Gil Marsh
by
A.C.E. Bauer (Goodreads Author)
Good looking, athletic, and smart, Gill Marsh is the most popular kid at Uruk High School, even though he is only a junior. When Enko, a new kid from Montreal, shows up, Gil is wary. Yet Enko is easy going and matches Gil's athletic prowess without being a threat. Soon, the two become inseparable friends, practicing, studying, and double-dating.
Then suddenly, to everyone's...more
Then suddenly, to everyone's...more
ebook
Published
(first published February 28th 2012)
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
This book is not yet featured on Listopia.
Add this book to your favorite list »
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
328)
Gil Marsh has an interesting story. The premise dragged me in, caught my interest. The writing, however, fell flat. The emotions Gil says he feels seem fake. He goes on a quest out of love for his best friend, but you never really feel that love. Gil and Enko's relationship spans about two chapters, and it's not very detailed. We're supposed to take it on faith that they had this great love, but I never really felt it.
Gil's quest itself was also not very deep. It gives us a nice look at Canada,...more
Gil's quest itself was also not very deep. It gives us a nice look at Canada,...more
Very rarely does a book come along that turns out to be nothing like what you thought you were about to read. This is that book. Although the very beginning looks just like another ‘high school trauma,’ with Gil Marsh being the perfect specimen of ‘man’ walking the corridors, the very deep meaning and beauty of this book arrives a short time later.
Gil is what you would call ‘that guy.’ People love him, he is uber-popular, he is the cross-country runner who can outrace everyone who steps beside h...more
Gil is what you would call ‘that guy.’ People love him, he is uber-popular, he is the cross-country runner who can outrace everyone who steps beside h...more
I feel horrible about writing a review on a book I couldn't read all the way through (although I did get halfway and then skimmed the rest in hopes that it would get better). Gil Marsh sounds interesting. The cover looks interesting. The concept of basing it on the story of Gilgamesh is interesting. Gil Marsh is anything but. From page one I was bored. The writing was dry, events told to us as opposed to shown, and I felt like the author was striving for a high literary style and fell far short....more
*It's always a struggle for me whenever I have to write a less than favorable review because I know the author has poured their heart into their work and I don't like to be the one to say I didn't like it. However, I do believe in giving my honest opinion and I will do my best to share it while being respectful of both the author and their work.
Thank you to Netgalley and Random House for the chance to read this book.
The cover is what originally caught my attention and made me want to read this s...more
Thank you to Netgalley and Random House for the chance to read this book.
The cover is what originally caught my attention and made me want to read this s...more
Going into this story I didn't have any expectations of what I thought this story would be like as a retelling because I wasn't familiar with the ancient story of Gilgamesh. I must have skipped over that one. But from reading the book summary, I did have an expectation that this was going to be a story about friendship, loss, self-discovery and growth. Unfortunately it didn't measure up to the standard I had set for it. That may be a bit unfair to the story, but I had very high hopes. I just thi...more
Ok...this is my fourth attempt to write this review. I don't know why this book bugged me so much, but it did. Plus, I hate criticizing writers work harshly and I don't know how to write this review constructively.
On page 41 when Enko dies I had had it with this book and could not read another page.
There was so much wrong with this book...I don't even know where to begin. I felt like I was reading a book about two boys who were lovers not friends (which would be fine if that is how the book was...more
On page 41 when Enko dies I had had it with this book and could not read another page.
There was so much wrong with this book...I don't even know where to begin. I felt like I was reading a book about two boys who were lovers not friends (which would be fine if that is how the book was...more
I am currently kind of obsessed with retellings of mythological and/or historical works (it’s my New Thing) and when I heard about Gil Marsh, a Contemporary YA retelling of the Epic of Gilgamesh, I immediately placed it at the top of my Most Highly Coveted Books of 2012. The Epic of Gilgamesh is one of the earliest known works of literature and it follows Gilgamesh, the oppressive king of Uruk in ancient Mesopotamia on an epic journey to become a better king and to understand the nature of death...more
The premise of Gil Marsh is that it is a contemporary telling of a 5,000 year old story, the Tale of Gilgamesh, where the Sumerian king loses his best friend and goes on a quest to bring him back from the dead.
Gil Marsh is the king in this story because he reigns over his high school with his blonde good looks, atheticism as a runner, and his smarts. When Enko comes to town from Montreal as the new guy, there is some apprehension on Gil's part because Enko is a fast runner and becomes well lik...more
Gil Marsh is the king in this story because he reigns over his high school with his blonde good looks, atheticism as a runner, and his smarts. When Enko comes to town from Montreal as the new guy, there is some apprehension on Gil's part because Enko is a fast runner and becomes well lik...more
I am sorry to say that, while I had high hopes for this novel, I actually struggled with it for a few different reasons. First, I found it to have a somewhat forced pacing and it just didn’t grab me. Events seemed to happen in a very quick succession without giving the reader much time to digest the information. For instance, one moment Gil and Enko hate each other, and the next moment they’re best friends, but I personally never felt like the story gave rise to these events. They just seemed to...more
I really, really wanted to like this book. A modern retelling of the epic of Gigamesh? What a neat idea! I teach sixth grade social studies (ancient history to the Renaissance) and am always looking for ways to bring the older stories to life for my students. I hadn't run into any modern versions of this story yet, and was pretty excited. Initially the novel did have promise, but it never truly delivered on it.
For one thing, I never felt as if I really connected to the characters. I didn't find...more
For one thing, I never felt as if I really connected to the characters. I didn't find...more
Bold.
In A.C.E. Bauer's stunning retelling of The Epic of Gilgamesh, you are thrown into a modernized version of the continual search for the answers of life. Reanimating the oldest recorded story seems to be a very daunting task, but Bauer does it with ease.
We follow Gil Marsh through his reign over Uruk High school (nice play on name of Gilgamesh's kingdom) and his meeting of Enko at the beginning of this book. The two boys seem to butt heads at first because they rival each other so closely....more
In A.C.E. Bauer's stunning retelling of The Epic of Gilgamesh, you are thrown into a modernized version of the continual search for the answers of life. Reanimating the oldest recorded story seems to be a very daunting task, but Bauer does it with ease.
We follow Gil Marsh through his reign over Uruk High school (nice play on name of Gilgamesh's kingdom) and his meeting of Enko at the beginning of this book. The two boys seem to butt heads at first because they rival each other so closely....more
I admit that it has been a long while since I read Gilgamesh, and so I may not be the best expert on the matter. Yet I have to say that GIL MARSH more confused than enlightened. The author followed the original story in its sparity of details, and I think that is where this modern-day story lost me. Gil and Enko’s friendship seemed underdeveloped to warrant Gil’s impromptu Canadian trip, and then his trip – inevitably doomed from the start – did not make much sense to me. I did not believe that...more
I wish authors - especially new ones - got do-overs. That's what editors are for, but with an increase in self-publishing, I'm seeing more and more drek that actually could be redeemed. This is one of those.
This book is based on the story of Gilgamesh ( get it? Gil(ga) Marsh?) and that's what it felt like - an outline of the myth that the author used to superimpose modern day details for a young audience. I know the point is the journey, but in order to care about what happens, you have to get...more
This book is based on the story of Gilgamesh ( get it? Gil(ga) Marsh?) and that's what it felt like - an outline of the myth that the author used to superimpose modern day details for a young audience. I know the point is the journey, but in order to care about what happens, you have to get...more
I had no clue that this was a play on The Epic of Gilgamesh. There is clever use of elements from the original, but this modern version is one that paints a story of friendship, grief and coming of age, with the teensy magical thrown in.
I didn't feel a connection to Gil at first. When he is introduced, he is blessed but when he reacted the way he did... well, it read to standard. With a new guy showing up how should the 'king' react? Magnonimity masking insecurity some jealousy leading to territ...more
I didn't feel a connection to Gil at first. When he is introduced, he is blessed but when he reacted the way he did... well, it read to standard. With a new guy showing up how should the 'king' react? Magnonimity masking insecurity some jealousy leading to territ...more
GoodReads Synopsis: Good looking, athletic, and smart, Gill Marsh is the most popular kid at Uruk High School, even though he is only a junior. When Enko, a new kid from Montreal, shows up, Gil is wary. Yet Enko is easy going and matches Gil's athletic prowess without being a threat. Soon, the two become inseparable friends, practicing, studying, and double-dating.
Then suddenly, to everyone's shock, Enko succombs to an aggressive cancer.
When Enko's parents take his body and return to Canada, G...more
Then suddenly, to everyone's shock, Enko succombs to an aggressive cancer.
When Enko's parents take his body and return to Canada, G...more
Based loosely on an ancient tale of Gilgamesh and his friend Enkidu, this is a story of two high school friends and the loss one suffers, leading him to a quest that takes him through parts of Canada. Get ready for a little French, readers.
This story is pretty good, although I think exclamation points should probably only be used in dialogue. Something gets lost in using them for narrating the story; perhaps what's lost is the author's assumption that the reader is well-read enough to know when...more
This story is pretty good, although I think exclamation points should probably only be used in dialogue. Something gets lost in using them for narrating the story; perhaps what's lost is the author's assumption that the reader is well-read enough to know when...more
Gil Marsh, by A.C.E. Bauer, is a retelling of the tale of Gilgamesh. It is set in a high school. Gil and Enko are thrown together and at first Gil does not like Enko but they grow to be the best of friends. When Enko gets sick and dies, Gil goes on a personal quest that takes him to Quebec to make peace with the death and to find himself. The struggle to do good and understand bad is central and watching the struggle is fascinating.
This book did start a little slow but built up to a entrancing...more
This book did start a little slow but built up to a entrancing...more
Originally posted here.
It is hard to write a review for a book when I have the sort of reaction to it that I had for Gil Marsh by A.C.E. Bauer. I was disappointed in it, but not through any fault with the actual writing. This is one of those cases where the author's vision for her story did not match my expectations as a reader. Keeping this in mind I'm going to try and split this into two parts.
For Readers Unfamiliar With The Epic of Gilgamesh
This is a story about a boy who is grieving for his...more
It is hard to write a review for a book when I have the sort of reaction to it that I had for Gil Marsh by A.C.E. Bauer. I was disappointed in it, but not through any fault with the actual writing. This is one of those cases where the author's vision for her story did not match my expectations as a reader. Keeping this in mind I'm going to try and split this into two parts.
For Readers Unfamiliar With The Epic of Gilgamesh
This is a story about a boy who is grieving for his...more
Originally reviewed here.
As evidenced by the reality that the two 2012 titles to get top ratings from me have been Cinder and The Humming Room, I am clearly a fan of retellings. There’s something so wonderful about seeing a new take on an old story, I love the newness and the familiarity wrapped up in one neat little package for me to enjoy. Sadly, Gil Marsh did not fit the bill.
Gil Marsh was pitched as a contemporary retelling of the Epic of Gilgamesh, possibly the oldest epic recorded tale in...more
As evidenced by the reality that the two 2012 titles to get top ratings from me have been Cinder and The Humming Room, I am clearly a fan of retellings. There’s something so wonderful about seeing a new take on an old story, I love the newness and the familiarity wrapped up in one neat little package for me to enjoy. Sadly, Gil Marsh did not fit the bill.
Gil Marsh was pitched as a contemporary retelling of the Epic of Gilgamesh, possibly the oldest epic recorded tale in...more
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
When I first heard about Gil Marsh by A.C.E. Bauer I was instantly intrigued. It sounded really interesting- an emotional and bittersweet contemporary read that I would just adore. However, as it turns out, Gil Marsh was just not for me, sadly enough. Gil Marsh tells the story of Gil Marsh and Enko, two best friends at Uruk High School. However, everything changes when Enko suddenly dies and Gil falls apart following this death. First, let me talk about the things I did enjoy about this book. On...more
Gil is fast, smart, popular. Then Enko moves to town from Montreal and he is even faster than Gil, as well as charming, and funny. Gil feels threatened by Enko; they get in a big fight but then become the very best of friends. When Enko becomes sick and dies, Gil sets off on a quest to visit Enko's grave in Montreal but he does it without his parents knowledge or permission.
A current day rendering of the Gilgamesh epic saga.
A current day rendering of the Gilgamesh epic saga.
This is a modern take on Gilgamesh. The character Enko in this story represents,Enkidu, the beast and Gil represents Gilgamesh.
It's a story of a two boys who had a connection through their love of running. Tragically one boy dies and the other is left to deal with the loss and finally picking up the pieces and moving on.
It's a quick read and any student who has studied legend of Gilgamesh will enjoy the comparison.
It's a story of a two boys who had a connection through their love of running. Tragically one boy dies and the other is left to deal with the loss and finally picking up the pieces and moving on.
It's a quick read and any student who has studied legend of Gilgamesh will enjoy the comparison.
I couldn't finish the book. I didn't connect to the voice, nor to the writing. I struggled with the storyline of this retelling of Gilgamesh. To be fair, I didn't particularly favor the original. I felt that this retelling had promise, based on the synopsis. A few scenes made me uncomfortable, and I would end up skimming through the story.
I'm sorry, but I just couldn't connect to Gil Marsh.
I'm sorry, but I just couldn't connect to Gil Marsh.
Thoroughly enjoyed this, not something I would have picked up normally, except that it is a retelling of the Gilgamesh story. Two boys become great friends, one dies, the other goes on a quest to ease his heart and maybe bring him back from the dead.
Very good story, I am a sucker for friendship stories between boys that are sensitive and more than potty jokes and punching. This is one.
Very good story, I am a sucker for friendship stories between boys that are sensitive and more than potty jokes and punching. This is one.
There are no discussion topics on this book yet.
Be the first to start one »
I have telling and writing stories since childhood. I took a short break to write dreadful poetry, and then a longer one while I worked as an attorney, writing legal briefs and telling stories about my clients. I have returned to fiction, and published two middle grade novels, No Castles Here (ALA Rainbow Book; Kirkus Review starred review) and Come Fall (CCBC Choices Book; Publishers' Weekly star...more
More about A.C.E. Bauer...
Share This Book
No trivia or quizzes yet. Add some now »






















Feb 21, 2012 07:40am