Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “A Train in Winter: An Extraordinary Story of Women, Friendship, and Resistance in Occupied France ” as Want to Read:
A Train in Winter: An Extraordinary Story of Women, Friendship, and Resistance in Occupied France
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating
Open Preview

A Train in Winter: An Extraordinary Story of Women, Friendship, and Resistance in Occupied France

3.77 of 5 stars 3.77  ·  rating details  ·  3,205 ratings  ·  751 reviews
On an icy dawn morning in Paris in January 1943, a group of 230 French women resisters were rounded up from the Gestapo detention camps and sent on a train to Auschwitz - the only train, in the four years of German occupation, to take women of the resistance to a death camp.The youngest was a schoolgirl of 15, the eldest a farmer's wife of 68; there were among them teacher ...more
Paperback, 353 pages
Published September 1st 2011 by Random House Export (first published January 1st 2011)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about A Train in Winter, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about A Train in Winter

This book is not yet featured on Listopia. Add this book to your favorite list »

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 3,000)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Will Byrnes
Updated 8/5/13 - see link at bottom

Paris had become a city of collaborators, both open and hidden, anti-Semites, anti-Freemasons, repentant communists and right-wing Catholics, who had hated Blum’s Front Populaire and felt more than a sneaking admiration for the German cult of youthful valour, orderliness and heroism.
Thankfully there were people who stood tall against the madness. A Train in Winter is a moving and devastating story of a group of two hundred thirty incredibly brave French wome
Melissa Prange
A Train in Winter tells the fascinating story of the French resistance during World War II. The author, Caroline Moorland, focuses her book on the women of the French resistance. These women might not wield guns or plant bombs, but they do house refugees in their hotels, print papers in their basements, and hand out flyers in the streets. These women chose to risk their lives rather than run to safety or simply endure. The women are grandmothers, mothers, daughters, and children, and all are dra ...more

In his Nobel Prize acceptance speech, the great Irish poet Seamus Heaney, whom we have lost this sad August morning, writes this:

"In one of the poems best known to students in my generation, a poem which could be said to have taken the nutrients of the symbolist movement and made them available in capsule form, the American poet Archibald MacLeish affirmed that “A poem should be equal to/not true.” As a defiant statement of poetry's gift for telling truth but telling it slant, this is both cogen
A very fascinating and well written account of 230 women from France that stood up and took part in the Resistance. The book follows them on the journey of German occupation of France to their fate up to and after the liberation of the concentration camps. The author did what great authors do and that is impose thought and reflection on what you've read. There were a lot of questions that were raised for me that will give cause to research and learn more about the many topics discussed. I think ...more
This is a powerful book and one that will stay with me for a very long time. A disturbing account of the atrocities that took place during WW2. A story about friendship, passion and survival. Women who were involved in the resistance movement of occupied France by the Germans; the steps they took to stand up and fight for their country and where it landed them: on a train bound for a concentration camp. All 230 of them. This is a story of the depth of love these women had for each other - how th ...more
Jeanette  "Astute Crabbist"
dry dry dry dry dry dry dry dry dry dry dry dry dry dry dry dry dry
A veritable Sahara of a book (minus the camels). The importance of memorializing these women is not in question, and I know many people will appreciate this book. I just couldn't take the writing.

One quibble I had with the portion I did read: She seems to be implying that all the people in the French Resistance were communists. I'm no history expert, but is that not incorrect?
In many ways, this book deserves a much higher rating. Moorehead reconstructs the lives (as best she can based on remaining historical evidence) of French women sent to Nazi concentration camps during World War II, specifically the women of Convoy 31000 (the number of the convoy that shuttled them from Paris to the camps and seared into their flesh forever as tattoos). Most of the women on the convoy were political prisoners: women who had been members of the Resistance or via other means, quest ...more
This book is true to its billing. Though I was born a couple of decades after the Second World War, the War itself for me is not an abstraction. My father and several relatives served in the military during the War, experienced the hazards of combat in Europe. Besides, my father also knew people who lived in France under the German occupation. Thus, reading this book was a reminder for me of how the Second World War impacted upon the heart and soul of a nation.

The focus of the book is on a group
Carl Brookins
This book falls under the heading of true crime. It deals with mass murder, attempted genocide and a side of France in the 1940’s that is generally not well-known. This is also one of the most difficult and amazing books I have ever had the privilege of reading. This is, as the cover states, “an extraordinary story of women, friendship and resistance in occupied France.”

In mid-June, 1940, the German army occupied Paris and France fell. There was, for a while, a partition, Vichy France under the
Whoa. It's been awhile since I've "missed" a book after I've finished it and sobbed while reading it. A meticulously researched work that was eye opening w/insights about occupied France and the role of the resistance. I was blown away by what the human spirit can endure. I think everyone wonders what they would do when put in extraordinary circumstances and this book served as a testament to spectrum of the nature of the human animal while capturing the bonds of friendships and the horrors of W ...more
Jan C
An excellent listen on a long distance ride. I really liked the reader, too. She was able to correctly pronounce French things. This is a real asset in a book about France. It doesn't always work out that way. There were certain stories in here that I'd read in When Paris Went Dark: The City of Light Under German Occupation, 1940-1944. But, here, the real focus is on what happened to this group of women. It turns out they are all Communists. Not quite sure why they all are but they are. Some, I ...more
I am not able to give this book a star rating, because it is both engrossing and poignant and awe-inspiring...while also being horrifying and heartbreaking. It is one I would recommend highly to everyone with the huge caveat that reading it might be awful. *The book* is not awful - what it details is, and the experience of reading it is a good-bad one. (See, I can't even review it coherently!) I knew a good deal about the Holocaust and the camps, but I learned more from this, frightening abhorre ...more
Elaine Burnes
I don’t think it’s possible to overstate the importance of this book. I’m not Jewish, I’m not French, but I am a lesbian and it is possible for me to imagine the evil that can be perpetrated against people simply for who they are. This was a story I’d never heard before. It is a must read for anyone who wants to call themselves human. It is both mind boggling and mind numbing. Inspiring but heartbreaking. It won’t answer the questions, why does evil exist or what makes people capable of inflicti ...more
Kristin Strong
A fascinating, heartbreaking, engrossing book about 230 courageous Frenchwomen, arrested and imprisoned for anti-Nazi activities, then transported to Auschwitz-Birkenau. The fates of many of the women come as no surprise; the miracle is that 49 of them survived horrible conditions, supported each other through the most unthinkable circumstances, avoided the gas chambers, and eventually returned to France. The author does a creditable job of rendering as many women as possible as developed charac ...more
ETA: please see message 27 below. This is a concise summary of my view:
I am glad I read it, but I do believe it has too many problems to give it more stars. I am glad I learned about this French group of women - particularly since I live and spend time in France! I also appreciated that the French behavior during the war is shown honestly. Many of them supported Pétain. This is not washed over. I also found the info about Mengele's experiments both riveting and horrible. I just wish I had come t
How do you write a review on a book that contrasts the absolute cruelty and sadistic imaginations with friendship and altruism? It is very difficult, indeed.

I've read many books on WWII that describe the Jewish POV and soldier POV. This time the POV is that of female political prisoners of war. This point of view hit closer to home as I am neither Jewish nor a soldier. It begs the question, if placed in a situation where not in immediate danger, what side of the line would I stand?

The first part
The Book Maven
This nonfiction piece lacked the same easy readability that other nonfiction authors (i.e., Laura Hillenbrand and Erik Larson) have achieved, so that's why I deducted a star. Other than a few tedious moments, however, this was a really rather pleasurable nonfiction read.

Excuse me--I should qualify that with the follow-up statement of, as pleasurable a read as the subject matter allows.

A Train in Winter follows the fates of over three hundred females who were arrested and punished for their activ
If a book is to be judged on how fiercely it pierces the consciousness of its reader, this book deserves multiple stars. Like others, I have seen the horrific photographs of the prisoners released from labor and concentration camps as the Allied forces swept through Europe. I am always stunned and appalled to see in those photos what human beings can do to other human beings. I'm also quick to look away, because the prisoners, emaciated, filthy,and shorn of hair, seem almost not real, not human ...more
This book recounts the journey of 230 French women who were arrested and imprisoned for participating in the French Resistance during the German occupation of France in WWII. Many of these women did not know each other before they ended up in prison together, and as they were grouped together by their captors quickly formed a bond and found ways to look out after each other as a way to get through their dire circumstances. Ranging in ages from 15 to mid-60s at the time of their capture, they wer ...more
David Williams
Having just put down this book it's difficult for me to marshal my thoughts for a considered review simply because of the impact this harrowing account has had on me emotionally and psychologically. It has left me weeping for the unimaginable cruelty humans are capable of wreaking on their fellows, and my heart full for the extraordinary sacrifices and selfless kind acts that others have been prepared to make in the face of such barbarity even while victims themselves, imprisoned in a man-made h ...more
Guyon Turner
A compelling book with certain ironies, compared with others of its genre:

1. The bulk of the women portrayed (all were women) were educated French resisters with an Aryan background;

2. Many were Parisian Communists who had worked together as part of the Resistance movement; therefore many knew and supported each other through their ordeals, likely saving many of their lives;

3. Few were Jewish. Therefore, they were sent early on to "prison/labor" camps rather than directly to extermination camps.
Haunted Greene
I found this book very interesting. However, it was difficult to follow as the author attempted to share as much as possible about the 230 French, female resistance fighters that were shipped to the concentration camps during WWII. It is an important book as it shares the history of these women and Vichy France. This was not something taught in your average history class or even in any of my college-level history classes. The author's zeal to name each of these women and share as much of their s ...more
Roger Gordon
Brilliant book. Well researched, well written, it highlights the bravery and suffering during the Vichy regime of WW2 of women resistance workers and others whom the Nazi occupiers simply did not like. It brings out the complicity of many French citizens in reporting these women for their brave actions, misdemeanors and opposition to the fascists. It also highlights the brutality that human beings are capable of as the concentration camps became the embodiment of evil. No crime was beyond the "g ...more
I am something of a connoisseur of survivor tales, avidly reading of survivors of shipwrecks, doomed polar expeditions, harrowing wilderness treks, calamitous military missions, devastating illnesses, and all-encompassing wars. A well-written tale of survival successfully steers away from being overly sensational, melodramatic, or sentimental but also offers something beyond the mere fact of survival. It's a tightrope walk between lapsing into "moral-of-the-story" tropes and succumbing to a blea ...more
I've always been a person who believes in "playing by the rules", who believes that laws are there for a good reason, who often resists change. This horrifying book put me in the very uncomfortable position of wondering if I would have had the courage and fortitude to do what these women did for something I believed in. They defied the Nazis, mostly in small but vital ways, and they paid dearly. Those not killed outright were taken away to prison camps, where they underwent such brutal mistreatm ...more
Mary Gail O'Dea
This was a bone rattling account of women of the French Resistance who ended up in Birkenau. Of 260 women in their transport, 49 survived. Each was certain that their friendship and resolute mutual support are what got them through. In addition, a few were determined to live to bear witness and two testified at the Nuremberg Trials. The horrible environmental conditions; the fleas, lice and rats; the unbearable cold; the beatings; the endless roll calls; the smell of burning bodies; the wretched ...more
Terri Lynn
Powerful. Astounding. Heartbreaking. When you read most books about the resistance movement in France or elsewhere in Europe during World War 2,it is almost always about the men. You would think that all the women did was sit home knitting socks and stirring soup, keeping the home fires burning.

This book will blow away those notions. When the Nazis routed the French military and occupied France, it was hundreds of French women ranging from young teens to upper 60's who worked diligently to tr
This is a hard book to read.

Hard because of the brutal conditions described but worthy of being read, nonetheless.

I do feel the subtitle: An Extraordinary Story of Women, Friendship, and Resistance in Occupied France is a little misleading. It gives the impression that the story takes place entirely in France. Much, however, deals with conditions in several concentration camps.

That aside, it is difficult not to get caught up in the harsh reality of what these women experienced.

Though it is chall
During the WWII occupation of France, the Gestapo imprisoned 230 women who were active in the French resistance. In 1943 they were moved to Birkenau, the women’s prison at Auschwitz.

The first part of the book covered the women’s personal lives, involvement in the resistance, and arrest. Later, describing their time at Auschwitz, there were lengthy passages that seemed almost like a book of obituaries, with a paragraph or two devoted to each death. I don’t think the author wrote about all 230 wo
This is such a record of pure bravery and endurance that I find it difficult to express the depth and meaning in this book in concise words.

The work in research, documentation or recording of witnesses, and the 1000's of interviews and follow-ups to put this all together for posterity, proof, history! Awesome accomplishment.

I hear them singing. The spirit of survival and hope too, against the impossible. And all the lost never out of mind.

This level of suffering and detail of suffering is not
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 99 100 next »
  • Americans in Paris: Life and Death under Nazi Occupation 1940-1944
  • The Envoy: The Epic Rescue of the Last Jews of Europe in the Desperate Closing Months of World War II
  • Behind Enemy Lines: The True Story of a French Jewish Spy in Nazi Germany
  • The Wolves at the Door: The True Story of America's Greatest Female Spy
  • Resistance: A French Woman's Journal of the War
  • Haven: The Dramatic Story of 1,000 World War II Refugees and How They Came to America
  • The Journal of Hélène Berr
  • Isaac's Army: A Story of Courage and Survival in Nazi-Occupied Poland
  • 50 Children: One Ordinary American Couple's Extraordinary Rescue Mission into the Heart of Nazi Germany
  • The Righteous: The Unsung Heroes of the Holocaust
  • Prague Winter
  • The Girls of Room 28: Friendship, Hope, and Survival in Theresienstadt
  • France the Dark Years 1940-1944
  • With Wings Like Eagles
  • Leap into Darkness: Seven Years on the Run in Wartime Europe
  • Nazi Germany and the Jews: The Years of Extermination, 1939-1945
  • Lest Innocent Blood Be Shed
  • Berlin Diaries, 1940-1945
Caroline Moorehead has written columns on human rights first for The Times and then for the Independent (1980-91) and has made a series of TV programmes on human rights for the BBC (1990-2000). She has also written the history of the International Committee of the Red Cross (1998) and has helped to set up a Legal Advice Centre for refugees in Cairo, where she has started schools and a nursery.
More about Caroline Moorehead...
Dancing to the Precipice: Lucie Dillon, Marquise de la Tour du Pin and the French Revolution Gellhorn: A Twentieth-Century Life Human Cargo: A Journey Among Refugees Village of Secrets: Defying the Nazis in Vichy France Iris Origo: Marchesa of Val D'orcia

Share This Book

“I had to hold fast to the end, and die of living.” 0 likes
More quotes…