5th out of 114 books
—
51 voters
The Melancholy of Resistance
A powerful, surreal novel, in the tradition of Gogol, about the chaotic events surrounding the arrival of a circus in a small Hungarian town. The Melancholy of Resistance, László Krasznahorkai's magisterial, surreal novel, depicts a chain of mysterious events in a small Hungarian town. A circus, promising to display the stuffed body of the largest whale in the world, arriv...more
Paperback, 314 pages
Published
June 17th 2002
by New Directions
(first published 1989)
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
2,292)
László Krasznahorkai, I am nervous. Isn't that ridiculous? I'm actually nervous about writing a review for your novel The Melancholy of Resistance because I just finished scanning through the (few) other reviews on this site and saw that they were mostly perfunctory in their praise, somewhat soulless and academic, and insufficiently rapturous.
This is an amazing book! Don't they understand that? When you've heard the word of god (and here it is), you just don't dither around with propriety or th...more
This is an amazing book! Don't they understand that? When you've heard the word of god (and here it is), you just don't dither around with propriety or th...more
2001. Anthology Film Archives. (one of the great places on the planet: i swear that when one studies taken-from-space photographs a faint heavenly light emanates from manhattan -- if one were to push further in, she'd see that most of it originates from the southeast corner of 2nd ave & 2nd st) a hungarian film the smart people at the newyorkpress raved about. i bought a ticket and dropped into one of those dreadful foldable chairs, fought off the stink of mold and time, and looked back to s...more
I was really enjoying this. The prose is a little dense, and there's no question that the author has a penchant for abstraction, as seen in the musings of the musicologist; but there is also wry humor and elegant surrealism, deftly handled. The opening sequence of the elderly Mrs. Plauf going into hysterics on the train is hilarious. As we move from character (Mrs Eszter) to character (Valushka), the story deepens. We see, or feel we do, their every ratiocination. I don't want to give away the f...more
Mar 23, 2011
Mariel
rated it
5 of 5 stars
Recommends it for:
M is for Melancholy. R is for resistance
Recommended to Mariel by:
David, brian and Nate
David and brian's reviews. Now no one is reading this so it doesn’t matter that I’m tongued-tied and confused how to express my feelings on The Melancholy of Resistance. (I can will myself to do anything if I tell myself that nothing I do matters. It feels like freedom. Everything I say is bullshit anyway.)
I’ve been doodling whales and stars for days and days. It’s difficult to ever translate those images to outside of me. Hold on, I meant to say that ‘Melancholy’ was translated from the Hungari...more
I’ve been doodling whales and stars for days and days. It’s difficult to ever translate those images to outside of me. Hold on, I meant to say that ‘Melancholy’ was translated from the Hungari...more
There are better reviews than this one to read about this book. Here is one. And another. And a third one. (For those who don't know if they want to click, those link to David's, Brian's and Mariel's reviews).
I had very strong feelings of fondness but not love for this book. It would have been a four and a half star book, but it never had that unquantifiable something that pushes a book past the really really like category and into the love category. Maybe I'm just being a superficial bastard...more
I had very strong feelings of fondness but not love for this book. It would have been a four and a half star book, but it never had that unquantifiable something that pushes a book past the really really like category and into the love category. Maybe I'm just being a superficial bastard...more
Mar 23, 2012
s.penkevich
rated it
4 of 5 stars
Recommends it for:
Those who question
Shelves:
cold-and-dark,
europe
I read The Melancholy of Resistance back in early October and it still haunts me months later. Krasznahorkai creates a dark allegorical novel that is saturated with dread and overflowing with malice as he depicts a city overrun by strange happenings and menacing mobs of strangers during the icy winter. Even if you were to read this on a warms summers day, he would make you feel as if the world outside your window was frozen over and treacherous. This novel deserves a more wide-spread critical ac...more
The Melancholy of Resistance is, George Szirtes says, ‘a slow lava flow of narrative, a vast black river of type’. And because I adore Szirtes, the poet, I chose to imbue his summation with promises of a linguistic operetta of multifactorial continuo. Alas, he too must earn his daily bread, (being the novel’s translator) and so it transpires, at the end of this epic polity, that he meant what he said entirely literally: a statement of fact rather than a literary endorsement.
A vast black river of...more
A vast black river of...more
Nov 30, 2010
Nate D
rated it
4 of 5 stars
Recommends it for:
stargazers and whalewatchers caught up in the whims of power-hunger
Recommended to Nate D by:
Bela Tarr
So who knew that Bela Tarr's Werckmeister Harmonies was an adaptation?
This dense, winding novel seemingly condenses much of the tumultuous experience of 20th century Hungary into a few days of carefully cryptic allegory that is stronger and more universal for its lack of easy 1:1 correspondences between its reality and the greater one. The novel was adapted for screen by Tarr with the author and its long sentences and lack of paragraph breaks are reflected in the film's long, seamless takes (of...more
This dense, winding novel seemingly condenses much of the tumultuous experience of 20th century Hungary into a few days of carefully cryptic allegory that is stronger and more universal for its lack of easy 1:1 correspondences between its reality and the greater one. The novel was adapted for screen by Tarr with the author and its long sentences and lack of paragraph breaks are reflected in the film's long, seamless takes (of...more
Luckily I found this book in a local bookstore the day after I saw Bela Tarr's film Werckmeister Harmonies. The author and Tarr have a very close relationship and have collaborated on adapting Krazhnahorkai's novels into films, but I think this is the only novel that has been translated into English.
As with other books, I read this so feverishly (and it begs to be read feverishly as the whole book is one long paragraph, and some sentences go on for pages) that I can't give any kind of detached d...more
As with other books, I read this so feverishly (and it begs to be read feverishly as the whole book is one long paragraph, and some sentences go on for pages) that I can't give any kind of detached d...more
Jan 14, 2008
lisa_emily
rated it
4 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Recommends it for:
Eastern Europhiles, collectors of weird novels
It starts with a long, nearly entangled sentence, then it runs from that. AT times when you think you will lose interest, it comes back with a uncanny scene, or a mental space you don't encounter often. I doubt one could ever learn about Hungary or about whales. The two main characters are an idiot and a cynic, and that can make for good conversations. I half-way liked it to really liking it, but it is a very heady book, a kind of book you might read to keep fluffy exclamists away.
Feb 09, 2013
Rise
added it
It was said that modern Mayans rolled their eyes at the suggestion of Armageddon on 12/21/12. But in László Krasznahorkai's novel, nobody is rolling his eyes as something wicked comes the way of a Hungarian village. The seriousness of the situation is evident from the ambiance of fear and foreboding as Mrs. Plauf travels by train to her home. She can't shake off the feeling that an infinitesimal change in the landscape brought something amiss to the relative peace of the village. That constricti...more
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
okay so i just now finished this one, and i gotta say that last 3 pg run of decomposition, from biochemical to philosophical was just astounding. the last time i viscerally reacted to an ending like that was fowles 'the collector'. of course the book is kind of like trying to speed walk through the ocean, but i set a healthy 10-20 pgs at a time pace for myself so i didn't feel like i was trying to chew peanut butter for hours on end.
these characters are amazing for their universality is central...more
these characters are amazing for their universality is central...more
Note:
*How I would love to give this book 4.5 stars, if only because it starts a little slow. Granted, the ending of the book echoes the beginning in a lovely way, and when I finished I felt wholly satisfied and frankly grateful to have stumbled upon Krasznahorkai, but starting with Mrs. Plauf didn't really gun the narrative engine - it felt to me like the novel proper didn't really start until Mrs. Eszter and Valuska entered the picture.*
A strange circus exhibiting a dead whale arrives in a smal...more
*How I would love to give this book 4.5 stars, if only because it starts a little slow. Granted, the ending of the book echoes the beginning in a lovely way, and when I finished I felt wholly satisfied and frankly grateful to have stumbled upon Krasznahorkai, but starting with Mrs. Plauf didn't really gun the narrative engine - it felt to me like the novel proper didn't really start until Mrs. Eszter and Valuska entered the picture.*
A strange circus exhibiting a dead whale arrives in a smal...more
It seems to me that the back cover blurb seriously misstates the nature of this novel; but the blurb-writer can be forgiven, because it's very hard to come up with a brief description of this unconventional, disturbing, densely-worded, elliptical work. Furthermore, when discussing it, I don't want to reveal enough to spoil its considerable suspense. However, to simplify, it seems to concern itself with various ways of living in a world dominated by destruction and decay. There are two threads to...more
It's just not possible not to read a book that is endorsed by W.G. Sebald and Susan Sontag, and whose author -- and his amazing translator -- can write sentences like this:[return][return]"To be wise, however, soberly to anticipate what might lie in store, was truly no easy task, for it was as is some vital yet undetectable modification had taken place in the eternally stable composition of the air, in the very remoteness of that hitherto faultless mechanism or unnamed principle -- which, it is...more
Moeilijk om dit boek te beschrijven. Het is een surrealistisch verhaal, maar wel zo spannend geschreven, dat je blijft lezen. Geschreven eind 80er jaren in Hongarije. Mischien is het boek een metafoor voor de politieke realiteit van toen in Hongarije.Ik weet het niet. Het gaat over een klein burgerlijk stadje, waar op een dag een circus verschijnt met in zijn gevolg een groot aantal hooligans. die laatsten richten in opdracht van "de prins", een duistere medewerker van het circus (een nauwelijks...more
The Melancholy of Resistance (written by Laszlo Krasznahorkai and translated from Hungarian by George Szirtes) is, to say the least, a very odd book. It is odd in content, in structure, in everything. A circus comes to a small Hungarian town and brings with it an uneasy malevolence. The circus features a taxidermied whale and a mysterious circus feature referred to as "The Prince" - but prince of who and what and why are never explained. The plot oozes along, first with a deep sense of forebodin...more
This book felt very similar to many novels I've read, but there was still something intangibly different. As you've already read if you've seen any reviews, he has a similar flow to authors like Bernhard, Marias, and other purveyors of long sentences, but I felt something distinctively strange about this book. He's fascinated by humans surely, and does a good job surveying the rabble that constitutes the majority of folk, but his interests also lie in the fact that we are floating around in a co...more
I have just spent a fascinating couple of weeks in the outer reaches of Hungary, with an excellent novel entitled “The Melancholy of Resistance” by acclaimed Hungarian author László Krasznahorkai.
Krasznahorkai, it must be said, stands out as a hugely significant writer whose importance has been rightly recognised outside of his native country. According to Susan Sontag, he is “the contemporary Hungarian master of apocalypse who inspires comparison with Gogol and Melville”. W. G. Sebald had this...more
Krasznahorkai, it must be said, stands out as a hugely significant writer whose importance has been rightly recognised outside of his native country. According to Susan Sontag, he is “the contemporary Hungarian master of apocalypse who inspires comparison with Gogol and Melville”. W. G. Sebald had this...more
Ultimately, I suspect Krasznahorkai's reputation is inextricably bound up with Bela Tarr's films in a way that buoys his critical reception, but this is a very, very good novel which works at its best when withholding information from the reader in a way that mirrors the imperfect knowledge of its characters (except for one moment late in the novel where a viewpoint character refuses to acknowledge the identity of a corpse for several pages in a way that simply doesn't make sense). Krasznahorkai...more
A surreal tale, compared by reviews to Kafka and Dostoevsky, but with echoes too of Beckett and Ionesco. A circus advertising "The World's Largest Whale" comes to a small Hungarian town (perhaps, but not obviously, during the period of late socialism) already on the brink of semi-apocalyptic collapse, and serves as the trigger for a brutal riot. In winding, more labyrinthine than lyrical prose, Krasznahorkai gives us three primary characters grappling to understand or capitalize on societal and...more
The prose proceeds like a glacier, slowly and solidly. There are not many paragraph breaks to give the eyes and the mind a rest. Bela Tarr's film, "Werkmeister Harmonies," is based on this novel, but it might be better to use the term "inspired by." Tarr employs the themes of the novel to unsettling effect, but embraces the kind of sensual ambiguity a film can convey with music and image. Krasznahorkai's world is built with words, and many of them. The result is a dense work, that is not easy re...more
The style of this mystical novel was challenging and the story haunting. The foreboding and dark mood made, and continue to make, me feel uneasy. Krasznahorkai brings to mind Dostoevsky and Kafka, but is quieter and more subtle- especially with either Ezster or Valuska narrating. K.'s use of metaphor and allegory are superb. He manages to create stirring images and beautiful lines. Through the eerie and unforgettable images of the whale and the followers in the square that he sets the tone for a...more
I have not been so mesmerized by a book and an author since I picked up my first David Foster Wallace book. No kidding, Krasnahorkai might just be the most talented writer living today. The fact that he's Hungarian will probably mean that few will experience his preternatural ability to climb deep, deep within the human soul, spirit and psyche. You just don't finish this book and put it down...you have to peel it out of your mind and ply it out of your gut. Do not be put off by the dense prose.....more
There are over 50 reviews of this book on goodreads so I won't sum up the story in any way. Just some comments.
The book is about destruction and decay; disharmony and disorder. It is also about, in a twisted, sad way, harmony and rebirth. Each character wins or loses according to their own take on the world; their own resilience and abilities, both intellectually and morally. (Moral ability?) Of the main characters, Mrs. Eszter, the true Leviathan of the story, through her Machiavellian maneuve...more
The book is about destruction and decay; disharmony and disorder. It is also about, in a twisted, sad way, harmony and rebirth. Each character wins or loses according to their own take on the world; their own resilience and abilities, both intellectually and morally. (Moral ability?) Of the main characters, Mrs. Eszter, the true Leviathan of the story, through her Machiavellian maneuve...more
In Belgian painter James Ensor's "Christ's Entry into Brussels in 1889", a vast carnival mob in grotesque masks advances toward the viewer. (wikipedia)
I can think of no better cover for this novel, in which a circus featuring a taxidermy whale and its menacing mob of followers arrive in a crumbling, decrepit city in Hungary. Four primary characters, whose souls are jolted into motion by this event, struggle to understand and cope with the impending cataclysm.
Ensor's massive painting is busy, ugl...more
I can think of no better cover for this novel, in which a circus featuring a taxidermy whale and its menacing mob of followers arrive in a crumbling, decrepit city in Hungary. Four primary characters, whose souls are jolted into motion by this event, struggle to understand and cope with the impending cataclysm.
Ensor's massive painting is busy, ugl...more
Astonishing prose so dense it makes it hard to breathe.
...more
Harrer, Volent, everyone was in the same condition—not so much convinced as flattened by the sheer weight of the director's rolling, irresistible cadences, by the combined force of something that comprised statements, arguments, pleas and revelations, in fact so utterly buried were they under it they needed someone to come along and dig them out, and it was not surprising that it took them some time before they recovered all their faculties
Mrs. Plauf, seemingly a subject of satire, nestled in her cloyingly comfortable house away from “the crazy whirlpool, the mad comings and goings of the outside world,” is really a variation on Eszter’s philosophically justified misanthropy. I can’t help thinking schematically about this novel: Both of these characters seek refuge indoors, in an internally driven space, Mrs. Plauf bolstered by routine, quaint objects, and cleanliness, Eszter bolstered by routine, philosophy, and music. Mrs. Plauf...more
There are moments of astounding beauty in this book. My personal favourite is when Valuska,the book's holy fool, demonstrates the motion of the planets around the sun in the kind of bar only found only in Hungarian and Slav lit, 'the penny Riesling in their scratch-marked glasses...'. Dark bars they are, where tables rock on their uneven legs and pickling spices permeate the walls. I think I read this stuff for those bars.
Valuska demonstrates the motion of the planets with his fellow drinkers,...more
Valuska demonstrates the motion of the planets with his fellow drinkers,...more
There are no discussion topics on this book yet.
Be the first to start one »
László Krasznahorkai is the difficult, peculiar, obsessive, visionary Hungarian author of eight novels.
He is probably best known through the oeuvre of the director Béla Tarr, who has collaborated with him on several movies.
More about László Krasznahorkai...
He is probably best known through the oeuvre of the director Béla Tarr, who has collaborated with him on several movies.
Share This Book
1 trivia question
More quizzes & trivia...

Loading...










view all 24 comments



































