where to start? After two chapters this was going to be a one star rating, and I was about to abandon the book, but, the next story was better so I stuck at it. As many other reviewers on here have said, I feel misled by this being called a 'novel' on the back. It's not. It is a book with six independent short stories, and one final short story which provides one thread which connects the six to the 7th, (but not the six to each other).
I don't feel the author's writing/research/knowledg...more
I don't feel the author's writing/research/knowledg...more
I found it really difficult to decide on the appropriate rating for this book, swerving anywhere between three and five stars. When I first heard about it - seven linked stories on the subject of pieces of art showing a girl reading - I was torn between two conflicting thoughts: "wow, sounds like a great and unusual concept," and "sounds a bit overly pretentious, the author must be going all out to get her Booker Prize nomination." Having read it, I think that both of these thoughts are true to...more
Girl Reading by Katie Ward
The Blurb on the back tells us: An Orphan poses nervously for a Renaissance maestro in Medieval Siena, and an artist servant girl in 17th century Amsterdam snatches a moment away from her work to lose herself in tales of knights and battles. In a Victorian photography studio, a woman holds a book that she barely acknowledges while she waits for the exposure and in Shoreditch bar in 2008 a woman reading catches the eye of a young man who takes her picture.
What is perhap...more
The Blurb on the back tells us: An Orphan poses nervously for a Renaissance maestro in Medieval Siena, and an artist servant girl in 17th century Amsterdam snatches a moment away from her work to lose herself in tales of knights and battles. In a Victorian photography studio, a woman holds a book that she barely acknowledges while she waits for the exposure and in Shoreditch bar in 2008 a woman reading catches the eye of a young man who takes her picture.
What is perhap...more
I’ve been putting off writing about my views of this book as I really didn’t enjoy it and only finished it because I was sent it to review. When I looked online after reading it I found that I’m definitely in a minority as lots of readers, both famous and anonymous, are hailing it as the best thing since the literary equivalent of sliced bread.
I really can’t agree, as the emotion I felt most often while reading it was irritation. For a start it’s described as a novel, but it really isn’t one. I...more
I really can’t agree, as the emotion I felt most often while reading it was irritation. For a start it’s described as a novel, but it really isn’t one. I...more
The book was awarded 3 stars, however this was not because of a luke warm appreciation. Like any short term relationship (it took me about a month to read because of reasons x and y) it kept pulling me between annoyance and true love.
There are moments of sheer delight, where the sentences are so beautifully constructed in a moment of spontaneous stupidity i thought about getting them tattooed to my arm, but then on the other hand WHERE IN GOD'S NAME ARE THE SPEECH MARKS?? Also the jumps in the...more
There are moments of sheer delight, where the sentences are so beautifully constructed in a moment of spontaneous stupidity i thought about getting them tattooed to my arm, but then on the other hand WHERE IN GOD'S NAME ARE THE SPEECH MARKS?? Also the jumps in the...more
This was one of those books that I really loved the idea of and I thought I would really enjoy all of the short stories contained within. Unfortunately, I'm not sure whether I expected too much, but I found this merely to be ok. While I loved the concept behind the collection - each story is based around an image of a woman reading - I found the lack of sympathetic characters rather disappointing and the whole book ended up being a little bit depressing. The collection has its highlights, in par...more
I really enjoyed this, I was completely immersed and when I had finished the seventh section I went back to check out the links and connections I thought I could see. I haven't read a book that has engaged me this much for ages.
I see from earlier reviews that others have struggled with the lack of punctuation and have found the jump from one story to another rather disruptive. I didn't have either of those problems, I think I have developed a style of reading for books like this (based on readin...more
I see from earlier reviews that others have struggled with the lack of punctuation and have found the jump from one story to another rather disruptive. I didn't have either of those problems, I think I have developed a style of reading for books like this (based on readin...more
May 06, 2012
Mark Patton
rated it
5 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
historical-fiction,
new-releases
Katie Ward's debut novel is a book of extraordinary scope and vision. Like Cloud Atlasor If on a winter's night a traveler, it consists of a number of stories, seemingly separate, but in fact intricately related, and in such a way that the book as a whole is very much greater than the sum of its parts. In this case the theme which links them is of an image of a girl or woman reading a text. There are seven chapters, eached based around the production of an image by an artist (Simone Martini Annu...more
Some books are quiet books. Gilead comes to mind. As does Jim the Boy. These books don't bowl you over or yank you into the storyline. Instead they slowly, quietly and persistently invite you into their world. Girl Reading is a quiet book. In it, Katie Ward takes you into the world behind seven works of art. Each world is fully fleshed out. Each character different from the last, yet engaging. Each time I left one world and moved on to the next, I wanted more. I like a book that leaves me wantin...more
Aug 02, 2011
Susan Anderson
rated it
4 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
historical-fiction
In Girl Reading, a debut novel, Katie Ward paints seven portraits of girls reading—their lives, their conflicts, their passions, their griefs. The author’s prose is rich, her syntax spare, exact, sometimes provocative, often surprising, usually delightful.
From the start we are caught up in the characters, the stories of young women who read. We watch with them. We weep with them. We wonder, what comes next. In short, most of the time we can’t turn the page fast enough, except for those passages...more
From the start we are caught up in the characters, the stories of young women who read. We watch with them. We weep with them. We wonder, what comes next. In short, most of the time we can’t turn the page fast enough, except for those passages...more
In Girl Reading, Katie Ward imagines the stories behind a number of portraits of girls and women reading; the portraits range in past time from Simone Martini’s Annunciation (1333) to a photograph on Flickr in 2008, and a concluding chapter set in 2060 provides context for the previous six. Ward has a distinctive writing style that creates a strong atmosphere for each of the time periods, and allows her to weave in details very subtly. I’ll single out her portrayal of Gwen – a girl in love with...more
This is Katie Ward's first novel and I was still thinking about it three days after I had finished it, so I think it's fair to say that she's done a decent job. Strictly speaking, it doesn't seem to be a novel. There are seven disconnected stories, but they are linked together in the final chapter which is set in the future ... still I have a wee suspicion that somebody's publisher very much wanted to push it as a novel rather than a collection of short stories which is after all the Cinderella...more
This isn't a negative review. I did enjoy Girl Reading, but like most short story collections there are bits you love and bits you couldn't care less about. Many reviews promised a link at the end of the novel, however, so I persevered with every story, but unfortunately when Girl Reading peaks with "Unknown, For Pleasure, 1916", it begins going downhill at an alarming rate and just doesn't recover.
It was the sixth story, "Immaterialism, Reader in a Shoreditch Bar, 2008" where the novel took a d...more
It was the sixth story, "Immaterialism, Reader in a Shoreditch Bar, 2008" where the novel took a d...more
I wanted to love this book, I really did. The premise was a wonderful one and I was intrigued to see Ward's interpretations of a series of different pictures. Whilst the lack of apostrophes to denote speech throughout worked well at first, it did become a little annoying after a while. Some of the stories were interesting and promising in their scope, but I struggled to get through others. I'm glad I've read it, but it's not a book which I'd pick up again in a hurry.
Having seen a lot of chat about this book through various online sources – and read some interesting reviews, I managed to catch the last twenty minutes of The TV book club programme which featured an item about this novel. Everyone was very enthusiastic about it and so I bought the book from Amazon that same evening. I have to say however that I don’t like the cover art of this latest edition – I have seen the art of the earlier edition and like it much more – I know that doesn’t or shouldn’t a...more
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
The old saying goes ‘you don’t miss something until it is gone’. In this book I really missed speech-marks. Call me lazy but I quite like to be able to identify who is talking by a slight flick of ink on a page. Speech-marks are important and whether you are trying to be literary or challenge your readers you should understand that readers have grown up with speech-marks and are not about to have them whisked away like some forlorn apostrophe I could mention.
I did struggle with Girl Reading and...more
I did struggle with Girl Reading and...more
For some reason I completely missed the initial launch of this book and was unaware of its existence until I happily stumbled upon it in my local Waterstones.
The concept - that of seven seemingly unconnected chapters, each based upon depictions of girls or women reading - intrigued me; I dipped in to the first chapter which was based upon a fourteenth-century painting by Simone Martini and was instantly hooked. The writing had a deceptively simple feel yet with an underlying power that I, for o...more
The concept - that of seven seemingly unconnected chapters, each based upon depictions of girls or women reading - intrigued me; I dipped in to the first chapter which was based upon a fourteenth-century painting by Simone Martini and was instantly hooked. The writing had a deceptively simple feel yet with an underlying power that I, for o...more
I have met the author through BookCrossing so I was a little nervous about reading this book on account of Katie and I once disagreed completely on The Accidental by Ali Smith. I was concerned that Girl Reading was going to be a book I hated! Also, although it is hailed as 'seven portraits', to me it's seven short stories; I must be a lazy reader because I find short stories too much like hard work and rarely read them. I was finding the 'girl reading' theme very tenuous until the final story wh...more
I really struggled with this one. I wouldn't call it a novel but instead a tenuously-related collection of short stories, each of which a snapshot of a particular moment in the characters' lives.
I'm not really a short story person, I suppose. I don't enjoy dismissing one set of recently-introduced chracters for another group. I also realise that I need a strong plot to keep me interested!
The lack of speech marks and associated punctuation was a real put-off for me. I often had to trace back lin...more
I'm not really a short story person, I suppose. I don't enjoy dismissing one set of recently-introduced chracters for another group. I also realise that I need a strong plot to keep me interested!
The lack of speech marks and associated punctuation was a real put-off for me. I often had to trace back lin...more
Feb 13, 2012
Kristin
rated it
2 of 5 stars
Shelves:
books-on-books,
lit-fic,
historical-fiction,
read-in-2012,
brit-fic,
short-stories,
reviewed
Okay, I really liked the concept. The writing was quite good. I liked how the stories weren't really connected, yet every now and then a painting from one story was mentioned in another story (and they're all mentioned in the last story, which takes place in the future). I liked that there were some real paintings, then some fictional photographs, which were based on real carte de vistes and Flikr photos. And I liked how there was a futuristic story to tie things together. But in the end, I just...more
Girl Reading is one of those books which leaves you wanting more, leaves you feeling bereft when you've read the last word on the last page. The quality of the writing, the creation of so many different atmospheres, the evocation of such a vast range of different eras - all these combine to make this an astounding debut novel. But even that is not praise enough for this book - it's quite simply one of the best books I've ever read.
Literary fiction at its best lets you forget who you are, stops y...more
Literary fiction at its best lets you forget who you are, stops y...more
This book grew on me. I started out not being sure if it was for me and ended up not being able to put it down. It is basically 7 short stories with a common theme - pictures of girls reading. in each story you get to know something about the woman in the picture and how the picture came to be made. The final story is set in the future in a world where art works have been removed from public view and galleries just have facsimiles of the real thing. In this future world people can interact with...more
This book is a collection of short stories which all tie together in the final story of the book (or don't depending on how you interpret the final tale I guess). It takes you on a journey through time on the production of images (paintings and photographs) of women reading.
I didn't like the first tale very much, and I honestly thought this was going to be the trend for the whole book. However, I absolutely loved tales two, three and four and by then I was hooked.
My only real issue with the bo...more
I didn't like the first tale very much, and I honestly thought this was going to be the trend for the whole book. However, I absolutely loved tales two, three and four and by then I was hooked.
My only real issue with the bo...more
Feb 27, 2013
Nigel
rated it
4 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
book-club,
21st-century-novels
I don't agree with the reviewers who have considered this a series of short stories. It is more a treatise of art versus technology and our interaction with both, as both forms advance - paintings/photographs/Internet/interactive mediums. From the artist in the first chapter pondering the political implications of the screen he is to paint for the cathedral in Sienna to the hastily taken photograph in a pub, each artwork seems simpler and quicker to make and with less thought. Does this give it...more
I admired many things about this novel - the intensity of the language, the vivid imagery and strong characterisation, the way the unusual structure stretched conventional boundaries - but what I enjoyed most was the exhilarating sense of having travelled, imaginatively, far and wide, through history, and into the future. With a quality of strangeness which is at first unsettling but becomes magnetic, the novel explores human imagination. In many ways, the form of the novel echoes its content.
I...more
I...more
| topics | posts | views | last activity | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Girl reading ending | 4 | 27 | May 02, 2012 09:14am | |
| Mesh is here! (Almost) | 1 | 11 | Apr 05, 2012 09:48am |
Katie Ward was born in Somerset in 1979. She has worked in the public and voluntary sectors, including at a women’s refuge and for a Member of Parliament. She took a career break in order to write her debut novel, Girl Reading, after coming across an article about a book of portraits of women and girls reading.
Girl Reading is published by Scribner (US) and Virago (UK).
Katie lives in Suffolk with h...more
More about Katie Ward...
Girl Reading is published by Scribner (US) and Virago (UK).
Katie lives in Suffolk with h...more
Share This Book
1 trivia question
More quizzes & trivia...
“Sometimes love is not enough to bind us to the world. What is beautiful may also be finite.”
—
7 people liked it
More quotes…

Loading...





view all 6 comments














