414th out of 661 books
—
557 voters
Three Cups of Deceit: How Greg Mortenson, Humanitarian Hero, Lost His Way
by
Jon Krakauer
Greg Mortenson, the bestselling author of Three Cups of Tea, is a man who has built a global reputation as a selfless humanitarian and children’s crusader, and he’s been nominated for the Nobel Peace Prize. But, as Jon Krakauer demonstrates in this extensively researched and penetrating book, he is not all that he appears to be.
Based on wide-ranging interviews with former...more
Paperback, 96 pages
Published
July 1st 2011
by Anchor
(first published May 3rd 2011)
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
3,000)
I did not read Three Cups of Tea. It seemed - from a distance - like a schmaltzy look at attempting large social change. That doesn't interest me, because I feel the terms are simplified to tell a story. And in that simplification, things are presented in a way that is too good to be true. This simplification loses how challenging it is to create lasting social change.
Jon Krakauer gave money to Greg Mortenson early on to support building schools in Afghanistan with an emphasis on reaching girls...more
Jon Krakauer gave money to Greg Mortenson early on to support building schools in Afghanistan with an emphasis on reaching girls...more
Jun 18, 2011
Marte Patel
rated it
4 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
kindle,
non-fiction
I saw Greg Mortenson speak in Miami in July last year and was captivated by his story. Each delegate at the conference were given a copy of Three Cups of Tea (the young adult version) and a hardback copy of Stones into Schools. I thought this was very generous of the publisher, but according to this exposé, Mortenson usually buys the books for such events using his charity's funds, so that (a) he can receive royalties (not his charity, mind!), which he wouldn't if the publisher donated the books...more
Having enjoyed Krakauer’s work in the past, I picked up this Kindle single on spec. Turns out to be quite a read. Krakauer was an emotional and financial supporter of Greg Mortenson, the author of Three Cups of Tea: One Man's Mission to Promote Peace ... One School at a Time, the mountaineer who created a non-profit empire building schools in Pakistan ostensibly as a way to thwart the influence of the Taliban and Islamic revolutionary teaching. He became somewhat of a cult figure and was soon je...more
Mr. Mortenson is a pathological liar. Yes he had nice idea, he performed many good things in Central Asia BUT all that as far as I'm concerned because what he was doing behind the scene doesn't justify him a bit. Of course I do hope charity will fulfill its mission without him and I hope even more that he'll face the justice.
However, the main thing is a massive disappointment he'll surely raise in hearts of thousands of people who fell in love in his personality while reading his books. I'm not...more
However, the main thing is a massive disappointment he'll surely raise in hearts of thousands of people who fell in love in his personality while reading his books. I'm not...more
The good news is Greg Mortenson had/has a nice idea. The bad news is that he's a pathological liar with little regard for credibility and accountabulity -- but he's happy to spend 41 cents of every non-profit-donated dollar on dubious Afghani schools, and 59 cents on what amounts to the glorification of Greg Mortenson.
Krakauer is an awesome "new journalist," and this "Kindle Singles" form was an outstanding platform for this work. What Krakauer has always done so well is to dlve into a fascinati...more
Krakauer is an awesome "new journalist," and this "Kindle Singles" form was an outstanding platform for this work. What Krakauer has always done so well is to dlve into a fascinati...more
Krakauer writes so clearly, than even though I wasn't really up on the whole Three Cups of Tea concept, I fully understood what was going on. Turns out this guy, Mortenson, is great at getting people to give him money, but he is lousy at managing a multi-million-dollar charity. As various well-intentioned but poorly thought-out celebrity charities have recently shown, a good "concept" is rarely the key to successful works. I sympathize with all those who have contributed to CAI and the Pennies f...more
I have read every book Jon Krakauer has written. I must say this one both shocked me and made me wonder how much of what did not happen had to do with the American military presence in Afghanistan, and Pakistan. This book goes into the humanitarian "projects" of one Greg Mortenson, a former nurse from San Francisco. Readers may know him by the books he had ghostwritten for him: "Three Cups of Tea" and "Stones for Schools". After reading this book, I wondered if Mortenson's parents should not hav...more
Krakauer documents the deceits, frauds, misappropriations, negligence, and breaches of trust of Greg Mortenson, author of "3 Cups of Tea" and founder of the Central Asia Institute. It was interesting that a worldly-wise investigative writer was taken in by Mortenson's cult of personality as was the rest of the great unwashed. Why didn't Krakauer's bulls*** detector not go off as quickly as mine did? Mine went off when I read the Parade article about Mortenson anointing him as saint and hero befo...more
Objective journalism is hard enough, but it's hard to be an objective reader when it comes to Jon Krakauer. I admire his ability to write and tell a story, but when I read him, I have to keep a very open mind. This particular piece is complicated, has many troubling elements - deception, an inability to keep promises, mishandling of a nobly-intentioned charity's funds, and a charismatic and difficult lead character in Greg Mortenson - and at times Krakauer's writing threatens to make the story a...more
I am a big Krakauer fan. I have read almost every book he has published. I am always impressed by his extensive research. He is able to find and interview folks that are able to paint a picture of the person in question. This book is no different. Its a short one of less than 70 pages, but it brings to light the manipulative, compulsive, manic, Greg Mortenson. You realize from the beginning that Mortenson was going to lie about practically everything in his bestselling books. He would literally...more
It took Jon Krakauer 75 pages to unravel all the lies spun by Mortenson and Relin in 350 pages of three cups of tea. I wasn't blown away by Krakauers writing in this one, but he didn't intend this to be like one of his longer books. He succinctly unravels Mortenson's deceit.
Like Krakauer I am really confused why Greg would go to all that trouble to concoct such an elaborate lie. The story, the parts that are true would be admirable. It reminds me of the woman who lied for years about being a Se...more
Like Krakauer I am really confused why Greg would go to all that trouble to concoct such an elaborate lie. The story, the parts that are true would be admirable. It reminds me of the woman who lied for years about being a Se...more
A disheartening book that paints a very convincing picture of how Greg Mortenson's "Three Cups of Tea" is more fiction than fact. While it acknowledges that he has done some good and had the potential to do much more, it captures how (although it cannot explain why) Mortenson has repeatedly turned his back on those who tried to bring to his attention problems with his organization. It highlights how he has altered the time and place of events and made many out of whole cloth. And it shines light...more
Three Cups of Deceit sheds light on the myth of Three Cups of Tea author Greg Mortenson. Krakauer, a well-known author of a number of excellent books, was conned by Mortenson along with many others. According to Krakauer's well-researched book, the accounting at the Central Asia Institute (Mortenson's charity) is highly suspect, and his books are filled with exaggerations and lies. Krakauer says that, were expenses reported honestly, "CAI's fundraising and administrative expenses would actually...more
In his usual style, Jon Krakauer investigates and documents in overly thorough footnotes the lies invented by Greg Mortensen, author of "Three Cups of Tea," and the Central Asian Institute, which builds schools in Central Asia.
This time, it's personal. Krakauer lost at least $50,000 to Mortensen, and lended his name to the charity. When the inconsistencies in Mortensen's books, speeches and interviews became apparent, Krakauer wrote a short ebook, which is on Kindle for maybe $1.99. It's listed...more
This time, it's personal. Krakauer lost at least $50,000 to Mortensen, and lended his name to the charity. When the inconsistencies in Mortensen's books, speeches and interviews became apparent, Krakauer wrote a short ebook, which is on Kindle for maybe $1.99. It's listed...more
May 07, 2012
Terra
rated it
4 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Recommends it for:
Anyone who has read Three Cups of Tea
Recommended to Terra by:
Abigail Stewart
Shelves:
social-problems,
real-life
Reading Deceit really helped to solidify the thoughts and feelings I had toward Greg Mortenson after reading Three Cups of Tea. I still think that set out to do a good thing, but his lacking managerial skills and his inability to be accountable for his actions are ultimately what's going to be his downfall. I'm still not convinced he's a malicious person, but I do believe he doesn't understand that running a charity has rules and expectations and that when someone donates to his organization, th...more
A cautionary tale to all who support charity through philanthropic means. It's very easy to get caught up in the wonderful story but it is far more productive to investigate exactly where your donation is going.
How do parents explain to the many children who saved thier pennies to build schools for disadvantaged children that thier sacrifice went to pay for chartered jets and book signing tours? How do they explain that in actuality there are no children being taught anything at all in abandon...more
How do parents explain to the many children who saved thier pennies to build schools for disadvantaged children that thier sacrifice went to pay for chartered jets and book signing tours? How do they explain that in actuality there are no children being taught anything at all in abandon...more
I recently finished Mortenson's "Three Cups of Tea" and knew that Krakauer had written a follow-up story to what occurred on those pages.
If you've read Mortenson's book, I recommend you read this, too. Krakauer offers some insight into the workings of Central Asia Institute (CAI) and the various issues they have had throughout the years. Initially written as an indepth review of "Three Cups of Tea," Krakauer speaks with former Board members and employees of CAI. While it's possible these partic...more
If you've read Mortenson's book, I recommend you read this, too. Krakauer offers some insight into the workings of Central Asia Institute (CAI) and the various issues they have had throughout the years. Initially written as an indepth review of "Three Cups of Tea," Krakauer speaks with former Board members and employees of CAI. While it's possible these partic...more
When I finished Greg Mortenson's inspiring story, Three Cups of Tea, there were things I wondered about.
In the episode of his capture and eight-day captivity, for example, what motivated his captors to take him in the first place, and then why did they let him go? Much of the detail in his description of that event seemed contrived. Why would nuns allow a giant stranger, showing up from nowhere, unsupervised access to the body of their cherished patroness, Mother Teresa? Most importantly, why w...more
In the episode of his capture and eight-day captivity, for example, what motivated his captors to take him in the first place, and then why did they let him go? Much of the detail in his description of that event seemed contrived. Why would nuns allow a giant stranger, showing up from nowhere, unsupervised access to the body of their cherished patroness, Mother Teresa? Most importantly, why w...more
Very well written, very well researched but, boy was I glad it was so short. Absolutely depressing as hell.I'd like to say my BS antenna was quivering when I read excerpts of Mortenson's books, but I'm afraid I bought his story hook, line and mullah. I just couldn't take the cloying, saccharine tone of the portions the works I did read, so I never pursued reading either in full. Didn't doubt him one bit, though.
Cynic that I am, I'm guessing Krakauer went out of his way to point out the few thing...more
Cynic that I am, I'm guessing Krakauer went out of his way to point out the few thing...more
A quick, worthwhile read. Just under 75 pages, and gets down to the nitty gritty. Not Krakauer's best because the writing suggests he was trying to get this written fast and furious. Still, the cover photograph comes back to haunt readers toward the end of the book. A completely empty school, built in Northern Pakistan, similar to other abandoned projects funded by Three Cups of Tea Greg Mortenson's never-ending book tour. Contemporary Orientalism and fetishizing the exotic is on ugly display. C...more
I literally just finished Three Cups of Tea the same day I came across this book at a little independent bookstore in Boston (and I hope in the near future to see it in all big-box bookstores and public libraries as well). Jon Krakauer is, needless to say, a prominent and well respected author, which lends itself heavily to the credibility of the accusations in this book:
Which include fabricating huge portions of the story- even making up a kidnapping- and misusing funds generated by Mortenson's...more
Which include fabricating huge portions of the story- even making up a kidnapping- and misusing funds generated by Mortenson's...more
I know Krakauer donated quite a lot of money to Mortenson's CAI over the years. Whether or not this book was born from spite, I can't say, but one thing is clear: If you are going to con people, avoid writers/investigative reporters who make a living on exposes.
Greg Mortenson is almost a cliche -- self-centered, egomaniacal, semi-psychopathic liar who believed his lies were untouchable. Because when you tell falsehoods about people in remote areas of the world...you just naturally assume no one...more
Greg Mortenson is almost a cliche -- self-centered, egomaniacal, semi-psychopathic liar who believed his lies were untouchable. Because when you tell falsehoods about people in remote areas of the world...you just naturally assume no one...more
I'm sorry to say that I think everything in this book is accurate. I read Mortenson's 'Three Cups of Tea' several years ago (and have since given it to many high school students to read), and I loved it. It was beautiful and inspiring and touching. And largely made up. I picked up Krakauer's book as I was so impressed with his journalism in 'Into Thin Air'. He comes across in both books as a reliable and well-researched writer. After reading 'Three Cups of Deceit', I find it hard to believe I di...more
Though I haven't read Greg Mortenson's book, "Three Cups of Tea", the object of critics by Krakauer's "Three Cups of Deceit", I understand Krakauer's points and went aghast at the scale of lies and shadows that Mortenson has created.
However, the book seems to be too thin and the evidence that Krakauer presented seemed to be to fragile. I wonder whether there is a serious audit going on to see where has all those millions of donations went and what actually Central Asia Institute (of Greg Mortens...more
However, the book seems to be too thin and the evidence that Krakauer presented seemed to be to fragile. I wonder whether there is a serious audit going on to see where has all those millions of donations went and what actually Central Asia Institute (of Greg Mortens...more
Crapola. I really loved "Three Cups of Tea." It was so inspiring. I also thought that Mortenson's second book was okay, too.
I also think that Krakauer is an incredibly gifted unbiased writer with a knack for storytelling and realistic portrayals. It is definitely moving to know that he felt so strongly about a negative issue that he was personally involved with, to write an entire book about it. I trust JK as a writer, almost more as a journalist than a novelist.
"Three Cups of Deceit" is clear...more
I also think that Krakauer is an incredibly gifted unbiased writer with a knack for storytelling and realistic portrayals. It is definitely moving to know that he felt so strongly about a negative issue that he was personally involved with, to write an entire book about it. I trust JK as a writer, almost more as a journalist than a novelist.
"Three Cups of Deceit" is clear...more
A damning expose of a humanitarian agenda run amok. I went in assuming that Krakauer had been bilked and was now out grinding an axe...and I was right. However, his investigations into the underlying facts behind two bestellers (Three Cups of Tea, Stones into Schools) prove that there is quite a bit of myth behind Mortenson's stories. (For a quick overview, read this story: http://www.cbsnews.com/stories/2011/0...)
Disappointing to say the least. Mortenson's intentions may very well be pure, but...more
Disappointing to say the least. Mortenson's intentions may very well be pure, but...more
A GOOD CON, A GOOD READ.
“The image of Mortenson that has been created for public consumption is an artifact born of fantasy, audacity and an apparently insatiable hunger for esteem.”—page 15
Everyone loves a good con. In his non-fiction short story / article ‘Three Cups of Deceit,’ Jon Krakauer does a good job trying to debunk the “con” run by Greg Mortenson (‘Three Cups of Tea,’ ‘Stones Into Schools’) and the charities he founded to build schools in Pakistan and Afghanistan—charities to which Kr...more
“The image of Mortenson that has been created for public consumption is an artifact born of fantasy, audacity and an apparently insatiable hunger for esteem.”—page 15
Everyone loves a good con. In his non-fiction short story / article ‘Three Cups of Deceit,’ Jon Krakauer does a good job trying to debunk the “con” run by Greg Mortenson (‘Three Cups of Tea,’ ‘Stones Into Schools’) and the charities he founded to build schools in Pakistan and Afghanistan—charities to which Kr...more
Important read if you have read Greg's books and fell for them, but I feel Karakuer went on a vengeance hunt against Mortenson and definitely lost some perspective.
Some of Karakuer's important accusations against Mortenson are written in a way to make it sound worse than it is - in some cases far worse - like when he accuses Mortenson's NGO of only spending 50% of it's intake of money on schools - but the actual figure on overheads turns out to be lower because Karakuer didn't mention that a goo...more
Some of Karakuer's important accusations against Mortenson are written in a way to make it sound worse than it is - in some cases far worse - like when he accuses Mortenson's NGO of only spending 50% of it's intake of money on schools - but the actual figure on overheads turns out to be lower because Karakuer didn't mention that a goo...more
Well it seems that both of these books have some element of truth in them. It appears that both authors, Krakauer and Mortenson, like to stretch the truth . Both authors makes wide general sweeping claims about their supposed facts. After reading both these books it appears to me that they are both rather inconsistent in their supposed facts. While Krakauer has made valid points throughout his novel, Krakauer has seemingly misquoted and has been erronous in some of his statements. This inconsist...more
I found this book so sad. I read the Three cups of tea story and had heard from alot of friends and family who had read it. This book was saying that the book was fiction and hardly any of it was true. This was sad to me that so many people read and loved the book, and to find out that we had all put our hopes in a falsehood made me sad. I can't remember if this was the guy that was on Oprah telling that the book was false and that she had Greg Mortenson on or not, but I remember hearing that hi...more
| topics | posts | views | last activity | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Karachi: October 2011 - Three cups of Deceit | 4 | 17 | Nov 01, 2011 04:10am |
Jon Krakauer is an American writer and mountaineer, well-known for outdoor and mountain-climbing writing.
More about Jon Krakauer...
Share This Book
2 trivia questions
More quizzes & trivia...

Loading...





view 2 comments





















