Aaron and Ahmed. Jay Cantor, Writer
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating

Aaron and Ahmed. Jay Cantor, Writer

by
3.11 of 5 stars 3.11  ·  rating details  ·  103 ratings  ·  24 reviews
"What causes terrorism?"

After his fiancée dies on 9/11, the question plagues Aaron Goodman. It makes him give up his career as a doctor to become an interrogator at Guantanamo Bay. It leads him to meme theory, as he wonders if there could be a cold science behind the conversion of people into suicide bombers. And ultimately, it brings him to Ahmed, a Gitmo prisoner who pro...more
Hardcover
Published June 1st 2011 by Titan Publishing Company (first published April 12th 2011)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.
This book is not yet featured on Listopia. Add this book to your favorite list »

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 159)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Jays
This is actually a pretty subversive little story, for a variety of reasons. I'm a little curious as to why it was written in graphic novel form, as it seems like a traditional novel would have served the story a little better, but that said I still enjoyed reading it. The central characters have a really nicely complex relationship, making for a very interesting and often surprising read.

On the downside, the story feels a little outdated. The central question of "what makes a suicide bomber do...more
Jonathan Lu
What an odd graphic novel� picked it up at the reco of the library as it sounded really interesting. An army psychiatrist who volunteers to become a Guantanamo interrogator after the death of his wife during 9-11, and the relationship he builds with a prisoner. Attempts to delve into the root causes of manipulation for how men could be driven to terror and suicide bombings, through planting meme � powerful concepts in their head. Aside from the showing how desensitized we have become to horror t...more
zxvasdf
I didn't see myself going where Jay Cantor took me and found myself punched in the brain. We all know about memes, and how they can take a life of their own. What if they could be primed like a rocket and set on a collision course trajectory? Cantor writes, through the dialogues of Aaron and Ahmed, that suicide bombers aren't merely fearless religious fanatics, but are as unaware of their intentions as we are. You find out about programming and deprogramming the psyche. You find that just maybe...more
Frank
What starts off as a seemingly cliched critique of Gitmo, quickly turns very bizzare...unfortunately, it just stays as weird, rather than gripping. The love story between the two main protagonists, while being odd as being between an interegator and his prisoner (and then oddly flipping), never really feels compelling, or even interesting.

I usually like weird and different, but this also stayed flat, despite its attempts (or perhaps because of their inadequacies) to tackle the big questions of...more
Linda Cohen
When I was finished I sat there in shock,shaking for a full minute. A really powerful book about both sides of the terrorist coin. I wish I could write something profound but I don't have the words. Read this book!!!
Matthew
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.
Dan
Reading this lame excuse for a graphic novel reminds me of my experience with the Matrix series. While the first one is a pretty good movie, though it most certainly doesn't deserve half the accolades it receives for its less than deep philosophy. While I digress from what might seem an unnecessary addendum, what makes the first Matrix movie of the series a good movie is that while it attempts to have some deep ideas behind it, it doesn't try to hard along these lines. This is the failing of the...more
Aj
The premise of this novel made me want to race out and buy it.
Addressing 9/11 in an engaging way? Yes!
Investigating the root causes of terrorism? Yes!
Exploring theories on terrorism? How cool!

I'll start out with the illustrations, however. I'm not a religious graphic novel reader. I'm not familiar with James Romberger. Illustrations that are landscape or scenic are very well done. The montage involving the Old Man, were slightly surrealistic, and enhanced the theoretical mind-altering experi...more
Eric Piotrowski
The illustrations are excellent; color palettes are intriguing and illuminative. The dialogue is well-paced.

Okay, that's all the good stuff out of the way. Sorry, but I was decidedly unimpressed by this book. Let's use 9/11 as the starting point for a really torturous and opaque exploration of "memes". Along the way we'll sidestep all of the myriad political, social, economic, and personal reasons for terrorism, and boil it all down to brainwashing and "love".

Don't bother. If you want a good gra...more
M
Doctor Aaron Goodman was a military therapist, working with veterans of various wars. Following his wife's death during the 9/11 attacks, Goodman chooses to utilize his mental tricks at Guantanamo Bay. Asked to crack a particulary difficult prisoner dubbed Ahmed, Goodman connects with the man over theories about terrorism. Determined to understand the root cause of the suicide bomber mentality, two men escape the prison camp and travel to Ahmed's training facility in Pakistan. As Goodman falls f...more
Chris
One of the best GN I've read all year. Amazing mind-f of a story line that will make you re-read to be sure you read it right. A look at terrorism and religious extremism, especially as influenced by meme psychology. Also, a gay love story.
Alden
I have to think about this book. This was one of those books where I wasn't quite sure whether I was missing the point because I'm ignorant about these issues, or if the book itself is confusing. It's certainly engaging and I'll certainly remember it.
Stewart Tame
Probably not as racy as you're imagining. This is one of those books whose primary mission is to provide food for thought. That said, it also functions fine as just a story. Honestly, I'm a bit underwhelmed, but this was at least an interesting read.
Kate
An okay comic, just not to my taste. overwrought post 9-11 story speculating on the roots of terrorism that misses the mark, in my opinion. I can usually figure out who I would suggest books to, but I'm not sure who the audience is for this book.
Khokebfit
Just curious about the graphic novel world.
Steve
An insightful book about how infectious ideas can be and how they can lead people down very dangerous paths. Set in the time shortly after 9/11 in Guantanamo Bay, this book does not shy away from controversy.
sweet pea
a provocative read i cannot wait to discuss. it's hard to say much without revealing key elements. suffice to say it's a wild ride and an intriguing take on terrorism, torture, current events, and love.
!Tæmbuŝu
Jun 26, 2011 !Tæmbuŝu marked it as to-read  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: graphic-novel
Reviewed by Broken Frontier
Ty Melgren
Jul 01, 2011 Ty Melgren rated it 3 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommended to Ty by: Mario
Pretty good and pretty weird story about how all teams are fake teams (as opposed to imaginary teams).
VeganMedusa
An interesting look at terrorism, brainwashing, and the God meme and whether it could be a virus.
laaaaames
Agggg I wanted so much more, but in a way that the book was doing its job.

(read: 49)
Brendan Howard
Mar 19, 2012 Brendan Howard rated it 3 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommended to Brendan by: Stories of 9/11 moral confusion, strange ideas, foreign culture
Shelves: comic-books
A Grant Morrison-esque tale of terrorists, memes, and the ideas in your head.
Claire Scott
Claire Scott marked it as to-read
Apr 06, 2014
Carla
Carla marked it as to-read
Feb 27, 2014
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
Krazy Kat The Death of Che Guevara Great Neck Forgiving the Angel: Four Stories for Franz Kafka On Giving Birth To One's Own Mother: Essays on Art and Society

Share This Book