Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “Death and the Virgin Queen: Elizabeth I and the Dark Scandal That Rocked the Throne” as Want to Read:
Death and the Virgin Queen: Elizabeth I and the Dark Scandal That Rocked the Throne
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating
Open Preview

Death and the Virgin Queen: Elizabeth I and the Dark Scandal That Rocked the Throne

3.49 of 5 stars 3.49  ·  rating details  ·  298 ratings  ·  65 reviews
In the tradition of Alison Weir's New York Times bestselling Mary, Queen of Scots and the Murder of Lord Darnley, comes the most sensational crime story of Tudor England.

On the morning of September 8, 1560, at the isolated manor of Cunmor place, the body of a young woman was found at the bottom of a staircase, her neck broken. But this was no ordinary death. Amy Robsa
Paperback, 456 pages
Published March 13th 2012 by St. Martin's Griffin (first published January 1st 2010)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about Death and the Virgin Queen, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about Death and the Virgin Queen

This book is not yet featured on Listopia. Add this book to your favorite list »

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 984)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
The death of Amy Robsart (wife of Robert Dudley) is one of my favorite historical mysteries; having always felt a connection to Amy. This, along with enjoying Chris Skidmore’s work, “Edward VI”, drew me to “Death and the Virgin Queen: Elizabeth I and the Dark Scandal that Rocked the Throne”.

A few choice words can be used to describe “Death and the Virgin Queen”: dry, heavy, and not earth-shattering are a few of them. The first 200 pages of “Death and the Virgin Queen” focus on setting the scene
Many negative reviews of this book talk about inaccuracy and repetitiveness. The specific inaccuracies I've seen mentioned seem to have been corrected between whatever earlier edition was reviewed and the edition I read. And while I found the book to be repetitive at times, I thought the repetition served the dual purpose of reinforcing concepts and illustrating different points that came up in different sections, so it was used effectively. Having commented on other people's opinions, here's mi ...more
Kate F
Having an interest in the Tudor period and voraciously reading any books that are published on the period I was really looking forward to this book - especially given the reviews that it attracted. Sadly, I have been left underwhelmed by it and wondering what the reviewers were reading.

Having read it assiduously all that has remained with me is the glaring factual errors in the text and the poor proof-reading that seems to be endemic in much of the publishing world today. In fact, books that ha
Pete daPixie
God's legs! Methinks herein dothe moche seem thereof a tragedie plainelie founde to liken that of Princess Diana in our own tymes. What saie thy goode Master Skidmore of this sorie matter that toucheth thy goode Lord of Leicester and the mysfortune of his Lady Amee. How so divers thinges as I learne doth appeare plainelie to suspecte the worse of her Majestie, our quene Ladye Elizabeth.

Skidmore's second work of Tudor history, published 2010. 'Death and the Virgin' is just a fantastic intricate i
Dull and repetitive.

I am not an historian but in a couple of places he takes a tiny inconclusive piece of data, adds a wild supposition and then uses this to back up some point he is making. Which makes me very sceptical about anything else he makes 'educated' guesses about.

The book jumps about all over the place in the time frame covered and there is no appendix or other reference section with known dates for the lay reader to track events against.

He seems to want to be taken seriously as an h
As you can tell from the books that I've read, that I'm a bit of a Tudor history buff. This book was intriguing, in that, it brought several different suspects in the death of Amy Robsart, be them people or disease. After reading this book, to me, there was no dramatic evidence to support either of these, so I can imagine, Amy's death is still remains a bit of a mystery. The most convincing cause of her demise is the least dramatic - that it was an accident and no misdeeds ever took place. Poor ...more
Having long been fascinated by the mysterious death of Amy Robsart and after reading the varied reviews, both positive and negative, of Chris Skidmore’s Death and the Virgin Queen I just had to pick it up and check it out for myself. What’s that saying about curiosity again?! Well, it didn’t kill me, but it sure did almost bore me to death!

Death and the Virgin Queen attempts to reconstruct the time leading up to and the events on the day that Amy Robsart, wife to Elizabeth’s favorite Robert Dudl
I had been looking forward to this book for awhile ever since I ran across it in a library book sale. It seemed like a very interesting book. I was sadly disappointed by the book though. Don't get me wrong I learned quite a bit from this book, it just didn't deliver on its main point of having new information in the death of Robert Dudley's wife, Amy Robsart (very little of the book actually focuses on the death in question). It is however a fascinating read if you want to learn more about Dudle ...more
C.S. Burrough
Jul 16, 2014 C.S. Burrough rated it 4 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommends it for: History readers
Having consumed many Elizabeth I biographies I was not disappointed with this addition to my shelf.

This book focusses on the lead up to, circumstances surrounding and long term consequences of one event quite early into a long reign: the suspicious death of Amy Dudley, wife of the queen's favourite.

There are so many other factors and events defining Elizabeth I's long reign than this one unsolved mystery. But for those seeking elaboration on why Elizabeth remained the 'Virgin Queen', married onl
This book presents the transcript of the coroner's report of Robert Dudley's wife's death in 1560, believed lost for centuries, but finally found by Dr. Steven Gunn in The Natinonal Archives (England). It says that Amy Robsart had a broken neck and two wounds at unspecified locations on her head, one of which would have involved some form of skull fracture. Since such injuries are not uncommon in serious and fatal stair falls, and since the report is a 16th century piece of paper and not the act ...more
I came into this book knowing almost nothing about Elizabeth’s reign. I’ve recently read The Lady Elizabeth, which got me wondering about her reign and this book was in the library so it seemed like the place to start.
This book focusses very much on the relationship between Elizabeth and Robert Dudley. Now I’m very curious: were they in love or was Elizabeth using him as a guard/foil to keep other suitors at bay? Was she teasing with him to keep him at her side?
Elizabeth had an unconventional u
Scandal? Maybe. But I think 'scandal that rocked the Throne' was overstating things a bit. Frankly I think the book was too long for what Skidmore actually had to say about 'the scandal'. A fair amount of the book was, I think, supposed to be background and context but felt more like unnecessary filler. Granted I'm familiar with Queen Elizabeth's life and reign, so maybe someone who'd never heard of the Tudors would find the information helpful.

While the mystery surrounding Amy Dudley's death wa
Note: this should NOT be read by people who don't already know how they feel about Elizabethan history and have at least a basic knowledge of it to start with. The second you can probably get around because this gives a very detailed account of events leading up to Amy's death as well as what happens immediately afterwards, but this is NOT for someone just wanting to dip their toes into history surrounding Queen Elizabeth I. You will more than likely be too bored by this. For people who DO alrea ...more
The title implies this book is about the mysterious death of Amy Dudley, but there are only about 50 pages on it. While the focus on the book is elsewhere, the author, Chris Skidmore, does help the reader interpret what little is known of Amy, her teen age marriage (unusual for its day), her few surviving letters, her moving from host family to host family, and the reports of an illness, from the few scraps of surviving materials.

Also, the author heightens your awareness of the impact of Amy's s
Judi Moore
Bit of a one-trick pony this. If you're into the Elizabethan era and were hoping for a genuine new insight into what, so conveniently, happened to Robert Dudley's wife there is new material, but there's a lot of rehashing too. If you're new to the Elizabethans then it's pretty much all here, and concisely told. There's serious scholarship in this book. Unfortunately this often manifests itself as a list of what people paid for things, which quickly palls: obviously invoices survive better than l ...more
A lot of research has gone into this factual book. The author uses numeorus primary sources to present a balanced account of the effect that the death of Dudley's first wife had on Elizabeth I's attitude to marriage.

There is a lot of detail and at times it can seem like wading through treacle to get to the core of the book. However, it is worth persevering. I learnt a great deal more about this period of history despite having studied the subject to degree level!

Unlike many books of this sort, the detailed account of the death of the Earl of Leicester's wife doesn't feel padded or stretched out. And the author does get ahold of some new information--though not enough to resolve the case. Made me think that the problem with new theories on a 500-year old mystery is that they raise more questions than they answer. Still, an interesting and well-written book.
Anyone who's a fan of Queen Elizabeth I should pick up this book. It's a good look at the death of Robert Dudley's wife, Amy, who was found at the bottom of a staircase with a broken neck. If not for this "accident?" would Elizabeth have married Dudley? The argument continues...
This was pretty accessible for an academic book, though I thought it's scope could have been more narrow. The author focuses on the entire Leicester/Queen relationship - which to a degree, you have to - but didn't focus as much on the murder as I would have liked. That relationship has been the subject of many books on its own - I picked this up because I was curious about theories into Robsart's death. Which he does cover, but doesn't give them the space I wish he had.

So, this is an interesting

Its an interesting topic, but, wow Skidmore repeats himself a lot. Padding much?
This book attempts to shed light on the mysterious death of Amy Robsart, the first wife of Lord Robert Dudley, Queen Elizabeth’s favorite courtier. Skidmore has certainly done his due diligence in researching the matter and draws upon a multitude of historical documents to present his case. But to understand the circumstances of Amy’s death, the reader must fully understand the breadth of the relationship between Robert and Elizabeth. A majority of the book focuses on the dynamic of the pair and ...more
The mysterious death of Amy Robsart, wife of Queen Elizabeth's favourite Robert Dudley, has long been one of the enduring mysteries of English history - was it an accident? was it suicide? was it murder? In this engaging book, half-mystery, half-history, Chris Skidmore sets out not so much to solve the mystery (at this remove in history, such a thing would be impossible) as to explore the various avenues and options and set the event in its proper context.

As a result of the latter, poor Amy feat
Emmanuel Gustin
I enjoyed reading this book, but in the end I was slighly dissatisfied. The death of Amy Robsart is a historical fait-divers of lasting interest, but it is also something about which we will never learn the full truth: It would be unfair to blame the author for that.
The good news is that Skidmore's book profits from the rediscovery of the original report of the inquest into Amy's death, as well as a lot of private correspondence and literature of the period. But he doesn't really succeed in draw
Sandra Strange
I really thought the book would be about the death of Queen Elizabeth I. However, it's really about something much more intriguing--the mysterious death of the wife of Robert Dudley, probably Elizabeth's true love. The historian has found and used all kinds of newly discovered contemporary sources to weave this interesting history, what my students call a "Renaissance soap opera" of international intrigue, courtiers' jealousy, competing religious beliefs, ambition and ruthlessness that swirl aro ...more
Christine Rogers
I was really pleased with this book and enjoyed reading it. It is not for the feint of heart as it does have a lot of facts and figures. I actually quite enjoyed the reports on the household accounts and found it really informative. If you already are familiar with this time period and these circumstances you will not learn much in the way of new information, but you might add a few layers of detail to what you already know. There is no big revelation on the death of Amy Dudley, and only a coupl ...more
Christine Rogers
I was really pleased with this book and enjoyed reading it. It is not for the feint of heart as it does have a lot of facts and figures. I actually quite enjoyed the reports on the household accounts and found it really informative. If you already are familiar with this time period and these circumstances you will not learn much in the way of new information, but you might add a few layers of detail to what you already know. There is no big revelation on the death of Amy Dudley, and only a coupl ...more
Skidmore's exploration of the scandal surrounding Queen Elizabeth I, Lord Robert Dudley, and the death of his wife Amy Robsart is thorough - but not thoroughly entertaining. While an excellent work of history, including new sources and reproductions of original letters, etc., Death and the Virgin Queen focuses more on the relationship between Her Majesty and Dudley, and the ongoing machinations surrounding the Queen's potential wedding and less on Robsart herself. Edited somewhat more, this wou ...more
3 1/2 stars (ugh). Is there such a thing as light history? If so, then this is it. Not to denigrate the author's research, which appears extensive. But an easy and entertaining (?) read about one facet of Queen Elizabeth's reign with which I was not familiar.
Really enjoyed this book, although not exactly the murder mystery or "case closed" book I expected. I've read almost every book about the Tudors that's come out and I usually find myself reading rehashes of stuff I know. Skidmore's book is one where I learned things I didn't know, mostly about Robert Dudley and his relationships with his women. Skidmore does a great job of giving both sides of the story and providing evidence both for and against Dudley's wife's murder. It does go off the rails ...more
Luna Ofthenight
Always interesting when historical documents previously laying hidden are discovered and put a new spin on a 450 year old mystery. An interesting presentation of the primary sources that overturns a number of previous theories. Of course we'll never truly know what happened, that's probably why the topic is fascinating. Everyone can have their own theory, argue their own case using the historical sources available.
Only one criticism which is that at times there was frequent repetition, sometimes
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 32 33 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
  • The Last White Rose: Dynasty, Rebellion and Treason. The Secret Wars against the Tudors
  • Jane Seymour: Henry VIII's True Love
  • A Daughter's Love: Thomas More and His Dearest Meg
  • The Six Wives of Henry VIII
  • Katherine the Queen: The Remarkable Life of Katherine Parr
  • 1536: The Year That Changed Henry VIII
  • The House of Tudor
  • The Uncrowned Kings of England: The Black History of the Dudleys and the Tudor Throne
  • The Divorce of Henry VIII: The Untold Story from Inside the Vatican
  • Anne Boleyn: Fatal Attractions
  • The Greatest Traitor: The Life of Sir Roger Mortimer, Ruler of England 1327-1330
  • The Pirate Queen: Queen Elizabeth I, Her Pirate Adventurers, and the Dawn of Empire
  • After Elizabeth: The Rise of James of Scotland and the Struggle for the Throne of England
  • Elizabeth and Essex
  • Queen Emma: A History of Power, Love, and Greed in 11th-Century England
  • A Gambling Man: Charles II and the Restoration
  • Ladies in Waiting: From the Tudors to the Present Day
  • The Secret Wife of Louis XIV: Françoise d'Aubigné, Madame de Maintenon

Share This Book