The Fifth Sacred Thing (Maya Greenwood #1)
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating

The Fifth Sacred Thing (Maya Greenwood #1)

4.24 of 5 stars 4.24  ·  rating details  ·  3,039 ratings  ·  336 reviews
An epic tale of freedom and slavery, love and war, and the potential futures of humankind tells of a twenty-first century California clan caught between two clashing worlds, one based on tolerance, the other on repression.


From the Trade Paperback edition.
Kindle Edition, 496 pages
Published August 10th 2011 by Bantam (first published 1993)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.
This book is not yet featured on Listopia. Add this book to your favorite list »

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 3,000)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Melody
11/2012 I find more to love each time I come back to this book, this time being no exception. I come to this book like water in the desert and it purifies and magnifies me.

2/2011 Unequivocally, I love this book. I live inside it and believe in it with all my heart. It feels like home, the society depicted herein, with its collective collaborative hippie soul. Sure, it's preachy and even didactic in parts. I find I don't mind preachy, so long as I'm sitting in the choir.

After reading the stark an...more
Eli
Good Reclaiming Witch that I am, I wanted to l-o-v-e this book. But it has issues.
*It honors and accepts every credal system except atheism, which is portrayed as antiquated and unenlightened.
*It denigrates monofidelity and single-sex orientation (homo as well as hetero).
*Secondary and tertiary characters often seem less people than tickmarks on Starhawk's gender/class/ethnicity/sexuality matrix.
*Ultimately, it embraces the either/or, us/them duality it claims to reject.
*Though the main characte...more
Tanuja
This book inspired a major paradigm shift for me. Shortly after reading it, I enrolled in acupuncture school, and life has not been the same, will never be the same. I have to reread this book every so often for its crucial reminder: that nonviolence can work and must work and will work to change the world...but we also have to work...we need to heal ourselves and others. I highly recommend this book.
Sapote3
Aug 03, 2007 Sapote3 rated it 4 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommends it for: crazed idealists
So I had a lot of politics in high school, and I also lived in Wiccantown, The Bible Belt, U.S.A. Therefore, this book resonated rather a lot with me. I still love utopias, and this book is very much a utopia: an idealistic nowhere, but a nowhere that's worth talking about.

Still, I haven't been able to make myself reread this, now that I'm no longer fifteen and no longer believe that 1) magic is an appropriately thorough way to deal with biological warfare 2) polyamorous pansexuality always wor...more
Caty
Couldn't stand it, couldn't finish it. And I usually love radical utopias+ conservative dystopias--the 2 paired together? Whhooooo! But the style was turgid and thick and the sentimentality oozed off the page. Maybe my aesthetic problems with paganism helped, too. The description of the prison and their escape from it was compelling, but that's about it.
Christy
This book has some good passages about nonviolent resistance and about building a community. If it could have set up those issues without depending on New Age-y "science" (e.g., manipulating ch'i, using intelligent crystals for computers that are programmed through advanced visualization techniques, acupuncture, using the brain's natural electronic field to manipulate electronic devices) and magic (e.g., communicating with the dead, communicating with bees, vision quests), it might have been goo...more
Nomy
this book kind of blew me away. i finished it a couple months ago and i keep meaning to write my review of it. what i really loved about this book was the way she describes the characters' internal processes, i felt like i really knew what they were feeling, i could feel it too and travel with them in their minds. there were parts of the book that were kind of too scary for me, i felt it too much, took it on in my body, which is not good for me. i had so many things to say about it when i read i...more
Jen
Aug 14, 2007 Jen rated it 5 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommends it for: everyone!
I am reading this book for the third time. I identify with the main character, even though I thought she was a brat the first time through....; )

Look--if you care about the Earth or your freedoms when it comes to clean water and pure food, then read this book. It's a quick read because you won't be able to put it down. The characters are likable, their relationships refreshing.

It's the only fiction piece (as far as I know) by Starhawk. Research her work.
Tammy Eaton
My first introduction to "ecofeminism." Extremely close to the end of the book so I will reserve judgement on the ending, but I am extremely impressed with Starhawk's ability to draw me into her world and keep me there. I felt attached to the characters and experienced so many emotions along with them. The description of the grandmother ripping the safety latches off her kitchen cabinets had me crying... it is so true that no matter what we do to protect them, they grow up and insist on doing da...more
*rob*
this is a favorite book of a lot of friends and acquaintances, so i think my expectations were high. the writing is pretty flat, which i was actually relieved to discover because it's a big book and so i gave myself permission to read quicker than i normally like to. also, it reeks of liberal white racism with the way starhawk idealizes inclusiveness, melting-pots, and tokenization in this multi-cultural post-apocalyptic utopia. as i've mentioned this to people, someone said that since writing i...more
Jeremy
This utopian "new age" vision of San Francisco in the not-so-distant future, written in the early mid 90's by STARHAWK, could have been a series of deep eye-rolls that permanently damaged my vision; But the novel was well written and the narrative enticing enough to keep me invested.
I actually found myself ready to read this type of idealistic "social-science' fiction if you will...
Walking around the city now, I can actually see the San francisco described in these pages in my minds eye and thin...more
Jackson
For me, this book wasnt a 'page-turner' but I read it avidly none-the-less. What brought me back to the bookmarked page day after day was the profound ideas inter weaved throughout the book. This book heralds not only spirituality, environmentalism and mythological symbolism but also social change, civil disobedience and revolution. For this reason, this book was inherently different, and exactly my cuppa-tea. It was my scholarly and spiritual minds transformed into fiction.
The characterisation...more
Briana Nervig
Feb 17, 2008 Briana Nervig rated it 4 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommends it for: Dystopia lovers, people who love to frequently read about group sex
So far quite interesting. Written by an eco-feminist, wiccan/pagan activist so, of course, there are alot of politics involved. This is her first fictional novel. (Sounds like your type of book, doesn't it, Aaron? hahaha)

Centered in California, mid-21st century. Regarding society's lack of consciousness and appreciation of the "Mother Earth's" resources, and the "Four Sacred Things": Water, Fire, Earth, Air. The once lush California landscape has been reduced to hard, unfruitful land from fires...more
Colin
Another one of my top five favorite books...The Fifth Sacred Thing skillfully addresses issues of oppression and social justice in a rich, complex narrative that never fails to leave me hopeful and invigorated by the end. One of this book's main triumphs is that Starhawk is able to present characters' differences--in race, class, gender, sexuality, ability--without seeming disingenuous. The characters and conflicts are engaging and utterly believable--this book never slips too far into fantastic...more
Rico
Where to start? This book is deeply affecting and touched on so many of my passions, it is difficult to know where to start.

First, it is another entry in the large (and still growing) list of what my friend Hobo Lee used to call Northern California Post-Apocalyptic fiction. Do we in Northern California have a cataclysm fetish? Or do we here in this beautiful and fragile place just wisely wish for an end to this society as we know it before it kills us all?

In any case, Starhawk has taken all th...more
Lori
Apr 17, 2008 Lori rated it 5 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommends it for: lovers of peace and goodness
Ever thought about tearing up the concrete and turning our streets into living gardens?
How about having seven old women running things by dreaming answers from a retreat up on the hill by Stow Lake (at 8th ave in GG Park)?
How about the prospect of running out of a little thing called water? Or having to blow up the bridges to stop the south from invading us for our water?
All these things happen and SO MUCH MORE in this thrilling tale of the rebirth of San Francisco, in an apocalyptic world of...more
Beth
Not for the faint of heart - this is a beautiful, haunting, challenging novel about a utopia surrounded and threatened by authoritarian regimes. Written 20 years ago, some of it seems eerily prophetic - water shortages, soil depletion, global warming, monopoly/power of drug companies, government run by hypocritical "purists," assaults on women's rights. However, many of the descriptions of the utopian enclave are something to strive for - where all people are honored along with the elements whic...more
Lindsay
I have been meaning to read this book for years. In September of 2009 I went on a personal sabbatical to Big Sur, California. I only brought a select number of books with me -- three actually. The first one on my list was this book by Starhawk. I had read the preface a month or two before I left on my sabbatical and quickly put it down. The preface to this book stunned me with its clarity, power, and heart. So, while at Tassajara Zen Center, I poured through this book whenever I got a chance. It...more
Nitya
Maybe not the best writing, but this book made me think long and hard about planetary resources, our current squandering of them, and how things might be if we continue on. it takes place in 2050, and resources are few. Water is scarce and precious, oil even scarcer. In San Francisco, the people have learned how to survive, thrive, even, by cooperative community.But of course, there are greedy bastards trying to control and hoard the resources at the deprivation of everyone else. That we, the pe...more
Abilouise
I seriously loved this book, it's one of the books that I've submerged in the whole time I was reading it, and I was sad when it was over. I enjoyed this in a similar way to the way that I enjoyed Marge Piercy's Woman on the Edge of Time and He, She, It. These books gives me clues and fantasies about the world I'd like to live in, how people could treat each other and the world, what peace might be like. I loved the scope of this, and I enjoyed the plot. I wish that I could find more things that...more
Natalie Dybens
This book is an awesome fantasy that ties in things I used to be interested in that i forgot.. like magic and astral planes. Combines magic, and the spiritual, including down to earth things and ways of life such as agriculture and the four sacred things [fire, earth, air, and water] and i don't think im giving anything away by saying that the fifth sacred thing is spirit. This book is about a peaceful accepting community trying to preserve their way of life from a very realistic and evil oppres...more
Ray Riddle
Starhawk has written a very impressive book with her first fiction novel. It's quite long and filled with many interesting characters. The city that is the main setting, or home to the main characters that are either imprisoned in the south or travel there to assist, is San Francisco in 2048. A revolution has taken place and the city has broken away from the rest of the world, creating what some call a utopia and others label it as a form of communism that works. Whichever it is, Starhawk has t...more
Ashley
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.
Veganeslesezeichen
Ich hatte das Buch schon lange auf meiner Wunschliste und bin nun dieses Jahr dazu gekommen es mir in der Bibliothek auszuleihen - zum Glück.
An sich klang der Inhalt vielversprechend, es geht um zwei verschiedene Welten. Die eine ist das Ideal, wo es keinen Hunger, Armut und Toleranz herrscht während in der Zweiten das totale Gegenteil vorzufinden ist. Und diese beiden Welten treffen in Kalifornien im 21. Jahrhundert zusammen, und der Ausgang dieses Konflikts hängt von einer kleinen Gruppe von M...more
Cathy
I enjoyed this book (but not the sleep it cost me when I stayed up too-late reading it) -- I've heard of Starhawk, and this makes me curious to read more of her stuff. It's good to get a dose of utopia set in SF, and the writing is compelling. Her characters are complex as are the ways she's envisioned society (and threats to it), and I appreciate the way she wrestles with questions of non-violence vs armed rebellion, though at times the plot asked me to make jumps that didn't actually flow.
Hanna
I'd give this book 2.5 stars. I was really uncomfortable with the author's special focus on penetrative sex (she really seemed to like having long discriptions of it) even to the extent that she felt like she needed to describe penetrative intercourse of bees (blagh!). I also didn't like the focus on 'group sex'. The book was interesting most of the time but wasn't compelling or very thought provoking.
Audra
I thought this book was AMAZING. The contrasts between the truly open-minded and forward thinking society against the tyrannical and structural government and religious fact is eye-opening. This book made me question my own abilities of acceptance and love, and it is beautiful how Starhawk shows how fine the line is that we all walk when we make decisions for our own beliefs. Beautiful story!
Jenny Schmenny
Anyone who knows me knows that I really don't want to read or hear about spiritual stuff. But despite having spiritual content and being written by a prominent witch, this is a great dystopian/utopian novel, with compelling characters and plot. I love seeing my own San Francisco as the utopian cooperative star. I've actually read it several times.
Mel
I don't know why I decided to pick this up and re-read it, but I'm so glad I did. I've been reading way to many dystopian novels lately, and although they all have hope in them, none touch me the way this book does. This book shows a painful future that is not unlike how we are living now, but it also shows a beautiful possibility of how things could be.
Andrew
Could not finish this book. Poorly written and poorly paced I only got as far into as I did because it was all I brought with me to jury duty. Loved the idea of a hippie-utopia nestled amongst the ravaged, polluted future US, but the laborious prose and overt sentimentality were too much.
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 99 100 next »
  • The Great Cosmic Mother: Rediscovering the Religion of the Earth
  • The Holy Book of Women's Mysteries: Feminist Witchcraft, Goddess Rituals, Spellcasting and Other Womanly Arts
  • Wanderground: Stories of the Hill Women
  • The Kin of Ata Are Waiting for You
  • Evolutionary Witchcraft
  • Ecotopia Emerging
  • Book of Shadows
  • The Gilda Stories
  • Parable of the Talents (Earthseed, #2)
  • Woman on the Edge of Time
  • Ancient Mirrors of Womanhood: A Treasury of Goddess and Heroine Lore from Around the World
  • Native Tongue (Native Tongue, #1)
  • The Shore of Women
  • Sea Priestess
  • Power of the Witch
  • Drawing Down the Moon: Witches, Druids, Goddess-Worshippers, and Other Pagans in America
  • A Door Into Ocean
  • The Margarets
6376
Starhawk (born Miriam Simos) is an American writer, anarchist activist, and self-described witch. She is well known as a theorist of Paganism, and is one of the foremost popular voices of ecofeminism. She is a columnist for both Beliefnet.com and On Faith (the Newsweek online forum on religion).

Starhawk currently lives in San Francisco, where she works with Reclaiming, a tradition of Witchcraft th...more
More about Starhawk...
The Spiral Dance: A Rebirth of the Ancient Religion of the Goddess Dreaming the Dark: Magic, Sex, and Politics The Earth Path: Grounding Your Spirit in the Rhythms of Nature Circle Round: Raising Children in Goddess Traditions The Pagan Book of Living and Dying: Practical Rituals, Prayers, Blessings, and Meditations on Crossing Over

Share This Book