2nd out of 10 books
—
5 voters
Tell It to the Trees
One freezing winter morning a dead body is found in the backyard of the Dharma family’s house. It’s the body of Anu Krishnan.
For Anu, a writer seeking a secluded retreat from the city, the Dharmas’ “back-house” in the sleepy mountain town of Merrit’s Point was the ideal spot to take a year off and begin writing. She had found the Dharmas’ rental through a happy coincidenc...more
For Anu, a writer seeking a secluded retreat from the city, the Dharmas’ “back-house” in the sleepy mountain town of Merrit’s Point was the ideal spot to take a year off and begin writing. She had found the Dharmas’ rental through a happy coincidenc...more
Hardcover, 272 pages
Published
September 20th 2011
by Knopf Canada
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
858)
This book will grab your attention from page one and will linger in your mind long after completion. It is a thought provoking book concerning family secrets, an unexplainable death of a tenant and an isolated family invested in maintaining a good family name. The cold harsh setting of a small Canadian town springs to life in Anita Rau Badami beautiful lyrical writing. The Dharma family- consisting of autocratic Vikram; his aged mother Akka, who has chilling secrets of her own; sweet gentle Suma...more
Tell it to the trees by Anita Rau Badami is more than just an immigrant story. It is a story of a close knit family where the family name is paramount. "The Dharmas are spotless and ab-SO-olutely perfect" so the belt connects with hidden places (back or legs) where nobody can see. This is a dark novel which centres on secrets and abuse.
Vikram is the autocratic, manipulative, controlling figure in this dysfunctional family. Suman is his second wife brought over to Canada from India because he jud...more
Vikram is the autocratic, manipulative, controlling figure in this dysfunctional family. Suman is his second wife brought over to Canada from India because he jud...more
Anita Rau Badami is an excellent writer. Her previous novels bear this out. Her writing is fluid and graceful, she gives us characters we care about and creates complete worlds in which her readers cannot help but immerse themselves. Her depictions of Indian family life, in stories set both here and in India, are morally complex, rich in detail, and find their crux in the cultural tensions that exist between east and west. It is disappointing then to report that her latest novel, Tell it to the...more
The book tells the story of the Dharma family living outside an isolated small town in northern British Columbia. Its members include Vikram, who went to India to arrange his second marriage to Suman, a quiet, gentle woman. The couple has a son, Hemant, but Suman is also stepmother to Varsha, a teenager who, because of the loss of her mother, fears losing Suman and becomes very possessive of her half-brother as well. Akka, Vikram's elderly and sickly mother, is the fifth member of the household....more
A dark novel about a dysfunctional family of E.Indian extraction living in a small N.BC town.
The father Vikram is a cyclothymic manipulative abusive man whose 1st wife Helen leaves him & their daughter Varsha. He remarries to a 2nd wife Suman, he finds in India & fathers a boy Hemant who is totally under the domination of his half-sister. Vikram abuses the submissive Suman & the 2 children physically & verbally. This is kept secret except that the children confess their secrets t...more
The father Vikram is a cyclothymic manipulative abusive man whose 1st wife Helen leaves him & their daughter Varsha. He remarries to a 2nd wife Suman, he finds in India & fathers a boy Hemant who is totally under the domination of his half-sister. Vikram abuses the submissive Suman & the 2 children physically & verbally. This is kept secret except that the children confess their secrets t...more
I won this book on a Goodreads giveaway, and did not know what to expect. It turned out to be one of the most gripping reads I have had in a long time. I couldn't put it down.
The story begins with the discovery of the frozen body of their tenant in the backyard of the Dharma family's isolated Northern B.C. home. What follows is the gradual unfolding of the events leading up to the death, told from the perspectives of the two children of the family, the mother, and the tenant herself through her...more
The story begins with the discovery of the frozen body of their tenant in the backyard of the Dharma family's isolated Northern B.C. home. What follows is the gradual unfolding of the events leading up to the death, told from the perspectives of the two children of the family, the mother, and the tenant herself through her...more
Set in the outskirts of a small mountain town in British Columbia, this novel follows an Indo-Canadian family of a father Vikram, his second wife Suman, his teen daughter Varsha, his small son Hemant, and his aging mother Akka.Vikram is an authoritarian figure, demanding a level of control of his family beyond normal. Suman has come to Canada as part of an arranged marriage and is both eager to please and isolated. Varsha feels abandoned by her mother, who died in an accident. Akka is a woman wh...more
You have a secret? Then tell it to the trees.
This book is full of family secrets and everything needs to be kept quiet for the good of the family name. The Dharmas live in a small northern B.C. town and the Indian-Canadian family includes the father Vikram, his gentle wife Suman, his mother Akka and his two children, Varsha and Hemant.
One day, Vikram decides to welcome a tenant in the back house and Anu is thrilled by the silence of the land. Neighbours are far away so it's perfect for her goal...more
This book is full of family secrets and everything needs to be kept quiet for the good of the family name. The Dharmas live in a small northern B.C. town and the Indian-Canadian family includes the father Vikram, his gentle wife Suman, his mother Akka and his two children, Varsha and Hemant.
One day, Vikram decides to welcome a tenant in the back house and Anu is thrilled by the silence of the land. Neighbours are far away so it's perfect for her goal...more
The Dharma family live in an isolated house in Merrit’s Point, a small town in northern British Columbia. One February morning their tenant, Anu, is found dead in the snow from hypothermia. Tell it to the Trees tells the story of the Dharma family in the months leading up to Anu’s death. Vikram Dharma abuses his wife and children, and led his first wife to run away. His thirteen-year-old daughter, Varsha, is terrified that her stepmother will leave her like her mother did. Suman has been married...more
Anita Rau Badami has done a wonderful job of compiling several perspectives into one compelling story, in Tell It to the Trees. And the poetic language with which Suman, the protagonist, shares her perspective offers a foretaste of events that will have occurred. We learn about Lalli, Suman's childhood friend, whose father "descended to Madras from northern India." This interesting quote suggests coming south and moving from the mountains to the seaside; it also suggests a change in life, which...more
I was really looking forward to reading this book based on reviews and promotions by Goodreads. I began reading as soon as I downloaded it, despite being in the middle of another book.
Unfortunately I was very disappointed. I felt that the characters were largely undeveloped and rather unlikable. While I wanted to sympathize with Suman and Hemi I found it difficult as I felt as if I did not know them. While I was easily able to dislike Vikram that was based on deeds rather than character develop...more
Unfortunately I was very disappointed. I felt that the characters were largely undeveloped and rather unlikable. While I wanted to sympathize with Suman and Hemi I found it difficult as I felt as if I did not know them. While I was easily able to dislike Vikram that was based on deeds rather than character develop...more
May 09, 2013
Brian
added it
Reading Tell It to the Trees by Anita Rau Badami was neither particularly enjoyable nor instructional. While family abuse is certainly a topical subject, readers looking for some insight into either its causes, dynamics or solutions will be disappointed. The abusers punch and kick and frighten while the victims cower and cover-up—over and over, from multiple points of view. Readers looking for a story will find it difficult to identify with, let alone fall in love with any of the characters. The...more
This was an interesting book with a good plot. I did not like the set up, one characters view per chapter, it became too repetitive. Each character told the events over, with a new event or two added in.
Akka made me very angry, I felt she should have done more, I'm not sure if that's cultural (older generation woman) or negligence.
The father of course ticked me off which I'm sure was intended by the author. However I am wondering about the reality of Varsha's character, wouldn't that kind of ev...more
Akka made me very angry, I felt she should have done more, I'm not sure if that's cultural (older generation woman) or negligence.
The father of course ticked me off which I'm sure was intended by the author. However I am wondering about the reality of Varsha's character, wouldn't that kind of ev...more
I think part of my problem was that I read this one fast in hopes of getting it done in time for book club. (No, I did not succeed. And yes, the ending was revealed to me ahead of time. But no, the ending wasn't a shocker. At least for me.)
Anita is a beautiful writer and describes things well and in an unique and interesting way.
Something that was mentioned in book club was that the story felt simple. A lot of people were hoping the storylines could be deepened. I get that, but at the same time,...more
Anita is a beautiful writer and describes things well and in an unique and interesting way.
Something that was mentioned in book club was that the story felt simple. A lot of people were hoping the storylines could be deepened. I get that, but at the same time,...more
I won this book from the Goodreads giveaway, and was very excited about it as I quite enjoyed Badami's other book, "Can you hear the nightbird call?". This is a very "gripping" book and somehow a bit spine-chilling for me. It was quite different from what I expected though - I was expecting to read another "immigrant-family-in-Canada" type of story. I mean, the family in the story is an immigrant family indeed, but their "problem" is definitely not exclusive to immigrants.
Dharmas' tenant, Anu,...more
Dharmas' tenant, Anu,...more
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
I LOVED LOVED LOVED The Hero's Walk - so I was a bit disappointed with Tell it to the Trees. There is still the same level of attention paid to the characters, and the same sense of slow, impending doom as you read into the book, but something about this book works less effectively. I think that ultimately it is the lack of connection I feel to Varsha, the 13 year old protagonist. I found that in the second half of the book I was flipping pages to get through the plot, without slowing down to en...more
I would rate this book a 3.5 if Goodreads would get their shit together and develop a better rating system! Badami is a great writer and I found myself fully immersed in her story. I particularly liked the depiction of the cultural tensions that arise when one moves from the East to the West, and as always I loved the cold Canadian landscape that I know and love so well. But, that being said, I felt as if the story was a little rushed and not as fully fleshed out as her other novels. The mystery...more
A good read, good story, moves quickly, wonderful description of an isolated location in British Columbia, one can feel the cold. This story is a real contrast to other books written by Badami, which was neat as it was so unexpected. The Dharma family has a lot of mysteries: from the grandfather who bought the remote piece of land to the anger of his son whose first wife left him and has never been heard from again. Varsha is his daughter from that first marriage and she is terrified that she wi...more
The four stars are for the writing, not because it was fun to read. The characters are all interesting, even the ones we only get to know tangentially, but most are not very likeable. I was chilled by the book's end. And yet, I keep thinking about it and that definitely marks it as a book of substance.
I was initially drawn to the book because of its unique setting -- an Indo-Canadian family living in the lumbering wilderness of Brtish Columbia, my home province -- but we learn almost nothing abo...more
I was initially drawn to the book because of its unique setting -- an Indo-Canadian family living in the lumbering wilderness of Brtish Columbia, my home province -- but we learn almost nothing abo...more
Anita Rao Badami is my favourite author and I was expecting so much from this book. But this book disappointed me. It looks like book is written in haste. Storyline is good but the author did not take time to develop the characters fully. All the characters seem kind of unreal. This is the first time that I did not like even a single character from a book. I wanted to like Suman, Akka and Anu's character but could not do it. There was so much scope for their charaters to develop more but author...more
I just finished reading this book. I love Anita Rau Badami and have now read all her books. This book was really well written - I love the changing voices and perspectives given of the same events. Very interesting presentation of male and female roles and power.
But this book was a tough read for sure. The abuse presented on so many levels and the use of secrecy so well integrated - combined with the knowledge that this really happens.
The book reminds of The Shining by Steven King in many ways.
I...more
But this book was a tough read for sure. The abuse presented on so many levels and the use of secrecy so well integrated - combined with the knowledge that this really happens.
The book reminds of The Shining by Steven King in many ways.
I...more
This is the story of a murder (in the 1st chapter), family secrets and domestic abuse all within the Dharma family who had immigrated from India to a small isolated town in Northern B.C.
I found it hard to close this book once I had started. The subject matter is very disturbing (various types of domestic abuse) yet the story grabs you. The characters were well-developed and I found that either my heart was breaking for them, I was terrified for them or I loathed them.
This has to be one of the be...more
I found it hard to close this book once I had started. The subject matter is very disturbing (various types of domestic abuse) yet the story grabs you. The characters were well-developed and I found that either my heart was breaking for them, I was terrified for them or I loathed them.
This has to be one of the be...more
I definitely have mixed feelings about this book. We seem to end up right where we started so I feel like the plot didn't really go anywhere, and one character's possibility of change at the end is darkly overshadowed by the determination of another character to remain the same.
I gave it four stars because it is an interesting character study and a well-written look into an abusive household. Although being an immigrant in rural Canada is dicussed in this book, the heart of the story is not rea...more
I gave it four stars because it is an interesting character study and a well-written look into an abusive household. Although being an immigrant in rural Canada is dicussed in this book, the heart of the story is not rea...more
What an great read (though not great literature)! It 's lovely to immerse one's self in a book that's hard to put down. This book is about keeping secrets and about violence and the way it affects family members through several generations. It focuses on an East Indian family living in a small town somewhere in rural B.C. Vikram is a controlling, abusive man. His gentle wife -Suman, daughter - Varsha, and son- Hemant live in constant fear of one of Vikram's violent outbursts. His mother, Akka, l...more
The book, Tell It to the Trees, by Anita Rau Badami is a gripping novel about an Indian family that lives in the isolated recluse of the wilderness found in a small town, Merrit’s Point, in northern British Columbia. And much like the setting, the family itself is hidden by the burden of their family secret—the domestic violence of their authoritarian father, Vikram Dharma.
One of Anita Rau Badami’s literary gifts is to be able to speak so effectively through first person narrative. Her prose as...more
One of Anita Rau Badami’s literary gifts is to be able to speak so effectively through first person narrative. Her prose as...more
***I won this book from Goodreads as a First Reads giveaway***
Tell it to the Trees by Anita Rau Badami
I found this book hard to put down. It is a very emotionally charged tale of domestic abuse, both physical and psychological, secrets and trauma. The subject matter is very disturbing yet the story is really gripping. It made me feel very angry and upset. The author has certainly done an excellent job – the writing is beautiful, descriptive and pulls the reader in.
In this novel there is an under...more
For as far as I was able to read in this novel, I'd give it a three star. The writing is good although there are a few weak spots near the beginning. I couldn't get past page 88 only because the novel deals with physical and emotional abuse by the husband- a topic that is not dear to my heart. The novel also examines the relationship between Suman and her step daughter Varsha. Varsha and her step brother Henant are also affected by the abuse they receive and behave oddly to the events around the...more
How can I say I really liked this when I'm hoping to soon shake the chilling effect this
dark story had on me? Perhaps because she writes so well (I really like her "The Hero's Walk"--a much more uplifting novel); perhaps because it was done so well it had its intended effect on me.
This tells the frightening, very well written and expertly plotted story of a family mired in
abuse, an evil passed on from a previous generation. The story is told through four voices, all of them sympathetic to one de...more
dark story had on me? Perhaps because she writes so well (I really like her "The Hero's Walk"--a much more uplifting novel); perhaps because it was done so well it had its intended effect on me.
This tells the frightening, very well written and expertly plotted story of a family mired in
abuse, an evil passed on from a previous generation. The story is told through four voices, all of them sympathetic to one de...more
I greatly enjoyed Anita Rau Badami's other books. Her Hero's Walk is one of my all time favourite novels. While I appreciated her usual invocative writing style that makes a place and its people come alive, I found the subject matter of this book a little too dark and disturbing for my taste. I found myself closing the book and feeling disappointed. It lacks the depth and sense of a well taken journey that I experienced with her other books.
| topics | posts | views | last activity | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| What's The Name o...: East Indian family living in B.C., father abusive, 3 children (2girls/1boy) [s] | 4 | 40 | Mar 04, 2013 11:16am | |
| Video Trailer for Tell It to the Trees | 1 | 5 | Aug 15, 2011 11:06am |

Loading...










view all 5 comments

















