How the Irish Saved Civilization
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating

How the Irish Saved Civilization (The Hinges of History #1)

3.79 of 5 stars 3.79  ·  rating details  ·  18,176 ratings  ·  875 reviews
From the fall of Rome to the rise of Charlemagne - the "dark ages" - learning, scholarship, and culture disappeared from the European continent. The great heritage of western civilization - from the Greek and Roman classics to Jewish and Christian works - would have been utterly lost were it not for the holy men and women of unconquered Ireland. In this delightful and illu...more
Hardcover, Large Print
Published May 1st 1998 by G.K. Hall & Company (first published 1994)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 3,000)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
John Wiswell
Mind-numbingly written, building up to a nearly inconsequential conclusion on how Irish monks might have helped preserve some of Europe's classic literature. I'm descended from the Irish and was looking forward to a little nationalist pride, but this failed by underdelivering from its title and being nearly unreadable from the first chapter. It hurts even worse to hear that the claims may have been false.
Amy
Jan 13, 2008 Amy rated it 5 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition Recommends it for: Irish, Irish lovers, travelers, historians, dreamers, lovers of literature
Recommended to Amy by: my dear dad
Shelves: past-read
I spent a semester studying on the rugged west coast of Ireland, utterly immersed in the culture.

My college owns a line of houses in a tiny village in Ireland, and for nearly 40 years they've paid the villagers to keep it in good condition for the yearly crop of foreigners who descend on it, like me, for four months every year.

The experience itself was wonderful, but preparing for it and the anticipation were almost MORE fun. I read this book with that spirit in mind. I learned how St. Patrick b...more
Mark
Though not exactly news to anyone who went to school in Ireland (Cahill seems to have an Irish-American readership as his target audience, particularly given-away by his repeated and annoying generalizations about the 'Irish Spirit' and such like: what does he mean, Jameson or Bushmills?), this nevertheless has lots of good stuff in it and the overall argument is strong.

I particularly liked the early material contrasting the moribund writing of Roman Gallic poet Ausonias with St. Augustine, and...more
Kathleen
Cahill may be overblown and off base at times, but he increased my interest in the Dark Ages. I read the first four books in the Hinges of History series, starting book 1 almost 20 years ago, so my memory is not bright, but they stuck with me fairly well. Kudos to the author for that. Since then, Cahill wrote two more books, but I have not read them. This is quasi-history told in a fairly accessible narrative style -- if at times meandering. Cahill is not a historian, per se, but his education...more
Wealhtheow
As the Roman Empire crumbled, so too did literacy and libraries suffer. By the seventh century, however, Patrick had converted enough men into being Christians and scribes that many ancient Greek and Roman books were preserved in Ireland, even as the originals crumbled elsewhere. The preservation of ancient texts is a fascinating theme upon which to relate a history, but alas, the majority of the book concerns how awesome Plato is. Seriously, there is a three page quote from Plato, followed by a...more
John
This is the kind of book where the title really seems to over-commit to an idea and overstate the reality of history. I went into this book thinking that Cahill was surely using hyperbole to say that the Irish saved civilization. He may be, but this is still a remarkable and relevant history. This is a great, great book that deserves the wide readership it has received.

The book begins with a retelling of the fall of Rome. Cahill does this to show the peril in which Western Civilization was steep...more
Andrew
Here Cahill provides a popular-level history of the early middle ages with mixed success. His greatest asset is a suprisingly strong prose style, which allows him to effortlessly, and even peotically, lead his readers through a complicated and fuzzy period of history. No doubt this is the reason the book was a bestseller. But it also proves to be his downfall in that his efortless sentences ellide the complexity of his subject matter. Perhaps this is the fate of all popularizers, but I found mys...more
Jen
This was awful. Many reviews say things like "charming" and "pleasant," but I thought it was tedious and meandering. Not all history has to be chronological; there's interesting stuff in here but it's too long with details of Roman society. Also, the author writes like a blow-hard, and interjects things like "Alas!" and "Dear Reader" and "It is up to the reader to decide." That kind of stuff irritates me to no end.

Searching for info online, I found references that refute much of what the author...more
Lisa (Harmonybites)
I do get why this book on "How the Irish Saved Civilization" was a bestseller. Not only is it the perfect gift for St Patrick's Day, it is entertaining and readable. But I also found it superficial and not reliable. It may be the contrast with some really fine histories and biographies I've read lately, but several things in this book made it suspect to me. Cahill isn't a historian. The short biography at the end says only that he has a MFA in "Film and Dramatic Literature" and that he has studi...more
Ramorx
Nov 08, 2007 Ramorx rated it 1 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition Recommends it for: Latin and Greek scholars
It seems to me that the basic thesis of this book is absurd. The "Irish" didnt save civilization - a few scholarly monks set to work on preserving the classics, all very noble, but meanwhile the rest of the Irish were cavorting around not being like fucking Romans or Greeks and living a different kind of anti-state and somewhat anti-authoritarian "civilization".

This from wikipedia -
Celtic Ireland (650-1650)
In Celtic Irish society of the Middle Ages and Early Modern period, courts and the law we...more
Jon Newswanger
In college I took a class entitled "Christianity in History." It turned out to be merely a church history class.

This book is everything I wished that course had been, but wasn't. It does an amazing job in pointing out how Christians have impacted history, summed up best in it's final sentence:

If our civilization is to be saved -- forget about our civilization, which, as Patrick would say, may pass "in a moment like a cloud or smoke that is scattered by the wind" -- if we are to be saved, it will...more
Ron
The title may be a slight exaggeration, but it's a good read for students of western history. Lots of good Middle Ages as well as the expected Irish background.

Multiple readings pull out a wealth of details and insights.
Susan
I've noticed that history books on Goodreads are often given lower star ratings by people who are upset to find that the author was using information to present a cohesive thesis rather than providing an unbiased account. Although it is right to bring up slant in evaluating the truth of a thesis, it's somewhat sad to see these complaints for Cahill's defense of pre-Joycean Irish civilization when one of Cahill's major arguments is that biased English historians prevented any appreciation of Iris...more
David A.
I'm Irish. Don't let my last name (Zimmerman) fool you. I'm the proud son of a guy whose surname unfortunately obscures the fact that my mother (of whom I'm also a proud son) is 100 percent Irish, so assuming my dad has a little Irish in him (who doesn't?) I'm at least 50 percent.

Not sure why that's so important to me, but it is. There's a mystique to Irishness that simply isn't there with other countries of distant origins. Ireland is ever green, it's charmed and charming, thick with thin spac...more
George Bradford
(If you’re curious about the life of St. Patrick, this book contains an excellent account.)

Some books have titles so awesome that the text can’t possibly live up to it. Here is a book whose title does just that. Whether “How the Irish Saved Civilization” lives up to its self-imposed challenge is up to the reader. Lovers of all things Irish will buy it and be filled with pride. Skeptical historians will find errors and omissions to criticize and debunk it.

During Europe’s Middle Ages most of the...more
Brian Hans
I hope I'm not the first to tell you that we have more to thank the Irish for than Saint Patrick's Day. During the dark ages of Europe, the holy men and women of Ireland preserved many of Western civilization's classic texts... and in telling the story of how that came to pass, the author takes us on a determined romp through history illuminated by characters from Irish myth, legend, religion and of course, Saint Patrick himself, who is a bit of all those in one!

It's a quick enough read and pack...more
Kelsea Dawn Hume
First, let's get this ridiculous title out of the way: challenging a racist assumption (that the Irish are lazy, wild, etc.) by buying into a broader racist assumption (that western civilization is the ONLY civilization) isn't really all that radical. And it's bad history. And it's a very bad start to a rather mediocre book.

It's not that I didn't enjoy anything in this book. Cahill meandered to places I found quite enjoyable -- a good history book should meander a bit, the side trails of histor...more
Mike
Nov 03, 2010 Mike rated it 4 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition Recommends it for: Anyone
This is a good and interesting book and although I think it's more a "3.5" than a straight "4", I'm willing to grade it generously.

The author has clearly done a good job on his research and analysis. His writing style is clear and clean; more "popular" than "scholarly" - almost too much so for my tastes. But this is a book written for a widespread and casual audience, so his tone and phrasing is understandably directed to that level.

I, having learned my Greco-Roman history and six years of Latin...more
Mark Gilroy
In 406 A.D the Rhine River froze solid - and the barbarians crossed this temporary bridge to strike one of the final blows to a lazy, corrupt, and aging empire. When Alaric, king of the Visigoths, showed up at Rome's gates in 410 A.D., the citizens still didn't know the end was at hand. Unable to defend themselves - it was a lot of effort after all - they negotiated a "sack" to spare the city from bloodshed:

"So they kept their lives, most of them. But sooner or later they or their progeny lost a...more
Mike Barresi
May 03, 2011 Mike Barresi rated it 4 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition Recommends it for: Anyone with a passion for history, Ireland, literature
Shelves: own, non-fiction
I recently wrote somewhere that Cahill is a great writer of popular history. I didn't really qualify that remark. Cahill doesn't write popular history, he writes about history in a way that the most readers possible, could enjoy. How the Irish Saved Civilization is a perfect example of this. His premise is fairly simple; while the Roman world is collapsing and being taken over by 'barbarians' across the continent, Irish monks, beginning with Saint Patrick, create a new civilization of religion a...more
Mel
An entertaining little history of Irish scholarship, culture, and monk/saint heroes of antiquity who greatly respected early learning, writing etc. This very much has a catholic bias but still well written and worth reading if you are interested in Irish history.
Nannie Bittinger
Feb 23, 2010 Nannie Bittinger rated it 4 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition Recommends it for: anyone with an interest in History or Ireland
Recommended to Nannie by: Cynthia Tooley (I think?)
Another audio book that was so chok full of info that I've ordered a hard copy from Amazon. SO much history of the Irish that I never knew. Every good Irish person should have this on their books shelves for reference:) Would really recommend getting a hard copy though..lots of Latin quotes and poetry that really need to be visually studied.

Memorable quote: " To be Irish is to know that in the end the world will brak your heart." Patrick Moynihan on the death of JFK.
Melissa
what an interesting read, illuminating a piece of history whose generalities are well-known, but whose details are not. i enjoyed cahill's presentation of history. in particular, i really liked the bits about how the irish catholic church was initially incredibly pluralistic, uninterested in focusing on sexuality, and who may have had female abesses, priests and even bishops! how fantastic and a shame that this part of the society did not formally survive. that said, perhaps my favorite part of...more
Jacob Aitken
I think Cahill is correct on his arguments, with a few exceptions. His knowledge of late Roman culture appears sound. His assertion that Rome fell from internal decay appears accurate. There are more factors, of course, but this seems to cover the details. His other argument, and main point, that the Irish preserved civilization by copying down manuscripts in monasteries is true for the most part. The Irish, unlike the Britons or the Gauls, did not have to worry about outside invasions. This gav...more
Ryan Handermann
Cahill focuses on Augustine when talking about the dying Western Civilization, and on Patrick, Columba and Columbanus when talking about how the Irish saved Western Civ. Ireland is place removed from Romanized Christianity, and, like the Assyrian Church, or the Copts, it demonstrates the provincial outlook of a Roman Christianity that tries to proclaim itself as "Catholic" and the center of the Christian world.

A few interesting facts:

Irish monks wrote fun and random notes in the margins of their...more
James
Thomas Cahill does a good job of bringing history alive and making the reader understand the stakes. In this case, the Roman Empire was collapsing and through an unusual set of twists, Ireland, a nation of poets, warriors and farmers, goes through a further evolution and gets introduced to Christianity and the intellectual legacy of the Greeks and the Romans. A young man named Patrick leaves behind his Roman citizenship and falls in love with Ireland. In the process, he helps weave a Christian n...more
Mike Ogilvie
I bought this audio book purely from browsing titles at the book store, not knowing what to expect. Overall I was very pleasantly surprised and thoroughly enjoyed the content.

History was one of my least favorite subjects in school, but I've recently been drawn to books that explore it and thought this one sounded interesting. I had never learned about world history during the transition from classical times (ending in the fall of the Roman empire) and medieval times. The book takes you through a...more
Kate Lawrence
It's March, I thought, why not read a book about the Irish? Cahill's account of the fall of Rome and how the Irish subsequently preserved, copied and disseminated its literature is erudite without being dense, is witty, anecdotal, and thought-provoking. For example, he comments that to be considered a heretic in the church's early centuries, one would need to reject some matter of doctrine, like whether Jesus was both human and divine, and so on. By the seventh century, when Roman Christianity a...more
Benandkaren
I'm sorry to say, I was actually rather disappointed by this book. Perhaps it was the big build up many people had given it. Perhaps it was that I just have too much of a love for history and for Ireland. Hard to say really but given the chance to do it all over again I'd pass on it. I think my main problem is that I've been longing for a book to explain exactly what life was like for people of various ranks during the peek of the Roman Empire. I want to know how life changed during the fall and...more
Elizabeth
I understand why some readers have given this book a low score since Cahill has created an alluring title to garner interest from those not normally inclined to reading historical non-fiction. This is not a book filled with action, battles, and Irish war heros saving "civilization" (although St. Patrick comes out as being a pretty awesome guy). Instead it is a nicely written chronology of the years following the Fall of Rome and Europe's descent into the Dark Ages. Medieval enthusiasts should fi...more
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 99 100 next »
topics  posts  views  last activity   
It's interesting--and true! 14 89 Oct 12, 2012 12:30PM  
Goodreads Ireland: November Read 17 18 Dec 02, 2011 07:24AM  
  • The Story of the Irish Race: A Popular History of Ireland
  • In Search of Ancient Ireland: The Origins of the Irish from Neolithic Times to the Coming of the English
  • Wars of the Irish Kings: A Thousand Years of Struggle, from the Age of Myth Through the Reign of Queen Elizabeth I
  • The Great Shame: And the Triumph of the Irish in the English-Speaking World
  • Paddy's Lament, Ireland 1846-1847: Prelude to Hatred
  • Malachy McCourt's History of Ireland
  • Michael Collins: The Man Who Made Ireland
  • A Distant Mirror:  The Calamitous 14th Century
  • The Great Hunger: Ireland: 1845-1849
  • The Course of Irish History
  • The Celts (Penguin History)
  • The Civilization of the Middle Ages
  • The Celts: A History
  • A World Lit Only by Fire
  • How the Scots Invented the Modern World: The True Story of How Western Europe's Poorest Nation Created Our World and Everything in It
  • 1066: The Hidden History in the Bayeux Tapestry
  • The Discoverers: A History of Man's Search to Know His World and Himself
  • Saxons, Vikings, and Celts: The Genetic Roots of Britain and Ireland
14055
Born in New York City to Irish-American parents and raised in Queens and the Bronx, Cahill was educated by Jesuits and studied ancient Greek and Latin. He continued his study of Greek and Latin literature, as well as medieval philosophy, scripture and theology, at Fordham University, where he completed a B.A. in classical literature and philosophy in 1964, and a pontifical degree in philosophy in...more
More about Thomas Cahill...
The Gifts of the Jews: How a Tribe of Desert Nomads Changed the Way Everyone Thinks and Feels Mysteries of the Middle Ages: The Rise of Feminism, Science and Art from the Cults of Catholic Europe Sailing the Wine-Dark Sea: Why the Greeks Matter (Hinges of History) Desire of the Everlasting Hills: The World Before and After Jesus A Saint on Death Row: The Story of Dominique Green

Share This Book

“The Irish innovation was to make all confession a completely private affair between penitent and priest - and to make it as repeatable as necessary. (In fact, repetition was encouraged on the theory that, oh well, everyone pretty much sinned just about all the time.)” 5 likes
“In becoming an Irishman, Patrick wedded his world to theirs, his faith to their life…Patrick found a way of swimming down to the depths of the Irish psyche and warming and transforming Irish imagination – making it more humane and more noble while keeping it Irish.” (161)” 3 likes
More quotes…